Il Milione: scritto in italiano da Maria Bellonci

by Marco Polo, Maria Bellonci (Editor)

Nel 1271 il giovanissimo Marco Polo partì da Venezia per la Cina, dove divenne uomo di fiducia dell'imperatore del Catai. Per lui viaggiò attraverso l'Asia, terra piena di storie e leggende. Quando, vent'anni dopo, fece ritorno in Europa, venne catturato dai Genovesi, e in carcere conobbe il poeta Rustichello da Pisa, cui dettò il resoconto dei suoi viaggi. Nacque così Il Milione, un'opera in cui si fondono l'amore per il fiabesco e il gusto per l'osservazione precisa, quasi scientifica. Secondo Maria Bellonci, che ha riscritto Il Milione in una lingua «libera ma fedelissima», la testimonianza di Marco Polo «rompe i limiti dello spazio e del tempo: ma ancora di più, ci libera dai limiti che abbiamo dentro di noi e quasi rende reale l'utopia della fratellanza».

Genres: History, Travel, Classics, Nonfiction, Biography, Adventure, Medieval

166 pages, Kindle Edition

First published January 1, 1298

About the author

From 1271, Marco Polo of Venice explored Asia to 1295; the only available Travels of Marco Polo accounted China to Europeans until the 1500s.

Marco Polo spun a tale of how people gave a life of sensual pleasure and a potion to make young Assassins to yearn for paradise, their reward for dying in action, before their secret missions.

Stories and various documents also alternatively point to his ancestry, originating in Korčula, Croatia.

People well knew this trader. He recorded his adventures in a published book. People lost the original copies of his works.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marco_Polo

Reviews

[emma]

marco polo was really the first travel blogger

[William2 · Rating 2 out of 5]

I find it interesting how Marco Polo's description of the Middle East of more than 700 years ago is pretty much a reflection of the way it is today. That is to say, in thrall to the same old tribal passions. Sad, that. The text is perhaps most remarkable for its narrator's incuriousness. We know the richness of these regions from the writings of subsequent travelers and historians, but Polo makes them all seem strikingly similar. The narrative is thin and repetitive. The only thing that makes the text special is its provenance. Not without interest, but too repetitive to sustain my own. Stopped reading page 200.

[David]

Here's a book that looks fantastic on the cover: it's the story of Marco Polo's incredible travels to the East, told by the man himself. Then you open the book and look into it a bit and realize that it might be boring against all odds. For one, it isn't the tale of his adventure. Instead, it's a systematic description of all the countries one can find east of Italy. Check that: no narrative.

Then you actually start reading and you find out that no one--not Marco Polo, not the scribe who wrote down his account as they both languished in prison--could bleach the book of its wonder. I'm not kidding. Despite their best efforts to not write an adventure, the adventure shines through. I read this book in long spurts, careful not to worry about soaking up the long, listlike information on each country, instead letting the sheer weirdness of the world wash over me. I flew through reports of roads manned by bandits and directions from oasis to oasis in the deserts (much of the book reads like a seven-hundred-year-old Lonely Planet guide) so I could slow down and marvel at stories like his account of the first assassins--young men drugged and taken to a paradise of women and wine they were told was heaven. After a week there they were drugged and returned to the real world, only to be told that getting back depended on their unbending devotion to the potentate who controlled access to "heaven."

Alexander the Great shows up from time to time as well, the truth of his legacy already twisted by history. But all of that pales to what Marco tells us about the great Khan's court: I was floored. Let me put it into context for you. I always wanted to be completely dumbfounded by the great wonders of human construction--things like the Eiffel Tower or Stonehenge--and it never happened to me until I stood in the courtyard at the main palace in Seoul. Something about the wide expanse paved by huge stones, all done for the love and reverence a people had for a king, knocked me senseless. I could write an essay extolling the wonder of the place, something meant to celebrate the number of man hours and the immense wealth necessary to construct such a wonder. My essay could easily be one-upped by one explaining the pyramids or the Great Wall, pushing the immensity of human achievement to the limit. But whatever any essay totes as the end-all--skyscrapers, space shuttles, lost continents, you name it--Marco Polo's account of Kublai's empire will smash it. It was to big, too great, too much. And to top it all, the emperor seems like a decent guy.

And that's only half of the book. Polo gets to wander around for another eighty pages or so before concluding that he's covered the known world. My verdict: entirely worth it. And there's no test at the end, so you can breeze through all the geography (though having a map handy can be quite fun--I can only imagine what a dedicated Google Earthling could do) and just enjoy the feeling of peeking in on a world of culture that has more or less disappeared completely.

[فؤاد · Rating 4 out of 5]

ماركو پولو، فرزند هفده ساله ى نيكولو پولو، تاجرى ونيزى است كه بيشتر به قصد سياحى (و بعداً به منظور سفارت) پايش به چين باز مى شود و با حيرت شاهد دربار پر هييت خان مغول "قوبيلاى قاآن" مى گردد. خان مغول، همچون كودكى هشتاد ساله كه حوصله اش سر رفته و پيوسته به دنبال چيزهاى جديد است، از اين مسافران غريب شديداً استقبال مى كند و نمى گذارد به كشورشان برگردند. اين است كه نيكولو پولو و پسرش و برادرش قريب به دو دهه در پايتخت حكومت مغول، "خان باليغ" ماندگار مى شوند.

در اين مدت، ماركو با دقت سرشار يك نوجوان پرشور، ريزه كارى هاى مراسم ها و عقايد و جنگ ها را نگاه مى كند و به حافظه مى سپرد تا سى سال بعد، در گوشه ى زندانى تاريك در فرانسه براى رفيقش تعريف كند و رفيقش اين سفرنامه را بنويسد.

چيزى كه مرا شيفته ى كتاب كرد، گزارش مهيجى بود كه راجع به جزئيات دربار مى داد. اين كه در جشن هاى روزهاى عيد لباس همه ى سران بايد همرنگ لباس انتخابى خان مغول باشد، يا به نورچشمى هاى خان لوحه اى زرين مى دادند كه بتوانند از هر نگهبانى بگذرند و به هر شهرى سفر كنند، حاكم موظف باشد خوراك و مسكن و زن برايشان مهيا كند يا سرود خواندن دسته جمعى مغول ها در روز جنگ يا خريد ساليانه ى دخترها از منطقه اى كه به خوبرويى معروف بودند و كيفيت كارشناسى ميزان زيبايى دختران تا متناسب با زيبايى چهره و رفتارشان (خرناس كشيدن يا نكشيدن در خواب يا بد بو بودن يا نبودن عرق و...) به خيل معشوقگان خان بپيوندند يا گلدوزى و آشپزى بياموزند و تأكيد مى كند كه نبايد اين كار را غير انسانى بدانيم، چرا كه خانواده هاى فقير آرزويشان است كه آينده ى دخترشان با ورود به دربار تأمين شود و...
اين جزئيات است كه به تصويرى كه از زندگى گذشتگان داريم، روح مى دمد. مى فهميم كه آن ها هم مانند ما انسان بودند و زندگى اى داشتند، نه چون بازيگران عصا قورت داده ى تئاتر كه جملاتى پر طمطراق مى گويند.

[Jan-Maat]

On the face of it this the classic account of traveller Marco Polo's journey from Venice to China and back again is pretty straight forward. Man makes journey, writes book, has mint named after him.

Yet it is still controversial over what it alleges, contains and does not contain. The book has a complex and unclear textual history. That names of persons, places and offices are in a Persian form is remarkable given the claim that the Polos were active at the court of the Mongol Khan in China rather than the Mongol Ilkhan in Prsia. The involvement of noted writer of courtly Romances Rustichello of Pisa, the two apparently spent some time together in prison, is grounds for suspicion -it has been suggested that possibly he was the author or compiler of the work. Though in which case one might wonder why the Travels aren't more literary and courtly in flavour. Some early commentators were disturbed that Polo doesn't mention what we now call 'The Great Wall of China', but since it wasn't built until the seventeenth century after the Mongols had been persuaded to mount up and seek out pastures new that seems a reasonable omission, others were sceptical of the Polo's claim to have worked in government service in China. But it seems there are enough examples in the Mongol world of employing, not necessarily Italians, but non-locals as administrators , judges and officials, for this to be plausible and not just the idle boast of someone who knows their story can never be fact checked. Another theory is that the book in fact was intended to be a kind of pre-Baedeker gazetteer to travel and trade in Asia for go getting ambitious European business men - I feel one would have to effectively reconstruct the text to get practical use out of it, like the number of days between towns, types of goods available in different entrepôts, ideal times of year to travel, deserts to avoid, that kind of thing - the information is there but not immediately accessible. Having said that, other medieval manuals thinking for example of The Goodwife of Paris are not user friendly either by contemporary standards.

We are left with the facts that the thing plainly exists, and that it is what it is. The problem perhaps is us and what we expect and look for.

It also contains a mildly garbled account of the rise to power of Genghis Khan and his Mongols.

I'd be inclined to give this a Ted score of two, unless it was an illustrated edition, in which case three

[Daren · Rating 3 out of 5]

A slow and (honestly) not very enjoyable read, but Marco Polo's book is obviously very important, and was ground breaking at the time. Reliable - no, but there is much that is accurate, mixed with plenty he clearly never experienced personally yet records as he was obviously told these stories by others.

My edition was complete with loads of footnotes which pointed out the differences between various editions, which adds little for the lay reader, but clarifies, I suppose where things were perhaps recorded incorrectly in one version, or tidied up later in another.

Polo, or perhaps Rustichello's formulaic phrasing is painful and annoying - it seems like every page we are given "Now I must tell you about another Kingdom... the people here are idolaters, ruled by a ... and speak their own language. They pay no tribute to anyone ... and as there is nothing else worthy of note we shall continue on our way."

While the base text was repetitive and dull, the anecdotes between kept me interested enough to seek out the next one. Small asides - on strange customs and behaviour (albeit many unbelievable); explanations on how ships were constructed; stories of collecting diamonds using raw meat and scavenging birds, etc.

Counterbalancing these were the repetitive running down of all non-Christian and non-Muslim people as idolators, savages, ugly and unclean. Somehow Polo manages to make so many of these 'kingdoms' sound the same, which was surely not the case as he travelled through them. For so many he reduces them to their trade goods, their leadership and then moves on. Many have speculated that he was writing a book on trade - guide book of sorts, and I can see that - distances travelled (in days), who the people pay tribute to, whether they are Christian, Muslim or idolators, their language - yes that would all tie in. Perhaps Rustichello looked to broaden the appeal of a trade guide but adding the anecdotes in? How dull it would have been without!

However, I am glad to have completed this book, and can move on!

3 stars.

[Nandakishore Mridula · Rating 4 out of 5]

I loved it. He was lying most of the time about India, however... I mean, it's hot here in the tropics, but boiling eggs in the river? And dog-headed people?? But they were such colourful and entertaining lies. 😊

[E. G. · Rating 3 out of 5]

Chronology
Introduction & Notes
Further Reading
A Note on the Text
Maps

--The Travels

List of Abbreviations
Appendix
Notes
Index

[Melcat · Rating 2 out of 5]

On an fascinating subject, the narrative of Marco Polo's book is unfortunately extremely dry and repetitive. It mainly consists of a list of all the different countries and regions that he has been to, with a few facts added here and there.

I saw in a review from a Goodreads member named David (unfortunately not active anymore, I really hope you're ok buddy) that "much of the book reads like a seven-hundred-year-old Lonely Planet guide ». While I find this sentence hilarious, that doesn't make it less true.

I wouldn’t really recommend it unless you're a collector of this edition (as I am) or particularly interested in travel stories/ geography listing. I’m very strict on reading every book I buy/keep, so the Audiobook kept me company on a few car trips. It really felt like a dream.

[Paul of Bethesda · Rating 5 out of 5]

Travelling, clearly, came naturally to Marco Polo, as we all know Venice’s most famous son for his prowess as a traveller. He left his Venetian home in 1271 and travelled all the way to China and India, following the Silk Road that had not been much traversed by Westerners before. More than two decades later, when Marco returned home to Venice in 1295, he had the misfortune of being imprisoned by Venice’s enemies, the Genoese (Venice and Genoa were then at war). Yet Marco made exceedingly good use of his Genoese incarceration, dictating to his cellmate Rustichello da Pisa a full account of his travels. That account, published around the year 1300 as Il Milione (“The Million”) or Book of the Marvels of the World, is now generally known as The Travels of Marco Polo, or simply The Travels. By any name, it is truly a vibrant and compelling account of the adventures of a brave and open-minded man whose travels brought two worlds together. If you love travel as I do, you should make a point of reading this book.

Translator and commentator Ronald Latham of the University of Belfast helpfully sets forth the historical context against which Marco Polo made his epic journey. East and West had been engaging in violent conflict for centuries, through the eight Crusades that occurred between 1096 and 1270. At the same time, there was a growing awareness that not all East-West interaction needed to be violent: across Asia, there were great civilizations with resources that could enrich the businesspeople enterprising enough to go forth and open the right trade routes. In Venice, a republic with a robust free-enterprise economy, such news resonated; and when Marco Polo’s father and uncle, Niccolò and Maffeo Polo, returned in 1269 from a successful journey all the way to China, the die was cast. The three of them – father with son, uncle with nephew – would travel into Asia together.

Part of the fun of reading The Travels, of travelling with the Polos into new lands, is the sheer storytelling verve of the book. This is one of those “classics” that is actually fun to read. Indeed, Marco Polo’s eagerness to tell a good story sometimes may cause him to play a bit fast and loose with the facts. Chapter 5, “From Peking to Amoy,” shows Marco Polo and his father and uncle playing a decisive role in the siege by the Great Khan of a city called Siang-yang-fu. As Marco tells it, the siege has been going on for three years without success, until “Messer Niccolò and Messer Maffeo and Messer Marco declared: ‘We shall find you a means by which the city will be forced to surrender forthwith’”. In response, the Great Khan “told Messer Niccolò and his brother and his son that nothing should please him better”, and told his troops to do as the Venetians told them. Promptly they manufactured a mangonel (a kind of trebuchet or catapult) that could launch 300-pound stones, and with this new technology they forced the people of Siang-yang-fu to surrender. “And the credit for this achievement was due to the good offices of Messer Niccolò and Messer Maffeo and Messer Marco” (pp. 208-09). It’s a lovely story, and no doubt it would have brought pride to the heart of many a Venetian reader.

But hold on a moment, please. There is contrasting testimony, to the effect that the mangonels may have been designed by Muslim engineers. It is even possible that the historical siege of Xiangyang, which ended in 1273, may have predated Marco Polo’s arrival in that part of China. One must read these parts of The Travels with a critical and questioning eye.

Indeed, there are parts of The Travels that are clearly – to us, if not to all readers of Marco Polo’s time – mythological. In the “Arabian Sea” chapter, Marco Polo tells the reader all about a “gryphon bird” and informs the reader that these gryphons are not the “half bird and half lion” creatures of European heraldry. Rather, gryphons are birds that “are just like eagles but of the most colossal size”, and are “so huge and bulky that one of them can pounce on an elephant and carry it up to a great height in the air” (p. 300). Here, plainly, we are in the realm of legend and myth – specifically, the legend of the rukh or roc, the giant bird that would figure importantly in the 1001 Nights or Arabian Nights tales a couple of centuries later.

Marco Polo is on firmer ground when describing important people of his time. It was through The Travels that many Western readers got their first impression of Genghis Khan – or, as Marco calls him, “Chinghiz Khan, a man of great ability and wisdom, a gifted orator and a brilliant soldier” (p. 93). Marco Polo’s reflections on the life and career of Genghis Khan are of great value – even if Marco spends a number of pages describing a nonexistent conflict between Genghis Khan and “Prester John,” a completely mythical Christian emperor of East Asia.

More vivid and more reliable, because they are first-hand, are Marco Polo’s impressions of Kublai Khan. Genghis Khan’s grandson, Kublai Khan was of Mongol heritage, and was the founder and first emperor (reigned 1271-94) of China’s Yuan dynasty. Marco Polo clearly made a good impression on Kublai Khan, as he served the Khan for years as a diplomatic representative. The picture of Kublai Khan that emerges from the Travels is strongly positive. Translator and commentator Latham seems to hit the mark when he writes that Kublai Khan “was a very different character” from previous emperors – a man who “had absorbed many of the best elements of Chinese culture, including something of the humanitarian spirit of Buddhism, while retaining much of the vigour and simplicity of the nomad” (p. 12).

Kublai Khan reminded me of Augustus Caesar in Rome – a savvy leader and effective administrator who could use either force or diplomacy to expand and protect his empire. He seems to have known the value of playing his cards close to the vest and keeping his options open. At one point, Marco Polo exults at how Kublai Khan has “sent word to the Pope that he should send up to a hundred men learned in the Christian religion, well versed in the seven arts, and skilled to argue and demonstrate plainly to idolaters…that the Christian religion is better than theirs” (p. 36).

Did Kublai Khan really hope that massive numbers of his subject would convert to Christianity and then find that their primary allegiance was to the Pope in Rome? Of course not. But Kublai Khan was clearly a canny ruler who knew the ways of individuals and nations. And if an important nation in the far West - a prosperous republic that could prove a lucrative trade partner - wanted to send representatives of their religion, then let them do so. Kublai Khan was going to make sure that things continued to go his way in his empire, no matter how many missionaries the Pope might send.

Marco Polo’s time with Kublai Khan has had a major influence on the history and culture of the Western world, as when Marco Polo describes how, in “a city called Shang-tu,” Kublai Khan had “built a huge palace of marble and other ornamental stones. Its halls and chambers are all gilded, and the whole building is marvellously embellished and richly adorned.” Another palace in the complex has its interior “all gilt and decorated with beasts and birds of very skillful workmanship. It is reared on gilt and varnished pillars, on each of which stands a dragon, entwining the pillar with his tail and supporting the roof on his outstretched limbs.” Shang-tu is a summer palace, where “The Great Khan stays…for three months in the year – June, July, and August – to escape from the heat, and for the sake of the recreation it affords” (pp. 108-09).

Shang-tu. Xanadu! It is this passage from Marco Polo’s Travels that inspired Samuel Taylor Coleridge’s 1797 poem Kubla Khan – “In Xanadu did Kublai Khan/A stately pleasure dome decree” – as well as the name of Charles Foster Kane’s retreat in Orson Welles’s film Citizen Kane (1941), and a 1977 song-suite by the Canadian progressive-rock band Rush, and a not-terribly-well-received Olivia Newton-John film from 1980, and so on and so forth. Marco Polo gave the people of the West the image of Xanadu, and so much else as well.

What brought me to The Travels was a visit to Hangzhou, China. Marco Polo loved Hangzhou (a city he knew as Kinsai), and said that the city “well merits a description, because it is, without doubt, the finest and most splendid city in the world” (p. 213). Marco Polo’s high regard for the city he knew as Kinsai, the “City of Heaven,” is reciprocated by the people of modern Hangzhou, where a very fine statue of Marco Polo stands alongside a picturesque stretch of the city’s West Lake.

Marco Polo’s travels took him through the modern nations of Israel, Armenia, Georgia, Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, Mongolia, China, Myanmar, Indonesia, Sri Lanka, India, and Turkey, before he returned home to Venice. How happy it must have made him to behold the Grand Canal and the Rialto bridge, and to reflect on all that he had seen and done in his adventures. I love travel (80 countries so far), and Marco Polo has always inspired me. He was a traveller who loved experiencing new nations, cultures, and landscapes. And anyone who enjoys travel will no doubt draw inspiration from going along with Marco Polo on his Travels.

[Chiara · Rating 4 out of 5]

Che viaggio! Più di un mese di lettura... del resto Marco Polo ci ha messo poco meno di vent'anni, quindi tutto sommato è andata bene...

A Marco Polo, grandissimo personaggio, viaggiatore straordinario, autore di una delle opere più importanti della storia, voto 5 su 5, e anche più! Al Milione, o Libro delle Meraviglie del Mondo, come da tradizione francese, o The Travels of Marco Polo, com'è noto dagli anglosassoni, 5 stelle meritatissime. Il racconto di una vita passata a esplorare terre lontane un mondo, assimilare nuove culture, per poi rendere il preziosissimo dono all'Occidente antico di narrare il tutto per iscritto, permettendo una nuova apertura tra popoli (e anche merci: il ruolo di mercanti della famiglia Polo è fondamentale, sia per l'accuratezza con cui viene assegnato un valore ad ogni mercanzia trattata, sia perché apre nuove possibilità di scambio) e rendendo note le meraviglie d'Oriente.
I temi trattati sono innumerevoli: dalle battaglie all'illustrazione di usi e costumi di varie culture, dalla descrizione di città e province a quella di grandi personaggi e le loro corti, il libro mantiene la struttura di un diario, che a tratti entusiasma, mentre in alcuni punti risulta un po' pesante da assimilare.
Tra le cose più affascinanti, la descrizione della città di Quinsai, allora capitale della Cina meridionale, l'ammirazione per Kublai e la storia della sua ascesa al trono, la caratterizzazione delle varie religioni incontrate, con tanto di spiegazione dei diversi culti e leggende, e il ruolo della donna nella società, che Marco puntualmente nota e riporta. E poi soprattutto, la prima menzione del Giappone, di cui mai si era sentito parlare nell'Europa occidentale.

Il Milione è frutto di una mente straordinaria (Messer Polo non scherzava: partito a quindici anni, parlava quattro lingue; dopo circa quattro anni di viaggio arriva alla corte di Kublai Khan, di cui riesce a diventare ambasciatore) e della penna di Rustichello da Pisa, che ascoltò la testimonianza di Marco durante la prigionia genovese.
Purtroppo, essendo perduto il manoscritto originale, di tutte le versioni esistenti, non si sa quali siano effettivamente le frasi pensate da Marco Polo, quali quelle aggiunte da Rustichello, quali aggiunte poi - o addirittura modificate - dai diversi traduttori. Ne risulta una lettura poco scorrevole in vari punti, almeno nella versione edita dalla BUR, che riporta varie versioni della stessa storia, parecchie in francese, altre in volgare toscano, con tanto di inutilissime note a piè di pagina che rimandano il lettore a vedere la precedente nota in tal capitolo LXXIV, 250 pagine prima, per capire quel termine. Eh sì, perché nonostante Marco Polo fosse veneziano, ho scoperto essere molto più facile leggere il Milione in altre lingue, ad esempio, in inglese: noi abbiamo ancora la traduzione di circa sei secoli fa, se non sette (che per me non ha senso, visto che l'originale era comunque in francese, non c'è niente di straordinario nel volerlo per forza vendere in volgare, visto che si tratta comunque di una traduzione).

Tutto sommato una lettura imperdibile per gli appassionati di viaggi, di storia o per chi volesse approfondire le culture orientali, che sono soddisfattissima di aver portato a termine

[Ivana Books Are Magic · Rating 3 out of 5]

Il Milione, the legendary account of Marco Polo's travels is a fascinating view into history. Commonly known as The Travels of Marco Polo in English, this thirteen century travelogue offers an unique view of an European adventurer and merchant visiting countries unknown to most Europeans. Marco Polo is cited as an author, but Il Milione was supposedly written by Rustichello da Pisa based on Marco Polo's personal narration of his travels. The two spent some time in prison together if I remember correctly. So, this book has a co-writer it could be said. Over the years there has been some despite over book's authenticity. The question whether Marco Polo really visited all those places was often raised. I personally don't really care whether every single story in it is 100 percent historically accurate. I think it's accurate enough.

This book describes Polo's travels through Asia. It often describes local traditions and customs of people Polo passed by. It is filled with descriptions, and one feels more like one is reading an encyclopedia then a travel or adventure book, but I found it interesting. My favourite part of the book was Marco Polo's experiences at the court of Kublai Khan. Anyhow, this is a nice read. It is easy to see how it influenced numerous artists and writers. I listened to an audio version of it that lasted for about 7 hours and had a surprising number of musical numbers. I also read a part of it (before option for an audio version). Honestly, I plan to read it once again, because I had a feeling I might have missed something (I've been a bit distracted lately).

Despite it being historically relevant and quite interesting, for most parts Il Milione is not an engaging read. There are some fascinating and engaging bits, but on overall one doesn't get the feeling of a personal narrative. The writing style leaves something to be desired. However, it is an important book and one well worth a read.

[Susan · Rating 1 out of 5]

It took me forever to finish this. A massive book of facts without flesh. It was like reading a phonebook -- dry, repetitive, lacking depth and in need of a good editor. And every so often, you'd come across odd statements like this:

"But, now that we have embarked on this topic, we have had second thoughts about setting it down in writing; for after all it is very well known to many people. So let us drop the subject and start on another one…"

It was very strange to me how any traveler to these fascinating places could make them seem so dull.

[Aurelia · Rating 4 out of 5]

Fin XIII siècle, Venise est cité état à l’influence immense, qui s’étend jusqu’à la mer noire en passant par Constantinople. Ses comptoirs commerciaux et sa supériorité navale lui permettent de faire le monopole sur le commerce avec le monde musulman, à travers lequel l’Europe se fournit par toutes les marchandises venant de l’Inde et de la Chine. Mais bientôt cette suprématie sera en péril, à cause des manœuvres d’une autre cité Etat de la péninsule italienne, à savoir Gênes. Ces luttes, ainsi que d’autres instabilités régionales, vont pousser trois marchands vénitiens, Mafeo, Nicolo et Marco Polo, déjà installés sur la mer noire, à avancer vers l’Orient, en menant un voyage aux dimensions épiques. Sur Un quart de siècle, leur voyage va les mener à travers les steppes de l’Eurasie, vers la Chine, en retournant sur la route du commerce de l’Océan Indien.


Marco Polo relate ce voyage périlleux et extraordinaire bien après son retour à Venise en 1298, avec son père et son oncle, le départ a été en 1272. Marquez que ceci est le deuxième voyage pour les vieux Polo en Chine. Le trajet est souvent en méandres, séparé par plusieurs pauses pour des raisons de mauvais temps ou de guerre. La première partie relatée dans le Livre I a pour départ Constantinople. Après les conquêtes Mongole, l’Est de la Turquie et l’Arménie étaient des territoires dévastés par les luttes sanglantes entre les descendants de Ghingis Khan. L’Irak et l’Iran, quoique d’importants centres commerciaux avec un artisanat de tissu et tapisserie avancé, vivent leur derniers moments de splendeur califale. A part le Samarkand et le Boukhara, importante stations sur la route de la soie, Le Sud de L’Ouzbékistan et le Nord de l’Afghanistan, le Pakistan sont un territoire vaste et inhospitalier. Le nord de la Chine et sa frontière avec la Mongolie est le lieu d’origine de ceux qui ont conquis le monde. Les mongols qui y restent ont préservé leur mode de vie rude. Ceux sont des archers, qui dressent les meilleurs chevaux et oiseaux. Semi nomades vivant sous des tentes, gardant les bêtes et excellant à la chasse. Du nord de la Chine on descend vers Pékin.


Le Livre II est entièrement consacré à la Chine. C’est la splendeur de l’Empire dans toute sa grandeur. Marco Polo est reçu à la cour du premier empereur de la dynastie Yuan, Kubilai Khan, également descendant de Ghengis Khan. La cour impériale est d’une richesse immense. Le pays est fortement urbanisé et industrialisé. La population est importante. L’état Chinois est fort complexe et efficace à la gestion et l’organisation des différentes fonctions régales : finance publique et impots, sécurité et défense, travaux publiques, Poste et même un rudiment des services sociaux… Ses différentes missions auprès du Grand Khan, vont mener Marco Polo au confin de l’Ouest à travers le Yuan jusqu’au Birmanie et le Nord du Vietnam, ainsi que vers l’Est, sur le Yangzi, jusqu’à Hangzhou, et les ports magnifiques sur la mer de Chine.


Le Livre III relate le trajet de retour à Venise, en empruntant la route du commerce de l’Océan Indien. Il s’agit des royaumes des épices, indépendants de l’influence de la Chine : l’Indonésie et ses iles riches Java et Sumatra, le Sri Lanka et toutes les cotes de l’Inde jusqu’au Gujarat. Un monde exotique, ou ni les gens ni les animaux ni les plantes ne ressemblent à ce que le reste du monde connait, leurs produits sont échangés avec les chevaux venant d’Arabie. Les courants de l’Océan Indien mènent les marchands au détroit de Hormuz, puis le Sud du Yémen, ensuite la corne d’Afrique jusqu’au Zanzibar.


Loin d’être une simple leçon de géographie, le livre des Merveilles est un témoignage d’un moment assez particulier de l’Histoire de l’Humanité : le monde après les conquêtes Mongole. Contrairement aux autres évènements bouleversant, celui-ci est peut-être le plus obscure. Cette description permet d’éclairer et la période et l’évènement. C’est un texte très précieux.

[Jenny · Rating 3 out of 5]

While this book can be fascinating and highly amusing, it is also extremely repetitive, fictitious, and at times, downright boring. I'm glad I read it, but I wish I had read a different translation. According to the translator of this edition, other people cut out the repetitive parts and the narrative technique of saying, "I will tell you" and things like that. I would probably have gotten through the book much more quickly without those things. That being said, it's a classic, and it does have its merits. The most interesting parts were those so out there that the reader knows they're fake and the parts about things that other historical accounts have corroborated because I know they're more or less accurate, so this book just offers a different perspective on an accepted truth.
I recommend this book only to people interested in 13th-century history and people who enjoy travel narratives, fictitious, truthful, or blends of both.

[Julian Worker · Rating 3 out of 5]

To me this is the travel equivalent of the Histories by Herodotus - how much of it is made up and how much did he experience?

My understanding is that these stories were told to Rustichello da Pisa, an Italian writer of Arthurian romances, when they were in prison together in Genoa after being captured in a naval battle. Does this mean that Marco Polo couldn't write and this is why he didn't keep a diary when he was travelling around?

[Carlos Bazzano · Rating 3 out of 5]

Marco Polo, fue uno de los personajes que más admiración despertaban en mí cuando era niño (recuerdo cierto programa de televisión en forma de dibujos animados que relataba sus aventuras, el nombre se me ha ido), quizá la leyenda más que el personaje histórico en sí mismo. Muchas veces había oído hablar del relato de sus grandiosos viajes y la curiosidad siempre me había conducido a buscar tales relatos y tardé en dar con ellos. Confieso que, de haber leído El libro de las maravillas en mi infancia o adolescencia lo habría encontrado tremendamente aburrido, no es que ahora no su lectura no me haya resultado aburrida, pero lo habría sido mucho más habida cuenta de la ingente cantidad de descripciones y el nulo contenido de aventuras que un chico habría esperado.

Ahora, a mis 31 años al fin puede leer esta obra que, valga la aclaración es un tremendo clásico, considero que a pesar de todo el sopor que me ocasionó este libro, extremadamente lento y profuso en descripciones, avanzar por sobre el aburrimiento ocasionado por el carácter monótono del libro, ha valido la pena poder ver el mundo a través de los ojos de uno de los personajes más destacados del siglo XIII, sus valores, su reporte de la realidad que, de tan peculiar que parece hoy día, viene a relativizar nuestra experiencia de la realidad misma.

El libro en sí cuenta con un ritmo lento y tedioso – lo cual deriva, como ya he dicho de la excesiva cantidad de descripciones y del tono utilizado en la narración – no obstante, debo decir que la inteligencia de Marco Polo me ha conquistado. Todo cuanto hace parece tener una razón, un motivo oculto que va más allá de apenar obtener lo necesario, busca siempre ir más allá, aprender, conocer y no quedarse únicamente con la respuesta básica, sino que intenta siempre conocer el funcionamiento de las cosas.

Con relación a sus viajes debo decir que me hubiera encantado formar parte de dicha expedición, si bien los relatos de tales viajes cuentan con un claro tono fantasioso, resulta perfectamente compatible con el imaginario europeo de la Edad Media. En este punto conviene aclarar que este libro contiene una de las leyendas gastronómicas más difundidas: la cual indica que supuestamente Polo introdujo los spaguettis a Italia desde China, leyenda que investigaciones más recientes han desmentido.

Este libro no contiene apasionantes relatos de grandes aventuras, es un buen documento histórico eso sí, pero no más.

[Jesús De la Jara · Rating 4 out of 5]

"Señores emperadores, reyes, gobernantes y demás gentes que deseáis tener noticias de los distintos pueblos y más variadas regiones del mundo, lean este libro donde hallarán relatadas asombrosas maravillas y la gran diversidad de los pueblos de Armenia, Persia, Tartaria, India y muchas otras regiones. Es lo que les referirá este libro tal como micer Marco Polo, sabio y noble ciudadano de Venecia, lo relata aquí según él mismo lo vio."

Bueno habría que hablar mil cosas sobre este libro, sobre todo en cuanto a su génesis, su veracidad, su influencia y sus fuentes. Pero eso sería muy extenso y corresponde a grandes estudiosos que se pueden pasar todo el tiempo con opiniones muy diferentes.
Lo que nadie duda es que Marco Polo fue un veneciano que gracias a las relaciones de su familia emprendió viajes fantásticos y los describió como nunca antes un europeo lo había hecho. Si recordamos la gran distancia (no solo me refiero a la geográfica sino cultural y de conocimiento del otro) que había entre Europa y Asia desde tiempos inmemoriales, tenemos aquí a un documento que debió ser el manual, la biblia o el diccionario para los europeos de lo que era Asia. Recordemos nomás que en la época de las cruzadas o de las guerras contra los musulmanes en Europa, los asiáticos (en este caso musulmanes) eran poco conocidos de cerca y la mayoría de la población que no había ido a Asia tenía una idea muy fantástica de lo que aquella gente era y sus costumbres. Pues bien, si antes Egipto, Siria o Jerusalén era lejano; pues, ahora, hablar de China, Mongolia o la India era definitivamete otro nivel. Esto, desde luego, fue propiciado por la amenaza mongola (tártaros llamados en el libro) que tenían todo Asia controlado y con ello las rutas de comercio de especias y otros objetos de no mayor valor.
Marco Polo y su familia eran mercaderes que tenían sus bases en Venecia y Sudak. Su papá y su tío viajaron mucho y al volver recogieron a Marco Polo cuya madre había muerto. Marco fue declarado legado (embajador o representante) por el Gran Khan. Aprendió 4 lenguas. Él se quedó a su servicio 17 años. En su época el máximo gobernante era Kublai Khan, descendiente de Gengis Khan. Marco Polo siempre hablará de él con respeto y admiración. Casi siempre se habla del Gran Khan. Ya que en esa época los mongoles habían conquistado todo. También se menciona a Tamerlán en las notas de esta edición, ya que fue el gobernante que luego tomó posesión de estas tierras.
Es interesante porque en la descripción de su libro se refiere a nombres antiguos. Me gustó conocer los nombres como Champa que es Vietnam o Ceilan que es sri lanka; y que por ejemplo Turquía estaba conquistada por Persia en esa época.

"Cuando llega un forastero, se ponen eufóricos y mandan a sus mujeres que lo sirvan en todo lo que necesite. Los maridos abandonan su casa y se van a otro sitio durante dos o tres días; y el forastero se queda con la esposa y hace con ella lo que quiere, como si fuera su mujer, y lo pasan muy bien. A todos en esta región los han hecho cornudos sus mujeres, pero a ellos no les da vergüenza; y sus mujeres son hermosas, alegres y están encantadas con esta costumbre."

A medida que Marco Polo va contando su viaje y diversas encomiendas del Gran Khan, nos va describiendo las tierras que visitó, así como sus leyendas. Se cuenta el milagro de la montaña de Bagdad. También que en Saba están enterrados los tres reyes magos. El da sus nombres y probablemente es uno de los primeros testimonios. Los reyes magos cuando ven al niño cada uno por separado lo ve de su mismo aspecto y edad. Luego entran los tres y lo ven niño. El niño les da un regalo que al verlo es una piedra pero luego está se ilumina desde el cielo y produce una llama mágica cuando vuelve.
En Persia, Marco Polo se admira de los hermosos corceles. Frutas como pistachos que no hay en europa. Llega incluso al estrecho de Ormuz. También nos cuenta la historia del viejo de la montaña, que él lo identifica como Ala ed-Din (Aladino) pero probablemente se trate de Hassan Sabah. Creó una secta de asesinos a los que les hacía creer con drogas y mujeres que estaban en el paraíso. Si fallaban se suicidaban pensando así volver al paraíso. Hulegu acabo con ellos.
Marco Polo es sensible a todo. Habla de los melones que pelados y secados son muy deliciosos. Habla de piedras preciosas como el rubí.
En Karakorum, antigua capital de los mongoles habla del Preste Juan un personaje muy misterioso católico que los árabes conocían. También nos da una pequeña historia de Gengis khan y cómo se volvió poderoso. A pesar de esto, es importante mencionar que el libro tiene un montón de errores históricos, lugares, fechas. Menos mal que esta buena edición de Cátedra tiene muchas notas que los corrigen. Habla maravillas del ejército mongol que es muy competente valiente y puede vivir hasta 1 mes sin comer solo bebiendo leche de yegua. Habla extensamente de sus costumbres por ejemplo casar a sus hijos muertos. Cuando habla de Kublai Khan lo hace con honor. Cuando unos cristianos pierden, él muestra respeto y dice que su Dios quiso que pierdan pues el era justo y el enemigo, no.
Pekín es la capital y es hermosa y con muchos arsenales de armas. Se describe la opulencia del Khan con sus joyas de oro y plata. La cantidad de regalos que hace a sus varones y cómo todos se inclinan cada vez que toma la copa en un banquete.
Los mogoles tienen un servicio de correo exclusivo para el Khan muy interesante como los chasquis pero a caballo. Se hacen relevos y se iluminan con antorchas de la gente si es noche. Los esperan tambien con caballos frescos. Le maravilla el puente de Lugou con sus leones de mármol que hoy se llama también puente de Marco Polo. Cuado llega a Tibet se encuentra una ciudad arrasada por los mongoles. También te habla de la importancia de la pimienta, que es una parte del estilo de vida medieval. Era tan valiosa como el oro a veces. El gran Khan cobraba impuestos enormes en los puertos que controlaba de los productos hasta 44 por ciento. Intentó el khan conquistar Japón dos veces pero no pudo. Los tifones (kamikazes) los salvaron providencialmente. Les llama a los rinocerontes unicornios, aunque saben que no son lo mismo. Desmiente otros mitos como los niños pequeños que en verdad son monos despellajados y preparados.
En la India habla de sus costumbres de no comer vacas. De que algunos criminales se suicidan dedicando su vida a un Dios y la familia se alegra. Y que las esposas si muere el marido se inmolan en su pira y es bien visto. En esa época solo habían diamantes en la India. Esta parte del libro es interesante porque se da muchas observaciones de la India muy pintorescas. Marco Polo es el primer europeo que da una descripción de Buda. En la India barco que llegan lo roban y desvalijan y no lo ven malo porque por algo llegó ahí, excepto si es su destino. A estas alturas de la narración, Marco Polo ya ve tensiones que terminarán con el imperio entre Kaidu y Kublai Kahn. Guerras feroces se dan en ambos bandos. Batu Khan controlaba la Horda de oro era la región que controlaba que abarcaba parte de Rusia.
Creo que la influencia de Marco Polo es más de lo que ha escrito. Ha dado nombre hasta a especies de ovejas y puentes. Sin duda, su libro constituye un acercamiento a parajes y costumbres que parecían de otro planeta para el lector de su época. Aunque no me llegó a encantar todo el libro, pero valoro su importancia. Cuando Polo habla de pueblos "sin interés" obviametne se vuelve repetitivo y sin sustancia.

"Son tan buenos magos que cuando el Gran Khan come en la sala principal, hacen que las copas de vino, leche y otra bebida que se colocan en el otro extremo de la sala se desplacen hasta él sin que nadie las toque. Esto lo ven con sus propios ojos diez mil personas y es absolutamente cierto, porque se puede conseguir mediante la nigromancia."

[Glen · Rating 3 out of 5]

While I was a bit tempted to label this as Historical fiction, but it is regarded as mostly nonfiction.

A great translation of Marco Polo's travels and knowledge of foreign lands. A lot of things re false, but I think Polo believed a lot of it.

[Carola · Rating 3 out of 5]

No puedo creer que me demoré tantos años en leer este libro cuando siempre he alucinado con Marco Polo y sus aventuras (yo soy viajera también, desde los 21 años, y mi abuela también lo fue en una época en que las mujeres estaban en su casa guardadas). De los sitios que él visitó (supuestamente), me gustaría tomar el tren transiberiano y recorrer parte de Rusia, China y Mongolia, ir a Japón (por el reiki) y, sobre todo Madagascar (Mogdasio).

Algunos apuntes del texto que me gustaron:

- "En esta Armenia Mayor es donde se encuentra el Arca de Noé en una alta montaña (el monte Ararat)".

- "En la zona limítrofe a la Georgia hay una fuente de la cual emana aceite en abundancia [¿petróleo?], de tal suerte que pueden cargarse cien naves a la vez pero no es comestible, más combustible y sirve para ungir los camellos contra la tiña y el forúnculo. Y los hombres vienen de muy lejos a recoger este aceite y en toda la comarca no se quema más que esta sustancia".

- "Los hombres son todos nobles y no se ocupan más que de caza y de cetrería. Las mujeres lo hacen todo, y sólo las ayudan los esclavos. Cuando las damas tienen un hijo varón lo lavan y lo envuelven en un pañal, y el marido se acuesta en la cama con el niño y se queda en ella durante cuarenta días, no levantándose más que para las precisas necesidades y amigos y parientes le vienen a ver y le hacen fiesta y solaz, y esto lo hacen porque dicen que sus mujeres han pasado fatigas llevando el niño en su vientre y no quieren que sufran cuarenta días. Pero la mujer, en cuanto ha parido, se levanta, hace todos los menesteres de la casa y sirve a su varón en la cama".

- "Todos los que tienen hospedería y albergue inscriben el nombre de los que hospeda y en qué día y mes han llegado. Así, el Gran Khan sabe quién entra y sale en su reino, y es cosa muy importante para un hombre prudente".

- "Ha ordenado que por las carreteras por donde pasa la posta, los mercaderes y los
peregrinos, se planten árboles, de dos en dos, a los lados del camino. Estos árboles
son tan grandes, que se ven de lejos. Y esto para que nadie pierda de vista la
carretera y no se aparte de ella. Y los encontraréis en regiones desiertas, muy útiles
para los viandantes, que no pierden el camino, y los hay en todas las provincias y
en todos los reinos".

[Adrian · Rating 5 out of 5]

The Travels of Marco Polo may be perhaps the most challenging travelogue ever put together. While Marco Polo was not the first to write about lands distant and alien to one’s own, he wrote of a journey of immense challenge and difficulty. Difficulty that is difficult to appreciate in our modern world.
First of all, the most notable controversy; was Maro Polo a fraud? This reader disagrees. While some regard it as suspect that he traveled to Yuan Dynasty China and did not mention the largely Han practice of foot binding, one needs to remember that he was employed in the court of Kubilai Khan, a Mongol Emperor who headed a very multicultural court.
While this reader is not a first class scholar of medieval China, the narrative through which Marco Polo describes the China of then corresponds somewhat to the cultural mosaic of today. While in the Southwest of China, he describes people of rather relaxed sexual practices, which have an eery similarity to the Naxi of Yunnan Province, he describes a religious mosaic that regularly alternates between either Christian, Muslim or, as he terms it, idolatory, he describes funerary practices, the choice of clothing, and dietary practices. Therefore, this reader rules favorably in the authenticity of Marco Polo’s account.
The book in itself is mainly a travelogue, and describes everywhere from Armenia and the Caspian Sea region, China, India, the Middle East, and in the final chapter, Russia.
Toward the end, the book becomes something of a commentary of the then current affairs, describing a conflict in what was then an area close to Russia’s frontier, and earlier parts of the book describe the conflict and intrigue in the court of the Great Khan. However, the book, for the most part, is a travelogue.
The book is an immensely entertaining and readable account. With just simple relaxation and the right approach, one feels themselves there with Marco Polo, exploring unknown lands, and traveling a greater distance traveled by no man since the creation, in the words of the introduction.
Marco Polo’s Travels, or to give it it’s actual title, Il Milione, is a timeless classic. A timeless work of inquiry and observation that is both intriguing and fascinating, and a pleasure for the soul.

[El Bibliófilo · Rating 4 out of 5]

Mis comentarios en video: https://youtu.be/5uf36oKTWZc

Germen y generador de historias.
Los viajes de Marco Polo (con los variados nombres el libro de las maravillas, millón, etc) nos presentan los relatos de los viajes del mercader veneciano por Asia, Medio Oriente, India, China, Indochina. Acá les presento la relación con Baudolino de Umberto Eco, la crítica de la mención de la Muralla China que sí encontré, no así la de comer insectos y que ojalá dejen sus comentarios, algunas imprecisiones pero también unas semejanzas que dan credibilidad a los viajes, en cómo nos presenta costumbres de verificación a largo plazo (luego no las comprobó sino las escuchó), mitos y leyendas de los lugares visitados y las batalla épicas (que es poco probable que presenciara, pero que le fueron referidas y afortunadamente nos las contó). Y también la reflexión que me generó frente a la gran pérdida para la arqueología algunos ritos funerarios de Oriente. Finalmente, destaco cómo inspiró obras como la trilogía de Trajano, la película "Silencio", entre otras, pues el poder evocador de la obra como cimiento histórico para el intercambio cultural Oriente-Occidente es inconmensurable.
Espero se animen a leer el libro, ver el video y dejar sus comentarios.

[Stacia · Rating 5 out of 5]

I feel like my reading of this book has taken as long as Polo's travels! (Mostly, though, it was because I got sidetracked by the extensive footnotes & subsequent internet research on various topics found in Polo's book.)

Polo's tales are an eclectic mix of geography notes, merchant/business observations, descriptions of plants/animals/governments/cultural customs interspersed with strange & outrageous tales (many true) along with plenty of gossip & hearsay (plenty false). It's almost like a mix of a dry textbook, a National Geographic documentary, a royal edict, Twitter, & the National Enquirer stirred to create his unique story. The complete mish-mash of information & mix of the mundane with the extraordinary reminded me a bit of the structure & jumble of Poe's The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym of Nantucket. Even though some parts are repetitive or boring recitations of business/trading/government facts, there are a lot of gems & fantastic observations... enough to make me overlook the slower parts in favor of the rest of it. Five stars for Polo's sheer chutzpah in living his life large & telling about it so that, even today, we can still enjoy his amazing travels.

[Dan · Rating 2 out of 5]

Interesting for both it's accuracies and inaccuracies and the insight provided on the medieval point of view of foreign cultures. Unfortunately, Polo tends to simplify nearly every culture he encounters into one very large pot. In example, he seems to be under the impression that all 'idolaters' (read non-christians, non-muslims, non-jews) all follow one giant pan-asian religion. These kind of assumptions make a lot of his observations nearly useless, revealing more about the author than the subject.

Add to that the fact that a great deal of the information is based on hearsay and presented as unvarnished truth while being demonstrably false. Polo's assertion of a Mongol victory over the Tran Dynasty in what would become Vietnam is a good example of an outright falsehood present as truth.

Lastly, the writing style can be summarized as "This is what I'm going to tell you. This is what I'm telling you. This is what I just told you." Multiplied and repeated ad nauseam for every. single. subject. This combined with Polo's tendency to reuse entire passages applied to different subjects repeatedly makes for an often frustrating and uninteresting read.

[Nova · Rating 2 out of 5]

هنوز شک هایی وجود دارد مبنی بر این که مارکوپولو اصلا پا فراتر از سمرقند نگذاشته باشد و در واقع، روایات و اسطوره های شرقی و آثار نویسنده های عربی منبع الهام و هیزم تخیل او بوده باشند.
نپرداختن به عناصر اصلی تمدن چین و هند از گواهان این گمانند؛ آنجا که نه سخنی از کشت وسیع چای رفته و نه کلمه ای از شیوه های منحصر بفرد ماهیگیری و زراعت چینیان؛ و اما در نیمی از سفرنامه با تکرار "ایمان، تقوا، عمل صالح"وار صفات و عباراتی برای تعمیم به سرزمین های پیموده (یا ناپیموده) سر و ته داستان را هم آورده بود .
سفرنامه ی مارکوپولو حتی در دوران خود چندان شناخته شده نبود و در مقایسه با سفرنامه های مشابه از سیاحانی که به مشرق زمین سفر کرده بودند (مانند دوماندویل)، از محبوبیت کمتری برخوردار بود. به عبارتی کسی آن را جدی نمیگرفت و این هم از صدقه سر حکایات هزراویکشبی مهیج لا به لای توصیفات بود که به نظر غیر واقعی می امدند.

شاید بشود گفت این کتاب تا حدودی جمع اضداد است. جذابیت هایی دارد و نقطه ضعف هایی هم. ارزش تاریخی بسیار دارد ولی ارزش ادبی اندک.

[Jenny]

⭐️ if you are expecting non-fiction
⭐️⭐️ if you are expecting action
⭐️⭐️⭐️ if you are expecting cultural insights
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ if you are into empire administration
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ if you suffer from insomnia

[Adam McPhee · Rating 2 out of 5]

What more shall I tell you? The town consists of Saracens and idolaters with a few Nestorian Christians. The people use paper (or salt) for money and the idolaters burn their dead. They trade in zinc, oil, lamb and peat. Their king is very wealthy and pays a tribute to the Great Khan. There is a sort of monkey that lives in the forests that sounds like a parrot but is unable to bend its knees.

That's not actually a paragraph from The Travels, but I swear to god it could be. There's a few good parts but it gets very monotonous. I did a thread on the cool parts here.

[Ehsan'Shokraie' · Rating 5 out of 5]

خواندن این کتاب برای بار دوم هم بی نهایت لذت بخش بود, این ریویو رو یه بامداد بارانی از هواپیما مینویسم..گاهی ریویو ها هم داستان خودشون رو دارند.

[Literarischunterwegs · Rating 4 out of 5]

Marco Polo, Sohn einer venezianischen Händlerfamilie, ist ein Reisender in der Welt. Vater und Onkel, die ebenfalls Reisende waren, begründeten wohl sein Faible fürs Reisen.
Das Buch beinhaltet Marco Polos Reise in den Fernen Osten. Es stellt keine chronologische Abfolge da, sondern beschreibt einzelne Gebiete, Orte und Völker in ihren Lebensweisen.
Gegliedert ist das Buch in folgende Teile:
1. Einführung in das Buch – Die Beschreibung der Welt und Die Wunder der Welt“
Hier werden die Personen und Verwandtschaftskonstellationen sowie das Buch selbst vorgestellt.
2. Die Beschreibung von Klein – Armenien
Hier lernt der Leser die wichtigsten Personen, Landschaften, Städte, Lebensumstände sowie Sitten und Gebräuche kennen.
3. Das Buch über Indien, über seine Wunder und seine Menschen
Im Zentrum stehen die verschiedenen Königreiche, deren Herrscher und Schlachten.

Laut Wikipedia kam der Titel des Buches folgendermaßen zustande: (…) Der Titel der ursprünglichen Handschrift des Werkes war Französisch und lautete vermutlich Le livre de Marco Polo citoyen de Venise, dit Million, où l'on conte les merveilles du monde („Das Buch des Marco Polo, Bürger der Stadt Venedig, genannt Milione, worin von den Wundern der Welt berichtet wird“) (…)

Seine Reiseberichte sind nicht ohne Zweifel glaubwürdig, da sie wohl auch falsche und unklare Angaben enthalten. Die Wissenschaft streitet sich hier bis heute, um eine klare Aussage. Daher gilt das Buch noch immer als sehr umstritten.
Aber auch wenn dies so ist, so liest es sich sehr schön und wäre ich ein Autor von Märchen oder Fantacy-Büchern, wäre es mir ein schier unerschöpflicher Quell an Ideen.

Il Milione liest sich wie eine Verbindung aus Märchenbuch, Reisebericht, Personen- und Städteregister und Sach- und Geschichtsbuch. Ein bisschen erinnern mich die Berichte an die Reiseführer von Baedeker, bzw. all jene, die viel Kulturelles miteinfließen lassen.

Selbstredend ist zu erwähnen, dass dieses Werk nur ein Ausgangspukt sein kann für diejenigen, die sich eingängiger mit dieser Thematik beschäftigen möchten. Zu viele Aspekte bleiben zwangsläufig an der Oberfläche bzw. müssten genauer eruiert werden, wenn das Buch von Personen wie mir gelesen wird, deren geschichtlicher Hintergrund in diesem Bereich nicht so ausgereift ist, dass zu allem direkt Bezüge und reale Fakten während des Lesens erscheinen, die zum Gelesenen in Beziehung gesetzt werden können. Hin und wieder ploppten bei mir solche Aspekte auf, aber leider nicht durchgängig.

[Metin Yılmaz · Rating 5 out of 5]

Bizlere o zamanları anlattığı için çok kıymetl bir kitap. Her ne kadar her söylediği doğru olmasa da, anlatılanların bir kısmı diğer seyyahlar tarafından onaylanan olaylar. Tabi abartı olmazsa olmazı. Fakat bu inandırıcılığu etkileyen bir faktör olduğu kadar, yalanın hemen anlaşılmasına da fırsat veriyor. Bu tip bir abartıda hemen anlıyorsunuz ki o durum öyle değil.