While his up close and personal recollections of the AIDS crisis certainly pack the biggest emotional punch, Alvin Orloff’s memoir Disasterama is so much more than merely a document of a dark time in America’s recent past. It’s the funny, colorful, poignant, smart, sometimes outrageous and surprisingly relatable story of a shy, geeky kid from the ‘burbs who finds his tribe and comes into his own in the big city (in this case, San Francisco). I’m just about the same age as Mr. Orloff so his story of discovering art and music as a teen in the early 1980’s really resonated with me. His memories of looking for love (and sex) at clubs while dancing to Gang of Four, Joy Division and the Flying Lizards in his funky vintage thrift shop clothes brought back fond memories of my own misspent youth clubbing at Danceteria, Maxwell’s and Hurrahs. I think anyone who wants to get a real flavor of (or reminisce about) that era will enjoy reading Orloff’s adventures.
I’ve read similar LGBTQ memoirs that might fall into the same category (notably, Wayne County’s Man Enough to be a Woman), yet what gives Orloff’s book its particular charm is that he comes across as a very down-to-earth and oddly “normal” person. Even his longstanding gig as a go-go boy and a brief foray into porn don’t come across as sleazy simply because he presents them in such a matter-of-fact way. Unlike County, he never seems to be saying, “Look at how outrageous I am!” That said, much of the story chronicles the artistic pursuits of the author, his circle of club kid friends and their ad hoc leader, “Diet Popstitute” (ne Michael Collins). In their heyday, they formed a pop group (the Popstitutes), hosted an ambitious cabaret night held at various Bay Area venues (Klubstitute), published ‘zines and mounted elaborate avant garde theater productions. This is certainly the lightest and most entertaining part of the book, before the inevitable specter of AIDS crashes the party and brings everything tumbling down.
In the 1980s and 1990s I read quite a bit of LGBT fiction. I devoured all genres - drama, romance, erotica, humor, mystery, coming out and coming of age, yet steadfastly avoided anything specifically about AIDS because it was just too disturbing. This book finally forced me to look at that horrific period in history and truly understand how devastating it was. The reader experiences the spread of the disease through Orloff’s eyes as he first learns about its existence, then as it afflicts men he’s seen around but doesn’t really know, as it moves on to those on the fringes of his circle, then to men he’s had brief or casual encounters with and eventually to former lovers and close friends. I can hardly imagine the magnitude of it or how frightening it must have been. As the story draws to a close, what started out as a quirky romp takes a turn for the heartbreaking. Orloff really takes the reader on an emotional journey with this book.
This is a terrific memoir and highly recommended.