Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Black Lives, Native Lands, White Worlds: A History of Slavery in New England

Rate this book
Shortly after the first Europeans arrived in seventeenth-century New England, they began to import Africans and capture the area's indigenous peoples as slaves. By the eve of the American Revolution, enslaved people comprised only about 4 percent of the population, but slavery had become instrumental to the region's economy and had shaped its cultural traditions. This story of slavery in New England has been little told.

In this concise yet comprehensive history, Jared Ross Hardesty focuses on the individual stories of enslaved people, bringing their experiences to life. He also explores larger issues such as the importance of slavery to the colonization of the region and to agriculture and industry, New England's deep connections to Caribbean plantation societies, and the significance of emancipation movements in the era of the American Revolution. Thoroughly researched and engagingly written, Black Lives, Native Lands, White Worlds is a must-read for anyone interested in the history of New England.

198 pages, Hardcover

Published September 9, 2019

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jared Ross Hardesty

4 books4 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
17 (24%)
4 stars
33 (47%)
3 stars
19 (27%)
2 stars
0 (0%)
1 star
1 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews
Profile Image for Edith.
552 reviews
May 27, 2020
3 1/2 stars.

This is a difficult book to review and thus a difficult book to rate. Thinking about it falls, for me, into two parts.

First, that this book saw the light of day in its present state ought to bring shame to Bright Leaf, the publisher, an imprint of the University of Massachusetts Press. It is full of tangled paragraphs and grammar and language usage that is bad not just because it's incorrect, but because it makes the author's thoughts confusing and sometimes even comical. (Hardesty on page 91 has black women milking cattle and black men rustling them, when he means in the first instance "cows" and in the second, "wrangling" or something similar.) The publisher did not serve the author well; it appears that he got very little editorial advice or assistance. This subject deserves much, much better than this.*

My impression of the author, Jared Ross Hardesty, is that he has done a very respectable job of research and is justly moved by the story he has uncovered and wants to tell us. But he has not organized his material in a way that makes it easy to grasp. He goes back and forth in time, and sometimes in place, in a way that makes it hard, for me at least, to grasp what kinds of things are happening when, and to really understand and compare the statistics he offers. He sometimes makes assertions without support, which are not footnoted (although there are footnotes).

But...

Second, in spite of the problems I've mentioned, there is a lot to be learned from this book. I grew up in Massachusetts in the the middle of the last century, and I can tell you, as young students we learned little or nothing of the black presence in New England or in our state. We were taught that Massachusetts' small farms and industries were not places where slaves would have been very helpful, and were left with the impression that the few slaves there were were completely free at the time of the Revolution. A brief flirtation with slavery, but we thought better of it. Massachusetts' constitution, after all, had been framed by John Adams, had freed our slaves. We were not like the South.

Of course, as it turns out, slavery itself, and the money to be made from trafficking slaves, were foundational to the prosperity of the New England area from the earliest times. Rhode Island was the commercial center of slave-dealing in the western hemisphere. The triangular trade in sugar, rum, and slaves (the one thing we did learn about in school) was the basis of many fortunes in the northeast. Slaves were numerous in NE urban areas, doing a wide variety of jobs, and were a presence in interior areas where they were involved in agriculture and animal husbandry, among many other things. Even the much-lauded emancipation turned out to be a painfully gradual process. A change in the nature of the labor force at the time of the Revolution was as significant in ending slavery in New England as the cries for abolition, according to Hardesty.

One big difference between southern and northern slavery appears to have been the Puritan insistence that everyone, even servants and enslaved people, be able to read the Bible. Northeastern enslaved people had the advantage of literacy. As a result, they were better able to understand and evaluate events and take advantage of them.

If you were to ask me whether, with the problems I think it has, it's worthwhile to read this book, I would say, in spite of the many irritated underlinings and exclamation marks in the margins of my copy, that it is. These things, however clumsily packaged, are worth knowing.
____________________________
* Bright Leaf describes its mission: "Bright Leaf, an imprint of the University of Massachusetts Press, publishes insightful and entertaining books about New England. Written for a popular audience, Bright Leaf books explore a myriad of subjects that highlight the history, culture, diversity, and environment of the region." There is nothing wrong with this. But to place a book with a subject such as this in a category with books on birdwatching, sightseeing, and Boston's bicycling renaissance seems a profound error in judgment.
300 reviews1 follower
July 17, 2024
By the time of the Civil War, the New England states were known to be home to abolitionists and to many free Black intellectuals and activists. Yet, New England history is not unstained by slavery.  In fact, Colonial New England was one of the earliest places in British North America where the practice of enslaving Africans and codifying their dependent status occured.  This slim but informative volume offers an outline of slavery in New England.

While the number of slaves in New England was small relative to the Southern colonies, there were greater concentrations in larger cities such as Boston, Newport, and Bristol where the Black population approached 10%, and even more rural communities such as Deerfield.  As a result of enslaved people being held in more urban areas, they were less likely to work in agriculture but in a great variety of skilled and unskilled labor such as building trades, shipbuilding, distilling, and as sailors.  Enslavers could hire out their enslaved people for extra income, and Hardesty even details the practice of self-hiring when enslaved people would take on jobs of their interest (sharing a percentage of their income with their masters).  Some Black people earned money to buy their freedom in this way.

Blacks were not the only people held as slaves, as New England colonists captured Native people and traded them to Caribbean colonies. In at least one instant, Carolina Indians were held as slaves in New England.  Apart from direct slave ownership, New Englanders were deeply invested in the trade and trafficking of slaves in Africa and the West Indies, particularly in the port cities of Rhode Island.  Even the common people profited by this trade by investing into shares of the slave ships.

The most illuminating part of this book is that it tells the personal stories of several enslaved and free Black people in New England.  Their is Belinda Sutton who successfully petitioned the Massachusetts legislature for reparations for her captivity by the Royall family of Medford.  Venture Smith had three different masters, learned a variety of trades, and eventually saved up to purchase his freedom. Onesimus, held by Cotton Mather, steadfastly refused to convert to Christianity.  Briton Hammon wrote a narrative of his life as a sailor. And Elizabeth Freeman and Quock Walker established the precedent for judicial emancipation in Massachusetts by filing suits under the commonwealth's new constitution of 1780.

This is an excellent and important work of popular history that should be read by anyone studying the history of New England, slavery, and Black Americans.

Favorite Passages:
“Most Africans who ended up in the region came from two places in Africa: the Gold Coast and Senegambia in the northern part of sub-Saharan Africa.” – p. 46

“Unlike our modern world, New England before the American Revolution was not a place of universal freedom. Rather multiple forms of dependence characterized society. Slavery, although an extreme and uniquely violent form of subjugation, existed alongside more traditional forms of bondage such as indentured servitude, apprenticeship, and marriage.  Almost everyone living in New England would have been in a state of dependence at some point in their lives, and at no given time was less than 60 percent of the total population legally bound in some way.” – p. 52
Profile Image for Christine Kinzfogl.
109 reviews
January 3, 2026
4.5 ⭐️

really short (150 pages) which makes it easier to digest, but definitely just an introduction to the topic.
i learned so much actually!! the chapters were broken up into the actual passage across the atlantic (and how that commerce worked in the context of new englands economy), the work that enslaved people did, how they made community, and then eventual emancipation.

i would recommend this to anyone who has ties to new england.

i loved most, was the amount of primary sources. plenty of slaves could read and write in new england (they would be trained so they could perform labor better), so there was a lot of first person accounts. or just newspapers from the era, so interesting to see.

-0.5 bc it wasn’t exactly a page turner haha. easy read! digestible! but i’m not gonna rate a nonfiction book 5 stars unless they make me feel some suspense
Profile Image for John.
1,013 reviews134 followers
February 26, 2020
This is really great, and very handy for teaching. It could conceivably be assigned to undergraduates, which I am seriously considering for next year - I think a focus on urban, northern slavery would make a lot of sense in a general Atlantic History-type class. This is also short and grounded in the stories of individual people. It has worked very well for me this semester as a guide for which primary sources to look for as I provide readings and lectures to my students. There was a need for this book too - there isn't really another one like it. There is this book called "Complicity" that I read a few years ago, but that is more about how northerners profited from southern slavery, rather than about the whole generations-long experience of slavery in the north.
Profile Image for Judalon Bornay.
Author 1 book5 followers
June 16, 2021
After listening to the author on C-Span, I bought the book for my history-teaching reference library.
If you teach or are a serious student of American history, you need to read this book, unpack the information and check the notes and bibliography. A must-have! If you are a person who wants to understand deep, old roots of enslavement in colonial America, you should read this book. It will change your perspective on everything.
Profile Image for Noah.
292 reviews2 followers
July 29, 2021
I definitely appreciated this book for illuminating some of the unique characteristics of New England slavery. However, I felt that Hardesty was too hazy on the enslaved people have agency v. “Happy Slave” line.
Profile Image for Jessy.
14 reviews
August 8, 2021
The book was well researched and it gave a great historical view of what enslaved peoples had to endure during four centuries of slavery. It gives written accounts of slavers and bonded men & women. This book also gives the reader insight in the practice of slavery, the commencement and ongoings of slave-trading, the trauma enslavement caused, and the changes in legality surrounding slavery. A good read for anyone wanting a more truthful examination of United State’s less than impeccable past.
Profile Image for Jocelyn.
207 reviews2 followers
November 22, 2019
Really good introduction to the history of enslavement in New England.
44 reviews
July 1, 2026
genuinely why would anyone read these books outside of an academic perspective. despite it being 150 pages it took me AGES to finish
Profile Image for Poppy.
158 reviews3 followers
December 30, 2025
This is an okay book. I think it would work well for undergrads. it avoids historical jargon and really doesnt get into too many historiographical debates. I wish i read his other book, Unfreedom instead, as I feel like it seems more aligned with what I need right now. Nonetheless it was okay. Some sweeping comments, minimal citations, and--perhaps most problematically--barely any discussion of indigenous peoples? Weird considering its in the subtitle....
Displaying 1 - 12 of 12 reviews