Well, this didn't necessarily turn out as planned. Harry Potter: A History of Magic promises to showcase the magical traditions that lie at the heart of Harry Potter's world. I'm not really sure if this catalogue lives up to its claim.
Personally, I would've preferred it if this book had really looked into all of those myths, creatures and people that inspired J.K. Rowling. It would have been such an enrichment if the curators would have tied these traditions to what is written in Potter rather than treating all of them in a very superficial manner without analyzing their significance.
This book was not particularly informative if you we're looking for a deeper analysis of J.K. Rowling's work. Instead it functions more as an introduction and general overview to different beliefs about magic and the hunt of fantastical creatures and objects throughout history. All of which is just loosely if at all tied to Potter. I found this very disappointing because I thought that so much potential was wasted. I get that this catalogue is also targeted at a younger audience, nonetheless, I don't think it would've hurt to spend more time on less artifacts and discuss their use properly.
Despite all of this, a three-star-rating is still appropriate since the catalogue could score in other areas. The main reason why I enjoyed myself whilst reading it were definitely the pictures. All of them were printed in full color and in the highest quality. It was fascinating to see every single detail.
Additionally, many of Rowling's personal illustrations and manuscripts were included in the catalogue. This was most definitely another highlight for me since I am a die-hard Potter-fan. Seeing all of these alternate versions, deleted scenes and unpublished drawings actually made my heart sing. It was a pity that Rowling's handwriting was so hard to read at times (I found it super fascinating btw that she was still plotting by hand and not on her computer when Hallows was in the making) and that some of her manuscripts weren't given the space they deserved, e.g. a DIN A4 page was at times printed as a DIN A6 (or even smaller) in this catalogue which made the writing almost impossible to decipher.
Anyways, I thought it would be fun to share some of the more interesting revelations:
1) Merpeople were intended to appear at the beginning of Chamber of Secrets before Rowling changed her mind. In a draft chapter the Ford Anglia flown by Ron and Harry originally crashed into the lake rather than into the Whomping Willow, leading them to see their first mermaid.
2) By 1991, Rowling had already fully envisioned the appearance of the Dursleys, Rubeus Hagrid, Peeves and many other side characters. I was aware that the idea for Potter came to her on a train to London in 1990 but I didn't know that her vision was already so clear this early on. It was truly fascinating to see her personal illustrations; a favorite of mine was definitely her portrait of Madame Sprout which she drew the night her own mother died.
3) Alice Newton, the daughter of Nigel Newton, the chairman of Bloomsbury Publishing, made the publication of Philosopher's Stone possible. She was given an early manuscript that led up as far as Diagon Alley and then pressured her father to bring home the whole thing.
4) J.K. Rowling had many different ideas as to how the sorting at Hogwarts would work. She envisioned sorting by the statues of the four founders, or the ghost court, or prefects with the respective heads of houses, or by letting the first year students solve a riddle. Eventually she came to the realization: 'Forget that, just put the hat on.' ;)
5) In an early draft, she wrote the character of Fudge as a Muggle Minister who was visited by Hagrid (on behalf of Dumbeldore) to warn him about Voldemort. She also drafted Vernon Dursley as a high ranking Muggle politician who wanted to take Fudge's place. They had some serious bonding moments over being the only two muggles in the know about wizards. It was quite hilarious!
6) And lastly, she originally intended the names of Dumbledore's Army and The Order of the Phoenix to be swapped. Oh well, that would've been weird.
Overall, it was fun to read Harry Potter: A History of Magic and even though it didn't grant me the insight and knowledge that I craved, I still wouldn't wanna miss this beautifully crafted coffee table book in my collection.