The book, as a story, was great quality. The book, as a guide for those currently suffering/possibly on the verge of or aftermath of a breakdown, not so good. This is why: When suffering from mental illness, the simplest of tasks seem daunting. You are faced with constant overwhelm. In these times, you need simplicity. The book is extremely detailed (too detailed to be simple) and written in quite small text with tight spacing. This visual would immediately put
some off even starting. I understand that mental illness is anything but simple, but when affected, you do need to feel like you are not being jammed with too much information, and information that isn’t all over the place. The author, being a writer and editor of many years, perhaps forgets that he wants the book to be accessible to the majority of people. I’m an English graduate, and I had to look up some of the words and phrases he used. At times, it seems completely unnecessary to use these words and especially the French phrases. This is supposed to be a book on mental illness and how to overcome it, but I feel like he also tries to educate us on philosophy, languages, and other such things. It can come across as ‘showing off’ although clearly not his intention. Considering its subject, it’s all a bit ... too much. Now, on to the good things.
There is such variety in this story, that you certainly won’t be short of ideas for how to care for yourself. Although in danger of having so many choices you could shut down and not try any of them, it could work the other way and provide you with lots of ideas if your current regime isn’t working. He gives practical advice too, shares advice from professionals and friends (sometimes both) and lists phone numbers you can call for help. This is all important stuff.
The book is broken down into three parts: Rock Bottom, Recovery, and Mental Health (meaning, ‘good’ mental health and how to stay there). This helps in breaking down the information and also pulling the information together as a whole. There is a page or two of suggested readings at the back, which I love, including some of the texts he mentions in the body of the book.
In summary, the book has been branded as a ‘guide’ when really, to me, it’s an autobiography with bits of practical advice. It is too much of an information overload to help someone who is genuinely in a crisis, and not as structured as it could be. On the other hand, it is honest, mostly down-to-earth and helpful in lots of places. For those who are willing to put in the time to read this, and are not in an immediate crisis situation, there are benefits you will be sure to reap. A unique read amongst what is currently available in the genre.