What do you think?
Rate this book
Inspector Ian Rutledge #22
A Divided Loyalty
Scotland Yard detective Ian Rutledge is assigned one of the most baffling investigations of his career—a cold murder case with an unidentified victim and a cold trail with few clues to follow.
Chief Inspector Brian Leslie, a respected colleague of Ian Rutledge’s, is sent to Avebury, a village set inside a great prehistoric stone circle not far from Stonehenge.
A young woman has been murdered next to a mysterious, hooded, figure-like stone, but no one recognizes her—or admits to it. And how did she get there? Despite a thorough investigation, it appears that her killer has simply vanished.
Rutledge, returning from the conclusion of a case involving another apparently unknown woman, is asked to take a second look at Leslie’s inquiry, to see if he can identify this victim. But Rutledge is convinced Chief Superintendent Jameson only hopes to tarnish his earlier success once he also fails.
Where to begin? He too finds very little to go on in Avebury, slowly widening his search beyond the village—only to discover that unlikely—possibly even unreliable—clues are pointing him toward an impossible solution, one that will draw the wrath of the Yard down on him, and very likely see him dismissed if he pursues it. But what about the victim—what does he owe this tragic woman? Where must his loyalty lie?
Chief Inspector Brian Leslie, a respected colleague of Ian Rutledge’s, is sent to Avebury, a village set inside a great prehistoric stone circle not far from Stonehenge.
A young woman has been murdered next to a mysterious, hooded, figure-like stone, but no one recognizes her—or admits to it. And how did she get there? Despite a thorough investigation, it appears that her killer has simply vanished.
Rutledge, returning from the conclusion of a case involving another apparently unknown woman, is asked to take a second look at Leslie’s inquiry, to see if he can identify this victim. But Rutledge is convinced Chief Superintendent Jameson only hopes to tarnish his earlier success once he also fails.
Where to begin? He too finds very little to go on in Avebury, slowly widening his search beyond the village—only to discover that unlikely—possibly even unreliable—clues are pointing him toward an impossible solution, one that will draw the wrath of the Yard down on him, and very likely see him dismissed if he pursues it. But what about the victim—what does he owe this tragic woman? Where must his loyalty lie?
328 pages, Hardcover
First published February 4, 2020
1665 people are currently reading
7637 people want to read
About the author
Charles Todd
102 books3,563 followersCharles Todd was the pen name used by the mother-and-son writing team, Caroline Todd and Charles Todd. Now, Charles writes the Ian Rutledge and Bess Crawford Series. Charles Todd ha spublished three standalone mystery novels and many short stories.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 738 reviews
February 19, 2020
I am delighted to see that Charles Todd (the writing duo) is back in a great style. I have been a fan of the Rutledge series for many years now, and in my opinion Book 22 is one of the best in it. It is 1921 and Ian Rutledge is tasked with finding a murderer of a woman whose body is found in a stone circle in Avebury, ancient though not that famous as Stonehenge. The investigation was originally conducted by Chief Inspector Leslie who failed to track down the murderer. This case will test Ian's loyalty to the extreme.
I always enjoy the way Rutledge analyzes each clue and puts puzzle pieces correctly. This and his quiet though disturbed by the past personality make me reach out for every offering by the writing duo.
I always enjoy the way Rutledge analyzes each clue and puts puzzle pieces correctly. This and his quiet though disturbed by the past personality make me reach out for every offering by the writing duo.
March 4, 2020
3.5 Another long running series of mine, this one historical. A slower paced book, since it's set shortly after WWI, and all detective work needs to be done by interviewing and traveling place to place. Ian Rutledge is the main character, a detective who carries with him, quite literally, the effects of the war.
As with many long running series, some have been better than others. In this one I felt the author is back on track, and I enjoyed the two different cases Rutledge must solve. Two young women murdered, in two separate locations, one easier and less costly to solve than the other. The second case presents a more difficult resolution, one that hits close to home.
Atmospheric, a mystery that can't be hurried through, rather one to emesh oneself in during long evenings.
ARC from Edelweiss.
As with many long running series, some have been better than others. In this one I felt the author is back on track, and I enjoyed the two different cases Rutledge must solve. Two young women murdered, in two separate locations, one easier and less costly to solve than the other. The second case presents a more difficult resolution, one that hits close to home.
Atmospheric, a mystery that can't be hurried through, rather one to emesh oneself in during long evenings.
ARC from Edelweiss.
December 12, 2019
It has been a pleasure to be back in the capable hands of the mother/son duo who comprise Charles Todd. I have been away too long. At this point in Inspector Ian Rutledge’s story it has been some three years or so since the end of the war and his return to Scotland Yard. Those years have not been easy as he continues to live with the side effects of the shell shock he suffered during trench warfare. And he continues to have Hamish as a constant vocal reminder of his worst wartime memory.
While quotations are not encouraged from ARCs as texts may change prior to publication, there is one that I want to include as it is so much a part of Rutledge and his daily existence.
Shell shock, it was called. Breaking under fire. But Rutledge
couldn’t accept that he’d been the lone survivor... He’d sacrificed one
to save the many. For Nothing. And when the war was over Hamish
came home with Rutledge in the only way possible. Not as a ghost,
not as a living man, but as a voice that haunted Rutledge night and
day. A reminder of that night. Survivors guilt, Dr. Fleming had called
it. Seeing in Hamish MacLeod all the many dead he’d sent into battle...
...and the voice hadn’t faded with the Armistice. Dr. Fleming...had
also warned him that it might never stop... (p 25)
In this episode, Rutledge has completed a complicated murder inquiry when he is tasked with re-investigating the murder of an unidentified woman found near one of the standing stones at Avebury in Wiltshire. The original investigating officer is someone Ian knows reasonably well, as well as his superior at the Yard, so the situation has the potential to be awkward. The investigation begins and Rutledge and the reader learn about the town and setting of Avebury, the stones and other early sites in the area. All contribute to the story, the attempt to identify the woman, etc. Why was she killed, and why in Avebury of all places?
As with the books in the series I have read before, this novel is well written, includes psychological insights on many characters, not only Rutledge, has a good sense of history, and well done settings.
I recommend this book highly and, personally, I intend to return and read those few episodes I have neglected, some of which are waiting on my kindle.
I received a copy of A Divided Loyalty through the Goodreads Giveaway program. The review is my own.
While quotations are not encouraged from ARCs as texts may change prior to publication, there is one that I want to include as it is so much a part of Rutledge and his daily existence.
Shell shock, it was called. Breaking under fire. But Rutledge
couldn’t accept that he’d been the lone survivor... He’d sacrificed one
to save the many. For Nothing. And when the war was over Hamish
came home with Rutledge in the only way possible. Not as a ghost,
not as a living man, but as a voice that haunted Rutledge night and
day. A reminder of that night. Survivors guilt, Dr. Fleming had called
it. Seeing in Hamish MacLeod all the many dead he’d sent into battle...
...and the voice hadn’t faded with the Armistice. Dr. Fleming...had
also warned him that it might never stop... (p 25)
In this episode, Rutledge has completed a complicated murder inquiry when he is tasked with re-investigating the murder of an unidentified woman found near one of the standing stones at Avebury in Wiltshire. The original investigating officer is someone Ian knows reasonably well, as well as his superior at the Yard, so the situation has the potential to be awkward. The investigation begins and Rutledge and the reader learn about the town and setting of Avebury, the stones and other early sites in the area. All contribute to the story, the attempt to identify the woman, etc. Why was she killed, and why in Avebury of all places?
As with the books in the series I have read before, this novel is well written, includes psychological insights on many characters, not only Rutledge, has a good sense of history, and well done settings.
I recommend this book highly and, personally, I intend to return and read those few episodes I have neglected, some of which are waiting on my kindle.
I received a copy of A Divided Loyalty through the Goodreads Giveaway program. The review is my own.
March 16, 2020
The mother-and-son writing team outdid themselves on this occasion! I was truly creeped out by the description of the barrow and even lost sleep over it! This series has been consistently good, however, I think this volume might be my favorite! It held me enthralled until the final word.
Here are my favorite passages:
"He sat down in the nearest chair starring at memory." This resonated with me as someone who often sits quietly contemplating.
"there was something...not a haunting...the imprint of an ancient people." This was part of a deliciously creepy description of the chambered long barrow (an ancient burial place) near the village of Avebury in Wiltshire, UK.
Here are my favorite passages:
"He sat down in the nearest chair starring at memory." This resonated with me as someone who often sits quietly contemplating.
"there was something...not a haunting...the imprint of an ancient people." This was part of a deliciously creepy description of the chambered long barrow (an ancient burial place) near the village of Avebury in Wiltshire, UK.
April 30, 2020
It's 3.5 stars but I can't round it up because of all the repeated and repeated redundancies re Ian's war experience, past regretted deeds and all the other WWI "voices" heard holdovers. You got that for the first 7 or 8 books in this series and by making such a "flashback" prequel- it encompasses just too much repetition to me.
The cases were well done, but there is so much travel and inquiry here too that it just gets same/same and extremely slow. Yet I feel that the crux crossed within the workplace duplicity made up for the endless stops, renting rooms etc. And I felt that Kate at least got a luncheon.
Knowing these people and how staid Ian is- I just think within London itself makes this particular series far more dishy and carved. Avebury and all the road time, just not so much. And there was a passage near the beginning of the book that completely gave away what the perp situation was in the more interesting case- which I find took quite a bit of the interest out of me.
Still, the Rutledge world does take you away to a well formed prose story of another time and place in which all the tiny details so much more matter. It always amazes me how much they can tell re class, role in life JUST from the victim's custom made clothing, shoes, hats etc.
The cases were well done, but there is so much travel and inquiry here too that it just gets same/same and extremely slow. Yet I feel that the crux crossed within the workplace duplicity made up for the endless stops, renting rooms etc. And I felt that Kate at least got a luncheon.
Knowing these people and how staid Ian is- I just think within London itself makes this particular series far more dishy and carved. Avebury and all the road time, just not so much. And there was a passage near the beginning of the book that completely gave away what the perp situation was in the more interesting case- which I find took quite a bit of the interest out of me.
Still, the Rutledge world does take you away to a well formed prose story of another time and place in which all the tiny details so much more matter. It always amazes me how much they can tell re class, role in life JUST from the victim's custom made clothing, shoes, hats etc.
January 13, 2020
**I won this novel from a giveaway on GoodReads and was asked for an honest review**
This is my first read by authors; Charles Todd. This novel is also #22 in the series, "Inspector Ian Rutledge". Even though this novel is #22 in the series, the authors did an excellent job in not letting the reader feel lost with the characters and if I didn't know any better this novel could easily be a stand alone novel. The story is set in England, 1921 just after WWI. The main character is a very likable Scotland Yard Inspector and the reader gets that feeling that you are right there with him attempting to solve several mysteries/murders. I really did enjoy this novel from beginning to end, the authors really had me guessing at every turn of the page. For anyone interested in the genres of; crime, fiction, historical fiction, and/or mystery then I would recommend these authors and series.
This is my first read by authors; Charles Todd. This novel is also #22 in the series, "Inspector Ian Rutledge". Even though this novel is #22 in the series, the authors did an excellent job in not letting the reader feel lost with the characters and if I didn't know any better this novel could easily be a stand alone novel. The story is set in England, 1921 just after WWI. The main character is a very likable Scotland Yard Inspector and the reader gets that feeling that you are right there with him attempting to solve several mysteries/murders. I really did enjoy this novel from beginning to end, the authors really had me guessing at every turn of the page. For anyone interested in the genres of; crime, fiction, historical fiction, and/or mystery then I would recommend these authors and series.
January 17, 2020
The Year 1921 after the War.
Scotland Yards detective Ian Rutledge was assigned to a cold murder case with few clues.
When letters were found in a secret place, Chief Inspector Brian Leslie was baffled. Someone had forged his signature and handwriting.
He was protecting his wife, but in the long run the blame was on him.
I want to thank Harper Collins Publishing Incl for sending me this interesting book.
Scotland Yards detective Ian Rutledge was assigned to a cold murder case with few clues.
When letters were found in a secret place, Chief Inspector Brian Leslie was baffled. Someone had forged his signature and handwriting.
He was protecting his wife, but in the long run the blame was on him.
I want to thank Harper Collins Publishing Incl for sending me this interesting book.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 22, 2019
Excellent is an understatement! I have followed Ian Rutledge since book one and have loved all the stories of cases he has solved. This is byfar the best of them all. Ian Rutledge (the main character) is like a dog with a bone, he doesn't stop until he has all the answers to solve his case no matter the cost. I don't know how two people can weave a tale the way "Charles Todd" does but it is a work of genius. If you have never read any of their many books before you are in for a real treat. Thank you!
January 20, 2021
My uneven reading of this series continues. I started well beyond the beginning and read a few more here and there. Some left me interested in continuing, others were difficult just to get through.
After the last one I thought I would try one more before quitting the series. So I started this one and enjoyed it all the way through. So I see I’ll be continuing a little further. I could get settled into this series with more like this one--dark without being dismal, complex without being convoluted, a strong plot well paced.
After the last one I thought I would try one more before quitting the series. So I started this one and enjoyed it all the way through. So I see I’ll be continuing a little further. I could get settled into this series with more like this one--dark without being dismal, complex without being convoluted, a strong plot well paced.
January 21, 2020
Series: Inspector Ian Rutledge #22
Publication Date: 2/4/2020
Number of Pages: 336
Betrayal, shock, dismay, regret, and sadness are all felt by Ian Rutledge as he solves his latest case. As always, the story is well-written and excellently plotted with twists and turns throughout. While this is the twenty-second book in the series, it can easily be read as a standalone – but since it is a great series, I’m sure you’ll want to run right out and get some of the earlier books. Ian is one of those characters that you really come to like and wish the best for him – all the while knowing how he suffers from the war. Not all wounds can be seen on the outside.
It is February of 1921 and Ian Rutledge, along with most of England, is still trying to put the war behind him. Although the war ended in November of 1918, Ian is still suffering greatly from shell shock. Balancing his duties as a Scotland Yard inspector and managing his symptoms is definitely not for the faint of heart. After his last big case, The Black Ascot, he is still in disfavor with his superiors and he knows he has to walk on eggshells for a while. After all, the Chief Superintendent still has his letter of resignation in his desk drawer and has let Ian know that he’ll pull it out and accept it at the slightest misstep.
After wrapping up a case in Shropshire, Ian was called into Chief Superintendent Markham’s office. Ian’s new assignment was to take a second look at a case that Chief Inspector Brian Leslie hadn’t been able to solve. Leslie was an excellent investigator as well as a friend and colleague, so Ian was sure that nothing had been missed in the investigation and was a little resentful to have been given the assignment. However, it was his assignment now so he’d best be off to Avebury.
Avebury is a bit of an eerie place as it is built in the center of an ancient stone circle. The body of the murdered woman was found at the foot of one of those stones. Ian retraces the steps taken by Leslie and discovers he is finding the same things as Leslie did. However, Ian is like a dog with a bone – he just doesn’t turn loose. As he stretches his imagination to picture how the murder could occur, how the murderer got the victim to where she was murdered without being seen and a myriad of other things – the clues just don’t add up. He slowly begins to suspect the unthinkable – yet there is no way to prove any of it.
Ian is drawn to the lovely young woman who was murdered. It pains him, and the rest of Avebury, to know that this young woman doesn’t even have a name on her gravestone because they can’t identify her. Ian is determined to identify her, to learn her story and to find justice for her.
In this taut, gripping tale you’ll cry for this young woman and root for Ian to identify her and bring her murderer to justice. Then, just when you think you have it all figured out, the author plagues you with doubt. You can’t be sure of what happened until the very end.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
Publication Date: 2/4/2020
Number of Pages: 336
Betrayal, shock, dismay, regret, and sadness are all felt by Ian Rutledge as he solves his latest case. As always, the story is well-written and excellently plotted with twists and turns throughout. While this is the twenty-second book in the series, it can easily be read as a standalone – but since it is a great series, I’m sure you’ll want to run right out and get some of the earlier books. Ian is one of those characters that you really come to like and wish the best for him – all the while knowing how he suffers from the war. Not all wounds can be seen on the outside.
It is February of 1921 and Ian Rutledge, along with most of England, is still trying to put the war behind him. Although the war ended in November of 1918, Ian is still suffering greatly from shell shock. Balancing his duties as a Scotland Yard inspector and managing his symptoms is definitely not for the faint of heart. After his last big case, The Black Ascot, he is still in disfavor with his superiors and he knows he has to walk on eggshells for a while. After all, the Chief Superintendent still has his letter of resignation in his desk drawer and has let Ian know that he’ll pull it out and accept it at the slightest misstep.
After wrapping up a case in Shropshire, Ian was called into Chief Superintendent Markham’s office. Ian’s new assignment was to take a second look at a case that Chief Inspector Brian Leslie hadn’t been able to solve. Leslie was an excellent investigator as well as a friend and colleague, so Ian was sure that nothing had been missed in the investigation and was a little resentful to have been given the assignment. However, it was his assignment now so he’d best be off to Avebury.
Avebury is a bit of an eerie place as it is built in the center of an ancient stone circle. The body of the murdered woman was found at the foot of one of those stones. Ian retraces the steps taken by Leslie and discovers he is finding the same things as Leslie did. However, Ian is like a dog with a bone – he just doesn’t turn loose. As he stretches his imagination to picture how the murder could occur, how the murderer got the victim to where she was murdered without being seen and a myriad of other things – the clues just don’t add up. He slowly begins to suspect the unthinkable – yet there is no way to prove any of it.
Ian is drawn to the lovely young woman who was murdered. It pains him, and the rest of Avebury, to know that this young woman doesn’t even have a name on her gravestone because they can’t identify her. Ian is determined to identify her, to learn her story and to find justice for her.
In this taut, gripping tale you’ll cry for this young woman and root for Ian to identify her and bring her murderer to justice. Then, just when you think you have it all figured out, the author plagues you with doubt. You can’t be sure of what happened until the very end.
I voluntarily read and reviewed an Advanced Reader Copy of this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
June 5, 2020
Every time I read one of the books from The Inspector Ian Rutledge Mystery series by mother and son duo, Charles Todd, I remember why I like these stories so much. A Divided Loyalty had to be the best one I have read in this series thus far. I love a good mystery but A Divided Loyalty took the intrigue one step further for me. As usual, Inspector Ian Rutledge never seemed to leave any detail to chance. He always persevered and went the extra yard to get the answers he required to solve the case. Character development was exceptional and the descriptions of the places allowed me to actually visualize the scenes with clarity.
Chief Superintendent Markham was not Ian Rutledge's biggest supporter but he was his boss. There had been a mysterious murder in a small town called Avebury. Avebury was located not far from Stonehenge. This town had been built inside a prehistoric stone circle. A woman had been found murdered near a hooded figure-like stone. She appeared to be a stranger. The town of Avebury was unaccustomed to murder. It was a sleepy, small town, where everyone knew everyone that lived there. Nothing like this had ever occurred in Avebury. One of Rutledge's co-workers from Scotland Yard, Chief Inspector Brian Leslie, had been assigned the case initially, but he returned to Scotland Yard with the case unsolved. Markham then assigned the case to Ian. He wanted Ian to take another look at this case with fresh eyes. Ian feared that Markham was setting him up for failure.
Ian halfheartedly accepted his new assignment. He knew that Chief Inspector Brian Leslie was thorough. What else was he going to discover? Was Markham doing this to further humiliate Ian? Little by little, Ian gathered pieces to the puzzle that would lead him to the murderer and the identification of the murdered woman. He pursued every lead, no matter how trivial. Ian was reluctant to believe that the murderer could be who he thought. The evidence was all pointing to one person but Ian had not gathered enough to prove it. One interview among the locals led to another. He broadened his scope. Discovery of a tandem bike, a lapis necklace, a name, and some letter all ultimately led to an arrest.
While reading A Divided Loyalty I found myself at the edge of my seat. Just when I thought I had everything figured out there was a very unexpected twist. I never saw the ending coming. Ian's character has always been very likable. He was very underappreciated in every sense. His PTSD was evident throughout the book. Those years of serving in World War I haunted him still. Ian was the kind of man that should have been respected in both his professional and private life. Things had not gone so well for Ian though. He continued to feel like he had to prove himself constantly to those around him. It was evident that he was quite intelligent, a good person, compassionate, kind and caring. Hopefully, Ian can find the respect he deserved and maybe some romance in future books.
I almost didn't want this book to end. Ian's path throughout the inquest left me in awe of his unrelenting questions, curiosity and unwillingness to give up until he was able to fit all the pieces in the puzzle together and solve the case. I can't wait to read the next book in this series. I highly recommend A Divided Loyalty.
I received a complimentary copy of A Divided Loyalty (Inspector Ian Rutledge, #22) by Charles Todd in a goodreads give away. Thank you to William Morrow, The Todd's and goodreads for my complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
Chief Superintendent Markham was not Ian Rutledge's biggest supporter but he was his boss. There had been a mysterious murder in a small town called Avebury. Avebury was located not far from Stonehenge. This town had been built inside a prehistoric stone circle. A woman had been found murdered near a hooded figure-like stone. She appeared to be a stranger. The town of Avebury was unaccustomed to murder. It was a sleepy, small town, where everyone knew everyone that lived there. Nothing like this had ever occurred in Avebury. One of Rutledge's co-workers from Scotland Yard, Chief Inspector Brian Leslie, had been assigned the case initially, but he returned to Scotland Yard with the case unsolved. Markham then assigned the case to Ian. He wanted Ian to take another look at this case with fresh eyes. Ian feared that Markham was setting him up for failure.
Ian halfheartedly accepted his new assignment. He knew that Chief Inspector Brian Leslie was thorough. What else was he going to discover? Was Markham doing this to further humiliate Ian? Little by little, Ian gathered pieces to the puzzle that would lead him to the murderer and the identification of the murdered woman. He pursued every lead, no matter how trivial. Ian was reluctant to believe that the murderer could be who he thought. The evidence was all pointing to one person but Ian had not gathered enough to prove it. One interview among the locals led to another. He broadened his scope. Discovery of a tandem bike, a lapis necklace, a name, and some letter all ultimately led to an arrest.
While reading A Divided Loyalty I found myself at the edge of my seat. Just when I thought I had everything figured out there was a very unexpected twist. I never saw the ending coming. Ian's character has always been very likable. He was very underappreciated in every sense. His PTSD was evident throughout the book. Those years of serving in World War I haunted him still. Ian was the kind of man that should have been respected in both his professional and private life. Things had not gone so well for Ian though. He continued to feel like he had to prove himself constantly to those around him. It was evident that he was quite intelligent, a good person, compassionate, kind and caring. Hopefully, Ian can find the respect he deserved and maybe some romance in future books.
I almost didn't want this book to end. Ian's path throughout the inquest left me in awe of his unrelenting questions, curiosity and unwillingness to give up until he was able to fit all the pieces in the puzzle together and solve the case. I can't wait to read the next book in this series. I highly recommend A Divided Loyalty.
I received a complimentary copy of A Divided Loyalty (Inspector Ian Rutledge, #22) by Charles Todd in a goodreads give away. Thank you to William Morrow, The Todd's and goodreads for my complimentary copy of this book. All opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
March 19, 2024
Library book. Read and listened. Decent narration. British historical mystery series by Charles Todd, a mother-son writing team. It was well written with a likable main character, plus I felt like I was actually walking in the past, following the clues, so all good.
However, I figured out who did it very early on and couldn’t understand why Rutledge was blind to the possibility. The twist at the end was so obvious. Even after an attack on the steps of Scotland Yard, all the witnesses were sooo slow to see the truth. Duh?
I liked the secondary character, Dr. Mason, and I felt Todd portrayed the victim with depth and sensitivity. I’m not sure about the characterization of Chief Inspector Brian Leslie.
Hamish is still active. Ian draws closer to Kate, but no romance yet. Chief Super Markham gets stabbed but lives.
No spoilers. Synopsis: Historically-grounded criminal procedural set in 1921 England. Scotland Yard’s Inspector Ian Rutledge solves a murder quickly so Chief Superintendent Markham assigns him a seemingly similar case: an unknown woman murdered at the foot of an ancient standing stone at the stone circle in Avebury, a site older than Stonehenge. At first, however, Chief Inspector Leslie took the case, and found nothing, so Rutledge felt Markham was setting him up to fail. That may be true, but doubtless Markham was sorry he ever sent Rutledge to Avebury. There’s a political twist. This book is aptly titled.
Scotland Yard characters:
Inspector Ian Rutledge is single, tall, well-educated, and fairly well connected. Age about 28. He has a sister, Frances. His parents are dead. Hamish lives in his head from shell-shock.
Chief Superintendent Markham recently returned from vacation. Jameson has filled his shoes while gone. Markham is a jerk and seems to want Ian to fail. Sergeant Gibson keeps the Yard organized and running. He knows everything and everyone, and reports to Markham but does not like him.
Chief Inspector (CI) Brian Leslie had served in the trenches in World War I and is a successful interrogator who used to visit Avebury as a child when Townsend was rector, a friend of his parents. Sara is Leslie's wife. Sergeant Richards. Inspector Bradley has a burst appendix. Inspector Kent got ahead of Rutledge. Sutton is getting married next month. Inspector Gaines is visiting his sister in Blackmon's Hotel. CI Murray. Inspector Hayes was in Maidstone. Inspector Hadley's wife is friendly with Sara Leslie. CI Stanley and Inspector Martin may have issues with Leslie. CI Hubbard from prior book. CI Cummings trained Ian, but now is retired.
Outside London — various local constables: Fuller, Leigh, etc.
The mysterious Haldane lives in Chelsea. He is supposedly part of the Foot Police, a division that was in charge of Army discipline and crimes...Ian reckons he's really with Military Intelligence. Edwards is a friend of Ian's who works at the War Office.
However, I figured out who did it very early on and couldn’t understand why Rutledge was blind to the possibility. The twist at the end was so obvious. Even after an attack on the steps of Scotland Yard, all the witnesses were sooo slow to see the truth. Duh?
I liked the secondary character, Dr. Mason, and I felt Todd portrayed the victim with depth and sensitivity. I’m not sure about the characterization of Chief Inspector Brian Leslie.
Hamish is still active. Ian draws closer to Kate, but no romance yet. Chief Super Markham gets stabbed but lives.
No spoilers. Synopsis: Historically-grounded criminal procedural set in 1921 England. Scotland Yard’s Inspector Ian Rutledge solves a murder quickly so Chief Superintendent Markham assigns him a seemingly similar case: an unknown woman murdered at the foot of an ancient standing stone at the stone circle in Avebury, a site older than Stonehenge. At first, however, Chief Inspector Leslie took the case, and found nothing, so Rutledge felt Markham was setting him up to fail. That may be true, but doubtless Markham was sorry he ever sent Rutledge to Avebury. There’s a political twist. This book is aptly titled.
Scotland Yard characters:
Inspector Ian Rutledge is single, tall, well-educated, and fairly well connected. Age about 28. He has a sister, Frances. His parents are dead. Hamish lives in his head from shell-shock.
Chief Superintendent Markham recently returned from vacation. Jameson has filled his shoes while gone. Markham is a jerk and seems to want Ian to fail. Sergeant Gibson keeps the Yard organized and running. He knows everything and everyone, and reports to Markham but does not like him.
Chief Inspector (CI) Brian Leslie had served in the trenches in World War I and is a successful interrogator who used to visit Avebury as a child when Townsend was rector, a friend of his parents. Sara is Leslie's wife. Sergeant Richards. Inspector Bradley has a burst appendix. Inspector Kent got ahead of Rutledge. Sutton is getting married next month. Inspector Gaines is visiting his sister in Blackmon's Hotel. CI Murray. Inspector Hayes was in Maidstone. Inspector Hadley's wife is friendly with Sara Leslie. CI Stanley and Inspector Martin may have issues with Leslie. CI Hubbard from prior book. CI Cummings trained Ian, but now is retired.
Outside London — various local constables: Fuller, Leigh, etc.
The mysterious Haldane lives in Chelsea. He is supposedly part of the Foot Police, a division that was in charge of Army discipline and crimes...Ian reckons he's really with Military Intelligence. Edwards is a friend of Ian's who works at the War Office.
February 25, 2020
I have maintained my yearly ritual of reading another chapter from the life of Ian Rutledge, Scotland Yard Inspector now having reached two years since he returned home from the war suffering from shell shock, claustrophobia and with the voice of Hamish in his head. A tad confusing in continuity since I thought book #21 took us a bit further down the timeline. Ian continues to be determined, always doing his best under the negative atmosphere of his superiors.
We visit Avebury, home of ancient stone circles, for the central murder investigation. Ian is the second man to visit the town on this case as the first has failed to find the murderer and has gone on to another investigation. The descriptions of the towns, landscapes, people and general daily life details are done well, as always. The challenges to Ian are brutally stark and overwhelm the sensitive reader who hopes for some glimpse of relief and/or happiness. That will not be found in this book.
THUS...to cheer myself up I had to login to the www and grab some good prices on stocks as they continue to be under pressure from the corona virus panic. Good therapy! Not sure if I can continue with this grim portrayal of young man Ian. I think I would appreciate a final book showing him in another profession with a wife and kiddies!
Library Loan
We visit Avebury, home of ancient stone circles, for the central murder investigation. Ian is the second man to visit the town on this case as the first has failed to find the murderer and has gone on to another investigation. The descriptions of the towns, landscapes, people and general daily life details are done well, as always. The challenges to Ian are brutally stark and overwhelm the sensitive reader who hopes for some glimpse of relief and/or happiness. That will not be found in this book.
THUS...to cheer myself up I had to login to the www and grab some good prices on stocks as they continue to be under pressure from the corona virus panic. Good therapy! Not sure if I can continue with this grim portrayal of young man Ian. I think I would appreciate a final book showing him in another profession with a wife and kiddies!
Library Loan
January 8, 2021
I won this book through a giveaway in exchange for an honest review...
Awesome! I absolutely loved this book!! Whenever i am reviewing a book that isn’t the first book in a series, i typically read whatever books come before that one i have first, so i can have more context and give it a fair review. In this case, that would mean reading 21 books before this one, lol. So I didn’t go back and read the previous books, however, I have added them all to my TBR list and plan to read them at some point.
The authors (mother and son team) did a wonderful job at portraying the time period in a realistic and picturesque manner. I enjoyed trying to “solve” the crime, and i was even able to guess who the killer was before it was revealed. That being said, it wasn’t one of those books where it was super obvious, either.
If you haven’t read any of the Ian Rutledge books, I highly recommend them! Especially if you like suspense, mystery, police procedurals, or historical fiction.
Thank you to the publisher and authors for supplying me with my copy to read and review!
Awesome! I absolutely loved this book!! Whenever i am reviewing a book that isn’t the first book in a series, i typically read whatever books come before that one i have first, so i can have more context and give it a fair review. In this case, that would mean reading 21 books before this one, lol. So I didn’t go back and read the previous books, however, I have added them all to my TBR list and plan to read them at some point.
The authors (mother and son team) did a wonderful job at portraying the time period in a realistic and picturesque manner. I enjoyed trying to “solve” the crime, and i was even able to guess who the killer was before it was revealed. That being said, it wasn’t one of those books where it was super obvious, either.
If you haven’t read any of the Ian Rutledge books, I highly recommend them! Especially if you like suspense, mystery, police procedurals, or historical fiction.
Thank you to the publisher and authors for supplying me with my copy to read and review!
March 16, 2020
Long anticipated Inspector Rutledge novel
This new installment in the Inspector Rutledge series was intense and dark in mood. Ian Rutledge is still struggling with his own demons following the first world war. He is also not a favorite at Scotland Yard due to circumstances out of his control from his previous investigation.
His superior sends him to investigate the death of a young woman, while a colleague is sent to investigate a similar crime in another part of the country. Ian is successful with his case but he ends up embroiled in the other case and things become very dangerous indeed. A very twisted mystery ensues.
I love the Inspector Rutledge books and his character never fails to touch my heart.
This new installment in the Inspector Rutledge series was intense and dark in mood. Ian Rutledge is still struggling with his own demons following the first world war. He is also not a favorite at Scotland Yard due to circumstances out of his control from his previous investigation.
His superior sends him to investigate the death of a young woman, while a colleague is sent to investigate a similar crime in another part of the country. Ian is successful with his case but he ends up embroiled in the other case and things become very dangerous indeed. A very twisted mystery ensues.
I love the Inspector Rutledge books and his character never fails to touch my heart.
March 23, 2023
"A Divided Loyalty," is the twenty-second installment in this popular Inspector Ian Rutledge series.
Inspector Rutledge investigates a perplexing case involving a missing person. The story is set in 1921, and Todd's attention to detail transports readers back in time to a period of significant change in England.
The novel is masterfully crafted, and the characters are well-developed and nuanced. A winning entry in the series.
Inspector Rutledge investigates a perplexing case involving a missing person. The story is set in 1921, and Todd's attention to detail transports readers back in time to a period of significant change in England.
The novel is masterfully crafted, and the characters are well-developed and nuanced. A winning entry in the series.
February 14, 2020
Back up to a full five stars for this book and I'm so glad to be able to say that. I thoroughly enjoyed this book #22 in the series and it kept me focused on something other than what was happening to a friend in the real world. Every year I look forward to the latest Inspector Ian Rutledge novel from the mother and son team who write as Charles Todd. Rutledge is given a no-win assignment by Chief Superintendent Markham when he is sent out to find the identity of a murder victim which another Scotland Yard Inspector was unable to solve. Rutledge finds himself investigating a murder where the female victim was left dead beside one of the stones of Avebury.
Charles Todd is absolutely expert in describing atmosphere and building tension in the stories. Add to the cold, rain and fog the atmosphere of those huge, almost brooding, standing stones and I had prickles zipping along my arms for most of the time I was reading this very satisfying mystery. The authors have done a superlative job in this story of explaining the element of the story which lends it almost a mystical air; Hamish MacLeod, the Army corporal whose voice lingers in the mind of Rutledge since 1916 following the horrible incident in the trenches. There is a character, Dr. Mason, who was so well developed it makes me sad to think he has been left behind. This is a difficult to solve mystery beginning with the identity of the victim and continuing on through all of the actions which take place both in Wiltshire and London. A very well concealed murderer had me reading almost frantically trying to make sure I picked up all the clues. I could have just taken my time because I didn't get there until it was revealed. A lovely, engrossing reading experience.
Charles Todd is absolutely expert in describing atmosphere and building tension in the stories. Add to the cold, rain and fog the atmosphere of those huge, almost brooding, standing stones and I had prickles zipping along my arms for most of the time I was reading this very satisfying mystery. The authors have done a superlative job in this story of explaining the element of the story which lends it almost a mystical air; Hamish MacLeod, the Army corporal whose voice lingers in the mind of Rutledge since 1916 following the horrible incident in the trenches. There is a character, Dr. Mason, who was so well developed it makes me sad to think he has been left behind. This is a difficult to solve mystery beginning with the identity of the victim and continuing on through all of the actions which take place both in Wiltshire and London. A very well concealed murderer had me reading almost frantically trying to make sure I picked up all the clues. I could have just taken my time because I didn't get there until it was revealed. A lovely, engrossing reading experience.
February 17, 2020
The mother-son team of Charles Todd never disappoints. A Divided Loyalty is a gripping story that reveals itself so slowly that I started it several times, only to abandon it for something else. For me, that’s a pacing issue. But the story is so good that I returned to complete it, which means that the writing is as beautiful as ever.
In some ways this novel is darker than previous Ian Rutledge books, and in my opinion, less of Rutledge’s personality shines through. His “inner voice,” Hamish, is less intrusive in this novel, and I didn’t miss this imaginary character much. Rutledge has developed enough that he doesn’t need Hamish looking over this shoulder, and by the 22nd book in the series, readers know that Rutledge will never forget what he did during the war.
Recommended.
In some ways this novel is darker than previous Ian Rutledge books, and in my opinion, less of Rutledge’s personality shines through. His “inner voice,” Hamish, is less intrusive in this novel, and I didn’t miss this imaginary character much. Rutledge has developed enough that he doesn’t need Hamish looking over this shoulder, and by the 22nd book in the series, readers know that Rutledge will never forget what he did during the war.
Recommended.
January 25, 2020
I was thrilled to learn that I'd won an Advanced Reader's Edition of the latest installment of the Inspector Ian Rutledge series. I have dipped in and out of this series, but this was the first time that I'd wished that I'd read the previous book before diving in. Despite missing the full backstories on certain plot points, I still thoroughly enjoyed this novel from start to finish. It made me want to go back and read its most immediate predecessors to find out what happened, which I'd say is a good sign. As I've come to expect from this writing duo, I found the writing style engaging and loved that the location was just as integral to the story as the characters were. The historical details that were woven in brought the time and place to life; I always appreciate the careful research that the authors do for this series to ensure the setting is just right.
Rutledge is sent to the village of Avebury, which is set inside a great prehistoric stone circle not far from Stonehenge, to investigate a seemingly impossible case on the heels of solving another one. A respected colleague already investigated the murder of an unidentified woman found near the stones, reaching no conclusions about the motive or murderer. None of the villagers recognize the woman, who seems to have been lured to the village only to be killed.
Rutledge is convinced that his supervisor has set him up to fail and that he will reach no better conclusion than his more senior colleague. However, the meticulous Rutledge soon begins to unearth clues that take him down unexpected paths, leading to dangerous conclusions. I found the pacing to be excellent and liked how Rutledge's investigation proceeded slowly, building up to the big reveal. Like Rutledge, the reader is reluctant to believe, but cannot ignore, the evidence as the pieces come together. While the revelation of the murderer's identity was not entirely a surprise, the events that take place afterwards are and provide quite the cliffhanger ending. I am curious to see the direction the series takes based on how this one ended.
Many thanks to William Morrow for my Goodreads Giveaways win and giving me a sneak peek at the latest Rutledge novel!
I used this for the 2020 POPSUGAR Reading Challenge advanced prompt "a book by an author who has written more than 20 books." This is number 22 in the Rutledge series. There are also 11 entries in the equally excellent Bess Crawford series (which I adore!), two stand-alone novels, and several novellas and short stories.
Rutledge is sent to the village of Avebury, which is set inside a great prehistoric stone circle not far from Stonehenge, to investigate a seemingly impossible case on the heels of solving another one. A respected colleague already investigated the murder of an unidentified woman found near the stones, reaching no conclusions about the motive or murderer. None of the villagers recognize the woman, who seems to have been lured to the village only to be killed.
Rutledge is convinced that his supervisor has set him up to fail and that he will reach no better conclusion than his more senior colleague. However, the meticulous Rutledge soon begins to unearth clues that take him down unexpected paths, leading to dangerous conclusions. I found the pacing to be excellent and liked how Rutledge's investigation proceeded slowly, building up to the big reveal. Like Rutledge, the reader is reluctant to believe, but cannot ignore, the evidence as the pieces come together. While the revelation of the murderer's identity was not entirely a surprise, the events that take place afterwards are and provide quite the cliffhanger ending. I am curious to see the direction the series takes based on how this one ended.
Many thanks to William Morrow for my Goodreads Giveaways win and giving me a sneak peek at the latest Rutledge novel!
I used this for the 2020 POPSUGAR Reading Challenge advanced prompt "a book by an author who has written more than 20 books." This is number 22 in the Rutledge series. There are also 11 entries in the equally excellent Bess Crawford series (which I adore!), two stand-alone novels, and several novellas and short stories.
November 1, 2019
It is 1921 and Chief Inspector Brian Leslie of Scotland Yard is sent to Avebury, a small village near Stonehenge to solve a murder. The body of a young woman was found near a prehistoric stone circle. No one seems to recognize her or know how she could have got there. It would have been too far to walk especially at night and no one saw the lights of an automobile despite how clear the night was. Despite all his efforts, Leslie gives up on the case. She remains nameless and there are no clues to the identity of the killer.
Inspector Ian Rutledge, having just solved a similar case of a nameless woman, is sent to see if he can learn any more. Rutledge knows this is a no-win for him. The Chief Superintendent is hoping he'll fail and, thus, tarnish his reputation. If he somehow solves the case, it will look bad not only on Leslie who is liked and respected but it could also reflect badly on the Yard itself.
Still Rutledge is determined to try. As he retraces Leslie's footsteps, he begins to suspect that the perpetrator may be someone very close to the case. After another body is found near the stones, he knows the murderer will do anything, including, if necessary, killing Rutledge to stop him from finding out what really happened.
A Divided Loyalty is the 22nd historical mystery entry in the Inspector Rutledge Mysteries by the mother-and-son team, Charles Todd and, like the rest of the series, it is very well-written and compelling. It is not so much about the action which is minimal or even really the denouement but how Rutledge gathers together the pieces to solve the mystery. It stays true to post-WWI era and the settings are interesting especially the stone circle and a cave near it which serve to add a dark even creepy atmosphere to the story. As you can probably guess from the review, I am a fan of this series and recommend it highly to anyone who enjoys historical fiction or just complex puzzles in their mysteries.
Thanks to Edelweiss+ and William Morrow Publishing for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review
Inspector Ian Rutledge, having just solved a similar case of a nameless woman, is sent to see if he can learn any more. Rutledge knows this is a no-win for him. The Chief Superintendent is hoping he'll fail and, thus, tarnish his reputation. If he somehow solves the case, it will look bad not only on Leslie who is liked and respected but it could also reflect badly on the Yard itself.
Still Rutledge is determined to try. As he retraces Leslie's footsteps, he begins to suspect that the perpetrator may be someone very close to the case. After another body is found near the stones, he knows the murderer will do anything, including, if necessary, killing Rutledge to stop him from finding out what really happened.
A Divided Loyalty is the 22nd historical mystery entry in the Inspector Rutledge Mysteries by the mother-and-son team, Charles Todd and, like the rest of the series, it is very well-written and compelling. It is not so much about the action which is minimal or even really the denouement but how Rutledge gathers together the pieces to solve the mystery. It stays true to post-WWI era and the settings are interesting especially the stone circle and a cave near it which serve to add a dark even creepy atmosphere to the story. As you can probably guess from the review, I am a fan of this series and recommend it highly to anyone who enjoys historical fiction or just complex puzzles in their mysteries.
Thanks to Edelweiss+ and William Morrow Publishing for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review
Read
February 27, 2021Good stories, and they don't have to be read in order.
The most believable part of the book is our hero's supervisor's, "You bastard! You did what we told you!" at the end.
The most believable part of the book is our hero's supervisor's, "You bastard! You did what we told you!" at the end.
January 14, 2020
This is the first book in this series I have read. I really enjoyed it. I received it as an advanced copy. The story moves at a good pace and kept me interested. I plan to read more in the series.
January 31, 2020
When Chief Inspector Leslie is called to a murder in Avebury, he tries to give the case to someone else. But when no one else is available, he himself must go down to the small town that has built in the midst of giant stones, similar to Stonehenge. As he hear his inner monologue, we discover that he knows who she is and why she had to die. But he must hide it from everyone else. So when the inquest comes back as "murdered by persons unknown," he thinks he is safe. Until Inspector Ian Rutledge gets involved. As Ian searches for clues as to who this woman is and why someone would kill her, he begins to come to an unthinkable conclusion: that Chief Inspector Leslie, a man with whom he has worked at Scotland Yard for years, is the killer. But as the evidence becomes more compelling, Ian is faced with a choice: does he go with what everyone believes, or does he tell the truth and destroy the Yard? Or is all as it seems?
In this latest installment of Inspector Ian Rutledge's story, Charles Todd brings you fully into this story, seeing how Ian feels and once again seeing how his shell shock affects everything he does. As Hamish's voice both keeps him safe and at the same time makes life more complicated, Ian continues to hide his shell shock from everyone he meets. His attention to detail makes a case that seemed unsolvable within reach. And his quest for justice for the victim means that he never goes with what is easy or perhaps socially accepted, but instead continues on in a dogged search for the truth. And in a story that appears to be straightforward, Todd does a great job of keeping you guessing.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an unbiased review.
In this latest installment of Inspector Ian Rutledge's story, Charles Todd brings you fully into this story, seeing how Ian feels and once again seeing how his shell shock affects everything he does. As Hamish's voice both keeps him safe and at the same time makes life more complicated, Ian continues to hide his shell shock from everyone he meets. His attention to detail makes a case that seemed unsolvable within reach. And his quest for justice for the victim means that he never goes with what is easy or perhaps socially accepted, but instead continues on in a dogged search for the truth. And in a story that appears to be straightforward, Todd does a great job of keeping you guessing.
*I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an unbiased review.
November 19, 2019
I was delighted to have won an advance reader's copy of "A Divided Loyalty" by the mother-son personae of Charles Todd via Goodreads! A good reading experience, indeed, during the past crisp weekend in Carroll County, Miss.; set in England, 1921, with characters and background still suffering from World War I experiences and haunted by all of the foggy isle's previous centuries -- intriguing as certain characters among the monoliths of Avebury and the alter ego of Detective Ian Rutledge, who suffered with him in war torn France (Hamish)! I very much liked this crime novel, which might seem to have very early on given its murderer away. Yet, the psychological intricacies of the story bear witness to the complex denouement. Not a flat-liner. By the way, I appreciated the sites I found online that share images and comments about the Avebury Henge, which along with the intermingled village there, is an integral character in this novel!
September 25, 2020
While this was much drier and slower than others, it's the wonderful narration by Simon Prebble that makes moments spent with Inspector Rutledge a great time. I switched to the ebook near the end, and audio is definitely the way to go here with this series. Todd features Hamish, the voice of conscience in Rutledge's head and the reading off the page of his Scottish brogue does not give it the life and brilliance that Prebble gives.
I found too in this instalment not enough of Rutledge and his personal life, which gave this one another aspect of its dryness.
Looking forward to #23 coming soon!
I found too in this instalment not enough of Rutledge and his personal life, which gave this one another aspect of its dryness.
Looking forward to #23 coming soon!
February 6, 2021
My husband and I listened to this on our daily walks. We enjoyed it, but felt that:
1. the 2 separate murder investigations were unrelated, and unnecessary
2. the question of how the bodies were moved - with no one seeing anything - was never adequately explained.
I had not realized that this was book #22 of a series, but I don't think that negatively impacted our enjoyment of the the book very much.
Audiobook
Narrated by Simon Prebble
11 hours 11 minutes
1. the 2 separate murder investigations were unrelated, and unnecessary
2. the question of how the bodies were moved - with no one seeing anything - was never adequately explained.
I had not realized that this was book #22 of a series, but I don't think that negatively impacted our enjoyment of the the book very much.
Audiobook
Narrated by Simon Prebble
11 hours 11 minutes
February 18, 2020
I have read all the Inspector Rutledge books. This is by far the best of the lot. I loved that he solved a case in the first chapters, and then we went on to the main mystery. Surprises all around.
February 12, 2020
Who doesn't love a good Scotland Yard mystery? It is shortly after WWI and those who were "spared" have returned home. Yes, they were spared in the sense that they can still breathe and look somewhat human, but their eyes and their mind still see the horrors and atrocities of war. Those sights haunt them like an addiction.
Ian Rutledge is home and back on the force, but he carries with him baggage. It causes him problems from time to time, especially when he hear that voice in his head. His supervisor is fed up with him and he is still holding Rutledge's resignation letter in his desk, that so far he has refused to accept.
In an area outside London lies an ancient circle of stone. The stones aren't as tall as Stonehenge but they are massive, obviously placed strategically by man and the circle of stones covers a large enough area that as a few stones began to fall many years ago, a village begin to spring up in its circumference.
A woman's body is found beneath one of the stones and a knife wound is the cause of death. She is not local and the body is giving up no clues as to where she is from, how she arrived in their community or who is responsible for her death. Inspector Leslie is first assigned to the case. He, too, is a veteran of the war and is haunted by his past. Unable to bring closure to the case, it is labeled "undetermined". The case is then handed off to Inspector Rutledge but with little hope of a different outcome.
I so enjoyed watching a master sleuth at work - knowing the right questions to ask -- looking outside the box for clues, even if they lead you to an outcome you don't want to fathom. This isn't a Sherlock Holmes/Dr. Watson murder mystery that proves elementary in the end, but it was spiked full of the inner workings of a detective, their perception of individuals and their non-verbal communication. I enjoy a murder mystery that doesn't lay out all of the puzzle pieces for you and makes you work for the final discovery and this author certainly delivered on that end.
I received this ARC for an honest review. I am so glad I won a copy as I'm now intrigued to follow this Inspector on past and future cases.
Ian Rutledge is home and back on the force, but he carries with him baggage. It causes him problems from time to time, especially when he hear that voice in his head. His supervisor is fed up with him and he is still holding Rutledge's resignation letter in his desk, that so far he has refused to accept.
In an area outside London lies an ancient circle of stone. The stones aren't as tall as Stonehenge but they are massive, obviously placed strategically by man and the circle of stones covers a large enough area that as a few stones began to fall many years ago, a village begin to spring up in its circumference.
A woman's body is found beneath one of the stones and a knife wound is the cause of death. She is not local and the body is giving up no clues as to where she is from, how she arrived in their community or who is responsible for her death. Inspector Leslie is first assigned to the case. He, too, is a veteran of the war and is haunted by his past. Unable to bring closure to the case, it is labeled "undetermined". The case is then handed off to Inspector Rutledge but with little hope of a different outcome.
I so enjoyed watching a master sleuth at work - knowing the right questions to ask -- looking outside the box for clues, even if they lead you to an outcome you don't want to fathom. This isn't a Sherlock Holmes/Dr. Watson murder mystery that proves elementary in the end, but it was spiked full of the inner workings of a detective, their perception of individuals and their non-verbal communication. I enjoy a murder mystery that doesn't lay out all of the puzzle pieces for you and makes you work for the final discovery and this author certainly delivered on that end.
I received this ARC for an honest review. I am so glad I won a copy as I'm now intrigued to follow this Inspector on past and future cases.
December 2, 2020
3.5 stars, debated whether to round up or down, and decided that the fact that I couldn't think of a reason made down the more appropriate choice.
I do think this one was generally quite well done in many ways. I liked the idea of the two unrelated deaths of two different women being essentially discarded in the middle of nowhere. I also liked Avebury as a setting, mainly because I've been there. I did think it dragged a bit in the middle, mainly because Rutledge was hitting too many dead ends, and I'd essentially guessed the solution:
I also got annoyed that
Seriously, if these books are gearing up for something depressing to happen to Kate Gordon... I get that this world is bleak, but sometimes nice things happen.
I do think this one was generally quite well done in many ways. I liked the idea of the two unrelated deaths of two different women being essentially discarded in the middle of nowhere. I also liked Avebury as a setting, mainly because I've been there. I did think it dragged a bit in the middle, mainly because Rutledge was hitting too many dead ends, and I'd essentially guessed the solution:
I also got annoyed that
Seriously, if these books are gearing up for something depressing to happen to Kate Gordon... I get that this world is bleak, but sometimes nice things happen.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 738 reviews