London, 1814
Grace and Hope Everly, 24 year-old twins, still living with their parents
Sooooo.... I’m apparently reading these books in the opposite order intended... a Kindle sort error for me. I read Saving Miss Everly recently, which was #3 . 😁 This is book #2 about twins Grace and Hope Everly. Both books begin with the exact same incident, but the rest of the stories are from the other twin's points of view and experiences.
The twins couldn't have been more different. Hope was outgoing, adventurous and clearly an extrovert. Grace was much more demure, accepting of social norms and unquestioningly obedient. So when an incident arose that was meant to be a punishment for Hope, it was literally a punishment for both women. The extrovert was being denied a trip to the Caribbean by their father because of her dangerous disobedience, but Grace, the introvert, who hated leaving her family to travel, was equally grieved to have to make the trip. So she devised a plan whereby both of them would get their way, and that was to switch places and get away with playing the other twin. Hope would get her adventure and Grace would get to stay home. The problem was pretending to be the other.
Book three is about Hope playing Grace and her experience on the ship, then being shipwrecked. In this book, Grace stays home playing the extrovert and upset twin, fooling everyone around her, then having to face her parents' wrath when it was revealed.
Right away their childhood friend and neighbor, Jacob Barnes, could see this was Grace, and was furious with her. Not only did the twin he wanted to court take off traveling for months, but the twin he was not interested in played along with this devious plan.
Whew. What a mess! Normally "changing-places" plots really bother me, but this one really worked. Both stories had completely different outcomes for the girls.
By the way, I used the pronoun "girls" for the twins because, although they were twenty-four, their positions in their home were more like sixteen year-olds. Submissive to their father because they were unmarried, etc., they were told by their father to go to their rooms, had to have permission for everything, and punished like children. I suppose that’s the way it was in the Georgian era until the father chose a spouse for his daughters. They were treated like children until they were married.
Ah well, good book with wonderful faith conversations and lessons.