This is by far the worst book I've read in 2012, or maybe in my lifetime. It is stupid. The plot, the characters, the writing, it's very bad. It feels like something a 14 year old would write.
In the first place I hated that he called the villain the bad wolf. Seriously. His wife is mrs. Bad wolf. We find early on that red number one is his wife's doctor and red number 3 goes to school were mrs bad wolf works as the principal's assistant. We never find out how he knows or where he meets red number 2. We don't even know what it is about the reds that caught the bad woods attention.
The book synopsis tells us he inflicts this mental psicological torture upon his victims, and while I think that being stalked is creepy and scary I wouldn't go as far as to say there's psicological torture involved. He sends them an anonymous note telling them he is going to kill them a link to a YouTube video of each of the redheads doing something in their everyday lives and he calls them once and doesn't say anything.
Maybe it's the lawyer in me but those things do not constitute a crime, yes it's creepy, yes it's scary but how can we know that he really is going to kill them?
Of all the redheads just one goes to the police, which offer no help at all, and I know this happens constantly in real life, because unless he actually acts on his threats there's nothing the police can do. Apparently he chose his 3 victims because they were vulnerable and redheads, each so different from the other, different ages different careers different backgrounds, yet all 3 redheads act exactly the same, no one tells anyone about the wolf and his threats, no one skips town or leaves the country, not one of them hires a bodyguard. And it is specially hard to believe in the case of Jordan red number 3, she is 17, an I don't care that her parents were absent and fighting and going through a divorce, I remember being 17 and if something like that we're to happen to me I would tell someone, plus she has been to therapists and counseling and everyone around her is worried about her, she is acting out, she wants Attention yet when she gets the ultimate Attention ruse she doesn't tell anyone? C'mon!
Redhead 2 is a widow who lost her husband and child in a car accident, she's drunk and high all the time depressed and wants to die, and when someone threatens to kill he she suddenly wants to live? It's just not credible, there's no process in which redhead 2 slowly awakens from her depression it's sudden and not subtle.
Bad wolf is a crime writer a dark novella author who thinks he is so suave and smart and he has found the way to commit the perfect crimes and wants to write a book afterwards because he is going to get rich. I'm not American yet even I know about son of sam's law. And he is not a sophisticated killer he uses disguises and is an average joe stalker driving around and following them. But the worst part of the book is when reds unite and suddenly they want to kill the bad wolf, they aren't even sure bad wolf is this guy, they don't follow him, stalk him, have him investigated they just break into his house one day in the middle of the night, the silent alarm goes off and they manage to make mrs wolf give the security company the code and tell the alarm company it was an accident, but this conversation took at least 10 minutes, I'm pretty sure any security company would send the police just to Check things out, specially because they live in a small town in which exciting things and crime never happen.
The ending is ridiculous, they bound and gag bad wolf and his wife, take a sample of their hair some blood and saliva as well as a scrapbook with newspaper clippings about some murders. He is a crime writer the scrap book proofs nothing it would be circumstantial at best, and that is if that evidence had been obtained legally. He is supposedly a great killer has never been caught thinks through every possible scenario yet he suddenly feels beaten at his own game and let's them go without revenge afterwards. Katzenbach seriously needs to talk to lawyers before publishing stupid things, specially since he was a crime reporter before becoming an author and his dad was US attorney general. There is no case even if the evidence would convict him it was obtained illegally.
Twice in my life have I thrown a book across the room in anger, katzenbach underestimates his readers intelligence and it made me angry. And the ending really is they all lived happily ever after except the wolf. Red number 3 was failing every single class in school yet she obviously graduates. I could go on and on and on about mistakes and stupidity in this book, all I can say is I was very generous giving him a star and katzenbach you owe me money!
Wouldn't recommend this book to my worst enemy.