Although this book provided a decent amount of food for thought, that food unfortunately came spiced up so much so as to make it barely edible (and to make me wonder if all that spice was to mask some subpar food underneath it all). The blatant and transparent sensationalization of every hypothesis Lindstrom tried to put forward only ended up detracting from it and even leading me to question the veracity of his supporting arguments.
In fact, some of his statements were complete and utter nonsense. For example, when—in one of his outbursts of paranoia that seems common for this book—he tries to scare his readers into thinking that their every movement is constantly being traced and monitored and analyzed, he points to the iPhone and iPad as storing location data in a file that is automatically copied onto the hard drive of any computer synced to the device. Even if that bizarre statement were true (which it isn’t—at least not in the way he portrays it), his next statement “explaining” what that means is ridiculous: “Meaning that if I charge my iPad on a colleague’s or acquaintance’s computer, he or she now possesses a permanent record of my whereabouts over the last year.”
Let’s analyze that reckless statement. First of all, he doesn’t mention that this does not quite apply to Wifi-only iPads, which account for the majority of iPads out there. Second, he doesn’t mention that this does not apply if the location-based service is turned off in the settings, which some people do (for paranoid security reasons). Third, for someone writing a book that’s supposed to be so authoritative on these “secrets”, he apparently doesn’t even know the difference between syncing and charging, whereby syncing would transfer files to the host computer, while charging would not. And, if he *did* know the difference between the two, he might realize that almost no one out there SYNCS his iPad or iPhone to a friend’s computer; they might charge an iPhone, but they won’t sync it. And, notice, I say only “iPhone” because you cannot charge an iPad using a computer—yet another distinction Lindstrom seems to overlook when he confuses charging and syncing. Finally, even if someone inexplicably DID sync his iPhone or iPad to his friends computer, chances are that the synced data is set to be encrypted—and even if it weren’t, it’s highly unlikely any person would know how to extract that data from even an unencrypted file, let alone what they would even do with it once extracted. I’d be surprised if Lindstrom can come up with even a SINGLE case where something like what he’s describing has actually happened!
And this is just one of many, many such frantic, paranoid proclamations that put this book over the top, ruining what otherwise might’ve been an interesting book.
Aside from the inaccuracies, there was also the annoying habit where he seemed to be always be surprised to “discover” something about human nature that any layperson could probably have guessed without all the research. For example, he describes himself as “genuinely flabbergasted by the power of word-of-mouth marketing”. As anyone with friends knows, if a friend tells you how much they love a product, you will value that recommendation more than almost any other source. In his experiment with a family that was secretly promoting products amongst their friends, he kept expressing such surprise that the friends would then go out and try it, or buy it! Why in the world is that so surprising?
Finally, if the paranoiac hyperbole and the inaccuracies weren’t enough, he had to also throw in a healthy dose of political posturing. His statement that heat-related deaths, floods, heavy rains, and droughts are “in part attributable to the major climate changes sweeping our planet” and the resulting “importance of going green” just really cast that final straw on this camel’s back. This “climate change” debate is far from over, and to portray it as proven science only shows me just how “scientific” the rest of his claims are.
In short, this could have been a pretty decent book had he stuck to facts and observations. He didn’t and, as a result, he blew it.