A really interesting study of the Bible’s use of numbers. I do see how people would find this an exceedingly boring book. It’s definitely written for those who are really interested in the subject.
I agreed with most of his stuff. I found the grammatical discussion really helpful and interesting, especially that 2 is an extension of 1 in Hebrew. It suggests that the “two shall become one flesh” would have been a really natural understanding in Hebrew. It was also really helpful to learn that the numbers in scripture were completely written out (one instead of 1, seventy three instead of 73). It means that scribal errors or textual corruption is highly unlikely as an explanation for the large numbers in scripture. I definitely agree with him that they should be taken at face value and as actual numbers of the Israelites. I disagreed with him on symbolic numbers, but I respect his concerns and find his caution justified. I mostly agree with him on mystical numbers. The Biblical Numerics movement sounds totally crazy and best left to the ages, but I am hesitant to discard the Gematria along with them. It’s been used throughout church history and I don’t think it’s right to dismiss it as gnostic or cabalistic. Though, if he is right that it is a Greek creation that the apostate Hellenic Jews started using just before Christ came and that we ought to discard it, I would argue a total discarding rather than leaving an exception for 666. If the Gematria is a totally unbiblical means of hermeneutics, then that will have serious implications for how we interpret 666.