Not really a 4-star, even compared to higher-quality pulps, but (as with everything by Dan Ross or VC Andrews) the Special Needs Rating Scale dictates rounding up when a book doesn’t totally suck. Some authors are only gonna get so good, & you have to reward them relative to their oeuvre. :D Such is the case here.
If you’ve experienced other Ross, you can tell he really did try with this particular effort—there’s an actual story with some unexpected twists, & the dialogue isn’t completely ludicrous. As with EVIL OF DARK HARBOR, this is framed by the tale-within-a-tale, & the modern bit is deliberately vague, i.e. a 20-page setup to reintroduce Dark Harbor native Captain Miller & his penchant for storytelling. The real plot is set in the 1890s, complete with an actress heroine (that perennial Ross fave) & the Scooby Doo family she’s marrying into. Let’s give credit where it’s due; my suspicions swerved twice at the midway point, but neither was correct. And Nero the Dalmatian didn’t die, so props for that. ;)
4 stars within the Ross pantheon, but more like 3/3.5 in comparison to better pulps.