Dr. John Andrew Hostetler, Ph.D. (Pennsylvania State University, 1953) was a scholar of Amish and Hutterite societies, a Fulbright scholar, and occasional film consultant and expert witness. He retired from the faculty of Temple University (Philadelphia, Pennsylvania) in 1985, and served the next five years as Distinguished Scholar-in-Residence at the Young Center for Anabaptist and Pietist Studies at Elizabethtown College, where his wife Beulah also held a teaching appointment.
Look, The Amish is the rare sequel-feeling standalone that doesn't need homework. John A. Hostetler hands you a world, a cast, and a conflict within the first few pages and trusts you to keep up, and the heist scene on the rooftop had me grinning like an idiot. The finale is a bit too neat for such a chaotic crew. For readers who like heist stories with real chemistry. Pass if you want gritty and realistic.
Real talk, The Amish is the kind of book you'll either defend at a party or throw across the room. I did a little of both. John A. Hostetler takes big swings, and some land hard, like the opening chapter that gutted me, while others whiff completely. The narrator's attitude gets exhausting after a while. For readers who like a book with some bite. Pass if you prefer your stories polite.