Years ago I read a brief description of the operation to kidnap Eichmann and bring him to Israel. With the release of this book I thought I'd take a deeper interest in what happened, how the operation was organized, and the background to the entire event. In the end I think this book delivers. Although the research is there, the book lacks in the usual endnote citations a scholarly work includes. Rather you can follow page numbers in the back and try to see which few words, designating the beginning of a sentence, are followed by a source, which is where the information in that sentence, and perhaps what follows, comes from. This is a bit annoying at times, but better than no endnotes at all.
Bascomb's impressive research is matched by a writing style that makes this narrative read more like a novel than a work of non-fiction. Although we already know the basic details about Eichmann's kidnapping, we are still on the edge of our seats as the author skillfully and suspensefully describes the false starts, glitches, close calls, political complications, subterfuge, and intricate logistics that made this operation so perilous. If any members of the Israeli team were to be captured on Argentinean soil, not only might Eichmann escape, but their failed effort would undoubtedly cause an embarrassing international incident, and the image of the Israeli government would suffer irreparable damage. There was a huge amount at stake, and failure simply was not an option.
There is so much to praise in this book: the effortless, precise, and understated prose; the striking photos showing Eichmann in his youth and shortly before his execution; the ways in which Bascomb places this monumental event in historical and cultural context; and the impressive footnotes, bibliography, and index. Eichmann's trial, with its extensive testimony and documentation about the Final Solution, educated Israeli youth about the tragedy of the Jewish annihilation at the hands of the Nazis. Furthermore, it "rooted the Holocaust in the collective cultural consciousness." The trial "stirred a debate" that led to an "outpouring of survivor memoirs, scholarly works, plays, novels, [and] documentaries" that continues to this day.
Also noteworthy is Bascomb's depiction of Eichmann's twisted personality and delusional thinking. In addition, the author takes the time to explore the backgrounds, traumatic memories, and ultimately, the pride mixed with terror of each Israeli who took part in the abduction and its aftermath. As Isser Harel, the head of the Mossad, tells his men: "You were chosen by destiny to guarantee that one of the worst criminals of all time, who for years has succeeded in evading justice, would be made to stand trial." At last, the Jews had the opportunity to judge their killers. "Hunting Eichmann" is an eye-opening and detailed look at an important chapter in the history of genocide.
What I really appreciated about this text is the fact that you see these Mossad agents for who they are, not supermen, but ordinary human beings with a past (a past that the majority inherited from the Holocaust) and in their humanity can easily complicate any and every perfectly created plan. From beginning to end this was an operation that with one false step could send the entire mission off course with repercussions none could predict for certain; luck, detective work, and a superior work ethic is what made the difference. Also, I found it interesting, and at the same time horrifying, that such a person like Eichmann can exist. To be so entrenched in one's beliefs and removed from his actions is simply beyond reason. Then again, he had fifteen years to convince himself that what he did was simply to follow orders, even if those orders came from a genocidal authoritarian regime. That Mossad agents were able to be around him and come face-to-face with one of Hitler's most ruthlessly efficient bureaucrats is hard to fathom; that they could restrain themselves from doing violence to him after having first hand knowledge of what went on during the Holocaust and the suffering he caused, is commendable. A recommended book that brings a lot of literature, interviews, and primary sources together on the subject.