What do you think?
Rate this book


214 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1997
There could be, I knew, no finality to the one raindrops, to the number and variousness of the stars, to the books to be read, to the languages to be learned. The mosaic of the possible could, at any instant, be splintered and reassembled into new images and notions of meaning. The idiom of heraldry, those “gules” and “bars sinister,” even if I could not yet make it out, must, I sensed, be only one among countless systems of discourse specifically tailored to the teeming diversity of human purposes, artifacts, representations, or concealment (I still recall the strange excitement I felt at the thought that a coat of arms could hide as well as reveal).
I have conducted my emotional, intellectual, and professional affairs in distrust of theory. So far as I am able, I can attach meaning to the concept of theory in the exact and, to some degree, applied sciences. These theoretical constructs demand crucial experiments for their verification or falsification. If refuted, they will be superseded. They can be mathematically or logically formalized. The invocation of “theory” in the humanities, in historical and social studies, in the evaluation of literature and the arts, seems to me mendacious. The humanities are susceptible neither to crucial experiments nor to verification (except on a material, documentary level). Our responses to them are narratives of intuition. In the unbounded dynamics of the semantic, in the flux of the meaningful, in the uncircumscribed interplay of interpretations, the only propositions are those of personal choice, of taste, of echoing affinity or deafness. There can be no refutations or disproofs in any theoretical sense. Coleridge does not refute Samuel Johnson; Picasso does not advance on Raphael. In humane letters, “theory” is nothing but intuition grown impatient.
'Love is the dialectic of hatred, its mirror-opposite. Love is, in varying intensities, the imperative wonder of the irrational. It is non-negotiable, as is the (condemned) search for God among His infirm. To shake, in one’s inmost spirit, nerve, and bone, at the sight, at the voice, at the merest touch of the beloved; to contrive, to labor, to lie without end so as to reach, to be near the man or woman loved; to transform one’s existence — personal, public, psychological, material — on an unforeseen instant, in the cause and consequence of love; to undergo unspeakable hurt and blankness at the absence of the beloved one, at the withering of love; to identify the divine with the emanation of love, as does all Platonism, which is to say, the Western model of transcendence — is to partake of the most commonplace and inexplicable sacrament in human life. It is, within one’s personal potential, to touch the ripeness of the spirit. To equate this universe of experience with the libidinal, as does Freud, to account for it in terms of biogenetic, procreative advantages, are reductions almost contemptible. Love can be the unchosen bond, to the pitch of self-destruction, between individuals blatantly unsuited to each other. Sexuality can be incidental, transient, or altogether absent. The ugly, the wretched, the most evil among us can be the object of disinterested, impassioned eros. The desire to die for the beloved or the friend — l'amie, as French so exactly and luminously has it — the clear-eyed insanities of jealousy, are counter-productive on any conceivable biological (Darwinian) or social reckoning. The celebrated Pascalian maxim whereby the heart has its reasons which reason does not know, plays defensively on rationality. It is not “reasons” which crowd the heart. It is necessities of a wholly different provenance. Beyond reason, beyond good and evil, beyond sexuality which, even at the crest of ecstasy, is so minor and ephemeral an act. I have stood through a rain-sodden night to catch a glimpse of the beloved turning a corner. Perhaps it was not even she. God have mercy on those who have never known the hallucination of light which fills the dark during such a vigil.'