**2.5 stars, rounding to 3**
I won His Cat and Other Strange Tales in a Goodreads giveaway and figured I’d actually write out a review for once.
With every collection of short stories, there are going to be a mix of ones that really hit the mark and ones that fall short. While there were some memorable and engaging tales in this collection, a lot tended to the latter for me.
Beginning with the positive, I really enjoyed “Stanley’s Tiger”, “The Pit”, and “The Candidate”. Each of these were unique stories that caught me off guard with their humor and absurdity (in the case of “Stanley’s Tiger”) and with their heart and twists. For most of the other stories, however, it was pretty apparent how they were going to play out after the first couple paragraphs. This didn’t stop them from offering entertainment, but they weren’t particularly memorable. The biggest issue I had with this collection wasn’t the stories themselves, though, but the writing. There were a lot of passages that were so awkward to read that I would get pulled out of the story because of the choppy cadence or repetitive word choices.
The following is an example from “In Her Image”:
“The boys had been good to him when he retired. His sons, his son the lawyer, his son the accountant. They’d made him chairman of the board. They’d let him come into the shops when he felt like it. He’d never interfered. It was their world now. His boys had plans. They’d take it forward. They’d build on what he’d established. He stopped dropping in on the shops. He hadn’t been by for, what, six months maybe.”
This is fine if used once in a while, but this style of writing is used through much of the book, and it just makes the reading seem tedious to me.
Overall, though, I liked His Cat and Other Strange Tales well enough, and there are some tales in here I really enjoyed and will come back to reread again.