I was fully prepared to give this 5 stars and declare it my non-fiction book of the year. Had it ended at 184 pages, I would absolutely be doing that. I'll explain.
First, you should know that the book is 422 pages long, but nearly 160 of those pages are notes (thus, putting to rest all the comments on book review forums claiming this to be a baseless cash grab), an index, and acknowledgements. That leaves 265 pages for actual prose.
The first 184 pages detail two young journalists from the NY Times (the co-authors of "She Said") as they chase down the decades-long story of how world famous mega-producer Harvey Weinstein abused his position of power by harassing and coercing scores of young women into sexual favors, and his history of litigating them into silence afterwards. For those of us who are already familiar with Weinstein (meaning, if you've been alive since 2017) the Weinstein story is not really the point; it's the big blob of cheese on top of the bowl of French Onion soup, but the good stuff is beneath.
The soup here is in how this story is told. It's in how these women manage to cull together leads long thought to be dead by other media, and how they uncover and come up against multiple systems (some by the Weinstein Company, some from legal firms, some from governmental agencies) that seem designed to punish victims while allowing their abusers the privacy and opportunity to abuse others. It's also in how they slowly gain trust from people who, by their own admission, should have had no reason to speak with them. It's in how, during this time when "fake news" frequently means "news I don't like," sources, redundancy, fact checking, method, and, ultimately, integrity matter. It's in their tenacity and success in getting people to finally take notice of how we can be better (although no real solutions are discussed). Through it all, Kantor and Twohey share their frustration over stonewalling, their nervousness at knocking on the doors of people who they know would rather forget their past, their thrill when someone unexpectedly says "yes, I'll tell you what I know," and their love of journalism. It's a terrific read, one that will only get better as future generations come across it.
That said, there are those final 80 pages to deal with. Here's where the book loses its way, as we leave the Times' newsroom and find ourselves a few weeks prior to the confirmation of Brett Kavanaugh to the U.S. Supreme Court. Dr. Christine Blasey Ford, as most of us know, recognizes him as the drunken teenager who forced himself upon her at a party. Her story is certainly relevant in the telling of a #MeToo history, but this book isn't that, and neither Kantor nor Twohey had anything to do with breaking or researching Ford's story (although Kantor inserts herself into room the night before Ford's testimony). As a result this part of the book reads like an extended article. It's dry and oddly emotionless when compared to the excitement of the Weinstein story, and it offers nothing previously unreported except how indecisive Ford was about testifying (due to her fear of the cameras, not the strength of her accusation). I suspect this section of "She Said" will age the best, as those of us who witnessed the events as they unfolded die off.
The book ends with Kantor and Twohey gathering together several of the women swept up in the initial #MeToo current into one room in order to connect them and have a discussion about where proclaiming their accusers has led them emotionally. Included are Weinstein victims Ashley Judd and Gwyneth Paltrow, Ford, Rachel Crooks (a Trump accuser), and Kim Lawson, a McDonalds worker who led a campaign forcing the corporation to address sexual harassment. (As Lawson was furthest removed from the glam and resources of both Washington and Hollywood where the other stories took place, I would have loved to read more about her. Unfortunately, despite being a $10/hr worker who took on an entire corporation, she gets barely a mention.) This might have been the most poignant part of the book, but it's not; no real discussion is offered about the broken systems that allowed this type of abuse to propagate, no real conversation takes place regarding how class system affects victims or enables predators (this is hinted at in a couple of places throughout the book, which is why I expected it to lead somewhere). There is the subtle undertone that healing can now take place for some of these women, but I wanted to learn more about how they thought that would happen; I wanted to feel their strength, their faith, their thoughts of the future. I did learn that Gwyneth Paltrow enjoys collecting gilded teacups, though.
The bottom line is that "She Said" is important, if only as proof that fair journalism still exists in America. I just wish the authors had either limited their focus to the Weinstein story, or broadened their range to really discuss the #MeToo movement, as the book seems to want to do. As long as you go into it knowing that the deep analysis hinted at never goes anywhere, then those first 184 pages are 5 star all the way.
(A final note, on notes: I read the Kindle version, in which notes appear at the end of the book, numbered according to each chapter. Unfortunately, none of these notes are linked within the actual chapters, making looking them up after reading too tedious a chore. As I have not seen a copy of the physical book, this might be a publishing decision, but it's something readers might want to be aware of.)