Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
The cops at the 43rd called it the unsolvable case.

October, 2010, Sally Jones had been stabbed in the heart in her apartment on Commonwealth Avenue, in the Bronx. Her coat was on the back of her chair. Her shoes were beside her bed, her clothes were neatly folded, and she was dead under the sheets.

The killer had removed Sally’s hands and feet and departed, leaving no trace - except the dismembered body.

October, 2019, as the national media focuses on the 43rd’s unbroken record in cold cases, Detective John Stone, head the unit, decides to tackle the case.

But he and Dehan are soon to discover that this is a case like no other: who were the visitors who came to see her before her death? What was their connection with the shadowy Sacred Brotherhood of Christ? And did her brother, Captain Ewan Jones, seek to help her - or murder her? It soon begins to look like this is indeed the case they will never crack.

And what, Dehan wants to know, happened to the Mustang?

232 pages, ebook

Published December 9, 2019

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Blake Banner

244 books425 followers
USA TODAY and Amazon #1 bestselling author of the OMEGA and DEAD COLD MYSTERY series. Learn more about Blake Banner at his website: www.blakebanner.com

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
961 (57%)
4 stars
518 (30%)
3 stars
159 (9%)
2 stars
28 (1%)
1 star
9 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews
Profile Image for Phrynne.
4,303 reviews2,869 followers
December 27, 2020
Now that is what I call action packed. Short, sharp and people getting shot every which way. Not excluding one of our dynamic duo.

Banner turns the tables on Stone at last and Dehan is the one to solve the crime, keeping her partner out of the loop the way he usually does her. Despite the seriousness of events there was still plenty of humour between the two of them which is always one of the best bits of this series.

I read these books for pure entertainment value and this one had that in spades. Five stars.
Profile Image for Shandare.
82 reviews11 followers
May 7, 2020
Finally. Finally!
Carmen Dehan gets to be in the driver’s seat.
If you have read any of the previous novels in the series, you’ll know that Dehan plays a slightly frustrated and oblivious Watson to John Stone’s Sherlock.
Now, finally, Dehan has a case where she sees the clues, and Stone is stumbling behind, trying to catch up. A nice change of pace in book 20!
Profile Image for Michele bookloverforever.
8,337 reviews37 followers
December 9, 2019
Whoa!

Guessed the murderer right away. Well, at least one of them. There were a lot of red herrings in this tale. Exciting, dangerous...a wild wild rice in every way. Greed...it played a part in every murder. Greed for money, greed for things ,greed for power.
Profile Image for Tonya Sullivan.
77 reviews2 followers
July 24, 2020
Major plot mismanagement

Imagine the disappointment of eagerly waiting for the next book, eagerly anticipating the confirmation of “baby news”, eagerly waiting for SOME KIND of movement forward in their relationship...and getting jack s**t in return.
A relationship that took FOREVER to reveal itself.
John Sanford consistently moves his characters through life, and life changes in the Prey Series. It’s what defines a good author.
We’ve read through book after book of John and Carmen “gazing at each other”. And just when it looks like things are going to get interesting, BAM, nothing.
Very very very disappointing.
13 reviews1 follower
February 17, 2020
SPOILER ALERT
I’ve read every one of the Cold Case books and I love them. But.....what happened to the pregnancy? Why can’t we have a little more of the personal lives of Deehan and Stone? And please, Blake, why don’t you get a proofreader to make the books even better? Deehan had begun to be less important to the detective process in the last few books as Stone was taking centre stage in all the stories. Can’t wait for the next book, though.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
16 reviews
December 26, 2019
Dean turned Sensi

Usually Stone is figuring out the cases and won't share with Dehan. It was good to see the tables turned.
Profile Image for sara ❥.
240 reviews1 follower
October 15, 2026
★★★☆☆.25

Unfortunately, this one was one of my least favourite books in the series so far. After the previous book being one of my favourites, this one just didn't hit the same 🥲 however, I will give credit where it's due because the plot was definitely plotting, especially towards the end!

The biggest twist was finding out that Sally, the victim at the centre of the cold case, was actually the one who killed Gus, only for her to eventually be killed by Leon, who had been their friend at the time. And all of this ultimately came down to a vintage car?! 😭 I genuinely didn't see that coming, so the unexpected reveal was probably what saved this book from getting an even lower rating.

My biggest issue was the subplot involving the Brotherhood, a group claiming to be servants of God and doing His work. I've noticed that Blake's books often revolve quite heavily around religion and although these storylines can be interesting, sometimes I feel like they're a little TOO much.

The whole situation with Jeremiah Rose, the Brotherhood's leader, and what happens with Dehan towards the end felt a bit unrealistic to me. It also felt disconnected from the actual cold case. Yes, some of Sally's family were connected to the Brotherhood, which made them potential suspects but the storyline eventually became so much bigger than the original investigation that I found myself wondering whether it was really necessary.

My favourite part was Dehan taking the lead on the case! 👏🏼 she basically gave Stone a taste of his own medicine by keeping her theories and conclusions to herself while she worked through the evidence. Anyone who knows Stone knows how much he loves being mysterious and acting like he's figured everything out before anyone else 😂 so it was nice seeing Dehan do the same thing to him for once!

Overall, I think this book had an interesting mystery and a reveal I genuinely didn't see coming but I would have much preferred the story to focus more on Sally, Gus and Leon rather than spending so much time on the Brotherhood subplot.

I could have easily read those 190-ish pages in one sitting if the entire book had focused more on the actual cold case. It wasn't necessarily a bad book but compared to the others in the series, it just wasn't a favourite. I'll definitely continue with the series but this one was a bit of a miss for me 🤠
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for M.
1,576 reviews
December 17, 2019
Enjoyable quips & zingers from two smart detectives. Plus, there’s greed, danger, hit men, SWAT, & hostage-taking.

What do the following have in common? 1) extremist Christians who turn a small, Maine town into Waco on steroids, 2) Actor Steve McQueen’s ‘65 Mustang Fastback goes missing from a heavily guarded estate, and 3) a grisly amputation-murder cold case is resurrected in NYC. Detectives Carmen Dehan and John Stone are both involved in the aforementioned situations, but they aren’t finding relevant connections . . . at first.

I chuckled whilst reading, because for once, Dehan has the upper hand. She just knows in her gut whodunnit, and Stone gets the kept-in-the-dark treatment from Dehan, in a fine turnabout situation. HE is usually the one hoarding information to frustrate Dehan, so this time he’s less than pleased. Stone is frustrated and petulant, and after a while, I found it annoying to read about his annoyance. I must think upon why I’ve been complacent about Stone annoying Dehan.

I enjoyed this well-written, mostly fast-paced book. I suggest the author hire an editor for spelling, word choices, punctuation, time discrepancies, etc.
Profile Image for Charles A. CALLARI III.
283 reviews1 follower
October 10, 2025
From the first page, Mustang Sally hits like a revved-up muscle car roaring down a dark highway—fast, loud, and impossible to ignore. Blake Banner delivers another gritty, action-packed ride featuring the unstoppable John Flynn. The dialogue crackles, the pacing never slows, and the mix of danger, loyalty, and dry humor keeps you fully locked in. I loved the way the tension built toward a cinematic showdown—pure adrenaline.

If you’re a fan of rough-edged heroes, sharp twists, and no-nonsense storytelling, this one doesn’t disappoint. A few moments felt a bit over the top, but overall, it’s a damn entertaining read.
1,477 reviews27 followers
December 13, 2019
Mustang Sally. Blake Banner

Another fantastic who dunnit murder mystery. Two murders are committed on the same night. One, very graphic, a clear message is sent. The other, a clean hit. Both turn into ten year old cold cases. The evidence and clues left behind point no where. Detectives Stone and Dehan, who are a married couple decide to take the case on. Just when you think the murder is solved, another strange twist occurs. This is an excellent read. Enjoyed immensely!
Profile Image for Chrystal Evans.
278 reviews2 followers
July 15, 2021
Back in form Blake! I must say 'thank god for that'. Two books in a row? Pat on the back!

This one was awesome. Action packed svu 2 part special kind of fucked up but so good. And Dehan finally got her pay back and one up'd Stone the smug bastard. All in all crazy ocult, sinister tricky shit. Would have loved to know a bit more about what went down with the brotherhoods records but it was great either way
Profile Image for Rosemary Dreyer.
1,695 reviews6 followers
November 28, 2022
2 3/4 Stars: Another weak book in the series. There were so many things wrong with this one: a ridiculous, convoluted plot; how Dehan was as obnoxious as Stone can get with his not sharing his process - the dynamic is extremely juvenile; the cussing and craziness of the Brotherhood - they would NOT cuss like this or as much as was written; this time Bernie is as ineffectual as the inspector usually is portrayed; the “smoking gun” with Leon. Overall, I would not recommend this novella.
5 reviews
January 2, 2023
Another great book in the series but loses a star because of the complete absence of the sub plot from the previous book!

Nothing mentioned at all regarding it, was very confusing and read the whole book with the thought in the back of my mind “he will mention it in this chapter”

I even went back and read the last few pages again in Death in Dexter, I did notice the Kindle version has no Epilogue, could that be why??
23 reviews
June 29, 2023
Can't stop reading these!

The Dead Cold Mysteries are my favorite detective stores. They are so cleverly developed, Stone and Dehan are the greatest team, and they keep you guessing thought up to the end. Then you think you're dumb for not having figured out out. My wife and i read them later into the night. Keep going Blake!
Profile Image for Angela.
10.5k reviews135 followers
August 4, 2024
4.5 stars

Mustang Sally is the twentieth book in the Dead Cold Mystery series by Blake Banner.
Great series. Cold Cases. Crime and investigation. Mystery. Suspense. Detectives. Police procedural. Intrigue. Tension. Dramatic developments. Action. Engrossing.
Would make a superb TV series.

Full Review to come.
240 reviews2 followers
December 11, 2019
Strangely Believable!

The most out there and interesting of the Dead Cold Series yet. Banner continues to capitalize on the undercurrents of modern society and twist them just enough to allow shock, awe and buy in by the reader.
Profile Image for Ann.
485 reviews6 followers
January 10, 2020
Once again everything is on hold while I get involved in the fascinating stories Mr Banner keeps coming up with. I just love following Dehan and Stone as they solve the case. Plenty of action and suspense.

It really did mean I could't stop until the end.
1,021 reviews23 followers
December 22, 2021
Mustang Sally

Very believable story of a group of people that have inbred for years under a strict code of conduct both religious and cultist with one supreme leader who is law. The second tale within the tale was a surprise!
353 reviews
October 19, 2022
FINALLY!!!

Yes, finally Dehan batted John a homerun in a cold case!
What a good time I had! It matters that for once (and I hope more times), Dehan can beat the hell out of a cold mystery.
Monica Beltrami. Montevideo, Uruguay.
Profile Image for Carol Thomas.
68 reviews1 follower
December 12, 2019
Great read!!!

What a team! Bring them a cold case and they solve two other crimes. Love these stories!😎
Bring on the next case.
Profile Image for Christine.
334 reviews
December 22, 2019
again a great story, I loved the way Dehan just knew that the Mustang was part of the plot, and used Stones method to tell him what happened, look forward to many more Blake, Please.
57 reviews
January 4, 2020
Another Page Turner

Great read another book you won't put down until you have read it cover to cover. Look for more books in the future.
Profile Image for Kelli.
89 reviews3 followers
March 22, 2020
I enjoy plot twists, and this one provides several.
I appreciate how this author tells a story!
Profile Image for Bklynsouth.
102 reviews
November 4, 2020
Story is good, but author is need of a good editor. Way to many mistakes.
Profile Image for Amanda.
41 reviews
June 20, 2021
Typos and question

I found a couple of typos. Also at the end of the last book, Dehan was pregnant or thought she was, yet no mention of that in this book.
Profile Image for Marianne.
335 reviews
June 28, 2021
Awesome story finished this one quickly kept me engaged couldn't put it down. Keep them coming. Love it.
34 reviews
April 20, 2022
But ...?

No follow up on the possible pregnancy?! Disappointing that, but this book like all those before keeps a fast pace and keeps y out guessing!!
625 reviews4 followers
October 24, 2022
Great story!

Another great mystery to solve for the crew. A strong plot with plenty of twists and turns to keep the pages turning.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 42 reviews