Plugged In by Daniel Strange is for Christians who want to think more carefully and critically about the cultural products they consume. Written in an engaging and winsome way, it provides a sort of blue print for participating in “Christian cultural analysis,” as Tim Keller puts it in the book’s introduction. With a strong emphasis on evangelism, much of the book’s energy is devoted to helping readers consider how they might tease out a text’s underlying presuppositional beliefs, and then discuss those findings in light of Christian doctrine with friends, colleagues, and neighbors.
My favorite chapter, and one that I think many Christians might find beneficial, is the one called “Can I Watch…?” in which Strange argues that the five Solas of the Reformation (Scripture alone, grace alone, faith alone, Christ alone, and God’s glory alone) “are a useful test or filter through which to measure our cultural consumption and creation” (84). I found this fresh and creative litmus test helpful in ensuring that the Christian conscience is “cared for, trained, and calibrated by the truth” (93).
My somewhat phlegmatic three star rating has less to do with the book’s merits—which are numerous—and more to do with my subjective experience with it. Though I found the book useful and fun overall, my indifference to all things sport-related ensured that the many references to such things in Plugged In would be completely lost on me. This feature of the book, however, could be a strong selling point for others.
I also have some lingering questions about the implicit theological debate simmering beneath the surface of the book (i.e. transformationalism versus the two kingdoms doctrine). From what I understand, this debate goes all the way back to Augustine and has implications for the way Christians are to think about politics, culture, and vocation. It’s a debate that I am keen to learn more about, thanks in large part to this book for raising the right questions. My guess is that Plugged-In is coming from the transformationalist angle, and I find myself naturally more inclined toward the two kingdoms view. I have therefore added David VanDrunen’s Living in God’s Two Kingdoms and Michael Horton’s Where in the World Is the Church? to my to-read list, in the hope that they might clarify some of the gut-level objections I felt while reading Plugged In.
Overall, Plugged In is sure to be a satisfying read for Christians who already love engaging in cultural analysis, and a necessary one for Christians who don’t.