I picked this up at the library out of fascination, because almost all of the books that we have on weddings are aspirational and unrealistic. Either they provide photos and details about other people's lavish, over-the-top weddings for inspiration, or they tell you in painstaking detail how to DIY yourself to death and make sure that your Big Day can stand up next to the most adorable, touching, and personalized corners of wedding Pinterest.
This book does neither. Instead, it provides a thorough guide to designing a practical, affordable wedding that is everything you want it to be, not everything that the wedding industry or the lady at the post office says that it ought to be. Meg Keene is funny, sassy, and insightful, and she helps to de-stress the wedding-planning process by encouraging her readers to keep the end in mind, focus their time, attention, and money on the elements of the ceremony and reception that they truly value, and jettison unnecessary traditions.
She also makes my history major soul very happy by including a chapter on how American weddings have changed over time, explaining that our concept of "tradition" is based on what the wedding industry tells us, not on the historical record, in which brides often wore the nicest dress out of their closet and stood up in the backyard for a ceremony that their family and neighbors decorated and fixed food for. She provides helpful talking points for her readers to bring up with friends and family to help them explain choices that go against "tradition," saying that it is possible to educate people about how subjective most traditions are without judging other people for what they chose to do in their wedding.
However, did you know that the concept of the unity candle originated in the script for a soap opera? WHY AM I NOT SURPRISED.
In addition to providing a reality check against the demands of the wedding industry (and your relatives!), Keene also gets into the nitty-gritty of wedding planning, providing practical tips and important warnings. There are so many things that she pointed out that I would never have thought about before, and this book is essential as a planning guide, not just as perky self-help. I would recommend this to absolutely anyone who is getting married, because it is that accessible, kind, helpful, and practical. Keene never assumes what kind of wedding you want to have, and provides examples from friends, acquaintances, and people she has worked with through her wedding website, sharing quotes and practical details from women who have had any permutation of a wedding that you can imagine. No matter what style, location, timing, guest list size, or other consideration someone has in mind, this book will address it in some way.
Keene also addresses challenging topics such as what to do when your parents are divorced, deceased, or don't approve of your relationship. There is a whole chapter on how to deal with the hard stuff while planning a wedding, and she also addresses couples' potential fears of divorce, when to consider calling off a wedding, and how to work through conflicts that arise during the planning process. She also repeatedly encourages couples to seek premarital counseling, and provides sample questions for couples to talk through together so that they can address complex issues related to their backgrounds, preferences, beliefs, and plans for the future. Again, this book is SO REALISTIC and helpful!
However, my absolute favorite thing about this is the respect, awe, and joy with which Keene writes about marriage. Even though this book is very modern in the sense that it encourages personalized, non-traditional weddings when they appeal and includes a chapter on the challenges that LGBTQ couples face, Keene's view of the institution of marriage is beautifully traditional. Over and over again, she emphasizes that your wedding day is the first time that you will be presented before your community as a new family unit. Unlike other resources, which focus on weddings as a personalized monument to your relationship, Keene gets real about the fact that your wedding is just the first day of your marriage, not the endgame. Your wedding doesn't have to be perfect, because your marriage isn't going to be perfect, but you can experience great joy, love, and community as you transition into a new part of your life.
She writes about divorce, and she acknowledges in the afterword that many couples quoted in this book have divorced since the 2011 first edition, but she never takes a jaded view towards marriage or assumes that divorce is desirable or always necessary. It's part of life, and it sometimes happens, but she is still dead serious about the fact that you are going to stand in front of your family and friends and vow to be love and be faithful to your spouse until death do you part. This was SO refreshing. Although faith-based sources about weddings emphasize the long-term nature of marriage and the seriousness of making vows to each other, I have never before encountered a secular book that has such a high view of marriage and lasting commitment.
Keene addresses the seriousness of commitment and what marriage means, and she also encourages her readers to leverage the stresses of wedding-planning to strengthen their relationship. This is not just about throwing an awesome party. You are beginning your life together in a very public and serious way, and she points out that if you are able to work through stressful, emotional issues during the wedding-planning process, you will be much better equipped to make other decisions later, such as how to handle aging parents' long-term care. All throughout this book, she treats marriage as a lifelong relationship with constant implications for families and communities, and it is beautiful.
In the section about wedding gifts, she encourages readers to accept their loved ones' generosity instead of feeling uncomfortable about getting free stuff just for getting married. She explains that gift-giving allows other people to have a tangible stake in the marriage, supporting the couple in material ways and providing something that they will use for years. She says that even though you may already have some plates from the thrift store, someone wants to give you the stoneware plates that you will possibly feed your children on someday and will take with you to the retirement community. YES. YES. This is exactly right.
I know that this is a very long review from a reader who isn't even planning a wedding, but this book is amazing, refreshing, and a wonderful resource. I'm so glad that I read it! I learned a lot, found the author's high view of marriage deeply encouraging, have new things to think about when I evaluate weddings, got ideas for my fictional character's weddings (I do plan those!), and will recommend this book to everyone I know who is getting married from this point forward.