Sorry GS, you missed the mark with me.
It's really too bad that I hated this book so much, because there are a lot of excellent foundational truths in here. The core principles—1) Respond vs. React, 2) Provide Structure, and 3) Create Safety — are brilliantly concise and well-explained. His suggestions for getting out of your head and into your body are genius. (I'd heard of several before, but many were new.) I love that he recognized that men and women are indeed different (shocker!) and we need to understand each other to create any kind of healthy relationship. I have long felt that men are hard-wired to protect and preside; GS seems to agree with me. It's also true that - as a woman - I am more attracted to my husband when he leads with confidence; I am capable of leading, but I get tired of it, and I would love to be more in my "Femininity," as GS puts it. I was also floored with his description of anxiety: like radio static played on full blast, blocking out all emotions. Wow, he nailed that. His provocation meditation was an interesting suggestion; I tried it and I definitely found value in it. I intend to continue practicing. And I'm always a fan of authenticity; he urges his male readers to just admit they're angry already - don't try to mask it or push it down. Own it, work through it, and move on. I am the mother of six incredible boys, and I, too, urge them to own masculinity with pride and power.
Yet despite all this - I really did hate the book.
He bundled all this truth into a truly heinous package. He repeatedly bleats that he means no offense to women. And yet - he's EXTREMELY offensive to women.
Here's a direct quote, page 239:
"The Feminine is moody. You might even say that the Feminine is "crazy," particularly when she is ranting and raving at you. .... In those times, she may seem scary and impenetrable."
The next page reassures that underneath it all, there "lies an inner child, a little girl that just wants her Daddy to protect her and take care of things."
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yes, this entire book, for all its wisdom, is constantly framed within the context of LEADING YOUR WOMAN to be the"sex kitten" she really actually wants to be. The book instructs us that there are only two reasons women don't want to have sex: she's not feeling loved, and she's tired of unskilled sex.
Wow. Just wow.
Never mind that this beautiful blueprint (again, Respond vs. React, Provide Structure, and Create Safety) is just the mark of a decent human being. ANYONE can use those principles with ANYONE they come in contact with - a parent, a child, a neighbor, a cashier, a coworker. All of these fantastic mental health tools will make you a better PERSON! Leading and confidence and empathy and emotional honesty are part of becoming HAPPY. Sure, they'll probably make you a better lover too. But that should be far down the list of motivations - not the primary one.
My favorite part is when GS tells his (male) readers that strong women may oppose his ideas. His advice? Just don't tell them. I kid you not.
Makes me wonder if "his woman" has read this book. (Ooooo, that grated on me so bad. He says he doesn't mean to use that term possessively, but ... that's the literal grammatical definition of the phrase.)
And hey, GS? Secrecy is the primary hallmark of manipulation and toxic control.
It's really too bad. I mean, I know I'm just a raging lunatic female, so he'll never read my review with any kind of open mind, but I sincerely wish that he would deliver his (very good!) message with the pure intent of improving people's personal happiness, rather than their sex lives.