What do you think?
Rate this book
The Lady Upstairs
A modern-day noir featuring a twisty cat-and-mouse chase, this dark debut thriller tells the story of a a woman who makes a living taking down terrible men...then finds herself in over her head and with blood on her hands. The only way out? Pull off one final con.
Jo's job is blackmailing the most lecherous men in Los Angeles--handsy Hollywood producers, adulterous actors, corrupt cops. Sure, she likes the money she's making, which comes in handy for the debt she is paying off, but it's also a chance to take back power for the women of the city. Eager to prove herself to her coworker Lou and their enigmatic boss, known only as the Lady Upstairs, Jo takes on bigger and riskier jobs.
When one of her targets is murdered, both the Lady Upstairs and the LAPD have Jo in their sights. Desperate to escape the consequences of her failed job, she decides to take on just one more sting--bringing down a rising political star. It's her biggest con yet--and she will do it behind the Lady's back, freeing both herself and Lou. But Jo soon learns that Lou and the Lady have secrets of their own, and that no woman is safe when there is a life-changing payout on the line.
A delicious debut thriller crackling with wit and an unforgettable feminist voice, The Lady Upstairs is a chilling and endlessly surprising take on female revenge.
Jo's job is blackmailing the most lecherous men in Los Angeles--handsy Hollywood producers, adulterous actors, corrupt cops. Sure, she likes the money she's making, which comes in handy for the debt she is paying off, but it's also a chance to take back power for the women of the city. Eager to prove herself to her coworker Lou and their enigmatic boss, known only as the Lady Upstairs, Jo takes on bigger and riskier jobs.
When one of her targets is murdered, both the Lady Upstairs and the LAPD have Jo in their sights. Desperate to escape the consequences of her failed job, she decides to take on just one more sting--bringing down a rising political star. It's her biggest con yet--and she will do it behind the Lady's back, freeing both herself and Lou. But Jo soon learns that Lou and the Lady have secrets of their own, and that no woman is safe when there is a life-changing payout on the line.
A delicious debut thriller crackling with wit and an unforgettable feminist voice, The Lady Upstairs is a chilling and endlessly surprising take on female revenge.
320 pages, Paperback
First published November 17, 2020
251 people are currently reading
6000 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 331 reviews
December 21, 2020
This is gripping, surprisingly entertaining, action packed reading with kickassing, tough, cool heroines tells provocative story with #metoo vibes and quite delicious feminism references.
We may proudly announce there is fresh talented author out there about the release her captivating debut novel! Well done dear Halley Sutton who brought an original, different plot and hooked me up at with those first pages. Even though at some parts I get lost my interest just a little bit, she wrapped up the story so well with quite intriguing and clever conclusion.
Let’s chat about the plot and meet with our heroines, bad guys and story’s progression:
We’re introduced to Joe: our one of kickass, strong, likable heroines, pays her dues, atones for her sins with a risky job she took. She works for Lady Upstairs to punish the ruthless men including corrupted police officers, abuser Hollywood Producers and dirty cheater actors. She seems like a vigilante who brings justice to town. Her coworker Lou gives the orders she took from their mysterious boss.
Everything seems going flat and Jo is about to pay her debt to earn her freedom. But she makes a big mistake at her job and one of her targets is found murdered which takes the attention of LAPD and her lovely, vicious and dangerous lady boss. Now her life is at the stake and she needs to accept the biggest con to save herself and coworker from the wrath of her boss. But her new assignment couldn’t be more risky: she needs to take down a dangerous and resourceful politician. Payback is karma’s little sister, both of them are real bitches! Could Jo achieve her mission and save herself from the danger? Lips are sealed. You gotta read it! But I have to admit especially last pages are thrilling, edgy, dazzling, twisty makes you squirm at your seats and forces you turn the pages as fast as you could.
Overall: I’m giving four moving, enjoyable, captivating, impressive stars! It was promising and great start! I’m looking forward to read more works of Halley Sutton in near future.
Special thanks to NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Putnam/ G.P. Putnam’s Sons for sharing this entertaining ARC in exchange my honest review.
We may proudly announce there is fresh talented author out there about the release her captivating debut novel! Well done dear Halley Sutton who brought an original, different plot and hooked me up at with those first pages. Even though at some parts I get lost my interest just a little bit, she wrapped up the story so well with quite intriguing and clever conclusion.
Let’s chat about the plot and meet with our heroines, bad guys and story’s progression:
We’re introduced to Joe: our one of kickass, strong, likable heroines, pays her dues, atones for her sins with a risky job she took. She works for Lady Upstairs to punish the ruthless men including corrupted police officers, abuser Hollywood Producers and dirty cheater actors. She seems like a vigilante who brings justice to town. Her coworker Lou gives the orders she took from their mysterious boss.
Everything seems going flat and Jo is about to pay her debt to earn her freedom. But she makes a big mistake at her job and one of her targets is found murdered which takes the attention of LAPD and her lovely, vicious and dangerous lady boss. Now her life is at the stake and she needs to accept the biggest con to save herself and coworker from the wrath of her boss. But her new assignment couldn’t be more risky: she needs to take down a dangerous and resourceful politician. Payback is karma’s little sister, both of them are real bitches! Could Jo achieve her mission and save herself from the danger? Lips are sealed. You gotta read it! But I have to admit especially last pages are thrilling, edgy, dazzling, twisty makes you squirm at your seats and forces you turn the pages as fast as you could.
Overall: I’m giving four moving, enjoyable, captivating, impressive stars! It was promising and great start! I’m looking forward to read more works of Halley Sutton in near future.
Special thanks to NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Putnam/ G.P. Putnam’s Sons for sharing this entertaining ARC in exchange my honest review.
August 17, 2020
A promising debut from Halley Sutton, a gifted new voice of the modern noir.
The Lady Upstairs was a timely novel about blackmail, secrets, revenge, desire, and sex. The rotten underbelly of Los Angeles, and its beautiful, famous inhabitants, was exposed in the dark bars and seedy hotels that line so many of her streets. There is something so deliciously satisfying about a group of women working to take down powerful, but vile, men...especially Jo, our femme fatale protagonist. It all ties so beautifully into the #metoo and #savethechildren movements.
While I enjoyed Jo's "tough cookie" vibes, I actually enjoyed her more during her moments of vulnerability. The fact it happened so rarely made it all the more poignant. She was definitely the most nuanced character in the story. Lou and Robert, unfortunately, weren't nearly as fleshed out. It felt like a missed opportunity to add more gradation and depth.
The story, though it started strong, stuttered about halfway through. We began hearing more of Jo's internal dialogue, often drunken, and it lost the intense urgency which made me want to keep turning pages. The conclusion was predictable, but vaguely satisfying.
I recommend this book to those who love the cynicism and moral ambiguity which highlights all that is the noir. By the way, how about that gorgeous cover?
3.5 stars
Thanks to the publisher for my review copy.
The Lady Upstairs was a timely novel about blackmail, secrets, revenge, desire, and sex. The rotten underbelly of Los Angeles, and its beautiful, famous inhabitants, was exposed in the dark bars and seedy hotels that line so many of her streets. There is something so deliciously satisfying about a group of women working to take down powerful, but vile, men...especially Jo, our femme fatale protagonist. It all ties so beautifully into the #metoo and #savethechildren movements.
While I enjoyed Jo's "tough cookie" vibes, I actually enjoyed her more during her moments of vulnerability. The fact it happened so rarely made it all the more poignant. She was definitely the most nuanced character in the story. Lou and Robert, unfortunately, weren't nearly as fleshed out. It felt like a missed opportunity to add more gradation and depth.
The story, though it started strong, stuttered about halfway through. We began hearing more of Jo's internal dialogue, often drunken, and it lost the intense urgency which made me want to keep turning pages. The conclusion was predictable, but vaguely satisfying.
I recommend this book to those who love the cynicism and moral ambiguity which highlights all that is the noir. By the way, how about that gorgeous cover?
3.5 stars
Thanks to the publisher for my review copy.
December 22, 2020
The lady upstairs is the operator of a ring of prostitutes who blackmail their rich marks. The lady’s identity is secret, but it is pretty easy to figure out. Jim Thompson or James M. Cain could have given this plot some bite and menace. Unfortunately, this book is just tacky. It isn’t clever enough to overcome the ickiness of it’s premise. Jo, the protagonist, drinks a lot and has sex a lot, with both her male and female colleagues and marks. She is also in charge of recruiting other women to be pimped out. During most of the book nothing interesting happens, then murder ensues, and I didn’t care. Jo (and the author ) try to rationalize this nastiness with some feminist pronouncements. I don’t agree with this definition of feminism. Really, I’m sorry I kept reading. 2.5 stars
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher.
I received a free copy of this book from the publisher.
December 26, 2023
Market research read. If anyone knows any novels published 2019 forward about women plotting to commit or caught up in crime, let me know.
The Lady Upstairs is the debut novel by Halley Sutton, a frequent contributor to the CrimeReads website. Published in 2020, I had high hopes for this due to its terrific cover design (by Erika Verbeck) and promise of a noir-soaked thriller about a blackmail agency in L.A.
First-person narrative, while not a dealbreaker, signaled trouble. Even when a narrator is delightfully peculiar, or wields snark like a superpower, first-person often runs its course by the 30% mark. A novel is a long time to spend in someone else's thoughts or opinions, if the author isn't bringing much else to the potluck. Sutton's narrator, Jo, is about a tenth as witty or clever as most narrators.
Jo spends most of the novel drinking with her gal pal Lou, who works with her in an employment agency that serves as a front for "the Lady Upstairs," their mysterious boss who runs a blackmail ring and who Jo has never met. A blackmail ring should inspire a harrowing paranoid filled thriller or mystery, but Sutton doesn't offer the reader much in the way of an exciting plot. Jo talks. And drinks. And haphazardly puts together honeypot schemes using other women. And it's all very boring.
The novel's irreparable flaw is telling instead of showing. An incessant amount of dialogue is accompanied by what Jo thinks this means or that indicates or what might be going on here. This overwriting completely kills whatever tension might be building in the scene. There is entirely too much editorial aside, too much of the Writer, for a novel that has a handful of characters and isn't complex.
Two stars for some well-written description and enough sleaziness to keep me engaged, though I skimmed often. I did want to find out what tragedy might befall Jo. Neither the climax or the ending are satisfying.
The Lady Upstairs is the debut novel by Halley Sutton, a frequent contributor to the CrimeReads website. Published in 2020, I had high hopes for this due to its terrific cover design (by Erika Verbeck) and promise of a noir-soaked thriller about a blackmail agency in L.A.
First-person narrative, while not a dealbreaker, signaled trouble. Even when a narrator is delightfully peculiar, or wields snark like a superpower, first-person often runs its course by the 30% mark. A novel is a long time to spend in someone else's thoughts or opinions, if the author isn't bringing much else to the potluck. Sutton's narrator, Jo, is about a tenth as witty or clever as most narrators.
Jo spends most of the novel drinking with her gal pal Lou, who works with her in an employment agency that serves as a front for "the Lady Upstairs," their mysterious boss who runs a blackmail ring and who Jo has never met. A blackmail ring should inspire a harrowing paranoid filled thriller or mystery, but Sutton doesn't offer the reader much in the way of an exciting plot. Jo talks. And drinks. And haphazardly puts together honeypot schemes using other women. And it's all very boring.
The novel's irreparable flaw is telling instead of showing. An incessant amount of dialogue is accompanied by what Jo thinks this means or that indicates or what might be going on here. This overwriting completely kills whatever tension might be building in the scene. There is entirely too much editorial aside, too much of the Writer, for a novel that has a handful of characters and isn't complex.
Two stars for some well-written description and enough sleaziness to keep me engaged, though I skimmed often. I did want to find out what tragedy might befall Jo. Neither the climax or the ending are satisfying.
December 29, 2020
This was decent for a debut, and it was so fast-paced that I listened to the audio in less than 2 days, however the subject matter just was not for me. Female con artists in pursuit of rich, cheating husbands (the richer the better), and other 'bad men' in hopes to seduce them and blackmail them with photographic or video evidence is essentially the gist of this novel. Jo is our protagonist in this one, and she's looking to pull off one final con in hopes of finally paying off her debt to her boss, 'the lady upstairs,' whoever she may be. Of course events don't always go according to plan when you are extorting people, and Jo soon finds this out the hard way. Little does she know that the 'lady' is not quite ready for her to hang up her hat and retire just yet! I didn't care for any of the characters as they were truly all bad people, so I found it hard to connect and empathize with any of them, which makes the reading experience for me that much less enjoyable. Additionally, I figured out who the mysterious 'lady upstairs' was pretty much after the first chapter. Had the pacing not been so swift and the book so short, but that's most likely on me for not reading the synopsis and solely relying on great reviews before I went out and got this one :-( I truly believe this author has a lot of potential, and were she to explore another trope moving forward I would definitely read her again. I think a lot of people enjoyed this, and I'm most likely in the minority in this opinion.
December 27, 2020
There was little I could connect to with this book.
The characters elicited no sympathy and I even began to wish for their demise; they seemed very one-dimensional. The plot is convoluted in an unnecessary and illogical way. The twist was predictable within the first few chapters too. The setting, Hollywood, should have made the premise of the story stronger but it fell flat in too many ways.
The blurb made it sound intriguing but the reality was that I was very happy to be finished with this novel; others may feel completely differently than I do, up to you to give it a go.
The characters elicited no sympathy and I even began to wish for their demise; they seemed very one-dimensional. The plot is convoluted in an unnecessary and illogical way. The twist was predictable within the first few chapters too. The setting, Hollywood, should have made the premise of the story stronger but it fell flat in too many ways.
The blurb made it sound intriguing but the reality was that I was very happy to be finished with this novel; others may feel completely differently than I do, up to you to give it a go.
September 21, 2023
This wasn't as thrilling as I thought it would be but I liked the plot and the ending!
November 9, 2020
4.5 stars
The Lady Upstairs is the twisty noir I needed in 2020!
Jo was recruited by Lou to blackmail the Hollywood elite: the lecherous movie producers, actors, and politicians are brought down with scandalous photos that they’re willing to pay big money to keep hush hush. Their boss, known only as The Lady Upstairs, carefully chooses the targets and pockets a large portion of the pay-out.
Jo and Lou keep an office to appear as a respectable staffing agency; no questions are asked about the women coming and going throughout the day.
Things go sideways when a target is murdered and suddenly the LAPD is breathing down Jo’s neck. She’s failed to mention to Lou that she used the hush money for the cops to pay off a working girl involved in their scam.
Realizing she knows nothing about The Lady Upstairs and that she’s in big trouble, Jo has to figure out a way to outsmart The Lady to free herself and Lou. She’ll take one last mark - a rising politician - behind the Lady’s back in order to pay off her debts and get the hell out of town before she goes down for murder.
This was seriously an amazing contemporary noir with plenty of secrets, lies, and double-dealing; it’s dark, smart, and sexy! I enjoyed every page of this story and can’t wait to see what Halley Sutton offers readers next!
Huge thanks to G.P. Putnam's Sons and Edelweiss for providing me with a DRC in exchange for my honest review. The Lady Upstairs is scheduled for release on November 17, 2020.
For more reviews, visit www.rootsandreads.wordpress.com
The Lady Upstairs is the twisty noir I needed in 2020!
Jo was recruited by Lou to blackmail the Hollywood elite: the lecherous movie producers, actors, and politicians are brought down with scandalous photos that they’re willing to pay big money to keep hush hush. Their boss, known only as The Lady Upstairs, carefully chooses the targets and pockets a large portion of the pay-out.
Jo and Lou keep an office to appear as a respectable staffing agency; no questions are asked about the women coming and going throughout the day.
Things go sideways when a target is murdered and suddenly the LAPD is breathing down Jo’s neck. She’s failed to mention to Lou that she used the hush money for the cops to pay off a working girl involved in their scam.
Realizing she knows nothing about The Lady Upstairs and that she’s in big trouble, Jo has to figure out a way to outsmart The Lady to free herself and Lou. She’ll take one last mark - a rising politician - behind the Lady’s back in order to pay off her debts and get the hell out of town before she goes down for murder.
This was seriously an amazing contemporary noir with plenty of secrets, lies, and double-dealing; it’s dark, smart, and sexy! I enjoyed every page of this story and can’t wait to see what Halley Sutton offers readers next!
Huge thanks to G.P. Putnam's Sons and Edelweiss for providing me with a DRC in exchange for my honest review. The Lady Upstairs is scheduled for release on November 17, 2020.
For more reviews, visit www.rootsandreads.wordpress.com
November 18, 2020
The Lady Upstairs is a feminist noir thriller about power and revenge, and how easy it is to lose yourself to both.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. The opinions in this review are honest and my own.
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for the ARC. The opinions in this review are honest and my own.
January 9, 2021
The Lady Upstairs is a dark, provocative, modern day noir thriller about women doling out vigilante-style justice in the form of blackmail to some powerful men in Hollywood with questionable ethics. The story has a decidedly feminist voice with the boss aka the lady upstairs deciding which men need knocking off their pedestal for violating a code of conduct. Lou, the only woman who knows the identity of the "lady", serves as the liaison between her and the working girls. Our protagonist Jo has almost paid off her debt to the lady upstairs and is planning to get out of the business once she does. One bad decision and suddenly Jo is in over her head and faced with helping dispose of a dead client. With both her unknown boss and the cops hot on her tail, Jo's only option is to pull one more job - this time entirely on her own. She'll make back the money she needs and be free. Can it really be that simple?
The Lady Upstairs is an intriguing, unique thriller that's leans heavily on a character driven plot line. It starts off strong with the setup and introduction of characters. There's a cynical tone and morality playing out with justice being handed down in a twisted match game of wits. I found the writing and story structure to be solid, and enjoyed the old Hollywood ties and ambiance. However, the story begins to wobble midway through as readers are abandoned to deal with Jo's repeated drunken ramblings. The results are a slight loss of focus and slowing pace. It left my mind rambling much as Jo did. The pace picks up again as the story rolls toward the finish line and while I wasn't shocked by the big reveal, I was entertained. This is Halley Sutton's debut novel, and she's off to a great start. Highly recommended to fans of mystery and suspense with a dark edge.
3.5 Stars
*Thanks to G.P. Putnam's Sons Publishing for an arc of this book
**Review posted at: Cross My Heart Reviews
The Lady Upstairs is an intriguing, unique thriller that's leans heavily on a character driven plot line. It starts off strong with the setup and introduction of characters. There's a cynical tone and morality playing out with justice being handed down in a twisted match game of wits. I found the writing and story structure to be solid, and enjoyed the old Hollywood ties and ambiance. However, the story begins to wobble midway through as readers are abandoned to deal with Jo's repeated drunken ramblings. The results are a slight loss of focus and slowing pace. It left my mind rambling much as Jo did. The pace picks up again as the story rolls toward the finish line and while I wasn't shocked by the big reveal, I was entertained. This is Halley Sutton's debut novel, and she's off to a great start. Highly recommended to fans of mystery and suspense with a dark edge.
3.5 Stars
*Thanks to G.P. Putnam's Sons Publishing for an arc of this book
**Review posted at: Cross My Heart Reviews
September 10, 2020
Behind me, the ocean kept its own counsel because nature is far wiser than any of us and who knows what sleeps under its waters. I bet you anything the ocean itself couldn’t even tell you.
On my blog.
Rep: bi mc, bi side character
CWs: death, murder, alcohol and drug abuse
Galley provided by publisher
The Lady Upstairs is, in all honesty, a difficult one for me to review. I liked it, definitely, but I wasn’t so engrossed by it that I couldn’t put it down. It was a good thriller, but I saw too many of the twists coming and, ultimately, it didn’t have the tension to make it a great thriller for me.
The plot follows Jo, who is part of a group of people making a living from blackmailing folks in Hollywood. Jo is in debt to the group’s leader, the Lady Upstairs, after being almost caught way back when she started, but the job she is currently working promises to be the last one to pay off that debt. Only, everything goes wrong and Jo finds herself trapped between the Lady Upstairs and the police.
First things first, the book has a very engrossing writing style and I found myself halfway through the whole thing before I knew it. It was easy to root for Jo and Lou throughout. So that wasn’t at all a problem. I enjoyed reading it for this exact reason. Add onto that some great characters and I figured I would love it.
But I think what caught me here was that there was a slight lack of tension, where there needed to be. It’s a thriller, right? But it didn’t thrill me. There was never a point where I gasped out loud at any plot twists, I never really felt like there was a moment where I genuinely had no clue what would happen next. And I don’t know if this is a product of having read too many mysteries or thrillers, that I know the genre conventions now and everything becomes a little samey, but that was my issue here.
This is not to say it’s not a good book, still, or it’s not a book that someone who may have read fewer thrillers might enjoy more. In fact, if you’re looking to get into reading more thrillers, I would definitely suggest this one. It’s just that, whether as a result of my having read too many or because it was genuinely predictable, I wasn’t that surprised by anything in this one. Even when it was suggested that the Lady Upstairs might dispose of Jo — and by dispose you know what I mean — I didn’t feel any tension.
Which, ultimately, is what let me down in this one.
Want to read
November 29, 2020eBook Giveaway Win!
February 3, 2021
“The Lady Upstairs” was compelling to read, but I am still not sure how I feel about this disturbingly dark view of a “female protagonist.” I recommend other readers decide for themselves.
Jo is a professional, the creator of elaborate stings, the designer of elaborate cons, and an expert blackmailer. She works for “the Lady Upstairs, the faceless woman who hands down orders, and delivers the paychecks. The marks are hand selected for their connections, visibility, and ability to lay their hands on tiny mountains of cash quickly.
Sutton structures the narrative in Jo’s first person account. Jo is a complex character with many layers of behavior, both good and bad, and perception, both culpability and guiltlessness. She is basically rather unpleasant; she drinks too much, has a lot of random sex, and owes a lot of money to “The Lady Upstairs.” She also must recruit new employees. Trauma and drama follow her everywhere, and then there is a murder.
“The Lady Upstairs” is a very different look at female revenge. It is gritty, alarming, and shocking. I received a review copy of “The Lady Upstairs” from Halley Sutton, G.P. Putnam's Sons and Penguin Publishing Group.
Jo is a professional, the creator of elaborate stings, the designer of elaborate cons, and an expert blackmailer. She works for “the Lady Upstairs, the faceless woman who hands down orders, and delivers the paychecks. The marks are hand selected for their connections, visibility, and ability to lay their hands on tiny mountains of cash quickly.
Sutton structures the narrative in Jo’s first person account. Jo is a complex character with many layers of behavior, both good and bad, and perception, both culpability and guiltlessness. She is basically rather unpleasant; she drinks too much, has a lot of random sex, and owes a lot of money to “The Lady Upstairs.” She also must recruit new employees. Trauma and drama follow her everywhere, and then there is a murder.
“The Lady Upstairs” is a very different look at female revenge. It is gritty, alarming, and shocking. I received a review copy of “The Lady Upstairs” from Halley Sutton, G.P. Putnam's Sons and Penguin Publishing Group.
January 18, 2021
There is quite a dichotomy of opinions on this book, but I loved it!!
.
I had it completely figured out, there were no surprises, but that didn’t take away from the entertainment for me!
.
It is a quintessential popcorn thriller. Reading it is like sitting in a theater-
I swear I could feel butter on my fingertips 🍿 😂
.
I also love stories set in the seedy scenes of Los Angeles. I just loved every second of this book! ✨
_________________________________
.
Jo and Lou blackmail predatory, unscrupulous, powerful men in Los Angeles.
.
They work for the mysterious “Lady Upstairs” whom Jo has never met. The Lady calls all the shots from her cloaked position. She gives them the mark, then gives them their cut. The Lady is rumored to be ruthless, but she takes care of Jo and Lou.
.
Jo finds herself in a situation. She needs money. Should she go behind The Lady’s back to run her own con?
.
I had it completely figured out, there were no surprises, but that didn’t take away from the entertainment for me!
.
It is a quintessential popcorn thriller. Reading it is like sitting in a theater-
I swear I could feel butter on my fingertips 🍿 😂
.
I also love stories set in the seedy scenes of Los Angeles. I just loved every second of this book! ✨
_________________________________
.
Jo and Lou blackmail predatory, unscrupulous, powerful men in Los Angeles.
.
They work for the mysterious “Lady Upstairs” whom Jo has never met. The Lady calls all the shots from her cloaked position. She gives them the mark, then gives them their cut. The Lady is rumored to be ruthless, but she takes care of Jo and Lou.
.
Jo finds herself in a situation. She needs money. Should she go behind The Lady’s back to run her own con?
January 17, 2021
3.5 stars
The Lady Upstairs had me confused as to who was who for a little while at the beginning but then again, that might be my fault as I was trying to play a game that took a little too much of my focus while listening to an audiobook. Once that was over and once the story finally hooked me, it was a much better experience. Now I have to agree that the big reveal was predictable as I had guessed it early in the book but I don't really mind. I still didn't know how it was going to end up and how our MC was going to react. Overall, it was a pretty entertaining Mystery/Thriller.
The Lady Upstairs had me confused as to who was who for a little while at the beginning but then again, that might be my fault as I was trying to play a game that took a little too much of my focus while listening to an audiobook. Once that was over and once the story finally hooked me, it was a much better experience. Now I have to agree that the big reveal was predictable as I had guessed it early in the book but I don't really mind. I still didn't know how it was going to end up and how our MC was going to react. Overall, it was a pretty entertaining Mystery/Thriller.
August 23, 2020
I was lucky enough to secure an ARC after screaming on social media about how much I NEEDED one and pals, I am obsessed with this book. Within pages, it became one of my favorite reads—not only of hell year 2020—but EVER.
A booze-soaked, twisty, captivating noir that doesn’t center cis-het men, THE LADY UPSTAIRS both reclaims a classic narrative and fully infuses it with fresh voice and a new story trajectory.
The prose is visceral, poignant, and sharp as a knife. I loved the quiet moments as much as the loud ones. Sutton gives us so many facets of love and lust and friendship and failing. The text is RICH and SUMPTUOUS.
Our heroine Jo is a potent mix of bravado and fear. Her determination and loyalty to Lou make her easy to route for, but what really won by heart is the way she’s messy in this controlled fashion. She breaks your heart and the ache is so sweet. I also fell for Lou (how could you not)—with her palpable charisma and veiled darkness. Even characters that I started out disliking, like Jackal and Ellen, were fully formed and I found myself growing invested in them. This book is full of flawed humans, each of them nuanced—broken in their own distinct ways.
This book is feminist but not the shiny pink plastic version. It’s as dynamic and complicated an issue in the story as it is IRL.
Halley Sutton is a wild talent. I can't wait to read everything she writes for the rest of forever.
A booze-soaked, twisty, captivating noir that doesn’t center cis-het men, THE LADY UPSTAIRS both reclaims a classic narrative and fully infuses it with fresh voice and a new story trajectory.
The prose is visceral, poignant, and sharp as a knife. I loved the quiet moments as much as the loud ones. Sutton gives us so many facets of love and lust and friendship and failing. The text is RICH and SUMPTUOUS.
Our heroine Jo is a potent mix of bravado and fear. Her determination and loyalty to Lou make her easy to route for, but what really won by heart is the way she’s messy in this controlled fashion. She breaks your heart and the ache is so sweet. I also fell for Lou (how could you not)—with her palpable charisma and veiled darkness. Even characters that I started out disliking, like Jackal and Ellen, were fully formed and I found myself growing invested in them. This book is full of flawed humans, each of them nuanced—broken in their own distinct ways.
This book is feminist but not the shiny pink plastic version. It’s as dynamic and complicated an issue in the story as it is IRL.
Halley Sutton is a wild talent. I can't wait to read everything she writes for the rest of forever.
May 22, 2020
I contributed this review to Really Into This
Check out all of our reviews at https://reallyintothis.com
Happy Reading, friends!
Special thanks to Putman for providing our copy in exchange for an honest & fair review.
This is a really interesting book & it took me several days to gather my thoughts about it.
I couldn't put this book down. The plot simmers. We know we will eventually meet The Lady Upstairs face to face, but I wanted to get there ASAP. I don't really know if the pay-off is there, but it was there enough to keep me reading as fast as I could. I just had to know!
I really like Sutton's writing style. Her female lead is flawed, real & honest with readers. We see everything. I so appreciate this & it makes me root for her more.
This title definitely has a darker, noir feel. I'm a huge fan of the show Imposters & I really see some similarities. I do love a con story SO much and this is a good one.
I did also appreciate & root for the women sticking it these disgusting men, even if I didn't always agree with their tactics.
Overall, a really engrossing read.
Check out all of our reviews at https://reallyintothis.com
Happy Reading, friends!
Special thanks to Putman for providing our copy in exchange for an honest & fair review.
This is a really interesting book & it took me several days to gather my thoughts about it.
I couldn't put this book down. The plot simmers. We know we will eventually meet The Lady Upstairs face to face, but I wanted to get there ASAP. I don't really know if the pay-off is there, but it was there enough to keep me reading as fast as I could. I just had to know!
I really like Sutton's writing style. Her female lead is flawed, real & honest with readers. We see everything. I so appreciate this & it makes me root for her more.
This title definitely has a darker, noir feel. I'm a huge fan of the show Imposters & I really see some similarities. I do love a con story SO much and this is a good one.
I did also appreciate & root for the women sticking it these disgusting men, even if I didn't always agree with their tactics.
Overall, a really engrossing read.
January 19, 2021
A group of women "living to take down terrible men". Sold! As expected, we get a read about sex, blackmail and revenge. Jo is our flawed protagonist who loves her job but is desperate for the money as she has pressing debts to pay off. Plus, it keeps her close to Lou, who she clearly is in love with and is hoping to run off into the sunset with her at some point. But first, she needs to get herself sorted and this is no easy task.
While I love the premise of this and felt it started strong, the middle lulled as we get further into Jo's gin-soaked brain. So many mistakes being made... GET YOUR SHIT TOGETHER, JO! Then it gets interesting again as the last quarter moves right along. The twist was expected but I wasn't sure if it was going to go *this* way or *that* way and then.... well, I don't know about you other readers, but WHAM, BAM, THANK YOU MA'AM. Though, admittedly, I could've done without the last chapter.
A very solid and promising debut from Sutton. I'll certainly be keeping an eye out for her as I have no doubt she's making her mark in this genre.
While I love the premise of this and felt it started strong, the middle lulled as we get further into Jo's gin-soaked brain. So many mistakes being made... GET YOUR SHIT TOGETHER, JO! Then it gets interesting again as the last quarter moves right along. The twist was expected but I wasn't sure if it was going to go *this* way or *that* way and then.... well, I don't know about you other readers, but WHAM, BAM, THANK YOU MA'AM. Though, admittedly, I could've done without the last chapter.
A very solid and promising debut from Sutton. I'll certainly be keeping an eye out for her as I have no doubt she's making her mark in this genre.
January 5, 2023
I'm sorry but this is not for me. I just cannot get into the story or the characters.
November 13, 2020
Thank you Putnam Books for the gifted copy!
This one just totally missed the mark for me.
I started reading it after putting Addie LaRue down for a break and ended up finishing it in one night.
I sat on reviewing it because I wanted to make sure that Addie didn’t effect my overall opinion on how I felt about it, but I now know that it just wasn’t what I was expecting with the title “The Lady Upstairs”
I always go in blind when it comes to a book and really thought this book was going to be different than it was. However, it still gave me the ultimate suspense I wanted in a thriller - I just don’t think that the ending gave me exactly what I needed from the whole storyline.
I will say that there is one part in this book that totally had me like 😱 and for that you’ll just have to read it and find out!!
C O M I N G S O O N 11 / 17 / 20
It’s the authors debut novel and because of that I have hopes that other books by her in the future will bring more of that thriller element of surprise I was looking for with The Lady Upstairs.
This one just totally missed the mark for me.
I started reading it after putting Addie LaRue down for a break and ended up finishing it in one night.
I sat on reviewing it because I wanted to make sure that Addie didn’t effect my overall opinion on how I felt about it, but I now know that it just wasn’t what I was expecting with the title “The Lady Upstairs”
I always go in blind when it comes to a book and really thought this book was going to be different than it was. However, it still gave me the ultimate suspense I wanted in a thriller - I just don’t think that the ending gave me exactly what I needed from the whole storyline.
I will say that there is one part in this book that totally had me like 😱 and for that you’ll just have to read it and find out!!
C O M I N G S O O N 11 / 17 / 20
It’s the authors debut novel and because of that I have hopes that other books by her in the future will bring more of that thriller element of surprise I was looking for with The Lady Upstairs.
May 1, 2021
Well, this was disappointing. I'm a sucker for what I call "Hollywood trash" and this is a crime noir, set in LA, featuring our heroine, Jo, who is running blackmail cons on powerful men. Her and her partners Lou (female) and Robert Jackal (seriously?!) work for the mysterious "Lady Upstairs" - and wouldn't you know it? Only Lou really knows anything about "The Lady" and she ain't sharing details. Then Jo's latest job, the one that would get her out of The Lady's debt goes sideways, the bribe money that should have gone to the cops didn't, bodies start falling, and the clock is ticking.
This should be good, but it's not mainly because Jo is the dumbest dumb bunny ever. The girl she has working the job that goes sideways is a dumpster fire, and since it's Jo's job to "train" the girls this doesn't say much about Jo. She spends the entire book not-so-slowly drinking herself to death and failing to see what's so painfully obvious from the very beginning regarding The Lady's identity - seriously, this girl is one dumb, dumb bunny.
Is it possible I've read too many suspense novels? Maybe. I've read a lot. But I can still be surprised when the author is really working it. Nothing worked here. And it could have been great. Oh well, moving on.
This should be good, but it's not mainly because Jo is the dumbest dumb bunny ever. The girl she has working the job that goes sideways is a dumpster fire, and since it's Jo's job to "train" the girls this doesn't say much about Jo. She spends the entire book not-so-slowly drinking herself to death and failing to see what's so painfully obvious from the very beginning regarding The Lady's identity - seriously, this girl is one dumb, dumb bunny.
Is it possible I've read too many suspense novels? Maybe. I've read a lot. But I can still be surprised when the author is really working it. Nothing worked here. And it could have been great. Oh well, moving on.
February 3, 2021
I have received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The Lady Upstairs started off a bit slow for me. Eventually things picked up but kind of simmered once again on the slowness. In it, you will meet Jo. Her whole job sounds kind of cool because she blackmails people. Well, not just any people but either way - it sounded interesting.
Unfortunately, the whole cat and mouse game wasn't as twisty as I thought it was going to be. Even though I wasn't actually thinking of someone as the big suspect reveal until around 75% of the book.. I wasn't surprised by it either. Mostly because little things weren't making sense to me in the beginning. Then it got a bit confusing towards the middle but then something clicked and I knew.
Then there's Jo. She was an okay character. I thought she was going to be a bit more badass than she was. I'm also kind of annoyed that she didn't seem to realize what was going on until the very end. She was there and saw things but still she didn't want to see it. Or know the truth. Then once she did I just wanted to scream at her.
In the end, it was an okay book with a sort of interesting ending.
The Lady Upstairs started off a bit slow for me. Eventually things picked up but kind of simmered once again on the slowness. In it, you will meet Jo. Her whole job sounds kind of cool because she blackmails people. Well, not just any people but either way - it sounded interesting.
Unfortunately, the whole cat and mouse game wasn't as twisty as I thought it was going to be. Even though I wasn't actually thinking of someone as the big suspect reveal until around 75% of the book.. I wasn't surprised by it either. Mostly because little things weren't making sense to me in the beginning. Then it got a bit confusing towards the middle but then something clicked and I knew.
Then there's Jo. She was an okay character. I thought she was going to be a bit more badass than she was. I'm also kind of annoyed that she didn't seem to realize what was going on until the very end. She was there and saw things but still she didn't want to see it. Or know the truth. Then once she did I just wanted to scream at her.
In the end, it was an okay book with a sort of interesting ending.
December 24, 2019
Devoured this one! Sutton is a gorgeous writer & this was a twisty & delightful, gritty, luscious read. Can’t wait to read more by her!
October 9, 2020
Disclosure: I received a netgalley of this book on my Kindle in exchange for an honest review. I was excited to get to preview this book. This is the first time a publisher has asked this of me and allowed me to do this except for when I was working as an editor for a publishing company, which was completely different. Since I have to give the book just two stars, it may be the last time a publisher asks this of me. I truly wanted to give the book a higher rating, but GoodReads' three star rating means one "liked it." That does not describe my reaction to this book.
First, the good news about the book. It is well-structured and well-written. The plot makes sense, the problem is presented at the beginning, and the pacing is done reasonably well, except the 10-44% part of the book where nothing really happens. But then at that 44% point, something does, and the plot moves along great after that. There is suspense as we wonder if the protagonist will succeed. The situation is mildly interesting, and the characters are convincingly and realistically presented.
So, what's the problem? That takes a little explanation. The book's premise is that there are a lot of jerks in Hollywood, big shot producers and the like, who are unfaithful to their wives, and, who knows, probably mistreat their pets too. The protagonist is here to set things right, get some justice from these despicable bigshots. How does she want to do this? She wants to screw them, literally, in a kinky way hopefully, and then blackmail them, threatening to expose their infidelities and deviant predilections to the public and the bigshots' family members. Our protagonist is surrounded by like-minded "friends" who help her by keeping the hidden camera rolling and assist with other logistics of the blackmailing.
Perhaps you can already see my problem with the premise from the way I have stated it. But in case you can not, I'll spell it out. In every novel the protagonist is good in some way and has to be trying to achieve something worthwhile. This "good" I refer to doesn't mean the protagonist is perfect. A protagonist can be seriously flawed, vexed by inner demons, struggling against bad features of her personality, less than competent, what have you. But at some level, in some inner core, there has to be something we can root for in the protagonist, something we can hope she achieves. There's nothing like that for me in this novel.
An author has wide latitude in portraying a protagonist's flaws because we the reader are getting the story from the protagonist's perspective and naturally want to be on the protagonist's side. There are limits, however, and here Sutton exceeds them. This protagonist has no morally redeeming features whatsoever. It doesn't matter that the people she is trying to harm are also morally repugnant. Sutton, by the way, doesn't even do a very convincing job of depicting the antagonists as being all that bad. She sort of assumes they are and that we will agree with her. Cheating on one's spouse is never cool, but given the temptation and manipulation these cheaters are subjected to by the protagonist, I can partially excuse them. If nothing else, the punishment the protagonist metes out to the blackmail victims certainly exceeds the parameters of their crime. The author, I suspect, disagrees, and probably thinks the blackmail perfectly just, leading me to wonder if Ms. Sutton may be trying to achieve some form of catharsis from feeling wronged by a cheater in her past. In any event, the wish fulfillment fantasy of the author's this novel may portray is not working to her advantage.
Since the protagonist is basically rotten to the core and trying to achieve one unworthy goal after another, including getting away with murder, the entire novel, however well-written, structured, and carefully plotted it may be, breaks down. That's why you see some reviewers saying they could not finish the book and that it was just too sordid. In books with this kind of failing, and thankfully they're rare, reviewers complain about how there are no likable characters. Here, the protagonist is not likable and no one around her is either. Also, the goals the protagonist is trying to achieve, except for one (survival) which is never seriously threatened, are completely unworthy.
Even though I give this book a low rating, a number of people will enjoy it. They will overlook the moral bankruptcy portrayed by the protagonist and extend her the well wishes a protagonist of any novel gets just from being placed within that role by a novel's structure. If you can do that, and many younger people brought up on reality TV no doubt can, then the novelty of the plot and the good writing will carry you through to the end of the book and provide a satisfying reading experience for you. I did not enjoy the book, although its strengths makes me give it a two star rating of okay. I was unable to feel any sympathy, empathy, or kind wishes for the disgusting specimen of humanity this bottom-feeding protagonist represented.
First, the good news about the book. It is well-structured and well-written. The plot makes sense, the problem is presented at the beginning, and the pacing is done reasonably well, except the 10-44% part of the book where nothing really happens. But then at that 44% point, something does, and the plot moves along great after that. There is suspense as we wonder if the protagonist will succeed. The situation is mildly interesting, and the characters are convincingly and realistically presented.
So, what's the problem? That takes a little explanation. The book's premise is that there are a lot of jerks in Hollywood, big shot producers and the like, who are unfaithful to their wives, and, who knows, probably mistreat their pets too. The protagonist is here to set things right, get some justice from these despicable bigshots. How does she want to do this? She wants to screw them, literally, in a kinky way hopefully, and then blackmail them, threatening to expose their infidelities and deviant predilections to the public and the bigshots' family members. Our protagonist is surrounded by like-minded "friends" who help her by keeping the hidden camera rolling and assist with other logistics of the blackmailing.
Perhaps you can already see my problem with the premise from the way I have stated it. But in case you can not, I'll spell it out. In every novel the protagonist is good in some way and has to be trying to achieve something worthwhile. This "good" I refer to doesn't mean the protagonist is perfect. A protagonist can be seriously flawed, vexed by inner demons, struggling against bad features of her personality, less than competent, what have you. But at some level, in some inner core, there has to be something we can root for in the protagonist, something we can hope she achieves. There's nothing like that for me in this novel.
An author has wide latitude in portraying a protagonist's flaws because we the reader are getting the story from the protagonist's perspective and naturally want to be on the protagonist's side. There are limits, however, and here Sutton exceeds them. This protagonist has no morally redeeming features whatsoever. It doesn't matter that the people she is trying to harm are also morally repugnant. Sutton, by the way, doesn't even do a very convincing job of depicting the antagonists as being all that bad. She sort of assumes they are and that we will agree with her. Cheating on one's spouse is never cool, but given the temptation and manipulation these cheaters are subjected to by the protagonist, I can partially excuse them. If nothing else, the punishment the protagonist metes out to the blackmail victims certainly exceeds the parameters of their crime. The author, I suspect, disagrees, and probably thinks the blackmail perfectly just, leading me to wonder if Ms. Sutton may be trying to achieve some form of catharsis from feeling wronged by a cheater in her past. In any event, the wish fulfillment fantasy of the author's this novel may portray is not working to her advantage.
Since the protagonist is basically rotten to the core and trying to achieve one unworthy goal after another, including getting away with murder, the entire novel, however well-written, structured, and carefully plotted it may be, breaks down. That's why you see some reviewers saying they could not finish the book and that it was just too sordid. In books with this kind of failing, and thankfully they're rare, reviewers complain about how there are no likable characters. Here, the protagonist is not likable and no one around her is either. Also, the goals the protagonist is trying to achieve, except for one (survival) which is never seriously threatened, are completely unworthy.
Even though I give this book a low rating, a number of people will enjoy it. They will overlook the moral bankruptcy portrayed by the protagonist and extend her the well wishes a protagonist of any novel gets just from being placed within that role by a novel's structure. If you can do that, and many younger people brought up on reality TV no doubt can, then the novelty of the plot and the good writing will carry you through to the end of the book and provide a satisfying reading experience for you. I did not enjoy the book, although its strengths makes me give it a two star rating of okay. I was unable to feel any sympathy, empathy, or kind wishes for the disgusting specimen of humanity this bottom-feeding protagonist represented.
June 22, 2020
☕🕶️"𝘽𝙤𝙤𝙠 𝙍𝙚𝙫𝙞𝙚𝙬"🕶️☕
𝐓𝐢𝐭𝐥𝐞: 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘓𝘢𝘥𝘺 𝘜𝘱𝘴𝘵𝘢𝘪𝘳𝘴
𝐀𝐮𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐫: 𝐻𝑎𝑙𝑙𝑖𝑒 𝑆𝑢𝑡𝑡𝑜𝑛
𝐍𝐮𝐦𝐛𝐞𝐫 𝐎𝐟 𝐏𝐚𝐠𝐞𝐬: 293(𝑎𝑟𝑐)
𝐆𝐞𝐧𝐫𝐞: 𝑃𝑠𝑦𝑐ℎ𝑜𝑙𝑜𝑔𝑖𝑐𝑎𝑙 𝑇ℎ𝑟𝑖𝑙𝑙𝑒𝑟
𝐏𝐮𝐛 𝐃𝐚𝐭𝐞: 11/17/2020
𝐑𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠: 📕📕📕📕📕
•
This is the author's debut novel. This book has a stunning cover.
•
𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬: This was one hell of a thriller. We follow Jo who's job is blackmailing the most lecherous men in Los Angeles. This book took me on a wild ride. I've never read a book like this before. This book gave me Mafia/mob vibes. I've never read a thriller that included murder, mixed with darkness and seduction throughout. Jo is the type of woman that I would be very scared of in real life if I ever met her. She is willing to do whatever it takes. The cat and mouse chase was a joy to read, and I cannot wait to read more books from this author. Halley has a unique way of sending you through a novel with your butt on the edge of your seat while being seduced wanting more. The thriller vibes included in this book were spot on, while the sultry and seductive vibes throughout had the hairs on the back of my neck standing up with goosebumps on my arms. This book comes out on 11/17/2020 so pre order your copy today!!!!!!
𝐓𝐢𝐭𝐥𝐞: 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘓𝘢𝘥𝘺 𝘜𝘱𝘴𝘵𝘢𝘪𝘳𝘴
𝐀𝐮𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐫: 𝐻𝑎𝑙𝑙𝑖𝑒 𝑆𝑢𝑡𝑡𝑜𝑛
𝐍𝐮𝐦𝐛𝐞𝐫 𝐎𝐟 𝐏𝐚𝐠𝐞𝐬: 293(𝑎𝑟𝑐)
𝐆𝐞𝐧𝐫𝐞: 𝑃𝑠𝑦𝑐ℎ𝑜𝑙𝑜𝑔𝑖𝑐𝑎𝑙 𝑇ℎ𝑟𝑖𝑙𝑙𝑒𝑟
𝐏𝐮𝐛 𝐃𝐚𝐭𝐞: 11/17/2020
𝐑𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐧𝐠: 📕📕📕📕📕
•
This is the author's debut novel. This book has a stunning cover.
•
𝐌𝐲 𝐓𝐡𝐨𝐮𝐠𝐡𝐭𝐬: This was one hell of a thriller. We follow Jo who's job is blackmailing the most lecherous men in Los Angeles. This book took me on a wild ride. I've never read a book like this before. This book gave me Mafia/mob vibes. I've never read a thriller that included murder, mixed with darkness and seduction throughout. Jo is the type of woman that I would be very scared of in real life if I ever met her. She is willing to do whatever it takes. The cat and mouse chase was a joy to read, and I cannot wait to read more books from this author. Halley has a unique way of sending you through a novel with your butt on the edge of your seat while being seduced wanting more. The thriller vibes included in this book were spot on, while the sultry and seductive vibes throughout had the hairs on the back of my neck standing up with goosebumps on my arms. This book comes out on 11/17/2020 so pre order your copy today!!!!!!
December 7, 2020
WOW. What a sharp, sexy, delicious book. Halley Sutton's writing cuts like a knife--there were moments throughout where I had to pause and re-read a sentence because it was just that good, that smart, and twisted that deep into my heart. Sutton's storytelling is masterful, and the plot sails forward, propelled by dark, smart, marshmellow-center Jo (yes, I am quoting VMars--fellow fans, jump on this book), and the people she loves and hates, who she pushes away and pulls in in equal measure.
Everything about THE LADY UPSTAIRS is so damn gripping--the twists and turns, which suprised me but also felt earned, Jo's voice, the dark, seedy LA setting that felt pitch-perfect for the book and rang true as a former Los Angeleno. I am in awe.
This is by far one of my favorite books of 2020 and I can't wait to see what Sutton brings us next.
Everything about THE LADY UPSTAIRS is so damn gripping--the twists and turns, which suprised me but also felt earned, Jo's voice, the dark, seedy LA setting that felt pitch-perfect for the book and rang true as a former Los Angeleno. I am in awe.
This is by far one of my favorite books of 2020 and I can't wait to see what Sutton brings us next.
January 10, 2021
I’m bummed. I thought I was going to LOVE this book… but it ended up just being kinda okay. Like, a modern day noir story about women who blackmail and take down awful men? Sign me up!! However, the story never ended up being as compelling as I hoped it would be based on that synopsis.
The main character Jo was just really bland and the overall plot felt a little bit slow and convoluted. I felt like I didn’t know enough about Jo or the other characters to be invested in their stories. Something really interesting finally happens around halfway through the book and things do get more exciting. I think there are glimpses of greatness in this and I’m open to reading more from Halley Sutton in the future. But overall this story never fully delivered on what was a great concept.
The main character Jo was just really bland and the overall plot felt a little bit slow and convoluted. I felt like I didn’t know enough about Jo or the other characters to be invested in their stories. Something really interesting finally happens around halfway through the book and things do get more exciting. I think there are glimpses of greatness in this and I’m open to reading more from Halley Sutton in the future. But overall this story never fully delivered on what was a great concept.
May 7, 2022
The characters are disasters. I can’t tell if this was supposed to be a mystery because if the end was meant to be a big reveal, it was a fail. I had to finish it to see if it got better or to see if there was twist I didn’t see coming. But no, I saw the ending coming about 50 pages in.
November 24, 2020
I ended up really disliking this book. Too predictable, and the main character couldn't decide if she was brutal and cold or desperate and pushed into a corner. I spent the first half thinking I just didn't enjoy the narrator (she was definitely, without a doubt, the wrong choice for this book... just way too upbeat and chipper for the tone) but by the end it was just too predictable. Rounded up from 2.5 because I think my opinion was tainted by the miscast narration.
did-not-finish
September 7, 2025DNF @ Chapter 5
I received a finished copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
I tried. I really did. This is the second book I've DNF'd in a row and now I feel like crap lol. I deserve an award for trying two debut authors in a row. I'm gonna go straight to Jeaniene Frost after this because I want to read and finish one good book, damn it!
The Lady Upstairs has an incredible concept. Jo, the main character, works for a mysterious boss who goes by the name "The Lady Upstairs." Jo's job? Executing sting operations to take down powerful men whose privilege lets them get away with doing terrible things.
First of all, I didn't vibe with the writing style. At times, the writing is fragmented and choppy, particularly when it comes to describing the settings. This disrupts the fluidity of the prose, which in turn gave me a headache. Second, I literally figured out the identity of the so-called mysterious Lady Upstairs in CHAPTER 3! It was laughably predictable 😂
I was expecting a noir thriller, like a darker version of Veronica Mars. Maybe the book gets better eventually, but I just couldn't push myself to continue because the overall set up is so weak. For instance: one of Jo's colleagues purposefully messes up a job, but Jo doesn't bother questioning him or forcing him to fix the mess, which makes zero sense. Furthermore, the characters introduced so far are stereotypical cardboard cutouts, and this includes the main character Jo.
As for the noir aspect of the story, maybe the tone becomes more noir as you keep reading. But based on what I have read so far: dingy hole in the wall settings do not make this a noir book. Colourful alcoholic beverages do not make this a noir book. Neon signs also do not make this a noir book. Come. On.
My advice? Just watch Veronica Mars instead 🤷🏽♀️
I received a finished copy of this book from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
I tried. I really did. This is the second book I've DNF'd in a row and now I feel like crap lol. I deserve an award for trying two debut authors in a row. I'm gonna go straight to Jeaniene Frost after this because I want to read and finish one good book, damn it!
The Lady Upstairs has an incredible concept. Jo, the main character, works for a mysterious boss who goes by the name "The Lady Upstairs." Jo's job? Executing sting operations to take down powerful men whose privilege lets them get away with doing terrible things.
First of all, I didn't vibe with the writing style. At times, the writing is fragmented and choppy, particularly when it comes to describing the settings. This disrupts the fluidity of the prose, which in turn gave me a headache. Second, I literally figured out the identity of the so-called mysterious Lady Upstairs in CHAPTER 3! It was laughably predictable 😂
I was expecting a noir thriller, like a darker version of Veronica Mars. Maybe the book gets better eventually, but I just couldn't push myself to continue because the overall set up is so weak. For instance: one of Jo's colleagues purposefully messes up a job, but Jo doesn't bother questioning him or forcing him to fix the mess, which makes zero sense. Furthermore, the characters introduced so far are stereotypical cardboard cutouts, and this includes the main character Jo.
As for the noir aspect of the story, maybe the tone becomes more noir as you keep reading. But based on what I have read so far: dingy hole in the wall settings do not make this a noir book. Colourful alcoholic beverages do not make this a noir book. Neon signs also do not make this a noir book. Come. On.
My advice? Just watch Veronica Mars instead 🤷🏽♀️
Displaying 1 - 30 of 331 reviews