This was a fast paced, quick read full of plotlines that I know many readers will eat right up- brother’s best friend, a first love story AND a second chance romance...not to mention we have the Boston Terriers sport rom-com vibe infused throughout.
As Maddie graduates high school, she starts to explore her budding attraction to her brother’s best friend, Shaw - who himself is finally coming to terms with his interest in Maddie. While brother’s away, these two play- getting to know each other over a sweet and slow burn romance in the summer. But, a (in my opinion quite silly) romantic catastrophe occurs, ripping these two apart just as they are starting to find their bearings with one another. Each goes off to school, and we find them reconnecting 18 months later, coming to terms with the new nature of their relationship and grappling with regret and being in the same place at the same time.
Jacob is a great writer, but there are elements of this story that are some of my reader pet peeves, so I didn’t love it as much as some prior stories. First, our characters spend the majority of the story apart- and we don’t get to see them “together” until the last 5%- MAJOR slow burn. We never really get to explore what they look like together much, even in the beginning- and lot of that occurs “off page” with generalities (we get to know each other, etc)- I just wanted to see a bit more of their evolution and connection- so much emotional impact happens behind the scenes. And because I’m told rather than shown, I don’t buy into their romance as much. Secondly, the whole “misunderstanding” was troublesome for me personally- I hate big dramatic moments like that where things are just done/no communication occurs, and it really bothered me that Shaw gave up on the relationship so easily. We don’t get to see the emotional blow out, either. Yet, when they reconnect, it’s like all the emotional impact is forgotten and we still don’t have them grapple much with it. And, the brother obstacle ends up being less of an issue, too- so basically the two things that have kept them apart for so long are just kind of easily forgotten/resolved- which just increases the futility of them turning their backs on each other- which may, in fact, be the point- accuse they needed to mature, but to me isn’t my favorite way to approach second chance.
They are definitely cute together, and this story has humor and is very sweet- and I know many others will be bothered less by some of the above plot devices- this just unfortunately just combined a few of the plot devices I enjoy less. Still a light and quick paced read- and I think many will love this sweet and charming story.