**this book was provided to me by the author for an honest review**
I'll start off by saying that I haven't had the best luck finding indie and self-published authors that I enjoy. When I first discovered the world of e-books, I downloaded everything in sight only to find poor or no editing, thin characters, bad writing and lack of decent story structure in most books that I read.
I am pleased to say that I found few of those negative traits in The Brightest Fell. Napur Chowdhury's book bypasses most of the pitfalls I find with self published books, though I still have a few criticisms.
I'll start with the positives!
For one, I read this book very fast (for me at least), just 3 nights, and those were work nights. So I was definitely compelled to keep reading. There are no choppy sentences here, the syntax is great and everything has a nice flow to it. This normally might be something I wouldn't even think about and I've come to expect otherwise with indie books, but the prose here is quality. Also, the editing is nearly pristine. These things might seem too nitpicky but as a voracious reader and would-be writer, I'm always on the lookout for good examples of the craft so I pay extra attention to these things.
Then there's the story itself. I will say that it took a good 3rd of the book before I really started to get invested in the characters. It was hard to decide who exactly I should be rooting for at first as the stakes weren't exactly clear in the beginning. I knew there were a lot of moving parts but didnt know what they had to do with one another or why I should care. But every time I was ready to throw my hands up, the next layer of the onion was peeled back and suddenly it made sense. The author does a good job revealing the story a bit at a time and ramping up the tension and this continues all the way to the conclusion. If you enjoy political intrigue, sabotage, espionage, etc, there's a lot to like here.
Now for some criticism: This book, especially in the beginning, is very dialogue heavy. At times it felt like whole pages would go by without a dialogue break. And while most of that dialogue seemed organic, there were a few cringe worthy moments, like a villain spilling the details of their plan to a captive hero in the typical Bond villain style.
The characters for the most part were fun to read but I would argue that the book may not have one single protagonist. By the first chapter alone, I would guess that Jehan would be the main character, but after that he seems to become more of the plot focus and the MC role is delegated to his body guard and son of his political adversary, who then spends the book trying to figure out if Jehan really is his enemy or if there's more going on that it seems. And that brings be to another problem: Jehan himself. I appreciate intelligent characters, but when a character is so intelligent that they are never afraid no matter their situation and they can talk or think their way out of any dilemma, it detracts from the tension of the book. I also feel that Jehan was unnecessarily mysterious and sometimes only acted cryptically because it was more interesting to the story. Him being more straightforward with everyone might have made more sense and I'm sure there would have been ways to keep the other characters guessing his motivations without him being so elusive and strange.
The story, while it all came together very well in the end, could have used some better structure in the beginning, so I would encourage readers to keep reading if they're having the same misgivings, because the ideas introduced early on do come back full circle later in the story. One of the primary focuses of the book, the drug Amven that starts all of the political intrigue to begin with, seems to take a backseat for a while and I'd almost worried that the author changed the focus of the storyuntil later when its importance is made clear.
Also one more minor criticism, but really more of a curiosity: is this supposed to be an alternate Earth? The nations and places are all made up, but very similar to Asian cultures of our world, and there was nothing else fantastical or alien to the world at all other than the nations being made up, so it made me wonder what brought on this choice and why not just have the story on Earth with existing nations. However, it doesn't detract from the plot so... *shrug*.
Overall, this was enjoyable and I'm really glad I got the opportunity to read it. 3 out of 5 stars (maybe closer to 3.5, but there's no half stars here). This author is a bright spot in the world of self publishing and I look forward to reading more from her in the future!