My first impression of this book is its amateurish. It was initially confusion as to where the story was going when the book began with chapters devoted to Merritt, Leesa, and Tulliver with little information on how they would all fit together in the story. This story is more like a horror story than a good news story for the characters. People pay good money to go on a space ship through a "RIP" (about the same as a wormhole in other books) to a planet that is 10,000 light years away because the Earth is overpopulated and cannot produce enough food for everyone. However, we find as the story goes that the new planet to be colonized has not been properly explored on the ground, only from a spaceship. And, while supplies have been dropped for the colonist, the people on the ship are not prepared for all of the unknown creatures that they encounter. After there is a mishaps with the transport vessel exploding and crashing on the planet due to an engine failure, the only way for them to get to the surface is via escape pods. This is strange since a ship as large as this transport vessel should have multiple shuttle to take people to the surface. It turns out later in the story that there were shuttles but they were not used. Strange!!. Then the colonist encounter creatures, in the caves, in the ocean, and just crawling around the ground, that they were not told about. Then they find a previous colony's settlement but no people in it and nobody seems to wonder what happens to the people.
So for me the bottom line is there were just too many strange and unexplained events in this story for it, in my opinion, to be good sci fi. The horror of this story is that all of the people who came to this planet will die, soon, because they don't have the tools and equipment to cope with their environment, they can only grow one plant which is supposed to provide food for all of them, and there will be no rescue ship coming. The story even ends with an epilogue that tries to make the best of a very bad situation.