What I wished for this book was to get more of the Matrix world. More characters and specially more ways to play within the rules of the set world
Some of the stories are great and just about what I wanted from them. However, there are too many stories that are simply boring or aimless. And over that, there are probably 5 or 6 stories that can be summarized in "I think this world isn't real, things are odd" (this is a generalization, of course, but it's the vibe that the stories gave me). This is a common theme explored in this universe, however, it's a bit like you see one, you see them all.
Here are my quick reviews for all stories (rated in 1 to 5 stars):
Bits and Pieces of Information ***
Not much more from what we saw in The Second Renaissance (The Animatrix).
Sweating the Small Stuff **
The first "I think this world isn't real, things are odd." Didn't like the art style.
Sweating the Small Stuff ***
Again, "I think this world isn't real, things are odd." I started to get worried that it would be all this. Good style, weird character.
Goliath **
Ok, by now I was about to stop. It's again "I think this world isn't real, things are odd." Kind of. And being Neil Gaiman, I had higher hopes.
Burning Hope **
It's ok, but again, we've seen "this" story been told in the matrix universe. In terms of art, it looked slightly too dark and confusing.
Butterfly *****
Very simple story, but how it looked sold it really hard. Just beautiful style, loved the parallel/mirrored panels.
A Sword of a Different Color *****
Nice and innovative. This is what I wanted of an extended world. Not my style, in terms of the characters, but ok.
Get It? **
It's a simple gag. Could be told in a single panel. Not my style and I'd dare to say that it didn't felt like it belong here.
There Are No Flowers in the Real World *****
Really good. Perfect addition to the world. Made me questions the rules and made me think about what else could happen inside these constraints. Liked the style, quite similar to Black hole.
The Miller's Tale ***
Ok story. It felt like an Animatrix story (as in, more documenting the history, than telling a story). I'm not that into going back to the characters of the original story, but this was fine. Visually it looked like a classic scifi book. I liked it.
Artistic Freedom ***
This one is the most Animatrix but for the wrong reasons (don't get me know, I like Animatrix, just believe Trans-media is a failure - too demanding on the viewer). Nevertheless, I liked the premise of the story (the primal nightmares) but there was not need for the just a tad "too cool" ending. It looked like Marvel's style, didn't felt quite right.
Hunters and Collectors ***
I wanted more of this story. I liked the characters, but the story was pointless, quasi frustrating. Great dystopian style, it felt like a spent world.
An Easy One **
This story had the setting for greatness but I got lost various times. Didn't know who was talking, about what, to whom. Shame. Liked the noir-cyber-punk style.
Farewell Performance ****
Even thought, in a way, this story was already told, I liked it here. It's a mix of how it looked but also the mix of worlds. It felt innocent. It didn't look like the Matrix. It was more The Prestige through an Art Nouveau lens.
Déjà Vu *****
This story added a 3rd layer to the whole thing, to me. As in, there's the Matrix and the Real World (in the movies), but there's also our world, seeing/reading this stories. And this story felt in our world. It's weird to explain but the story took steps that felt how we, in our world, would react to anything as weird as the Matrix was happening. Looked really good.
System Freeze ****
Something is added to the world of The Matrix here and I like it. Looked good.
The King of Never Return *
I couldn't understand where they were. Very confusing. Not my style.
An Asset to the System ***
An ok story. A slight hint of "I think this world isn't real, things are odd." Didn't like how the characters looked, gave me vibes of old newspaper panels.
A Path Among Stones **
It gave me similar as in Deja Vu (aka "our world") but not as successful. I missed some development, it didn't deviate from "I think this world isn't real, things are odd" enough. The style also harmed it. I would say that in a more realistic style, the story would work better.
Run, Saga, Run ***
It looks amazing, love the style. Just wished the story would have gone somewhere new. The first two pages set a nice question "what if these characters felt like doing something else", but then what the story delivers is more of what we've seen before.
Wrong Number **
This story almost contradicts the rules of the matrix. It raised a question that I'm not sure I want answers. Didn't like how the characters looked. They gave me vibes of Cronenberg's body horror, but I'm not sure if that was intended.
Broadcast Depth **
Really simple story. Doesn't develop. Not my style, I was never into comics and graphic novels that have this collage style. They overwhelm me.
**Who Says You Can't Get Good Help These Days? **
Even more than in "Get it?" this is just a gag. Made me realize that I don't want Matrix's comedy. Not my style.
Saviors ***
We've seen this story, in a way. I did like the "bug", that raised questions that I want answers! The style looked video-gamey, it was fine.
I Kant **
I liked how it looks, very "cartoony". I don't like the character that it's focused on. Wait, I think this character would be interesting if approached differently, but it suffers from arrested development and becomes repetitive.
Day In... Day Out ****
Was a bit confused, but I liked the agents jumping around al the time. I could bet that this was from the same author as Run, Saga, Run. I even thought it was a sequel of that story.
Return of the Prodigal Son **
This was confusing. Couldn't even understand if these characters know of the Matrix or not. Ok style, reminded me of Max Payne.
Let It All Fall Down ****
I'm not sure if I fully understood what was the conclusion, but I wanted more. It looked amazing.