As the United States grew into an empire in the late nineteenth century, notions like “sea power” derived not only from fleets, bases, and decisive battles but also from a scientific effort to understand and master the ocean environment. Beginning in the early nineteenth century and concluding in the first years of the twentieth, Jason W. Smith tells the story of the rise of the U.S. Navy and the emergence of American ocean empire through its struggle to control nature. In vividly told sketches of exploration, naval officers, war, and, most significantly, the ocean environment, Smith draws together insights from environmental, maritime, military, and naval history, and the history of science and cartography, placing the U.S. Navy’s scientific efforts within a broader cultural context.
By recasting and deepening our understanding of the U.S. Navy and the United States at sea, Smith brings to the fore the overlooked work of naval hydrographers, surveyors, and cartographers. In the nautical chart’s soundings, names, symbols, and embedded narratives, Smith recounts the largely untold story of a young nation looking to extend its power over the boundless sea.
Ships are fragile entities bearing men on rough uncharted waters along dangerous reefs and shores. In this book, To Master the Boundless Sea: The US Navy, The Marine Environment, and the Cartography of Empire explains the science of navigation and the expansion of American sea faring as a cultural phenomenon in the 1800s. What this book is not by the author Jason Smith, is not a complete history of science of the oceans. He leaves out the engineering of the navy, or guns, and the stars for the development of navigational charts. His book is to correct previous historians work with disconnection of early science development from the cultural history of the US. Navy and the charting of the oceans. Maps helped define the United States and our space as a nation. We cannot and should not neglect this same definition for the ocean. Man’s drive to map land should be applied to the seas. Chapter one, Smith lays the groundwork of culture and science as it pertains to the marine environment. In 1830, navigational science grows with American maritime commerce. The U.S. Navy grows also in response. Any discussion of naval science rightly includes the previous use of “dead reckoning” as the primary means of early navigation. With the increased cultural movements of rationalism and the Enlightenment, the navy sought to replace “folkloric meanings” with maps and charts. Smith describes the conquest of the west as just one aspect of the exploration narrative. Do you agree with Smith that exploration of the sea by the United States was the same as the drive for better mapping as it was for the drive to Oregon? This was just one thing I considered as occurring at the same time. American commerce is fueling both expansions regardless. Whaling at this time was a huge part of our commerce and this helped drive the science of our own coastlines and the Atlantic. Literature about shipwrecks, shorelines, and poorly charted waters are dramatic cultural history that is part of the need to chart and control the sea. But the thing is, America was not exceptional in the 1800s or even the best at this. Britain had charts and maps that were almost 100 years in the making before the US navy ever got involved in the same endeavor. In Smith’s book, he focuses specifically on US Navy and the people who chart the seas like Maury, Wilkes, and other Naval men and his book should be read as a cultural glimpse of the sea from the coasts of North America. In chapter 2, we learn about the ex ex, otherwise known as United States Exploring Expedition of 1840. This exploration was a mimic of previous British explorations with one significant difference, the United States discovers and maps the coastline of a new continent, Antarctica. The claim of nationalism and discovery of this continent beats the British and this expedition also helps the foundation of the Smithsonian institution with 60,000 natural specimens from the Fiji Islands. The people of the islands were culturally compared to the sea, cannibal savages and three months of inability to adequately survey due to the difficult vastness of the area and shores along with killing of several sailors including the commanding officer’s nephew, leads to military aggression and submission of one area’s native people. Violence and charting went together in the Pacific and asserted the dominance of science and the United States use of military to achieve scientific goals. This dominance of science within the US navy was not assured in the early 1800s, Matthew Fontaine Maury role in science and navigation is the focus of Smith’s chapter 3. Maury’s work while initially not accepted, is recognized due to the speed of the journey for commerce is improved. Maury was a scientist who could write in metaphor, like a river in the ocean described the Gulf stream and understood the sea as a common highway while utilizing as many mariners that would fill his logs of their surroundings, wind, charts of voyages leading to a global sea chart for the international community. Maury may have been credited with helping American commerce and saving millions of dollars due to faster ship journeys but he was controversial as someone who left the US Navy to join the confederate cause and for fellow scientists his lack of objectivity for the natural world was not part of the cultural drive for rationalism in the scientific world. Regardless of Maury’s personal views, he contributed to naval science and cartography. Beyond the Civil War, Smith jumps to the years of steam ships, soundings of the depths, laying of telegraph lines, Pacific Ocean and Alaskan exploration. Naval still using Maury’s wind and charts are considered already antiquated. We learn of the science performed by Belknap, aboard the Tuscorosa, who maps the bottom of the Pacific Ocean. The years between the end of the Civil Car and to the Spanish American war ends the largeness of the Navy for a time, but the sounding and mapping of the Pacific leads to the assessment by Belknap of an area in Hawaii that becomes a great naval base in the Pacific, called Pearl Harbor. Imperial power in the Pacific is expanded from this early naval science and commercial interests by Belknap. Who was he as a person and how did the culture impact his research as it did Maury? In the final chapter, the Navy becomes new again with a watershed book in 1890 by Mahan, called” The influence of sea power upon history, 1660-1783.” His book and the ensuing Spanish American war, the charting of the coasts and naval science for charting is fully resurrected. The charts around Cuba were not updated and the sea/coast were just as dangerous as ever. Charts change focus to strategy instead of commerce in this New Naval power. This chapter is a thrilling and scary review of ships avoiding shoal and shallow waters around Cuba and Puerto Rico due to poor charts of both. Grounding of ships and assessment of the win of the Spanish American war is also about a mixed review of naval prowess due to the foe of the sea itself. In conclusion, Smith’s book is about the history of naval charting of the seas, at times at the forefront for economic reasons, then abandoned, then for strategic reasons while putting the scientist at arm’s length within the U. S. navy to their sometimes significant detriment. The success is when the Navy embraces the science, and the civilian embraces the US. Navy. The people who straddle both worlds are few and far between in Smith’s excellent review of the U.S. Naval interplay with culture, science, and military development during the 1800s. We, as his readers, cannot forget that the ocean has been treated as foe within the our culture and within the U.S. Navy and trying to chart it as a scientific endeavor has and will continue as climate change impacts the shorelines once again. Smith reminds us that only 2 percent of the majority of our earth has been charted, will we continue to explore and update our charts with the water’s rise on current coasts, especially in Norfolk, where the largest naval base in the world is located? Or will we again ignore naval science within our military until it is too late?