Ruby Drake's early years are like a fairy tale, a beautiful child, loved and nurtured by her parents, Serena and Denton, exposed to Shakespeare and rich language, an idyllic life. In 1910, when she is twelve, on a winter sleigh ride at night, her parents, "too happy and devoted to live," are killed; Ruby's great-aunt Bertha hastily ships her off from Beardsley, Illinois, to Salisbury, Iowa. Herr and Frau Oster, colorless compared to her parents, are kind German Lutherans who have lost their only son and teach Ruby many skills on their farm; Ruby comforts herself with a picture of her parents, a china tea set, her mother's books and a special painting and frequent conversations with her mother.
Three years later when the Osters inherit a small estate in Bavaria, arrangements are made for Ruby to live with a family in Harvester, Minnesota, a familiar setting for Faith Sullivan's novels.
Again, Ruby settles into her new life on a larger farm with more responsibilities than before, surrounded by the artifacts of her life with her parents. Emma and Henry Schoonover, who have also known loss, are dedicated to a work ethic that makes their farm profitable, expecting the same of those who work for them, treating them with dignity and respect.
The young couple who live on the adjacent farm have been the subject of Harvester gossip. Dora, pampered and used to being the center of attention, has married Roland, a man ambitious about farming, yearning to learn as much as he can, committed to working hard. She knows little about keeping house and has less interest in farm chores. When her new baby dies, Dora suffers a deep depression.
Fifteen-year-old Ruby is attracted to the very handsome Roland, and for a short time, she yearns for him in a typical adolescent way until one day, while Dora suffers, Ruby and Roland begin an affair.
The description of farm life, long hours and back-breaking chores, is balanced with descriptions of winter evenings playing rummy and Parcheesi, weekly trips into Harvester, the easy friendship between the Schoonovers and their hired help, and letters with her parents' friend, Barrett Cromwell. All the while, Ruby and Roland meet when they can. The Lusitania is sunk, and the inevitability of war haunts the people of Harvester, foreshadowing what is to come for Ruby and Roland and Dora.
While the very young Ruby might have wished for a fairy tale ending and Roland may have shown more fidelity to his suffering wife, the astute reader knew a different outcome was in store. The ever-so-kind Emma directs Ruby to assist Dora, first with cleaning and cooking, and then after Dora has an accident, with her recovery and housekeeping and farm skills. An unexpected friendship grows between the two young women, and when Dora's tutelage is complete, Ruby returns to Beardsley.
"You put one foot ahead of the other, little girl. And hope that someday they carry you to a high and peaceful place." Despite her broken heart, Ruby develops new friendships and new skills, becomes more independent, enjoys the companionship of Professor Bartlett Cromwell, and summoned to spend time with her great- aunt Bertha, comes to understand Bertha's complicated emotions, "a soul in torment," and her feelings about Ruby and her mother. As always, she is sustained by her love of literature, nurtured by her mother.
The plot continues to evolve with Ruby unexpectedly returning to Harvester, making choices that might surprise some readers and disappoint others. Strong women are developed throughout this novel, resilient, supported by friendship and perhaps, the comfort of the Harvester community in the heart of the mid-west. "We love whom we will."