I am legitimately shocked this book has received as well of a reception as it has, to the point I’m wondering if people listened to a shorter BETTER version than what I got because I was at the point of screaming “SHUT UP AND MOVE ON FOR GODS SAKE”. It is not often I get such a strong reaction from a book, and that is rooted in its deeply missed potential that I have never seen in a piece of published fiction, and only in amatuer fanfiction that was so close to hitting its mark.
To explain how I review things: 3 stars is what a book starts with, what I consider an okay book, that I wouldn’t remove from my library. It will gain and lose stars during its course and final judgement.
To summarise, It was barely tolerable, I would NEVER recommend this book to anyone. It’s performer R. C. Bray was okay, I may just not like him, but his southern accent that permeated everything just made me feel an undercurrent of petty annoyance. This is not his fault so he gets 3 stars, he does and adds nothing to the character or actions of the story. There was I think one act of audio mixing to give some SOUND to the book that wasn’t his narration. But It was competently done, therefore I see no faults for giving this lower than the standard.
For the story however. It is the hallmark of a truly failed execution in many respects.
We have a superfluous character who adds like 4 hours to the book and does nothing in it besides see some heart wrenching moment, crash lands, see another heart wrenching moment, gets shot at, sees another heart wrenching moment, finds her daddy, and nearly gets raped. That is her entire character arc of importance. Sandra is a pointless character, and is the first time in my life that I have truly wished a character to die for having done nothing wrong other then exist. Her inclusion is the greatest sin an author can do, to waste your reader’s time. She is hours of wasted space in this book, that was already way too long. Do you know the worst part? She is congratulated by a general for doing a good job bringing them information. Information they had already learned hours previously, information that took her significantly longer to tell them. Information that was pretty much useless in the end. I want Sandra to die in retribution. To have turned out to have died with the rest of her squadron. At least then her character would have meant something - 1 star for the first character I actually sincerely wished to die.
We have repetition of information, that while valuable, is repeated ad nauseum. Did we really need to know that the blast wave is 100 kilometers radius? Sure. Did we really need that information shared with us half a dozen times? No. How about the ending battle, where we see it from 4 (FOUR!) different angles. No I don’t mean it goes from set to set in chronological order. No. We get each scene told to us in four different viewpoints, so a bomb hits Yay! That same bomb hits, Yay! That bomb hits with effect, YAY! That bomb hit the ship,YAY! I don’t know how he did it, he made the final climactic battle infuriating with how annoying it was portrayed. This is done throughout the book, adding HOURS of time that could have been concluded in one chapter. Time that could have contributed something actually interesting or entertaining. It’s so bad that I felt if I didn't read this book, I could have just read retribution and gotten everything of importance I needed in the first 5 chapters, where he retells the entire story because Dean thinks you’re an idiot. -3 stars This is the first audiobook I’ve actually yelled aloud “SHUT THE F UP”
The book is overly prousy and descriptive. Now a good description is all fine and dandy. But he way way way way overuses it for the most banal of things. This is more a personal thing, if you like Tolkien’s super descriptive stuff, you may not care as much. But it really adds up when I’m sitting there tapping my foot saying, ”Okay, move on, that's not important, okay, move on, that's not important, okay, move on, that's not important.” wearing down my already finite patience. Now I’m not normally like this, I like 40k stuff which can really get into the scenery and grandiose phrases. Indeed I don’t mind it in certain sections. The alien sections, where the description is actually damn important, where it’s actually INTERESTING. I don’t need a meticulous description of a SERVICE TRUCK. If this were a paperback book I would have skipped entire pages as being boring descriptions. Sorry *I* would have skipped entire CHAPTERS to avoid Sandy’s pointless pov and unnecessary chapters. Look Dean, I get it, you know how aviation works, now make like Tom Clancy and apply that to actually interesting scenes. I don’t need meticulous descriptions of eventless take off and landing. Multiple times. -1 star Get an editor to pare your writing down. Hey, I’LL DO IT FOR FREE
The “heroes” do LITERALLY nothing of importance that couldn't have been done easier and swifter by other people. I’m not joking. Even the final climactic action was only slightly lessening the effects of a tsunami originating for the center of the atlantic. In short, Dean Cole wasted 12 hours of my time following these moose knuckles. -1 star, its BORING
Now some more minor problems. Your chronology is whack, in the course of the book something like 2 days, pass, the alien invasion last maybe 2 hours at most, which spans the bulk of the book at something like 40 of 50 chapters. Most of which is very boring go here info dump this, gut punch, continue and proceed to next info dump and gut punch of empty clothing. It feels like days have passed, not minutes, with how its written.
The Socsith or whatever the aliens are called are either liars, stupid, or just random.
Pacing is off. You spend an entire 15-30 minute chapter describing the process of moving 50 feet in zero G. How the hell do you have a single five star review? But with your previous blunders if you fix these this will be solved along with it.
The description? Totally misleading, this does not feel like X-Files. Or Independence Day.
“When a plan to elevate present-day Earth leads to an alien invasion, a team of military officers may be all that stands between humanity and certain annihilation. (If the US military used radio and satellites they’d have learned in five minutes what it took the “heros” 6 hours of listening) If you like action-packed novels, (HAHAHAHA AA. There is like… THREE whole action scenes in the entire book, and one of them is listened through a RADIO ) then you'll love the electrifying action in this apocalyptic thriller.(Something like 100+ million people die. Significant yes but I don’t even care by the fifth time he says “apocalyptic”)
Grab Ambush today! (NO! DO NOT BUY)
Independence Day meets The X-Files(Those were fun! This is boring.) when Air Force fighter pilots Jake Giard and Sandra Fitzpatrick join a decades-old secret project to integrate today's Earth into a galactic government(Sandra joins jack and shit, she was never part of the organization). But when a galactic war spills onto our shores(when a galactic war is STARTED on our shores), plunging the planet into an otherworldly post-apocalyptic hell (No. Just no), can Jake and Sandy save humanity from extinction?”(No. They contribute nothing to the story.)
I was expecting action, drama, politics, a great galactic war already in session. Instead I wait 10 hours for the story to start only to be given a plate of poo four times.
Okay what did he do right?
The alien scenes were good. The Socsith felt suitably alien if pretty stupid, and the argonians acutally feel like long lost cousins in space, even if they were hilariously incompetent. +1 star maybe try describing the aliens and their culture more instead of the same pile of clothes the tenth time.
The concept alone is fascinating. While I’m not a humanity F yeah kind of guy, I fully acknowledge an alien species can totally wipe us out just with their drive emissions, a story of an underdog earth proving vital to a great a galactic war for whatever reason is certainly full of promise. +1 star good premise!
Okay so that takes me to the score: a whopping 0 out of 5 stars. Good job! You started with an excellent premise, a wonderful idea, interesting alien species, and you ruined it with terrible characters, plodding plot, pointless chapters, out right infuriating dilly dallying, a merely OK narrator with just about NO sound boarding. I wanted a galactic war, I got walking simulator, the book.
In conclusion: How would I Improve this book? Scrap EVERYTHING after chapter 10. Just scrap it, its all a waste of the readers time and yours Dean Cole. While Star Trek Enterprise was very on the nose with hard men making hard decisions bull, go more that route, a quick one chapter terrorist attack or lightning strike against Earth, then have the Argonians come around, allowing us to start to see the galaxy. This would play to your strengths over describing every damn tree branch, give Sandra an actual story to follow instead of being pointless. Have our heros do something except shuffle from scene to scene.
For all the people who put up with my total rant on this book: I have no idea what ANYONE else who reviewed this book were thinking, they must have gotten the cut down 3 hour novella that was actually good. My recommendation: If you hate slow boring plots, if you hate over description, if you hate characters who have no right in being the story, DO NOT BUY.