What do you think?
Rate this book
The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the German Students Who Defied Hitler
Inspired by the incredible true story of a group of ordinary men and women who dared to stand against evil The ideal of a new Germany swept up Sophie Scholl in a maelstrom of patriotic fervor--that is, until she realized the truth behind Hitler's machinations for the fatherland. Now she and other students in Munich, the cradle of the Nazi government, have banded together to form a group to fight for the truth: the White Rose. Risking everything to print and distribute leaflets calling for Germans to rise up against the evil permeating their country, the White Rose treads a knife's edge of discovery by the gestapo.
Annalise Brandt came to the University of Munich to study art, not get involved with conspiracy. The daughter of an SS officer, she's been brought up to believe in the f�hrer's divinely appointed leadership. But the more she comes to know Sophie and her friends, the more she questions the Nazi propaganda.
Soon Annalise joins their double life--students by day, resisters by night. And as the stakes increase, they're all forced to confront the deadly consequences meted out to any who dare to oppose the Reich.
A gripping testament to courage, The White Rose Resists illuminates the sacrifice and conviction of an unlikely group of revolutionaries who refused to remain silent-no matter the cost.
Annalise Brandt came to the University of Munich to study art, not get involved with conspiracy. The daughter of an SS officer, she's been brought up to believe in the f�hrer's divinely appointed leadership. But the more she comes to know Sophie and her friends, the more she questions the Nazi propaganda.
Soon Annalise joins their double life--students by day, resisters by night. And as the stakes increase, they're all forced to confront the deadly consequences meted out to any who dare to oppose the Reich.
A gripping testament to courage, The White Rose Resists illuminates the sacrifice and conviction of an unlikely group of revolutionaries who refused to remain silent-no matter the cost.
336 pages, Paperback
First published May 1, 2020
62 people are currently reading
2087 people want to read
About the author
Amanda Barratt
18 books393 followersLibrarian Note: There is more than one author in the Goodreads database with this name.
Amanda Barratt is the bestselling author of numerous historical novels and novellas including THE WARSAW SISTERS, WITHIN THESE WALLS OF SORROW, and THE WHITE ROSE RESISTS. Her work has been the recipient of the Christy Award and the Carol Award, as well as an Honorable Mention in the Foreword INDIES Book of the Year Awards.
Amanda is passionate about illuminating oft-forgotten facets of history through a fictional narrative. She lives in Michigan and can often be found researching her next novel, catching up on her to-be-read stack, or savoring a slice of her favorite lemon cake.
To connect with Amanda, visit: www.amandabarratt.net.
Amanda Barratt is the bestselling author of numerous historical novels and novellas including THE WARSAW SISTERS, WITHIN THESE WALLS OF SORROW, and THE WHITE ROSE RESISTS. Her work has been the recipient of the Christy Award and the Carol Award, as well as an Honorable Mention in the Foreword INDIES Book of the Year Awards.
Amanda is passionate about illuminating oft-forgotten facets of history through a fictional narrative. She lives in Michigan and can often be found researching her next novel, catching up on her to-be-read stack, or savoring a slice of her favorite lemon cake.
To connect with Amanda, visit: www.amandabarratt.net.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 190 reviews
May 26, 2020
This is a perfect novel. I can't think of a single thing I would have changed.
The White Rose Resists is one of the best books I've read. It's important, eye-opening, full of drama and emotional power, and still manages to inspire hope by the end. The pace is excellent, the characterizations deeply human, the prose brilliant. It made me cry but it wasn't overwrought. The novel strikes that elusive balance between action and reflection. In other words, the plot moves along but not so quickly that it sacrifices space in which the characters can react to it, respond and and develop accordingly. It also manages to portray evil without being as graphic as some of the other WW2 novels I've read. The author's choices of how to blend fiction with fact made this story highly readable, thoroughly compelling, and completely her own.
Amanda Barratt is one of the most gifted authors I know. She is a force. I am officially in awe of her abilities. The last time I was this stunned at the end of a novel, it was The Seamstress by Allison Pittman.
The White Rose Resists is one of the best books I've read. It's important, eye-opening, full of drama and emotional power, and still manages to inspire hope by the end. The pace is excellent, the characterizations deeply human, the prose brilliant. It made me cry but it wasn't overwrought. The novel strikes that elusive balance between action and reflection. In other words, the plot moves along but not so quickly that it sacrifices space in which the characters can react to it, respond and and develop accordingly. It also manages to portray evil without being as graphic as some of the other WW2 novels I've read. The author's choices of how to blend fiction with fact made this story highly readable, thoroughly compelling, and completely her own.
Amanda Barratt is one of the most gifted authors I know. She is a force. I am officially in awe of her abilities. The last time I was this stunned at the end of a novel, it was The Seamstress by Allison Pittman.
June 1, 2023
Honestly and truly, after perusing in quite meticulous detail my Goodreads friend Marquise’s majorly negative but also by necessity realistic and scathing review of Amanda Barratt’s 2020 historical fiction novel The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the German Students Who Defied Hitler (and which I do in fact strongly recommend, Marquise’s review, that is), I was originally not even going to bother trying to read The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the Students Who Defied Hitler. However, after I received The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the Students Who Defied Hitler as a Christmas present, I finally decided (but indeed only majorly grudgingly and with much uncertainty and trepidation) to at least give Amanda Barratt a bit of a chance. And yes, sadly (albeit for me also not at all unexpectedly) my reading experience with The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the Students Who Defied Hitler has definitely and horribly been totally annoying at best, has been absolutely terrible in every way for me, and with no joy and nothing even remotely pleasurable, engaging, with nada really personally worthwhile whatsoever.
Because aside from Amanda Barratt’s awkward and often inadvertently funny use (or rather her misuse) of German syntax and vocabulary to the fact that the author, that Barratt has actually based one of her fictional members of the White Rose movement on Adolf Hitler’s private secretary Traudl Junge (which is in my opinion a total and utter insult and equally majorly inappropriate, as Traudl Junge was very actively involved with and in the NSDAP), I really and massively have despised every single word part of Amanda Barratt’s text (and yes, also her as an author) and so much so that The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the Students Who Defied Hitler is not only a one star book for me but is also a novel that I do in fact consider as being lower than one star (and I really and truly equally have massive problems understanding why this here story, why The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the Students Who Defied Hitler has such a high and in my opinion absolutely grossly overly exaggerated and ridiculously uncritical positive general ranking).
Because aside from Amanda Barratt’s awkward and often inadvertently funny use (or rather her misuse) of German syntax and vocabulary to the fact that the author, that Barratt has actually based one of her fictional members of the White Rose movement on Adolf Hitler’s private secretary Traudl Junge (which is in my opinion a total and utter insult and equally majorly inappropriate, as Traudl Junge was very actively involved with and in the NSDAP), I really and massively have despised every single word part of Amanda Barratt’s text (and yes, also her as an author) and so much so that The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the Students Who Defied Hitler is not only a one star book for me but is also a novel that I do in fact consider as being lower than one star (and I really and truly equally have massive problems understanding why this here story, why The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the Students Who Defied Hitler has such a high and in my opinion absolutely grossly overly exaggerated and ridiculously uncritical positive general ranking).
June 6, 2020
My Thoughts...
Wow. What I can say. There are no words. This is a must read book. Barratt has shared her heart on the pages of this book and I just don't know how to put words to what I read. The story telling was like no other.
I don't want to say this but if you don't read any other book this year, please read this book.
The Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required and all views expressed are our own.
Wow. What I can say. There are no words. This is a must read book. Barratt has shared her heart on the pages of this book and I just don't know how to put words to what I read. The story telling was like no other.
I don't want to say this but if you don't read any other book this year, please read this book.
The Mary Reader received this book from the publisher for review. A favorable review was not required and all views expressed are our own.
July 27, 2020
If we lived in Nazi Germany, would we risk our lives to resist - or would we choose the safe path of silence? The White Rose Resists brings this dilemma to life through the eyes of the real-life members of the White Rose and the fictional eyes of Anneliese and Kirk. Having researched Munich and the University of Munich for my upcoming novel, When Twilight Breaks, I was impressed by the depth and accuracy of the author’s research. However, the intriguing characters and the beautiful writing made an even deeper impression. This novel drew me in and made me ponder. This is not an easy book to read, nor should it be. But it is a good read, a necessary read. And a highly recommended read.
March 4, 2021
I'll start with the positives in this book: first, a story about resisting the horror that was the Nazi dictatorship is always worth reading, especially when it's a true story, and the story of the bravery of the Munich students who campaigned against Hitler with leaflets and graffiti, and paid for it with their lives, is a great one. Outside Germany, the White Rose movement isn't that well known, at least not until recently when films and media have made it more readily available. So a book that contributes to making this more known for new generations of readers is good out the door.
Secondly, although Hans and Sophie Scholl are the centrepiece and the soul of this movement, there were many others in the White Rose who were also very interesting people with lives worthy of a novel, and writing a book that gives a voice to the other Resistance members besides the Scholls so they'll also get due recognition by new audiences is commendable. The White Rose Resists checks both these boxes.
But here the positives end. Unlike what the high average rating would indicate, this isn't a quality historical novel but is full of issues that aren't being mentioned in reviews. So, with the due spoilers ahead warning, I'm going to lay out the issues here.
The first and major issue is the misuse of German, and by this I mean the incorrect use of words in German as well as the cliché and very annoying introduction of common phrases in German to lend the dialogue a veneer of "authenticity." For example, Amanda Barratt has her characters say things like:
"But nein."
"Danke for coming."
"Nein. Please, nein."
Does that sound like natural speech for a German? No! And it's even less natural when it's inner monologue. It appears that the author is trying (too hard) to reproduce German speech patterns, but since she has no knowledge of how people talk in Germany, she grabs the English stereotype at hand and runs with it to mimic an offensively affected speech no German would be caught dead sporting. And on top of this unnatural stereotyped speech, Barratt insists in interspersing common words in German all over the book: her characters seem biologically incapable of saying just yes or no, they always HAVE to say ja and nein. They can never say goodbye, they HAVE to say Auf Wiedersehen. They can never say father and mother, they HAVE to say Vater and Mutter, and so on. And what's even worse, when she's not stereotyping the speech or overusing German everyday words, Barratt uses the language incorrectly: for example, she writes "vaters and mutters." With all due respect, you're embarrassing yourself here by showing your complete ignorance of the language; the plural of father and mother in German isn't "vaters and mutters," it's Väter and Mütter. It's not advanced German! It's basic, school-level German! Something the author should know since she is so set on using a language she doesn't even speak.
Why even do this, though? The author says in her notes that she had to have some Scholl letters translated, and it's very obvious she doesn't speak a lick of German, which makes her enthusiasm for using the language all the more cringe-inducing. Besides, she writes rather modernly, there's plenty of modern and very American turns of phrase in this novel, so throwing in a few ja and nein isn't making her characters sound "authentically German."
That said, let's see the next issue: characterisation. The novel starts with three POVs: Sophie Scholl, Annalise Brandt, and Kirk Hoffmann, the first is a real person and the two latter are fictional (more on this later). Now, because the POVs are written in first person and due to the authorial quirk of making her characters speak with that fake German affectation, the result is that they all sound the same. Sophie's chapters are exactly the same as Annalise's, and you can hardly tell Kirk is a man because he, too, reads like the two girls. If you took away the chapter headers with their names, you'd not know whose POV it is, the sameness is so glaring that it drags down the story quickly. It'd have been better to just have one single POV narrate everything, or not have all POVS be first person narration because the author can't pull distinct "voices" and doesn't even make an effort given her obsession with German phrasing. She also has all of them "translating" phrases and names of institutions in German, even in their inner dialogue, which again is unnatural and sometimes doesn't even need translation; it isn't like it's obscure or untranslatable stuff either.
Because of this sameness of characterisation, I couldn't care less about any character in this book save for Sophie, and only because I already know her from before. If I were a newcomer to the White Rose, I'd probably not have cared.
The next issue has to do with the choice of characters and the chosen storyline. As I said before, I'm all for giving other White Rose members a time in the limelight; it was a collaborative effort, it wasn't all Hans, Sophie, Willi, Alexander, Christl, and Huber; the cast of members of this Resistance movement is large enough. So why did Barratt feel the need to insert two fictional characters in a very real story and give them more importance and exposition? Her explanation in the notes says that she got inspired for Annelise by Traudl Junge, Hitler's secretary, who grappled with the guilt of not resisting the regime and sought excuses in her youth until she found out about the Scholls, who were even younger. That's well and good, but where is that reflected in Annelise's story? Traudl Junge was an active collaborator, part of Hitler's innermost circle, she typed the orders of his that had millions killed. Whatever absolution she needed isn't going to be achieved by fantasising about having a chance to resist instead of being the participant she was. Annelise, on the other hand, is nowhere near Traudl in any way, shape or form: she's not a participant nor an active collaborator, she's simply the daughter of a SS-Standartenführer who always was wary of Nazism and jumps at the first chance to join the White Rose. How is that even remotely similar to Frau Junge? Not only is the disconnection between premise and execution quite stark, but this also hints that the author simply wanted to play redeemer for someone who didn't need it. Sorry to say, but not all Germans resisted; plenty went along with Nazism. It's a sad reality. But this also means that the few that DID resist are all the more admirable and noble and brave for doing so. So don't cheapen their sacrifice by inserting a faux-redemption for the tyrant's secretary.
Then there's the other fictional character, Kirk. The author says he was based mostly on Jürgen Wittenstein, another lesser known White Rose member. The question here is: why a fictional member? Why not go with the real Wittenstein? Or even use another member as a POV, maybe Schnmorell or Willi? Willi would've been a great character, as would Schmorell. Even the tragic Christl would have. I honestly can't see the point of inserting a wholly fictional character.
Or . . . I can. Actually, I think I can see why there's two fictional characters here that overshadow the real one, Sophie. It's simple: because with these the author can write a romance inside this. Before you tell me that's rather cynical, let's see the last and perhaps biggest flaw, that for me killed whatever hope I had that this novel would have something salvageable. Ready? It's a spoiler. So considering this, it'd be hard to convince me that these characters weren't created for the romance factor, given the ending and the Hollywood-style unbelievable rescue, and the fact that the story still continues its sappy plotline long after the one real POV has been executed.
Oh, and by the way, some of the scenes look copied from the Sophie Scholl: Die Letzte Tage film from 2005, especially the ones during the imprisonment and trial.
To conclude, this isn't a novel I'd recommend in view of the multiple issues it presents. For the White Rose, there's some good non-fiction books that read pretty well and are much better than fiction. Even Hans and Sophie's diaries are available, if you want the facts from the horse's mouth. But if you'd still would like to read a historical novel about them, pick up Resist by Emily Ann Putzke instead; that one is better and more respectful of these real life heroes' story.
Secondly, although Hans and Sophie Scholl are the centrepiece and the soul of this movement, there were many others in the White Rose who were also very interesting people with lives worthy of a novel, and writing a book that gives a voice to the other Resistance members besides the Scholls so they'll also get due recognition by new audiences is commendable. The White Rose Resists checks both these boxes.
But here the positives end. Unlike what the high average rating would indicate, this isn't a quality historical novel but is full of issues that aren't being mentioned in reviews. So, with the due spoilers ahead warning, I'm going to lay out the issues here.
The first and major issue is the misuse of German, and by this I mean the incorrect use of words in German as well as the cliché and very annoying introduction of common phrases in German to lend the dialogue a veneer of "authenticity." For example, Amanda Barratt has her characters say things like:
"But nein."
"Danke for coming."
"Nein. Please, nein."
Does that sound like natural speech for a German? No! And it's even less natural when it's inner monologue. It appears that the author is trying (too hard) to reproduce German speech patterns, but since she has no knowledge of how people talk in Germany, she grabs the English stereotype at hand and runs with it to mimic an offensively affected speech no German would be caught dead sporting. And on top of this unnatural stereotyped speech, Barratt insists in interspersing common words in German all over the book: her characters seem biologically incapable of saying just yes or no, they always HAVE to say ja and nein. They can never say goodbye, they HAVE to say Auf Wiedersehen. They can never say father and mother, they HAVE to say Vater and Mutter, and so on. And what's even worse, when she's not stereotyping the speech or overusing German everyday words, Barratt uses the language incorrectly: for example, she writes "vaters and mutters." With all due respect, you're embarrassing yourself here by showing your complete ignorance of the language; the plural of father and mother in German isn't "vaters and mutters," it's Väter and Mütter. It's not advanced German! It's basic, school-level German! Something the author should know since she is so set on using a language she doesn't even speak.
Why even do this, though? The author says in her notes that she had to have some Scholl letters translated, and it's very obvious she doesn't speak a lick of German, which makes her enthusiasm for using the language all the more cringe-inducing. Besides, she writes rather modernly, there's plenty of modern and very American turns of phrase in this novel, so throwing in a few ja and nein isn't making her characters sound "authentically German."
That said, let's see the next issue: characterisation. The novel starts with three POVs: Sophie Scholl, Annalise Brandt, and Kirk Hoffmann, the first is a real person and the two latter are fictional (more on this later). Now, because the POVs are written in first person and due to the authorial quirk of making her characters speak with that fake German affectation, the result is that they all sound the same. Sophie's chapters are exactly the same as Annalise's, and you can hardly tell Kirk is a man because he, too, reads like the two girls. If you took away the chapter headers with their names, you'd not know whose POV it is, the sameness is so glaring that it drags down the story quickly. It'd have been better to just have one single POV narrate everything, or not have all POVS be first person narration because the author can't pull distinct "voices" and doesn't even make an effort given her obsession with German phrasing. She also has all of them "translating" phrases and names of institutions in German, even in their inner dialogue, which again is unnatural and sometimes doesn't even need translation; it isn't like it's obscure or untranslatable stuff either.
Because of this sameness of characterisation, I couldn't care less about any character in this book save for Sophie, and only because I already know her from before. If I were a newcomer to the White Rose, I'd probably not have cared.
The next issue has to do with the choice of characters and the chosen storyline. As I said before, I'm all for giving other White Rose members a time in the limelight; it was a collaborative effort, it wasn't all Hans, Sophie, Willi, Alexander, Christl, and Huber; the cast of members of this Resistance movement is large enough. So why did Barratt feel the need to insert two fictional characters in a very real story and give them more importance and exposition? Her explanation in the notes says that she got inspired for Annelise by Traudl Junge, Hitler's secretary, who grappled with the guilt of not resisting the regime and sought excuses in her youth until she found out about the Scholls, who were even younger. That's well and good, but where is that reflected in Annelise's story? Traudl Junge was an active collaborator, part of Hitler's innermost circle, she typed the orders of his that had millions killed. Whatever absolution she needed isn't going to be achieved by fantasising about having a chance to resist instead of being the participant she was. Annelise, on the other hand, is nowhere near Traudl in any way, shape or form: she's not a participant nor an active collaborator, she's simply the daughter of a SS-Standartenführer who always was wary of Nazism and jumps at the first chance to join the White Rose. How is that even remotely similar to Frau Junge? Not only is the disconnection between premise and execution quite stark, but this also hints that the author simply wanted to play redeemer for someone who didn't need it. Sorry to say, but not all Germans resisted; plenty went along with Nazism. It's a sad reality. But this also means that the few that DID resist are all the more admirable and noble and brave for doing so. So don't cheapen their sacrifice by inserting a faux-redemption for the tyrant's secretary.
Then there's the other fictional character, Kirk. The author says he was based mostly on Jürgen Wittenstein, another lesser known White Rose member. The question here is: why a fictional member? Why not go with the real Wittenstein? Or even use another member as a POV, maybe Schnmorell or Willi? Willi would've been a great character, as would Schmorell. Even the tragic Christl would have. I honestly can't see the point of inserting a wholly fictional character.
Or . . . I can. Actually, I think I can see why there's two fictional characters here that overshadow the real one, Sophie. It's simple: because with these the author can write a romance inside this. Before you tell me that's rather cynical, let's see the last and perhaps biggest flaw, that for me killed whatever hope I had that this novel would have something salvageable. Ready? It's a spoiler. So considering this, it'd be hard to convince me that these characters weren't created for the romance factor, given the ending and the Hollywood-style unbelievable rescue, and the fact that the story still continues its sappy plotline long after the one real POV has been executed.
Oh, and by the way, some of the scenes look copied from the Sophie Scholl: Die Letzte Tage film from 2005, especially the ones during the imprisonment and trial.
To conclude, this isn't a novel I'd recommend in view of the multiple issues it presents. For the White Rose, there's some good non-fiction books that read pretty well and are much better than fiction. Even Hans and Sophie's diaries are available, if you want the facts from the horse's mouth. But if you'd still would like to read a historical novel about them, pick up Resist by Emily Ann Putzke instead; that one is better and more respectful of these real life heroes' story.
March 10, 2020
Endorsement:
Woven with bittersweet delicacy, Barratt’s intimate voice wraps you so tightly and holds you so closely you are surprised at an outcome history already taught you. A monument to courage and conviction, The White Rose Resists blends Barratt’s hallmark of immersive research with a lovely poetic resonance. This staggering look at love and danger, hope, treachery and unfathomable bravery is delicately handled in Barratt’s deft, assured and masterful voice. The novel is a formidable and bold portrait of impossible courage in a time of sheer evil, yet in Barratt's intelligent care, we are left with the most potent sense of shimmering hope. This book deserves to be on every shelf, at the centre of every book club conversation and on the tips of every reader's tongue for years to come.
Woven with bittersweet delicacy, Barratt’s intimate voice wraps you so tightly and holds you so closely you are surprised at an outcome history already taught you. A monument to courage and conviction, The White Rose Resists blends Barratt’s hallmark of immersive research with a lovely poetic resonance. This staggering look at love and danger, hope, treachery and unfathomable bravery is delicately handled in Barratt’s deft, assured and masterful voice. The novel is a formidable and bold portrait of impossible courage in a time of sheer evil, yet in Barratt's intelligent care, we are left with the most potent sense of shimmering hope. This book deserves to be on every shelf, at the centre of every book club conversation and on the tips of every reader's tongue for years to come.
April 20, 2020
When author Amanda Barratt asked for early readers for her new release, The White Rose Resists, I responded immediately. I had just finished reading A Promise for Tomorrow (her contribution to The Heart's Stronghold novella collection) and I previously enjoyed My Dearest Dietrich (2019). In my mind, I could expect another well-crafted story and that's just what she has delivered.
I gravitate to historical fiction because stories make learning fun! Through her novel, Barratt introduced me to two historical figures—Hans and Sophie Scholl—and showed how their passive resistance to the Nazi regime left an indelible mark on German society. Days after I finished reading I couldn't stop thinking about the Scholls and the ultimate sacrifice they were willing to make for their fellow man. I decided to read it again; then I asked my son and husband if they had ever heard of them. It's that sort of book... one you want to discuss with others.
For me, Barratt struck the perfect balance between fact and fiction. She explains in her author's note how Kirk Hoffmann and Annalise Brandt were fictional characters—inspired by people she encountered while researching the White Rose. While I'll remember Hans and Sophie Scholl for their brave stand against tyranny, Kirk and Annalise were memorable in their own right due to the hope their faith brought to this tale. Love conquers all.
I've read 38 books so far this year and The White Rose Resists is a true standout! Whether you enjoy non-fiction titles like The Hiding Place and Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl or prefer historical novels by authors like Melanie Dobson, Sarah Sundin, Susan Meissner, and Jennifer Chiaverini, this is a must-read title for YOU!
My Favorite Quotes:
"I’m ashamed of the fearful thoughts crowding in, eclipsing all else. If I give into my fear, I’ll be no better than the rest. Buckling beneath the oppressing hand of the Reich out of cowardice."
“In the end, it comes down to the worth you ascribe to freedom. What price you’re willing to pay.”
"The laughter of childhood is a casualty of war."
“Anxiety is like hunger. The longer it gnaws at you, the more used to it you become, though it doesn’t make enduring it any easier."
“It takes effort to feel hate. Indifference is easy.”
"It’s humbling, this daily, childlike reliance, but faith has given me courage outside of myself."
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
I gravitate to historical fiction because stories make learning fun! Through her novel, Barratt introduced me to two historical figures—Hans and Sophie Scholl—and showed how their passive resistance to the Nazi regime left an indelible mark on German society. Days after I finished reading I couldn't stop thinking about the Scholls and the ultimate sacrifice they were willing to make for their fellow man. I decided to read it again; then I asked my son and husband if they had ever heard of them. It's that sort of book... one you want to discuss with others.
For me, Barratt struck the perfect balance between fact and fiction. She explains in her author's note how Kirk Hoffmann and Annalise Brandt were fictional characters—inspired by people she encountered while researching the White Rose. While I'll remember Hans and Sophie Scholl for their brave stand against tyranny, Kirk and Annalise were memorable in their own right due to the hope their faith brought to this tale. Love conquers all.
I've read 38 books so far this year and The White Rose Resists is a true standout! Whether you enjoy non-fiction titles like The Hiding Place and Anne Frank: The Diary of a Young Girl or prefer historical novels by authors like Melanie Dobson, Sarah Sundin, Susan Meissner, and Jennifer Chiaverini, this is a must-read title for YOU!
My Favorite Quotes:
"I’m ashamed of the fearful thoughts crowding in, eclipsing all else. If I give into my fear, I’ll be no better than the rest. Buckling beneath the oppressing hand of the Reich out of cowardice."
“In the end, it comes down to the worth you ascribe to freedom. What price you’re willing to pay.”
"The laughter of childhood is a casualty of war."
“Anxiety is like hunger. The longer it gnaws at you, the more used to it you become, though it doesn’t make enduring it any easier."
“It takes effort to feel hate. Indifference is easy.”
"It’s humbling, this daily, childlike reliance, but faith has given me courage outside of myself."
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. The opinions I have expressed are my own.
June 2, 2020
I want to review this book because it’s...amaaaaazing.
At the same time, I feel like no matter what I say, it won’t do justice to the beautiful story inside these pages. The research and historical detail is just impeccable. The story itself is both captivating and heartbreaking. There were multiple moments where my eyes were so full of tears as I read that I had trouble even making out the words. I was (and still am) so moved…so challenged…so inspired. And truly, I don’t think I’ve ever been so convicted (in a good and so-very-needed way) by a novel. The White Rose Resists is rich and deep and soul-stirring. And, of course, the romantic in me loved that we got a little side of romance, too. ❤️
Between this and Amanda Barratt’s previous novel, My Dearest Dietrich, I’m in awe of her storytelling gift and am already looking forward to whatever she writes next.
At the same time, I feel like no matter what I say, it won’t do justice to the beautiful story inside these pages. The research and historical detail is just impeccable. The story itself is both captivating and heartbreaking. There were multiple moments where my eyes were so full of tears as I read that I had trouble even making out the words. I was (and still am) so moved…so challenged…so inspired. And truly, I don’t think I’ve ever been so convicted (in a good and so-very-needed way) by a novel. The White Rose Resists is rich and deep and soul-stirring. And, of course, the romantic in me loved that we got a little side of romance, too. ❤️
Between this and Amanda Barratt’s previous novel, My Dearest Dietrich, I’m in awe of her storytelling gift and am already looking forward to whatever she writes next.
October 21, 2020
How much courage would it take for any of us to step up and speak out about the evils we hear and see happening daily in our midst? Especially when their perpetrator is the most powerful, heinous monster in all of Germany…in all of Europe?
Brother and sister Hans and Sophie Scholl had the valor and conviction to take on such a task. In her novel, The White Rose Resists, author Amanda Barratt illuminates with hauntingly beautiful clarity the true story of the Scholls and their White Rose network; how Hans and Sophie, along with their fellow Munich university students, resisted the yoke of the Nazis by revealing the shocking truth to their countrymen. In these pages, I relived Hans and Sophie’s remarkable journey; their greatness amidst human degradation and an impenetrable faith that defied a godless regime as a few risked all to expose Hitler’s reign of terror during WWII.
A suspenseful, heartrending story that will leave you changed by the final page, The White Rose Resists offers new hope in our humanity and reaffirms what it means to have courage and character. Once again, Barratt’s telling is sublime and a must-read for fans of WWII historical and inspirational fiction!
Brother and sister Hans and Sophie Scholl had the valor and conviction to take on such a task. In her novel, The White Rose Resists, author Amanda Barratt illuminates with hauntingly beautiful clarity the true story of the Scholls and their White Rose network; how Hans and Sophie, along with their fellow Munich university students, resisted the yoke of the Nazis by revealing the shocking truth to their countrymen. In these pages, I relived Hans and Sophie’s remarkable journey; their greatness amidst human degradation and an impenetrable faith that defied a godless regime as a few risked all to expose Hitler’s reign of terror during WWII.
A suspenseful, heartrending story that will leave you changed by the final page, The White Rose Resists offers new hope in our humanity and reaffirms what it means to have courage and character. Once again, Barratt’s telling is sublime and a must-read for fans of WWII historical and inspirational fiction!
March 11, 2020
The White Rose Resists is that rare and powerful story that rips your heart apart at the same time that it inspires you to live for something greater. With a lyrical and skillful voice, Amanda Barratt tells the amazing true story of the German students who dared to use their voices in a culture of oppression. This novel will have readers turning pages late into the night, it will have their own blood surging and boiling with a need for justice. Most of all, it will remind them of what is truly important, and spur them on to live more fully. A beautiful masterpiece of a novel!
May 26, 2020
This is not your typical WWII novel. This is a behind-the-scenes look at some idealistic youth in Germany under an oppressive dictator and how they become disillusioned and try to wake the average man to action. Ms. Barratt has thoroughly researched the true story of The White Rose drawing on the leaflets, letters, diaries and interviews with people contemporary to the events. She seamlessly adds a few fictional characters into the mix to flesh out the story. Throughout the novel, she shows hope, faith and courage of ordinary people.
The White Rose Resists brought me to tears again at the injustice that was wrought during the Hitler regime. I was in awe at the lengths that these souls went to in order to bring truth to their fellow countrymen.
The story is told in turns by the members of The White Rose.
Sophie Scholl: “ There is purpose in this. In death, as in life. Someday perhaps my story will be told, and others will remember. That to witness wrong and stay silent is as much a crime as committing evil oneself. That youth does not exempt one from responsibility. That freedom is a gift.”
I am reminded of the many examples in the Bible that God reserves a remnant even when things look bleak. And that He is with that few in spite of the overwhelming odds.
Notable Quotes:
Sophie:“How can we expect righteousness to prevail if there is hardly anyone willing to sacrifice themselves for a righteous cause.”
Kirk:“The laughter of childhood is a casualty of war. Childhood itself is stolen by war’s cruel hand.”
Sophie: “Freedom looks like this sunshine. Freedom to live without fear, to speak one’s beliefs without glancing around and behind.”
Tension permeated the pages as Sophie, her brother, Hans and their friends put their plans into action. Ms. Barratt captures the heartache as the characters try to protect each other, then take responsibility for their actions. Sophie: “In spite of my exhaustion, the risk of discovery, the nagging anxiety, I wouldn’t go back to doing nothing. Pain is better than emptiness.”
Annalise: “Even the greatest darkness can be breached by the flame of a single candle.”
It was my privilege to read such an accomplished book. Ms. Barratt truly brings the past to life.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher on behalf of the author. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
The White Rose Resists brought me to tears again at the injustice that was wrought during the Hitler regime. I was in awe at the lengths that these souls went to in order to bring truth to their fellow countrymen.
The story is told in turns by the members of The White Rose.
Sophie Scholl: “ There is purpose in this. In death, as in life. Someday perhaps my story will be told, and others will remember. That to witness wrong and stay silent is as much a crime as committing evil oneself. That youth does not exempt one from responsibility. That freedom is a gift.”
I am reminded of the many examples in the Bible that God reserves a remnant even when things look bleak. And that He is with that few in spite of the overwhelming odds.
Notable Quotes:
Sophie:“How can we expect righteousness to prevail if there is hardly anyone willing to sacrifice themselves for a righteous cause.”
Kirk:“The laughter of childhood is a casualty of war. Childhood itself is stolen by war’s cruel hand.”
Sophie: “Freedom looks like this sunshine. Freedom to live without fear, to speak one’s beliefs without glancing around and behind.”
Tension permeated the pages as Sophie, her brother, Hans and their friends put their plans into action. Ms. Barratt captures the heartache as the characters try to protect each other, then take responsibility for their actions. Sophie: “In spite of my exhaustion, the risk of discovery, the nagging anxiety, I wouldn’t go back to doing nothing. Pain is better than emptiness.”
Annalise: “Even the greatest darkness can be breached by the flame of a single candle.”
It was my privilege to read such an accomplished book. Ms. Barratt truly brings the past to life.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher on behalf of the author. I was not required to give a favorable review. All opinions are my own.*
September 8, 2020
Faced with the atrocities of the Nazi regime, a group of university students join together to apprise their fellow students and neighbors through leaflets they will produce. Knowing what may happen if they are discovered, they choose standing up for their beliefs over what they may face.
Standing strong for beliefs can be traced back to the beginning of time: the Disciples for their Christian faith, dissenters during the American Revolution, World War 1, World War 2, and the Vietnam War, and so many other examples. This story traces the real life activities of the group of university students who published the White Rose to make those around them in Berlin aware of the truth of the events happening because of the Hitler regime. They gave their all in their work and some made the ultimate sacrifice of their lives as well.
Well written with varying perspectives from the different students involved. This story brought to mind some of the events taking place in the US and around the world and what choices each of us will make that may change our country or even our world.
Standing strong for beliefs can be traced back to the beginning of time: the Disciples for their Christian faith, dissenters during the American Revolution, World War 1, World War 2, and the Vietnam War, and so many other examples. This story traces the real life activities of the group of university students who published the White Rose to make those around them in Berlin aware of the truth of the events happening because of the Hitler regime. They gave their all in their work and some made the ultimate sacrifice of their lives as well.
Well written with varying perspectives from the different students involved. This story brought to mind some of the events taking place in the US and around the world and what choices each of us will make that may change our country or even our world.
June 21, 2020
The truth of Hitlers ulterior motives are showing through in Germany, as rumors of war breaks out. Uniformed soldiers are being seen everywhere, curfews are in place as well as round ups and blood red banners have been hung all over the city and in every building. The country screams Hitler and the Nazi party.
Sophie feels she needs to do something. She sees everyday how it is affecting her family. The rationing of food, and fuel as well as people no longer having their businesses because of their religious belief. She knows her brother has been up to something, but he is keeping quiet. Meanwhile, she is trying to get through her university classes, when she makes a new friend, Annalise.
Han's eventually lets Sophie in on his adventures as night, as she promises to help and feels she might have finally found an effort that will help with the war. Well, resisting everything Hitler is trying to do. Han's makes it clears she could lose her life, and this is literals life or death. There can be no mistakes, no slip ups. Sophie, Hans and a few other recruits of his have all figured out how to get their pamphlets and words out. Resistance, that is what needs to happen.
At first it seems their attempt is futile for all of the work it is taking, and how can they do more than 100 copies, they will need a machine, but those are nearly impossible to get and puts a target on your back. They need to find a way to mass produce thousands of pamphlets. Sophie calls in a favor, with her fiancé and they are in business. They never thought they would have gotten their hands on a machine.
All of their extra time is spent on putting their words on paper, mass producing, mailing or dropping these without getting caught. They have found ways to split up and mail from different cities to make it not so obvious that it is localized. Word is getting around, and there are murmurs of the White Rose group that is printing these pamphlets. Excitement and feeling of doing good is cursing through them all.
Sophie asks to bring in her friend Annalise, another female to help purchase stamps and paper and distribute. A female is less likely to be assumed to be helping with a resistance. They are uneasy about letting Annalise in, her father after all is an SS officer. But she has shared her beliefs with Sophie, and so they give in and trust bringing her in as well.
With all of them working together, they are able to produce thousands of leaflets, but that also makes things more risky as that means that many more have to be mailed or delivered. Rumors are, they are looking for the perpetuators. They are not happy that this is getting the hands of people.
Han's then decides to take a risk and one night a few of the men, paint the sides of buildings with words and phrases. Including the university. Now there really is uproar over this resistance group, and they really have to be cautionary with everything they say and do. But due to all of their extra time spent on this, they are all becoming exhausted and that is where potential for mistakes is made.
Han's then decides on a more bold approach, and Sophie won't let him do it alone. The two are taken amidst the chaos that had ensued and are cuffed and interrogated for hours, and days. Over, and over the same questions, the same bright light, no food or water. But can Sophie and Hans prevail and take it all to their grave without giving up, or will they connect the dots that will lead them to all of the others?
Very well researched and written novel! Thank you to Amanda Barratt, the author for a copy of the book. I really loved this novel and how she wrote it from a few viewpoints. This novel was based on true people, and a true resistance group.
Sophie feels she needs to do something. She sees everyday how it is affecting her family. The rationing of food, and fuel as well as people no longer having their businesses because of their religious belief. She knows her brother has been up to something, but he is keeping quiet. Meanwhile, she is trying to get through her university classes, when she makes a new friend, Annalise.
Han's eventually lets Sophie in on his adventures as night, as she promises to help and feels she might have finally found an effort that will help with the war. Well, resisting everything Hitler is trying to do. Han's makes it clears she could lose her life, and this is literals life or death. There can be no mistakes, no slip ups. Sophie, Hans and a few other recruits of his have all figured out how to get their pamphlets and words out. Resistance, that is what needs to happen.
At first it seems their attempt is futile for all of the work it is taking, and how can they do more than 100 copies, they will need a machine, but those are nearly impossible to get and puts a target on your back. They need to find a way to mass produce thousands of pamphlets. Sophie calls in a favor, with her fiancé and they are in business. They never thought they would have gotten their hands on a machine.
All of their extra time is spent on putting their words on paper, mass producing, mailing or dropping these without getting caught. They have found ways to split up and mail from different cities to make it not so obvious that it is localized. Word is getting around, and there are murmurs of the White Rose group that is printing these pamphlets. Excitement and feeling of doing good is cursing through them all.
Sophie asks to bring in her friend Annalise, another female to help purchase stamps and paper and distribute. A female is less likely to be assumed to be helping with a resistance. They are uneasy about letting Annalise in, her father after all is an SS officer. But she has shared her beliefs with Sophie, and so they give in and trust bringing her in as well.
With all of them working together, they are able to produce thousands of leaflets, but that also makes things more risky as that means that many more have to be mailed or delivered. Rumors are, they are looking for the perpetuators. They are not happy that this is getting the hands of people.
Han's then decides to take a risk and one night a few of the men, paint the sides of buildings with words and phrases. Including the university. Now there really is uproar over this resistance group, and they really have to be cautionary with everything they say and do. But due to all of their extra time spent on this, they are all becoming exhausted and that is where potential for mistakes is made.
Han's then decides on a more bold approach, and Sophie won't let him do it alone. The two are taken amidst the chaos that had ensued and are cuffed and interrogated for hours, and days. Over, and over the same questions, the same bright light, no food or water. But can Sophie and Hans prevail and take it all to their grave without giving up, or will they connect the dots that will lead them to all of the others?
Very well researched and written novel! Thank you to Amanda Barratt, the author for a copy of the book. I really loved this novel and how she wrote it from a few viewpoints. This novel was based on true people, and a true resistance group.
May 18, 2021
"What an indifferent world this is."
Silence. Indifference. Hatred. War. When does one act? When is it right to stand up against the government? Do we just give in and shrug our shoulders to reality?
Sophie Scholl, her brother, Hans, and their friends had to make a hard choice in Germany during Hitler's rule. In printing their thoughts, in sharing the truth of the evil existing in their country, they were willing to die. They were ordinary young people. They saw what was happening and sought a path. This book is sobering, yet hopeful. I enjoyed the fictional aspects woven in but I found the historical aspects that I did know to be accurate.
There is romance and emotional feelings expressed. Some kissing, not detailed. Smoking and drinking is shown throughout.
A book of hope in a time where hope seemed lost.
Silence. Indifference. Hatred. War. When does one act? When is it right to stand up against the government? Do we just give in and shrug our shoulders to reality?
Sophie Scholl, her brother, Hans, and their friends had to make a hard choice in Germany during Hitler's rule. In printing their thoughts, in sharing the truth of the evil existing in their country, they were willing to die. They were ordinary young people. They saw what was happening and sought a path. This book is sobering, yet hopeful. I enjoyed the fictional aspects woven in but I found the historical aspects that I did know to be accurate.
There is romance and emotional feelings expressed. Some kissing, not detailed. Smoking and drinking is shown throughout.
A book of hope in a time where hope seemed lost.
November 15, 2021
1942-1945 Berlin & Munich, Germany
Well written novel based upon the actions of student Sophie Scholl during WWII.
Most of the characters and events were based upon factual events. The fictional characters included seemed plausible and captured my heart.
Amazing bravery and selflessness shown by a group of students driven to spread the truth about horrendous happenings that occurred during the war.
I was late to read this novel and am so glad I finally read it.
Well written novel based upon the actions of student Sophie Scholl during WWII.
Most of the characters and events were based upon factual events. The fictional characters included seemed plausible and captured my heart.
Amazing bravery and selflessness shown by a group of students driven to spread the truth about horrendous happenings that occurred during the war.
I was late to read this novel and am so glad I finally read it.
April 17, 2020
2020 Top Pick! Author Amanda Barratt displays a masterful touch with a powerful story.
This beautiful novel relates the tale of Sophie and Hans Scholl, their real-life collaborators, and two winning fictional characters, who pit their youth and passion against the unforgiving Reich. The first person, present tense POV pulls readers into the story and allows them to watch events unfold through their own eyes. Barratt’s deft hand with details brings history to life without overpowering the rich emotions at the heart of this novel. And that ending . . . perfection!
5+++ stars! A winner! Can’t wait to share this with my students!
Best Quote: “Someday perhaps my story will be told, and others will remember. That to witness wrong and stay silent is as much a crime as committing evil oneself. That youth does not exempt one from responsibility.” ~Sophie Scholl
This beautiful novel relates the tale of Sophie and Hans Scholl, their real-life collaborators, and two winning fictional characters, who pit their youth and passion against the unforgiving Reich. The first person, present tense POV pulls readers into the story and allows them to watch events unfold through their own eyes. Barratt’s deft hand with details brings history to life without overpowering the rich emotions at the heart of this novel. And that ending . . . perfection!
5+++ stars! A winner! Can’t wait to share this with my students!
Best Quote: “Someday perhaps my story will be told, and others will remember. That to witness wrong and stay silent is as much a crime as committing evil oneself. That youth does not exempt one from responsibility.” ~Sophie Scholl
June 22, 2020
Amanda Barratt writes with courage, heart, and the kind of brain power that is super impressive to me. I am so impressed with the way she devotes so much, not only to research, but also to writing real people with compassion, dignity, and humanity.
I'm eager for whatever she brings us next!
I'm eager for whatever she brings us next!
May 4, 2020
Amanda Barrett sets a high bar of excellence in this stirring tribute to the real life heroes of the White Rose resistance group, a group of German college students during WWII. Ms. Barrett's impeccable attention to detail and expert research brings to light a story of which I had little prior knowledge.
Hans and Sophie Scholl's message that one cannot stand innocently by to the injustice and evils in our world is compelling. Beautifully written, this expertly crafted tale will change its readers with its message of hope and action, amidst tragedy and evil. One for the keeper shelf!
One of many quotes I highlighted:
"If I do not fight against, aren't I as good as fighting for?"
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are mine.
Hans and Sophie Scholl's message that one cannot stand innocently by to the injustice and evils in our world is compelling. Beautifully written, this expertly crafted tale will change its readers with its message of hope and action, amidst tragedy and evil. One for the keeper shelf!
One of many quotes I highlighted:
"If I do not fight against, aren't I as good as fighting for?"
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the author/publisher and was not required to write a review. All opinions expressed are mine.
April 29, 2020
'Show me what to do. You, O Lord, are my only solace.'
I have studied the Holocaust for decades and when I saw the subject of Amanda Barratt's newest book, I knew this would be interesting. The books is not directly a Holocaust related book, but indirectly.
'What worth do you ascribe to freedom?
Amanda Barratt gives us the true story of Sophie Scholl and some of her fellow compatriots who acted to renounce Hitler and his ideas for Germany in the 1930s and 1940s. These young college students wrote and mailed/passed out leaflets in direct opposition to the Nazi regime.
'What little I have to offer, I will give. No matter the cost.'
Barratt tells their story with writing so stellar it grabs your mind and refuses to let go. I knew the outcome of Sophie Scholl's story before reading this book, and yet Barratt makes Sophie's life and her friends' lives come so alive! She puts you 'in' their lives. You feel their pain, their fear, their determination to try and make Germany a better place, a place free of a tyrant's rule, a place where lives mattered and not just lives that tyrant thought were worthy.
'Our instincts for evil have been nurtured. Once, acts of violence were condemned. Now, they're condoned. As long as the targets those deemed deserving.'
Incredibly well written and heartrendingly told, this book will stay with you. It's not a quick read. It takes time to absorb. While it is based on fact, parts are fictionalized but Barratt stays totally true to the facts. This book is impeccably researched and well worth reading. Bravo!
*My thanks to Kregel Publications for a copy of this book via Net Galley. The opinions in this review are expressly my own.
I have studied the Holocaust for decades and when I saw the subject of Amanda Barratt's newest book, I knew this would be interesting. The books is not directly a Holocaust related book, but indirectly.
'What worth do you ascribe to freedom?
Amanda Barratt gives us the true story of Sophie Scholl and some of her fellow compatriots who acted to renounce Hitler and his ideas for Germany in the 1930s and 1940s. These young college students wrote and mailed/passed out leaflets in direct opposition to the Nazi regime.
'What little I have to offer, I will give. No matter the cost.'
Barratt tells their story with writing so stellar it grabs your mind and refuses to let go. I knew the outcome of Sophie Scholl's story before reading this book, and yet Barratt makes Sophie's life and her friends' lives come so alive! She puts you 'in' their lives. You feel their pain, their fear, their determination to try and make Germany a better place, a place free of a tyrant's rule, a place where lives mattered and not just lives that tyrant thought were worthy.
'Our instincts for evil have been nurtured. Once, acts of violence were condemned. Now, they're condoned. As long as the targets those deemed deserving.'
Incredibly well written and heartrendingly told, this book will stay with you. It's not a quick read. It takes time to absorb. While it is based on fact, parts are fictionalized but Barratt stays totally true to the facts. This book is impeccably researched and well worth reading. Bravo!
*My thanks to Kregel Publications for a copy of this book via Net Galley. The opinions in this review are expressly my own.
January 21, 2021
Young, daring, faith-filled, in love with life, yet committed without reservation—this is the White Rose, a close-knit group of University students determined to defy Hitler and rouse the German people from their egocentricity and complacency, no matter the cost. Meticulously researched and beautifully, brilliantly told, Amanda Barratt weaves tension, suspense, love and loss with a skillful hand. Stirring, and a reminder that courage should never be relegated to the pages of history alone, The White Rose Resists kept me turning pages as fast as my eyes could read.
May 27, 2020
There are some books that come along that simply require reflection and muse, that take your breath away while reading, and that leave a mark on your mind and heart that a lesson is meant to be heard. I got all of that and more from this amazing book.
The character development is so incredibly well done, and you really feel as if you know them as your neighbors. These young students are amazing...risking all to tell the truth no one else will tell. It provokes the reader to think about what one would do and what one would be willing to risk in telling the truth. For me,the start and development of the story was a bit slow in the beginning. My mind that is affected by neuro disorder had a bit of a difficult time following the different people in short time spans. As the book progresses,the reader spends more time with each character...this actually helps the book really build into the fantastic read that it is. It is pure genius once you realize how well the story is told...and how it has to be told.
The fact that so much real detail and facts are in this book makes it powerful,the way the author writes and weaves those facts into this book makes a spectacular, heart wrenching story!
There is an obvious faith and truth theme through the book...and the eternal fight of good versus evil. A book truly written for the times in which we live.
The first book by this author set the bar very high for this one, but that was not a problem. Once again,she exceeded my expectations. I really do not feel any review is quite going to do this book justice, but I am thrilled I read it. It will not soon be forgotten...and much to ponder and absorb.
I received this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
The character development is so incredibly well done, and you really feel as if you know them as your neighbors. These young students are amazing...risking all to tell the truth no one else will tell. It provokes the reader to think about what one would do and what one would be willing to risk in telling the truth. For me,the start and development of the story was a bit slow in the beginning. My mind that is affected by neuro disorder had a bit of a difficult time following the different people in short time spans. As the book progresses,the reader spends more time with each character...this actually helps the book really build into the fantastic read that it is. It is pure genius once you realize how well the story is told...and how it has to be told.
The fact that so much real detail and facts are in this book makes it powerful,the way the author writes and weaves those facts into this book makes a spectacular, heart wrenching story!
There is an obvious faith and truth theme through the book...and the eternal fight of good versus evil. A book truly written for the times in which we live.
The first book by this author set the bar very high for this one, but that was not a problem. Once again,she exceeded my expectations. I really do not feel any review is quite going to do this book justice, but I am thrilled I read it. It will not soon be forgotten...and much to ponder and absorb.
I received this book from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
May 30, 2020
"The day of reckoning has come, the reckoning of the German youth again the most heinous tyranny our nation ever had to suffer. In the name of all German youth, we demand of Adolf Hitler's state the return of personal freedom, the most precious good of the German people, of which he has cheated us in the most wretched manner."
A manifesto of sorts; defining the demands of "The White Rose", a student resistance movement, who against all odds, fought a regime of terror with the only means they had available; their words. Did they accomplish their purpose? Perhaps the fact that we are still honoring them with our words is a fitting tribute to their legacy.
Amanda Barratt has written these brave young men and women back to life within the pages of her book; carefully peeling back the layers of their humanity, their conscience, their determination, their sanctity of life, and ultimately their ineffable courage in the face of dire consequences. And even then . . .
"I don't regret my conduct. I believe I have done the best I could for my country and my conscience. I'm ready to stand before God only with the regret that I didn't do more."
What an outstanding example of historical fiction.
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
A manifesto of sorts; defining the demands of "The White Rose", a student resistance movement, who against all odds, fought a regime of terror with the only means they had available; their words. Did they accomplish their purpose? Perhaps the fact that we are still honoring them with our words is a fitting tribute to their legacy.
Amanda Barratt has written these brave young men and women back to life within the pages of her book; carefully peeling back the layers of their humanity, their conscience, their determination, their sanctity of life, and ultimately their ineffable courage in the face of dire consequences. And even then . . .
"I don't regret my conduct. I believe I have done the best I could for my country and my conscience. I'm ready to stand before God only with the regret that I didn't do more."
What an outstanding example of historical fiction.
I received a copy of this book from the author and publisher. The opinions stated above are entirely my own.
June 12, 2022
Germany 1942-45. I’m not even sure how to review this great book. It definitely tells a different part of WW2 in Germany than you ever hear. About several university students (most of whom were real people in history) who are opponents to Hitler and his regime. They look to not be ones who do nothing and are determined to fight with what they can - through the written word. They know that being against Hitler can put their lives in jeopardy but they go and do it anyway.
Good character building. Again, most were real people but the author does well to blend them in with the fictional characters. Just an excellent read!
Good character building. Again, most were real people but the author does well to blend them in with the fictional characters. Just an excellent read!
May 12, 2020
I’m having trouble finding the words to describe this book. It was that good! I enjoyed it immensely. It is such a powerful story about young people standing up against injustice. I truly cared for these characters, including the fictional ones. This book even made me cry a few times, which is really hard to do. I hadn’t heard of The White Rose group before this, but now I want to know more about these brave young people. I highly recommend this book!
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
I received a complimentary copy from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine alone.
June 14, 2020
Wow!
Stunning. Haunting. Masterful. Amanda breathes life into this story and leaves you breathless. You don’t want to miss this. It will leave you questioning if you have done enough in your life to fight for truth and freedom.
Stunning. Haunting. Masterful. Amanda breathes life into this story and leaves you breathless. You don’t want to miss this. It will leave you questioning if you have done enough in your life to fight for truth and freedom.
May 26, 2020
"Faith is trusting through the darkness, but sometimes I ask how and come up empty."
Amanda Barratt is a master storyteller who weaves beautifully crafted fiction into heart-rending history to produce a thought-provoking and soul-stirring story of unspeakable tragedy and hope. She pens such unique and unforgettable historical fiction with attention to detail that will bring you into the heart of her characters, both historical and fictional, and have you living in their shoes. I knew nothing about the White Rose student movement in Munich during WWII prior to reading this book but experiencing the students' passion and sacrifice for freedom through the author's poignant words has given me a new focus in perspective. This is a book that will stay with you long after you've finished the last page; echoes of "if an opportunity presented itself, would you risk your own life to save another?" will continue to resound in your spirit once you get to know Hans, Alex, Kirk, Sophie, Annalise, and Willi.
The White Rose Resists has a very different feel and tempo from the author's previous book My Dearest Dietrich but is equally captivating. Told from first person present perspectives of Sophie (historical figure), Annalise and Kirk (fictional characters), the plot has a passionate - almost reckless - urgency, fire and abandon that can only come from university students in 1942 Munich. Sophie's brother Hans, with his like-minded friends, Sophie, and Annalise, forms White Rose to stand up against the inhumane atrocities through printed pamphlets. There is also a relatively large secondary character cast which is mostly made up of actual historical figures who were a part of White Rose or helped with some type of resistance during the war. Even in the midst of darkest evil, death, and suffering, the author infuses hope into each character and encounter. Yes, the fate of Sophie and Hans is known, but you will not be able to stop the tears from flowing or heart from breaking when they bravely meet their sentence.
With poetic, melodic voice and meticulous research, Amanda Barratt puts forth another must-read, faith-based historical fiction that is absolutely riveting. This is definitely on my Top 10 for The Best Books of 2020.
I received a copy of the book from Kregel Publications/author and was under no obligation to post a positive review. All comments and opinions are solely my own.
Amanda Barratt is a master storyteller who weaves beautifully crafted fiction into heart-rending history to produce a thought-provoking and soul-stirring story of unspeakable tragedy and hope. She pens such unique and unforgettable historical fiction with attention to detail that will bring you into the heart of her characters, both historical and fictional, and have you living in their shoes. I knew nothing about the White Rose student movement in Munich during WWII prior to reading this book but experiencing the students' passion and sacrifice for freedom through the author's poignant words has given me a new focus in perspective. This is a book that will stay with you long after you've finished the last page; echoes of "if an opportunity presented itself, would you risk your own life to save another?" will continue to resound in your spirit once you get to know Hans, Alex, Kirk, Sophie, Annalise, and Willi.
The White Rose Resists has a very different feel and tempo from the author's previous book My Dearest Dietrich but is equally captivating. Told from first person present perspectives of Sophie (historical figure), Annalise and Kirk (fictional characters), the plot has a passionate - almost reckless - urgency, fire and abandon that can only come from university students in 1942 Munich. Sophie's brother Hans, with his like-minded friends, Sophie, and Annalise, forms White Rose to stand up against the inhumane atrocities through printed pamphlets. There is also a relatively large secondary character cast which is mostly made up of actual historical figures who were a part of White Rose or helped with some type of resistance during the war. Even in the midst of darkest evil, death, and suffering, the author infuses hope into each character and encounter. Yes, the fate of Sophie and Hans is known, but you will not be able to stop the tears from flowing or heart from breaking when they bravely meet their sentence.
With poetic, melodic voice and meticulous research, Amanda Barratt puts forth another must-read, faith-based historical fiction that is absolutely riveting. This is definitely on my Top 10 for The Best Books of 2020.
I received a copy of the book from Kregel Publications/author and was under no obligation to post a positive review. All comments and opinions are solely my own.
October 10, 2020
I had the privilege of reading an ARC of The White Rose Resists: A Novel of the German Students Who Defied Hitler by Amanda Barratt. Since I was only vaguely familiar with the actual events, I did a little research on my own before starting. I wanted to have the students’ faces in my mind while reading. Having done so, the story ceased to be just words written on a page. The events came alive as I read and I was right there with them joining in as they questioned what they had been raised to believe about right and wrong. I did a lot of soul searching along with them. It is easy for someone to think how they might act in a given situation but quite another when actually faced with that situation.
This book isn’t just written, it is beautifully crafted in a hopeful, heartbreaking, haunting way. I had to stop reading at one point because I couldn’t see through my tears. This book is just so real. Told through several characters’ eyes, I was captivated from the very first page. Yesterday would have been Sophie Scholl’s 99th birthday, a fact that was all the more poignant while reading her story. Even though I knew the ending, I kept hoping it would change.
Because of Amanda Barratt's masterful use of actual quotes and excerpts from letters and diaries to achieve realness, I know The White Rose Resists is one book that won't ever leave me.
I was trying to think who I would recommend this to and I have decided the answer is
simply...everyone.
This book isn’t just written, it is beautifully crafted in a hopeful, heartbreaking, haunting way. I had to stop reading at one point because I couldn’t see through my tears. This book is just so real. Told through several characters’ eyes, I was captivated from the very first page. Yesterday would have been Sophie Scholl’s 99th birthday, a fact that was all the more poignant while reading her story. Even though I knew the ending, I kept hoping it would change.
Because of Amanda Barratt's masterful use of actual quotes and excerpts from letters and diaries to achieve realness, I know The White Rose Resists is one book that won't ever leave me.
I was trying to think who I would recommend this to and I have decided the answer is
simply...everyone.
July 31, 2020
Oh my goodness, I can't encourage you enough to read The White Rose Resists by Amanda Barratt. Without a doubt, it is one of my top two reads of the year thus far. And I'll venture to say it will stay among my top reads ever.
Before reading this novel, I didn't know about the White Rose—a group of German students who would not stand by and continue to watch the atrocities that Hitler and many of their countrymen were inflicting on so many innocents. No, these students decided to do their part to open the eyes of other Germans and inspire them to resist as well, knowing full well they were risking their lives in doing so.
Thank you, Amanda Barratt, for giving us this powerful, heartbreaking, and inspiring story. It's one everyone should read. One everyone should remember. One that will cause us to salute those who've sacrificed much—and even given their lives—for the cause of freedom and for the love of their fellow man. I very highly recommend this important book.
Before reading this novel, I didn't know about the White Rose—a group of German students who would not stand by and continue to watch the atrocities that Hitler and many of their countrymen were inflicting on so many innocents. No, these students decided to do their part to open the eyes of other Germans and inspire them to resist as well, knowing full well they were risking their lives in doing so.
Thank you, Amanda Barratt, for giving us this powerful, heartbreaking, and inspiring story. It's one everyone should read. One everyone should remember. One that will cause us to salute those who've sacrificed much—and even given their lives—for the cause of freedom and for the love of their fellow man. I very highly recommend this important book.
December 4, 2024
Oh, my heart (again) 🥺.
Another heartbreakingly beautiful book by Amanda! Again, she beautifully recounted another incredible true story of unsung heroes during World War II—a group of German young adults who bravely defied Hitler through leaflets they anonymously published throughout Munich, Germany.
I find myself utterly in awe of these young folks, individuals who were not much older than I, who stood bravely for the truth, no matter the cost.
Stories of heroics like these are honestly the ones that deserve to be recounted the most. I am so thankful that Amanda uses her gift of writing to keep their memory alive to a new generation. Their story will inspire many others of my generation to continue to fight for truth.
I find Amanda’s writing extremely captivating, making it so hard to put the book down. The characters she highlighted in this book were easy to connect with. And I appreciated her author’s note, explaining more in detail about the real historical figures fictionalized in this book.
I’ve said it before regarding her books, and I’ll say it again, her books do tend to highlight the darker elements of World War II. This makes it really hard for me to see myself rereading frequently her fiction. But at least once I recommend all readers to pick up this book and uncover the treasure within.
“Some things, you just have to do afraid. Some things, you can't wait to do until you're strong enough.”
Another heartbreakingly beautiful book by Amanda! Again, she beautifully recounted another incredible true story of unsung heroes during World War II—a group of German young adults who bravely defied Hitler through leaflets they anonymously published throughout Munich, Germany.
I find myself utterly in awe of these young folks, individuals who were not much older than I, who stood bravely for the truth, no matter the cost.
Stories of heroics like these are honestly the ones that deserve to be recounted the most. I am so thankful that Amanda uses her gift of writing to keep their memory alive to a new generation. Their story will inspire many others of my generation to continue to fight for truth.
I find Amanda’s writing extremely captivating, making it so hard to put the book down. The characters she highlighted in this book were easy to connect with. And I appreciated her author’s note, explaining more in detail about the real historical figures fictionalized in this book.
I’ve said it before regarding her books, and I’ll say it again, her books do tend to highlight the darker elements of World War II. This makes it really hard for me to see myself rereading frequently her fiction. But at least once I recommend all readers to pick up this book and uncover the treasure within.
“Some things, you just have to do afraid. Some things, you can't wait to do until you're strong enough.”
June 8, 2020
4.5 stars for this WWII historical fiction. This book brought to light a movement that I'd not heard of before - the White Rose. This book is based on the actual lives of brother/sister duo Hans and Sophie Scholl, and their effort as college students to educate their fellow German citizens on what Hitler was really doing. Having not heard about any German resistance during WWII, I found this fascinating, particularly because of their youth.
Because of the subject matter, this book was a bit "heavier" than what I'm used to reading, though it's not TOO heavy. As the White Rose group was fighting against the racism prevalent in the era - seeking a pure Aryan race, there were a lot of conversations and sentiments that were particularly reminiscent of what's happening in the US right now after the recent death of George Floyd. I was able to relate a lot to how the group was feeling. Belonging to the race that is claiming superiority, but wanting to broadcast that it's not at all superior. I appreciated the differing viewpoints throughout the book and the fact that Ms. Barratt combined some of the outlying members of the White Rose to be represented in her fictional characters of Annaliese Brandt and Kirk Hoffman. The other viewpoint was Sophie Scholl, whose journals offered insight to the author on her thoughts, feelings and character. I think it is difficult to write about real-life historical figures, but I believe Ms. Barratt did an admirable job in this instance.
One of the things I love most about historical fiction is the ability to teach me something different or to see a different perspective of well known historical events. This book did both of those things and I loved learning about this group who fought back against their own countrymen with the written word. I would strongly recommend this one to any fans of historical (particularly WWII) fiction.
Special thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to write a positive review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.
Because of the subject matter, this book was a bit "heavier" than what I'm used to reading, though it's not TOO heavy. As the White Rose group was fighting against the racism prevalent in the era - seeking a pure Aryan race, there were a lot of conversations and sentiments that were particularly reminiscent of what's happening in the US right now after the recent death of George Floyd. I was able to relate a lot to how the group was feeling. Belonging to the race that is claiming superiority, but wanting to broadcast that it's not at all superior. I appreciated the differing viewpoints throughout the book and the fact that Ms. Barratt combined some of the outlying members of the White Rose to be represented in her fictional characters of Annaliese Brandt and Kirk Hoffman. The other viewpoint was Sophie Scholl, whose journals offered insight to the author on her thoughts, feelings and character. I think it is difficult to write about real-life historical figures, but I believe Ms. Barratt did an admirable job in this instance.
One of the things I love most about historical fiction is the ability to teach me something different or to see a different perspective of well known historical events. This book did both of those things and I loved learning about this group who fought back against their own countrymen with the written word. I would strongly recommend this one to any fans of historical (particularly WWII) fiction.
Special thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an e-copy of this book. I was under no obligation to write a positive review and the thoughts contained herein are my own.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 190 reviews