Ever since I was a little girl, "Alice in Wonderland" has been one of my all-time favorite books. Even now, at 36 years old, it consistently ranks in my top 3. It's one of the best, most wonderful books I've ever read, so you can only imagine my excitement when I was offered the opportunity to listen to this new "The Wonderland Collection" on audio book.
So how did it turn out?
In a word: Excellent!
I'm always a little nervous about approaching an old favorite in a new way, such as once it's been made into a movie or a new retelling of the old story. I had the perfect mixture of excitement and trepidation concerning this audio book, but it did not disappoint. The narration was excellent. As far as I know, I'm not familiar with the narrator, Thomas Nelson, unless I've heard him narrating something else and just didn't know him by name. (It's highly possible; I listen to a LOT of audio books.)
Despite not knowing him, I was very impressed with his narration style. He really brought the characters to life for me. Anyone who has ever read "Alice in Wonderland" or "Through the Looking Glass" knows how many different characters there are. On top of that, these are all characters with which we are extremely familiar. I'd hazard a guess that there isn't a single person, at least in the UK or USA, who hasn't read/watched/heard/etc. of Alice, the Red Queen, the Mad Hatter, the Cheshire Cat, Humpty Dumpty, Tweedle Dee and Tweedle Dum, etc.
I think a narrator has a much harder job narrating a well-known tell than narrating a story no one's ever heard. With a story no one knows, the narrator can create the characters from scratch and make them come alive. With a story like "The Wonderland Collection," everything the narrator does is going to be compared to someone else we've seen bring these characters to life before. Whether it's Alan Rickman or Ben Kingsley, we all have a version of how we expect the Caterpillar to sound. The same goes for all of the other characters.
This narrator had some big shoes to fill.
And he did a great job.
He brought these characters to life a new way all his own, but he did it in such a way that I was really impressed by his choices. No two characters sounded the same. In a scene full of dialogue, it was always very clear who was speaking. I especially loved the choices he made for the Mad Hatter, the Mock Turtle and the Tweedle brothers. He did well on all the characters, even the female ones, but he did an especially good job on those four.
The pacing was just right too. I tend to listen to my audio books on double speed (2x). With this particular book, I was able to listen at 1.5x speed, and it sounded perfect to me. It wasn't too rushed, and it didn't drag. A few times, my phone (which isn't all that great) glitched out, and the book would stop. On those occasions, I'd have to go back into the Netgalley app and hit play on the book again. When I did, it would reset my reading speed preferences back to default (1x speed). There were several times when I forgot to readjust it to 1.5x, and even in those times, the book flowed well.
Most of the time, an audio book on regular speed is much too slow for me and drives me nuts. This narrator did a great job of narrating at a pace that I didn't mind listening to at regular speed. (Although, because I prefer things to be a little faster, I did go back and speed it up to 1.5x whenever my brain clued into the fact that it was at normal speeds again. Still, my point is that I could have listened to it normally and wouldn't have been too bothered by it.
The only time the book failed to hold my attention was at the end. The mathematician stories at the end of the book couldn't really hold my interest. That was to be expected though, as I never really cared for many of Carroll's short stories. There are a few that I like, but most, I can do without. In other words, it was the story itself that didn't hold my attention, not the fault of the narrator.
I highly recommend this audio book to anyone who loves the Alice stories and wants to dive back into them. I also highly recommend it to anyone who has never read them before. Finally, I think even children would enjoy this audio book. The wide array of voices the narrator uses almost makes it seem like a cartoon, and I think kids would be able to get interested in it without too much trouble or fidgeting.
It was a great audio version of two of my very favorite tales.