Rubbish. Rating: minus 5 on a scale of minus 5 to plus 5
I am doing this rewrite with the expectation that no none will read this. For my new hobby I thank Goodreads employee and member for several years of harassment as response to my formerly mild reviews.
This next was brought to you by TV - Carol and the End of the World, Landscape with Invisible Hand, Inside Job, Mr and Mrs Smith, Kim's Convenience, Dead Boy Detectives, Alien Intervention, Bodkin, Dead Like Me.
YouTube contributed visits to Doctor Who/They Break My Heart - RecklessGirl100, Red Glasgow, LuckyBlackCat, Supertanskiii, Leeja Miller, Andrewism, FAFO, ScaredKetchup, Ana Fern, Sarah Z, Truth to Power, Times Radio, Reese Waters, Girls Rock Asia, Kyiv Independent, Puddles Pity Party, ATP Geopolitics, Ukraine Calling SOF UA, Authors Behaving Badly, Fit 2B Read, Wednesday Addams - Paint it Black, Mynameismarines, A Lil Bit Mads, Roads with Belle, Cindy's Villa, Hoots, Business Basics, Horses, Think That Through, Silicon Curtain, Smack the Pony, Ukraine Matters, Fredda, Eugenia from Ukraine, With Cindy, Philosophy Tube, JohnTheDuncan, NanyaCim, Matriarchetype, Sanctioned Ivan, Not the Andrew Marr Show, ThePrimeChronus, Cambrian Chronicles, Inside Russia, Living Anachronism, Fundie Fridays, Real Time History, Jessie Gender, Military History Visualised, Liz Webster, Bitchuation Room, Think Ukraine, Stanzi, Democratic Penguins Republic, Hildegard Von Blingin, Military Aviation History, Then & Now, Octopus Lady, Ben G Thomas, RFU News, Keffals, Dark Brandon, Bobbing Along, BobbyBroccoli, Ben and Emily, Dark Side of Russia, Narrowboat Pirate, Planarwalker, Gutsick Gibbon, The New Enlightenment with Ashley, OliviaReadsaLatte, The Shades of Orange, Outlaw Bookseller, AuroraTrek, Ukraine Matters, Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox, Jay Exci, Physics Girl, Up and Atom, Megalithhunter, May Moon Narrowboat, Nomadic Crobot, Sailing Melody, Louise Proven, Quarantine Collective, Medieval Tavern Music, Radio Retrofuture, Aditu Laudis, Once Upon a Word, See U in History, Trae Crowder, Answer in Progress, Whitney Avalon, Julie Nolke, Emperor TigerStar, Central Crossing, Riverboat Jack, Mr Newberger's AI Funnies, AllShorts, Dr Fatima, Gutsick Gibbon, Hetty and the Jazzalato Band, J Draper, TVP World, WokeGardener, Nini Music, Owen Jones, Erutan, Hoots, Table Top CP, Ro Ramdin, Sakhalia Net, Unlearning Economics, Jabzy, Kat Abughazaleh, Gingers are Black.
I found that a moron had complained to a trans female essayist whom he was busy insulting that I had trans creators among the channels which I listed. Besides the idiocy, the lack of self-awareness was stunning even for a US male. A trigger warning for morons. My channel list includes Canadian, witch, cis, physicist, military historian, redhaired, het, tall, anthropologist, linguist, trans, brunette, primatologist, bi, Welsh, socialist, essayist, gay, sewist, WOC, German, asexual, autist, gamer and other female creators whom the sane refer to as Women. The others include anarchist, other neurodivergent, Scottish, miniatures gamer, mathematician, librarian, Danish, other BIPOC, socialist, modeller, hobbyist, other LGBTQ, philosopher, Estonian, fashion historian, economist, communist, ginger, boater and others which the sane think of as Human Beings. If the voices persist, consider emergency therapy, immediate pastoral counselling or our Catholic exorcism. My feelings towards the moron and his ilk are similar to that of the 13 Ukrainian marines defending Snake Island, when their surrender was demanded by the Russian navy. Their response was "Russian warship, go f@ck yourself". Glory to Ukraine.Glory to the Heroes. Crimea is Ukraine.
There is no worldbuilding to speak of and for books of this quality that seems the standard. There is no character development nor a pathway towards it which I could discern. The characters are all american supermen, which sums up the extent of character description. The interactions and dialogue are poorly conceived and delivered.
As usual the only space force which humanity can muster are the US Navy. The US are allowed to commit the entire human race to war with no objection and no readers found this weird. This is common to most of Kindle boom-boom spacey-space books. The US control half the galaxy because US sailors and soldiers are the bestest, smartest, most badass and only military of the human race. The characters are as usual of limited ethnicity which is justified by the US fascination with the Great Replacement Theory. It is prevalent in most of the first person shooters and I have yet to see a challenge to this racist portrayal of US society.
When a non-US character is presented they are even more wooden stereotypes of the laziest kind. The non-existence of a role for women is standard for these books. On the rare occasions in which a woman appears, she is unimportant. Female portrayal is usually so awful that one wonders whether the writers have ever met a woman. This summary applies to all of Kindle recommendations. That reality is why I ended my Unlimited sub. I received a notice that Kindle will no longer support Goodreads, which announcement is meaningless.
It is the typical lack of imagination which infects almost all of the Kindle Unlimited offerings. As the US empire continues to fail, the superiority will seem increasingly absurd. No research was done into the designs of current military or naval forces which are what space militaries probably will inherit, even if modified. No research is done into the current scientific consensus and engineering practice, which would lend a consistency and logic to these books.
Kindle/Goodreads work hard to direct taste and tolerance for bad writing. They also use the genres to reinforce every gender and racial stereotype possible. Prose on average is at the eleven year old level for romance and romantasy and seems to be the ten year old for the science fiction. My judgement is based on a sample size of more than 1000 Kindle recommendations. The US publisher respect for any genre is suspect.
I will step away for a bit before continuing. This next was made possible by YouTube channels - NCMI, fig tree, The Bands of HM Royal Marines, ATP Geopolitics, Dark Brandon, Hej Sokoly, Eileen, Holly the Cafe Boat, Well Deck Diaries, May, Maggie Mae Fish, SK Media, KernowDamo, Fantasy and World Music by the Fletchers, Library of a Viking, Professor Tim Wilson, Winging it on a Budget, Abby Cox, Travelling K, Ash L G, Krimson Rogue, Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox, Bellum et Historia, Curious Archives, Kazachka, Anna from Ukraine, Sarah C M Paine, Star Wreck, Think that Through, Verilybitchie, Venom Geek Media, Nomadic Crobot, Holly the Cafe Boat, Ben and Emily, Bobbing Along, Chris and Shell, The Cosy Creative, Kayla Kamper, Anna Gramling. Stories Matter, Novara Media, The Juice Media, Honest Government Ads, Dungeons and Discourse, The Grungeon Master, Players Aid, Aid Thompsin, Ship Happens, Sailing Melody, Politics Joe, UATV, EarleWrites, Stevie Emerson, Hoots, Lavendar, Covert Cabal, Stories Matter, Vintage Tomorrows, Battle Order, Space 1889, Abney Park, Adele Marie, Raw News and Politics, Kirkpattiecake, Art Deco, Evie Lupine, Spacedock, Think Ukraine, Mia Mulder, Don't F@ck with Ukraine, The Sword and the Pen, Brandon Talks, No Justice, Burd's Books, Yanis Varoufakis, Kat Blacque, The Skaldic Bard, The Steampunk Explorer, Nini Music, Hardy's Books, Honestly Sophie, Dr Ben Miles, Bizarre Beasts, Michael Lambert, Artur Rehi, Mercado Media, Anna from Ukraine, Jessie Gender, Steve Shives, Queen Penguin, Jess of the Shire, Princess Weekes, Amie's Literary Empire, Alizee, Alice Cappelle, May, Gabi Belle, Weirdo Book Club, Book Furnace, OrangeRiver, Professor Gerdes Explains, Times Radio, Silicon Curtain, According to Alina, Lore Reloaded.
Consider treating this as a potentially hostile site. 🤔
Goodreads discourse does not exist. About four years ago, I wrote a mild negative review of Powers of the Earth, a poorly written, juvenile salute to the sociopathic January 6,2021 hero written by Travis Corcoran, self-described libertarian and vocal advocate for the return of chattel slavery, admirer of Putin, employee of an unnamed US agency, a veteran. he is the very portrait of a MAGA idiot. He and six fellow patriots took issue with my view that the glorification of the overthrow of the US government with the aid of the military in order that a twat not pay inheritance taxes was dangerous and unhealthy. The writer seems prescient. There was a year long demand that I engage with their increasingly bizarre comments from slavery being a social good through bad things happen to holders of certain views. A communist reader inspiring that much vitriol is sad irony.
Finally Claes Rees Jr aka cgr710 aka Clayton R Jesse Jr (self-described Nazi) wrote a comment to declare that They had "won' (?). I discovered that They had launched a year long (it continues still) deluge of vile sexual and racist attacks against apparently all the channels which I mention. They failed to impress the economist, the hobbyist, the historian, the science educator and the many other female creators. The world's overabundance of unpleasantness was certainly increased and They did deliver an accurate self-portrait of the Snowflake (arrogant, whiny, ignorant, vicious US man-child) to a multinational audience. It seems that this was a Victory. Goodreads literary discourse, Yay ?? USA, Yay ??
Comments to a number of my reviews justified all character names deriving from a very small pool of English names as a result of 70% of US citizens having European names. Their ignorance of maths, that only 7% of americans identify as of English descent and that the US government keep no tally of names is stunning.
These writers never improve because they have neither imagination nor talent. I begin to suspect that there is a major effort to shrink the horizons of the imaginations of US readers. Degrading genre fiction would most certainly serve.
This is the quality of writing that has put me off recent (15 years or less) US science fiction print. There are better writers of military science fiction who know which way a character points a gun, what a ship class is and what world building entails. Kindle and Goodreads never recommend them. For good stories and better writing, I go to the streaming services. I began looking through YouTube for science fiction channels a bit more than five years ago now and found all sorts of interest area channels that I had not known existed. Then I stumbled upon the book tubers. 😍 The book channels are many and varied, covering all elements of the bookish experience. They host communities of readers who are friendly, thoughtful with differing tastes and interests, excited by all things bookish. It is a far different experience to that of this site.
This next was courtesy of YouTube channels - aidan knight, History of Everything, Red Plateaus, Ship Happens, Dreamloop Cinema, Renegade Cut, DUST, Alt Shift X, Kanal 13, Venom Geek Media, May Moon Narrowboat, Yugopnik, Yarmak -Ragnarok, Council of Geeks, TVP News, Princess Weekes, Cold Fusion, Jay Exci, Eckharts Ladder, Chris and Shell, Kris Atomic, May, Aid Thompsin, Supertanskiii. Science of Science Fiction, Space 1889, Inside Russia, Maggie Mae Fish, Ula and Josh, Science Insanity, Outlaw Bookseller, Reads with Rachel, Fit 2B Read, Northern Narrowboaters, Winging it on a Budget, Autumn's Boutique, Merphy Napier, Serena Skybourne, Megalithhunter, The British Museum, Institute of Art and Ideas, ConeOfArc, History with Kayleigh, Fall of Civilisations, Nini Music, Burd's Books, Emma Thorne, Dark Side of Russia, The Templin Institute, Roomies Digest, Military History Visualised, Sarah Millican, No Justice, Mia Mulder, RFU News, UNTV, Aditu Laudis, Omeleto, Cruising on the Border, Kiko1006, The Welsh Viking, Books N Cats, Nerdy Kathi, Scallydandling About the Books, Evie Lupine, Hardy's Books, Petrik Leo, Mrs Betty Bowers, Randy Rainbow, Answer in Progress, Venom Geek Media, Lore Reloaded, Mom on the Spectrum, Ask a Mortician, Certifiably Ingame, Fraser Cain, Terrible Writing Advice, Perun, Veritas et Caritas, Jormungandr, Military Aviation History, Tank Encyclopedia.
Ominous music begins. 😊 The comment gangs have appeared on others' reviews. The dangerous harassment has also been applied to readers of romantasy, romance against one star reviewers and BookTubers. Amazon neither acknowledge the behaviour nor discipline the members, punish the writers who sometimes lead them or dismiss the employees who enable them, Fortunately the romance and romantasy BookTubers do follow the stalking, doxxing, threats made against reviewers, their family and friends. Science fiction review channels never discuss the issue as they are focused on the titles discussed and never on Goodreads membership. I think that a shame but their channels are the creators' to design and I think that it also reflects the fading of the site's relevance.
My very limited message history was given over to these deranged members. That enabled a request being made of Australian Security through Pine Gap Centre to interrogate the one friend whom I occasionally messaged on Goodreads. The attempt to secure my personal information failed but it did result in two very outraged customers. The episode did not concern Amazon until we both publicised the incident. Suddenly the visible harassment towards this reader disappeared. Vicious comments & commenter names were masked, changes to my review pages were reversed, etc. My Kindle service was no longer interrupted, the keyboard format magically returned to normal functioning and Amazon sent me a notice that Kindle no longer support Goodreads. No other notification other than only two insulting previous Goodreads messages did I receive for about five years. Amazon, Kindle and Goodreads are one and the same. Customer service protocols might benefit from an overhaul.
Recently a seventh EBay ex-employee was sentenced for the months long harassment of a couple who managed a small ecommerce channel deemed unkind to EBay. The couple were awarded multi-millions of pounds and the ex-employee had been EBay Chief of Global Security or some such. Things to consider.
I suggest precautions which should make you safer, if not Safe while using this site until such time as you are able or ready to exchange Kindle for a safer non-Amazon product. The data corporations have developed dangerous cultures and Amazon is a data corporation.
I suggest removal of all personal information from Goodreads profile and avoid messaging. Given the Goodreads penchant for Altering customer pages, screenshots of the odd, the ugly and the threatening are incredibly useful. Remove the lurkers, those friends who never post. They are monitors not admirers. Think of them as pack scouts. For Goodreads exposure those should suffice.
Using Kindle is a more serious circumstance. Do Not use Kindle Files, Calendar, Email and Contacts. Kindle opens and records all of your kindle emails stripping away contact information to export to Contacts. Files are a giveaway to Kindle and even Calendar can be dangerous in the hands of stalkers and other degenerates of which Amazon pull many into the fold. Do Not purchase ebooks from Amazon, as you own only the device, not downloads. Those may be deleted at Amazon's whim.
Fortunately I am very cautious by nature and these precautions will cost you nothing but to not implement them might well do. You might also do well not to forget that these animals, members and employees alike are without morality, restraint, courage or fear of consequences but are US patriots with all that implies. Ominous music ends. 😊
Be well. May we all find Good Reading. 🤗
Some of my favourite YouTube channels are.
Some More News, Tom Nicholas, Alice Cappelle, Chloe Stafler, Captured in Words, Tara Mooknee, Mrs Betty Bowers, Munecat, Books with Chloe, Alizee, Lynn Saga, Owen Jones, Riverboat Jack, Narrowboat Pirate, Katy Montgomerie, World War Two, The Great War, Books and LaLa, Sabine Hossenfelder, What Vivi did next, Boat Time, May Moon Narrowboat, Up and Atom, Books with Chloe, Tulia, Jake Broe, With Olivia, Perimeter Institute, Patrick is a Navajo, Spacedock, Ana Psychology, Vlad Vexler, The Piano Guys, A Cup of Nicole, DW News, Books with Emily Fox. Rebecca Watson, Sort of Interesting, Three Arrows, A Clockwork Reader, Northern Narrowboaters, CBC News, Narrowboat Adventures, Novara Media, Prime of Midlife, Katie Halper Show, Jack in the Books, Dr Becky, Sci-Fi Odyssey, Leena Norms, Jake Broe, Hello Future Me, TIKHistory, Natasha's Adventures, IzzzYzzz, Alayna Joy, Renegade Cut, Brandon Fisichella, Books like Whoa, Words Unravelled, Bellum et Historia, Pink Floyd -Hey Hey Rise Up, Lady knight the brave, Joe Scott, Richard Wolff, Ember Green, No Justice, Military Aviation History, Scholars Shelf, Lady of the Library, Ukrainian Canadian, The Historian's Craft, Tibees, Then & Now, Alt Shift X, Travelling K, Lilly's expat life, Roads with Belle, Jessie Gender, Engineering with Rosie, Nomadic Crobot, Cruising the Cut, Adult Wednesday Addams - 2 seasons, Crecganford, Serena Skybourne, Three Arrows, Sarah Z, The Mindful Narrowboat, Epimetheus, David and Romany Gilmour, The People Profiles, Kings and Generals, The Juice Media, Nerine Skinner Comedy, Chris Animations, Writing with Jenna Moreci, Atun Shei Films, Squire Violet Orlandi, Filaxim Historia, Eleanor Morton, Kathy's Flog in France, Holly the Cafe Boat, Engineering with Rosie, Linguoer Mechanic, The Prime of Midlife, Grace McGuire, Depressed Russian, Rowan J Coleman, Natasha's Adventures, 2Cellos, Awful Archaeology, The Templin Institute, Foster on the Spectrum, Just in Time Worldbuilding, Fiction Beast, Fun Size Reader, The Shitty Book Club, Honest Government Ads, Biz, Tale Foundry, Adam Something, Keffals, AllShorts, Demon Mama.
I wish you a refreshing morning, a beautiful afternoon, an exciting evening, a splendid night and may we all continue learning.
Like Music, Hope makes us braver.
Sir John Moore at Corunna