Two and a half stars.
Every. Single. Drama. Point that Love Inspired has *EVER* come up with? That's this book. It's astonishing that Johns was able to cram that much into a slender novel. Must be why there's absolutely no character development, no descriptive writing, and barely a plot.
Okay. So Thomas and Noah's dad died ten years ago, and their mother tells them they weren't born Amish, they were Mennonite TURNED Amish, and she wants to go back to being Mennonite, because she misses her sister and music and literature and art and LIFE. Cool... but she never would've gone Amish to begin with, because there is *NOTHING* to be gained by it. More, Mennonites and Amish can associate with each other, so there's no reason for her to have been estranged.
Johns also seems to have difficulty realizing that Mennonite and English are TWO DIFFERENT THINGS. It's confusing as hell to the people who haven't read Patricia Davids, Emma Miller, or the other *BETTER* Amish-story writers.
Anyhow, the two boys remained Amish and live with a man and his grandmother that are NOT related to them, so THAT gets confusing as heck, too. Noah rejected his mother completely. Thomas left on 'rumspringa' to live with his mother as an Englischer (wouldn't that be Mennonite?!), but she was apparently not interested in him (!?!?!), so he sought love with Tina, a TOTALLY English girl raised in a foster system. NO. HE. WOULDN'T Someone like that is FAR to big a departure. This is all preposterous.
He also knocks Tina up, leaves her pregnant, and goes back to the Amish. Um... really? NO, he wouldn't If she's the hot mess we're told she is? He'd've been able to easily get the baby from the court system. And he would've had SERIOUS issues with the child being raised Englisch.
Now Tina's dead (of course) and the four year old child is being dropped off to Thomas in AmishWorld, and she's grieving and does NOT want to assimilate.
Enter Patience, the not-really-but-gonna-be schoolteacher ((hrmph)) who has offered to help transitition the little girl.
THAT'S NOT A NANNY
The whole book title/premise is fake/a lie. A nanny is a paid employee who takes care of a child in lieu of the parent. Thomas is there THE WHOLE TIME, doesn't pay Patience, and is taking care of the child WITH her.
((((((((SIGH.))))))))
How is it that 'Wiebe' - a GERMAN name isn't 'normal' for Amish, but 'Smoker' is?!
But then it gets more complicated than that. Thomas' mother has decided to come BACK to the Amish, because TEN YEARS LATER she misses her sons. (!!!!) WHO WRITES THIS GARBAGE!?!!
And apparently the Amish are perfectly fine with the Mennonite-no-Amish-no-Mennonite-no-Amish grandmother of the half-English-hate-Amish little girl that they're shoving in the faces of everyone around them.
Meanwhile, Thomas is falling in love with Patience, because she's the only onliest one who will completely accept this MESS. Why? Because she luvvvvvvs children, and had 30 tumors or something in her uterus that left her unable to have children, OF COURSE!!! And she could never have Thomas, because the spoiled brat Englischer kid needs brothers and sisters to help her assimilate, since the Amish children want nothing to do with her demands for TV and Disney Princesses.
I. Can't. Even.
There are SOAP OPERAS written better than this!
I only liked it because it was a terrific train-wreck, and some of those are THE most entertaining to watch. Seriously. At least there weren't spelling/grammar errors. The bar is low with 'Love Inspired', as it is. I guess I should count blessings, hm?