Stuff I Read - Creatures of the Night Review
I borrowed this book from my wife, who got it mostly because it combines Neil Gaiman and animals, so a win-win in most any book. And while the art is quite good and the stories are decent, this was something of a let-down, as the book really doesn't have the legs needed to carry an entire graphic novel. It's only two stories, and though both of them are fine, they are a little lacking in depth. At less than fifty pages that might be understandable, but I was hoping for a bit more from Gaiman, who has proven he can do a lot with limited space.
The first of the stories, dealing with cats, was the better. Dealing with a man and a mysterious cat who shows up at his home, it is interesting to watch, and there is a slowly building suspense throughout the story that made me want to get to the end, to find out what was happening. Unfortunately, when it does make its way to reveal what's happening, the answer is rather weak and really not that satisfying. The visuals were good, the art solid, and the prose worked quite well. There just wasn't much there, and while I appreciated the story, I wanted more. Given that Gaiman has told much better cat stories even during his Sandman tenure, this one left me wanting more.
The second story was a bit weaker, told as a sort of fable of the daughter of owls. Again, this is a fairly straight forward story, but I don't think it really worked as much as a fable. Basically people think that this child is the daughter of owls, and every woman wants to kill her for being an abomination. The men decide no and send her away, and she grows up to be hot. The men then all go to rape her and instead are killed because she actually is the daughter of owls. And that leaves me with some questions. Because obviously the women at the beginning were then right? Or they were wrong, and the men were wrong, and...I'm not sure. I guess I just didn't like as much that every woman wanted to kill it and every man wanted to rape it. It was a morality tale, in that everyone was punished, but I couldn't get to invested in it because I wasn't sure exactly what should have been done.
So with these two stories there just isn't a whole lot to work with for the book. I wish there were more stories, or that these ones were longer, but so it goes. As it stands they are serviceable, but nothing really special, and not up to par with Gaiman's work on Sandman or most of his other graphic novel work. The art was the best part, and I would have liked for some more dynamic stories for the artist to really show off more. All told, it's not bad, but it could have been a lot better, and so I'm left giving it a 6.25/10.