What do you think?
Watchers of Outremer #2
The Lady of Kingdoms
Magic made her a warrior.
Justice will make her a legend.
Jerusalem, 1180: A catastrophe destroyed Marta Bessarion's family and whisked her away from everything she once knew. Now, armed with a magic spear and a burning thirst for justice, Marta vows to protect her new home and family, no matter the cost.
But trouble is brewing in the glittering palaces of Jerusalem...
The young Leper King, Baldwin, is dying. Before he goes, Baldwin must choose a successor...but every choice is a bad one. An innocent child, exploited by stronger men? A crafty cousin who has already tried to snatch the crown? Or his brilliant, passionate sister who is determined to rule - even if it triggers a war?
When enemy armies muster on the kingdom's borders, Marta charges into battle. But when Baldwin's choice puts her newfound family at risk, Marta finds herself fighting a new kind of battle - one in which intrigue, deception, and betrayal are the weapons.
To save the kingdom, she’ll need more than a magic spear to destroy its enemies.
She'll need a saint to save its soul.
Justice will make her a legend.
Jerusalem, 1180: A catastrophe destroyed Marta Bessarion's family and whisked her away from everything she once knew. Now, armed with a magic spear and a burning thirst for justice, Marta vows to protect her new home and family, no matter the cost.
But trouble is brewing in the glittering palaces of Jerusalem...
The young Leper King, Baldwin, is dying. Before he goes, Baldwin must choose a successor...but every choice is a bad one. An innocent child, exploited by stronger men? A crafty cousin who has already tried to snatch the crown? Or his brilliant, passionate sister who is determined to rule - even if it triggers a war?
When enemy armies muster on the kingdom's borders, Marta charges into battle. But when Baldwin's choice puts her newfound family at risk, Marta finds herself fighting a new kind of battle - one in which intrigue, deception, and betrayal are the weapons.
To save the kingdom, she’ll need more than a magic spear to destroy its enemies.
She'll need a saint to save its soul.
438 pages, Kindle Edition
First published November 24, 2019
About the author
Suzannah Rowntree
34 books637 followersHi! I live in a big house in rural Australia with my awesome family, drinking fancy tea and writing historical fantasy fiction that blends real-world history with legend, adventure, and a dash of romance.
If you like the historical fantasy of H. G. Parry, Gail Carriger, or S. A. Chakraborty, you'll probably like my stories too!
You can visit me online at https://suzannahrowntree.site
AI POLICY: It is my firm conviction that only human beings, being made in God's image, have the unique creativity and divine inspiration that engenders art worthy of the name; and that so-called "art" created with the use of generative AI has worth only insofar as it steals and defaces the true art created by human beings. In this conviction I have not and will not in the future make any use of AI in researching, writing, editing, or advertising my books; and to that end I also include no-AI stipulations in my cover design and illustration briefs.
GOODREADS FRIEND POLICY: I'm afraid I don't accept every single friend request I receive, unless we already know each other, or it looks like we have tastes broadly in common. However, please feel free to follow and interact.
If you like the historical fantasy of H. G. Parry, Gail Carriger, or S. A. Chakraborty, you'll probably like my stories too!
You can visit me online at https://suzannahrowntree.site
AI POLICY: It is my firm conviction that only human beings, being made in God's image, have the unique creativity and divine inspiration that engenders art worthy of the name; and that so-called "art" created with the use of generative AI has worth only insofar as it steals and defaces the true art created by human beings. In this conviction I have not and will not in the future make any use of AI in researching, writing, editing, or advertising my books; and to that end I also include no-AI stipulations in my cover design and illustration briefs.
GOODREADS FRIEND POLICY: I'm afraid I don't accept every single friend request I receive, unless we already know each other, or it looks like we have tastes broadly in common. However, please feel free to follow and interact.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews
my-books
October 25, 2019Re-read preparatory to starting work on the sequel, THE HOUSE OF MOURNING.
Marta Bessarion is my darling sledgehammer conscience girl and I am so excited (if a bit daunted) to be writing her again.
--
It may not actually be true that reading this book will freshen your breath, improve your fashion sense, or give you a more soulful connection with the people you love, but multiple beta readers have told me the book left them feeling, and I quote, "a bit giddy". We're just two books into the Watchers of Outremer series, but this is the instalment I'm most excited about.
PLUS, THAT COVER THO.
(A note on reading order: you can start reading the series either with this book; or with Book 1, A Wind from the Wilderness; OR with the novella, Children of the Desolate, which you can get free here!)
Marta Bessarion is my darling sledgehammer conscience girl and I am so excited (if a bit daunted) to be writing her again.
--
It may not actually be true that reading this book will freshen your breath, improve your fashion sense, or give you a more soulful connection with the people you love, but multiple beta readers have told me the book left them feeling, and I quote, "a bit giddy". We're just two books into the Watchers of Outremer series, but this is the instalment I'm most excited about.
PLUS, THAT COVER THO.
(A note on reading order: you can start reading the series either with this book; or with Book 1, A Wind from the Wilderness; OR with the novella, Children of the Desolate, which you can get free here!)
December 31, 2019
This book definitely ranks in my top five. Rowntree's lead is so well fleshed out and relatable which is a rare find for fantasy gals these days. The settings were rich and evocative as usual but this one felt like a step above. This is truly read that will transport you to both a realistic and fantastical view of days long ago.
(I read this about 18 months ago, but apparently forgot to leave a sensible review)
(I read this about 18 months ago, but apparently forgot to leave a sensible review)
September 8, 2022
ENGLISH: Second installment of the series about the Watchers, which combines historical novel with fantasy. In this book, the protagonist is Marta Bessarion, who has been thrown over half a millennium into the future, from the Muslim invasion of Syria in 636, to the year 1180, during the last years of the Kingdom of Jerusalem, a few years before the fall of the city under Saladin, and the Third Crusade.
The historical part is very well documented and explained. I liked best the first twelve chapters, plus a number of later ones, those more faithful to history, where there is no intervention of magicians or demons (such as Lilith). When they appear, the historical part is diluted and we pass into the realm of fantasy. I wonder about the Watchers, who are supposed to do good and protect the people, but usually fail. In fact, I think the role of the Watchers was actually fulfilled by religious orders such as the Knight Hospitaller of Saint John of Jerusalem or, to some extent, the Knights Templar.
The main character in this novel is a saint, always putting her mission and principles before her own interests and wishes. She is even more upright than her brother, in the first book of the series.
A detail in this novel reminded me of my own The Emerald Tablet: that a real historic character (and a king) is supposed to have fallen in love with a fictional girl protagonist. In both cases, for different reasons, this love cannot be consummated.
ESPAÑOL: Segunda entrega de la serie sobre los Vigilantes, que combina novela histórica con fantasía. En este libro, la protagonista es Marta Bessarion, que ha sido lanzada más de medio milenio hacia el futuro, desde la invasión musulmana de Siria en 636, hasta el año 1180, durante los últimos años del Reino de Jerusalén, pocos años antes de la caída de la ciudad en manos de Saladino y de la Tercera Cruzada.
La parte histórica está muy bien documentada y es fiel a la realidad. Me gustaron mucho los doce primeros capítulos, además de otros posteriores, los más fieles a la historia, en los que no intervienen magos o demonios (como Lilith). Cuando aparecen, la parte histórica se diluye y nos trasladamos al reino de la fantasía. También me sorprenden los Vigilantes, que se supone deben hacer buenas obras y proteger al pueblo, pero que usualmente fracasan. De hecho, pienso que el papel de los Vigilantes lo realizaron las órdenes religiosas, como los caballeros hospitalarios de San Juan de Jerusalén y, hasta cierto punto, los Templarios.
La protagonista de esta novela es una santa, que siempre antepone su misión y sus principios a sus intereses y sus deseos. Es aún más recta que su hermano, el del primer libro de la serie.
Un detalle de esta novela me recordó a mi novela La tabla esmeralda: que un personaje histórico real (y además rey) se enamore de una protagonista ficticia. En ambos casos, por distintas razones, este amor no puede consumarse.
The historical part is very well documented and explained. I liked best the first twelve chapters, plus a number of later ones, those more faithful to history, where there is no intervention of magicians or demons (such as Lilith). When they appear, the historical part is diluted and we pass into the realm of fantasy. I wonder about the Watchers, who are supposed to do good and protect the people, but usually fail. In fact, I think the role of the Watchers was actually fulfilled by religious orders such as the Knight Hospitaller of Saint John of Jerusalem or, to some extent, the Knights Templar.
The main character in this novel is a saint, always putting her mission and principles before her own interests and wishes. She is even more upright than her brother, in the first book of the series.
A detail in this novel reminded me of my own The Emerald Tablet: that a real historic character (and a king) is supposed to have fallen in love with a fictional girl protagonist. In both cases, for different reasons, this love cannot be consummated.
ESPAÑOL: Segunda entrega de la serie sobre los Vigilantes, que combina novela histórica con fantasía. En este libro, la protagonista es Marta Bessarion, que ha sido lanzada más de medio milenio hacia el futuro, desde la invasión musulmana de Siria en 636, hasta el año 1180, durante los últimos años del Reino de Jerusalén, pocos años antes de la caída de la ciudad en manos de Saladino y de la Tercera Cruzada.
La parte histórica está muy bien documentada y es fiel a la realidad. Me gustaron mucho los doce primeros capítulos, además de otros posteriores, los más fieles a la historia, en los que no intervienen magos o demonios (como Lilith). Cuando aparecen, la parte histórica se diluye y nos trasladamos al reino de la fantasía. También me sorprenden los Vigilantes, que se supone deben hacer buenas obras y proteger al pueblo, pero que usualmente fracasan. De hecho, pienso que el papel de los Vigilantes lo realizaron las órdenes religiosas, como los caballeros hospitalarios de San Juan de Jerusalén y, hasta cierto punto, los Templarios.
La protagonista de esta novela es una santa, que siempre antepone su misión y sus principios a sus intereses y sus deseos. Es aún más recta que su hermano, el del primer libro de la serie.
Un detalle de esta novela me recordó a mi novela La tabla esmeralda: que un personaje histórico real (y además rey) se enamore de una protagonista ficticia. En ambos casos, por distintas razones, este amor no puede consumarse.
August 25, 2020
Starting to think these books have ruined me for all other medieval fiction.
(not that I've read a lot, it's just that the medieval setting usually seems to be used as only the thinnest of veneers to prop up a historically inaccurate plot...but maybe I've just only been exposed to particularly bad ones)
While I enjoyed A Wind From the Wilderness, I liked The Lady of Kingdoms even more. A large part of this probably had to with Marta, a character for whom I would most definitely sacrifice myself should the need arise. However, I also found myself invested in the supporting characters, too- especially Baldwin.
But this book also made me think about my own life, and how I live it. Am I willing to bend my own morals for the sake of pragmatism or some vague, "greater good?" Are those greater goods ultimately worth it if it means we betray the "smaller" goods in between?
(not that I've read a lot, it's just that the medieval setting usually seems to be used as only the thinnest of veneers to prop up a historically inaccurate plot...but maybe I've just only been exposed to particularly bad ones)
While I enjoyed A Wind From the Wilderness, I liked The Lady of Kingdoms even more. A large part of this probably had to with Marta, a character for whom I would most definitely sacrifice myself should the need arise. However, I also found myself invested in the supporting characters, too- especially Baldwin.
But this book also made me think about my own life, and how I live it. Am I willing to bend my own morals for the sake of pragmatism or some vague, "greater good?" Are those greater goods ultimately worth it if it means we betray the "smaller" goods in between?
June 19, 2020
The second volume of the Watchers of the Outremer series is as fast paced as the first volume, keeping you turning pages to see what will happen next, because you don't expect what is going to happen!
The first novel happened during the first crusade, so we saw quite a lot of fighting. In this one, we are in the Kingdom of Jerusalem during the reign of the Leper King. There is some fighting too, but above all political intrigue. With the exception of the added fantasy elements and the main character (Marta Bessarion) and her closest friends, the book is eminently historical, superbly researched and vividly written.
I enjoyed this volume more:
First, I love Marta. She is a more resourceful protagonist than Lukas. She wins her friends quickly because she cares. Her conversations with Baldwin were gold, and the climax with the King... I did not expect it at all, but it fits so well. It also shows that the healing God wants to send may not be at all the one we are hoping for (I am talking from the point of view of the characters, I was not expecting the author to change history in his case).
Secondly, the sorcerer and demons in the first volume were so seemingly invincible, that Lukas' story is much darker. They are still here, but there is hope now.
Miles needs somebody to bang his head! But the story would not be as good without his backs and forths.
I am looking forward to the next adventure of the Bessarion family!
The first novel happened during the first crusade, so we saw quite a lot of fighting. In this one, we are in the Kingdom of Jerusalem during the reign of the Leper King. There is some fighting too, but above all political intrigue. With the exception of the added fantasy elements and the main character (Marta Bessarion) and her closest friends, the book is eminently historical, superbly researched and vividly written.
I enjoyed this volume more:
First, I love Marta. She is a more resourceful protagonist than Lukas. She wins her friends quickly because she cares. Her conversations with Baldwin were gold, and the climax with the King... I did not expect it at all, but it fits so well. It also shows that the healing God wants to send may not be at all the one we are hoping for (I am talking from the point of view of the characters, I was not expecting the author to change history in his case).
Secondly, the sorcerer and demons in the first volume were so seemingly invincible, that Lukas' story is much darker. They are still here, but there is hope now.
Miles needs somebody to bang his head! But the story would not be as good without his backs and forths.
I am looking forward to the next adventure of the Bessarion family!
Read
December 7, 2019The Lady of Kingdoms swept me off my feet into a world brimming with life and love, death and betrayal, angels and demons - all set to the gorgeously detailed backdrop of history. As in the preceding book, A Wind from the Wilderness, Suzannah Rowntree has done her research. Every page is dripping with rich detail, whether about textiles, the layers of armour a knight wears, political intrigues, or gruesome wounds and their treatments, it's evident that she has poured her love for history into this story.
I find it hard to put into words just how much I relished every word of this book. It's the kind of story that has you madly turning pages to find what happens next, that you can't stop thinking about when you have to put it down to work/eat/do life. It delights, and thrills, and ravages your heart with all its beautifully imperfect characters. Every action, every decision, whether it is carried out for the right or wrong reasons, has a consequence. The layers of politics and personal stakes are crafted with precision, and when they collide... wonderful, heartbreaking, real consequences.
I fell in love with Marta, our recklessly righteous heroine, and her knightly deeds (because lady knights are awesome!) What's even more wonderful about her is that her character is so much deeper than that. She is also shy, creative, a skilled weaver. Her heart is honest and open, she weeps even for those who would do her harm.
Persi, the shrewd businesswoman that Marta is not. A brave, steadfast friend, skilled with both her hands and her words. Quick to laugh, even though she has endured suffering and hardship.
Miles, the bastard knight, striving for greatness, for recognition. He wants to make a name for himself, so much that his heart aches to be noticed, to be renowned. His ambition clouds his judgement and betrays his good heart.
Baldwin, debilitated by his disease since he was a boy - still so young, at eighteen - with the weight of the kingdom on his shoulders. The moments when his true nature shines through the pain are truly beautiful. His interactions with Marta are often thought-provoking - I love the way they challenge each other!
I could go on and on and on about this book, but I'll leave it here with you - go forth and read this incredibly crafted story. You will not be disappointed.
I find it hard to put into words just how much I relished every word of this book. It's the kind of story that has you madly turning pages to find what happens next, that you can't stop thinking about when you have to put it down to work/eat/do life. It delights, and thrills, and ravages your heart with all its beautifully imperfect characters. Every action, every decision, whether it is carried out for the right or wrong reasons, has a consequence. The layers of politics and personal stakes are crafted with precision, and when they collide... wonderful, heartbreaking, real consequences.
I fell in love with Marta, our recklessly righteous heroine, and her knightly deeds (because lady knights are awesome!) What's even more wonderful about her is that her character is so much deeper than that. She is also shy, creative, a skilled weaver. Her heart is honest and open, she weeps even for those who would do her harm.
Persi, the shrewd businesswoman that Marta is not. A brave, steadfast friend, skilled with both her hands and her words. Quick to laugh, even though she has endured suffering and hardship.
Miles, the bastard knight, striving for greatness, for recognition. He wants to make a name for himself, so much that his heart aches to be noticed, to be renowned. His ambition clouds his judgement and betrays his good heart.
Baldwin, debilitated by his disease since he was a boy - still so young, at eighteen - with the weight of the kingdom on his shoulders. The moments when his true nature shines through the pain are truly beautiful. His interactions with Marta are often thought-provoking - I love the way they challenge each other!
I could go on and on and on about this book, but I'll leave it here with you - go forth and read this incredibly crafted story. You will not be disappointed.
October 27, 2019
IN LOVE WITH THESE COVERS
October 30, 2020
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, like all of Suzannah Rowntree's books. It is very well written and researched. This was a very hard book to put down. Now I am anxiously awaiting the third book!
January 4, 2020
Engaging and gripping
Really couldn’t put this one down. Characters so well crafted, story intriguing and compelling. Though I’m interested in history, I often find it dry. But I forgot this was even historical; all I knew was that I was in that world and it was enthralling. Can’t wait for the next one! (Soon??)
Really couldn’t put this one down. Characters so well crafted, story intriguing and compelling. Though I’m interested in history, I often find it dry. But I forgot this was even historical; all I knew was that I was in that world and it was enthralling. Can’t wait for the next one! (Soon??)
November 26, 2019
It's not a good choice, but none of our choices are good ones.I read book one and I was afraid this would be the theme of the entire series. I read book two and now I have hope that it's not.
Let me make something clear: I don't see things in terms of black and white. For me there are always a thousand unexplored options in between. That doesn't mean I don't believe in right and wrong, but it does mean I believe the line between the two is often difficult to discern. Difficult, but not impossible with God's wisdom. The overwhelming darkness in A Wind from the Wilderness depressed me with it's pronounced force of evil, but no obvious force of good. The characters were hopeless and the ending was hopeless. I worried that this book would carry on the theme, and to an extent it does. Moral ambiguity is still going on, but a glimmer of light appears this time in the form of Marta.
Marta is a young woman who has perfected the art of rooftop chase scenes. She wields a magical spear while trying to survive without her family (though I'm not too confident that her family would have been much help in the survival department). She passes the time by weaving beautiful cloths, advising the king, and fighting demons. Consciences are a novelty in this book, and Marta is one of the few who has one. She would be my favorite character, but I never feel like I got to know her very well. I can't put my finger on what's missing, but somehow she lacks individuality. My mind doesn't readily distinguish between her and Blanche from Pendragon's Heir (same author).
The king Marta advises is the most likeable character in the book and I fear that isn't a good thing. He's also original and unique where many of the others lack that same something Marta lacks.
Sybilla, the king's sister, is complex and interesting. She can't decide which side she's on, but eventually she finds out who she's been fighting for all along.
Those are only three of my favorites in a large cast of characters!
The historical details in this book are meticulously researched, as usual. An author's note details historical inaccuracies. I wish certain parts would forget that they're supposed to be factual. Sometimes the facts of history are overly gloomy! Really, I'm beginning to think that Suzannah Rowntree is completely heartless when it comes to dealing with her characters. (This might sound disgruntled, but I'm actually trying to hide my admiration at her research skills.)
Plot is another strong point. It's well thought out and full of suspense, heartache, joy, and grief. The story ends on a fairly hopeful note. Maybe I shouldn't say "ends" because the story is actually far from over. I can't wait for the next installment! Which basically means I can't wait to read about the misfortunes of another Bessarion. Am I as heartless as Suzannah Rowntree?
*I received a free advance review copy from the author. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.*
May 13, 2020
The Lady of Kingdoms took a while to pull me in, but once it did, I could hardly put it down! A fascinating blend of history and fantasy with a kick-butt heroine like no other, this story is epic in proportion, yet viewed mainly through the eyes of the main character.
Intrigue, drama, battle scenes, amazing escapes, heroic actions, tragic romance, betrayal, and genuine friendship and love--this story has it all!
My favorites? Persi, Baldwin, and Balian. And Marta, of course. I may even have cried a little during a climactic scene . . . And Sybilla, Miles, and other characters add drama and depth to the story.
I don't often read epic novels, but I will be snatching up the sequel to this one, for sure!
Intrigue, drama, battle scenes, amazing escapes, heroic actions, tragic romance, betrayal, and genuine friendship and love--this story has it all!
My favorites? Persi, Baldwin, and Balian. And Marta, of course. I may even have cried a little during a climactic scene . . . And Sybilla, Miles, and other characters add drama and depth to the story.
I don't often read epic novels, but I will be snatching up the sequel to this one, for sure!
December 2, 2019
Lady of Kingdoms
This historical fantasy gave me life. It was a breath of fresh air at a time when I was trying to find that book that was outside of the box. We readers live to find treasures like this. The Lady of Kingdoms has an interesting plot, interesting characters, and lots of intrigue. This book had me wondering why I hadn't heard of this author before and it also encouraged me to purchase two other books by Rowntree.
This historical fantasy gave me life. It was a breath of fresh air at a time when I was trying to find that book that was outside of the box. We readers live to find treasures like this. The Lady of Kingdoms has an interesting plot, interesting characters, and lots of intrigue. This book had me wondering why I hadn't heard of this author before and it also encouraged me to purchase two other books by Rowntree.
April 2, 2025
seraphs, weavers of cloth, weapons of legend, Baldwin the Leper King, MARTA FLIPPING BESSARION
i really like political intrigue, right up until i really don’t. this almost crossed that line for me but retrieved itself. probably because it is such a bright story, which definitely has something to do with the protagonist. (also the acknowledgment that it’s not the strength of evil, but rather the cowardice of those in the middle, that delays and weakens the triumph of good) I would DIE for Marta Bessarion, your honor. I also love Lord Balian and Maria Comnena, and I really hope they come back in future instalments!
so far this series is literally everything i’ve ever wanted from historical fantasy AND Christian fiction, all in one package. it’s wild
i really like political intrigue, right up until i really don’t. this almost crossed that line for me but retrieved itself. probably because it is such a bright story, which definitely has something to do with the protagonist. (also the acknowledgment that it’s not the strength of evil, but rather the cowardice of those in the middle, that delays and weakens the triumph of good) I would DIE for Marta Bessarion, your honor. I also love Lord Balian and Maria Comnena, and I really hope they come back in future instalments!
so far this series is literally everything i’ve ever wanted from historical fantasy AND Christian fiction, all in one package. it’s wild
August 24, 2021
Actual rating 4.5
Excellent prose and character work, with that character work being tightly interwoven into the story’s narrative themes, which are in turn tightly interwoven into the narrative plot. The Lady of Kingdoms also happens to be one of those rare, superbly paced books that intermingles action scenes, intrigue scenes, and character interaction scenes with none feeling rushed, taking too long or ever being less than entertaining, and without any scene ever feeling like fluff or filler.
Excellent prose and character work, with that character work being tightly interwoven into the story’s narrative themes, which are in turn tightly interwoven into the narrative plot. The Lady of Kingdoms also happens to be one of those rare, superbly paced books that intermingles action scenes, intrigue scenes, and character interaction scenes with none feeling rushed, taking too long or ever being less than entertaining, and without any scene ever feeling like fluff or filler.
May 24, 2021
Oh god Marta is such a boring character. Like the last book, the main story-line isn't really the good part of the book, but unfortunately the Crusades story-line in this book isn't all that interesting either. It really feels like the attempt to shoehorn the fantasy elements into this book takes away a lot of what would normally be some interesting political machinations. But reducing it all to "the evils spirits are making them do it" drains it of all the drama. Ah well. I'll finish the series but . . .
June 18, 2021
*I was assigned this book for SPFBO7*
The Lady of Kingdoms, although marked as #2 in a series, can be read as a standalone. It's part of the Watchers of Outremer series, and A Wind in the Wilderness, the first book, made it to the finalists of SPFBO6.
The Lady of Kingdoms primarily follows the story of Marta Bassarion, a Syrian girl who, from the beginning pages of the book, faces many unwanted circumstances. In a series of events, she is transported from the AD 600s to the 1100s, without her family, entirely alone. Things, of course, have drastically changed in the years she missed. She finds herself unable to speak the language of those in Jerusalem and the surrounding area, and is forced into servitude weaving. She is quite good at it, and is bought by the prestor of the Watchers, a group of people committed to doing good and righting wrongs. This Watcher has an artifact she recognizes as her father's, something called the Brassarion Lance, which is a magical spear that makes its holder unstoppable in battle.
Another character this book follows is Sybilla, sister of the king, with ambitions for the throne. She marries a warrior, hoping that between his might and her intelligence, they can make an unstoppable bid to be named the king's appointee for the throne when he dies. The king, Baldwin, is also called the Leper King. He's had leprosy since he was a boy, and I really enjoyed his character. He struggles between doing what is right, and what is necessary, whereas Sybilla has no qualms to do whatever is necessary to get what she wants. She is, in fact, quite ruthless. She manipulates others for her own ends.
Miles of Plancy is a squire to the prestor, and Marta and he strike up a friendship when she is brought into the Ibelin family. Marta falls for him, and he for her, but Miles is also ambitious. A bastard, he has no inheritance, so he must forge for himself a name in order to obtain a fief. He irked me, to be honest. Marta, who is sweet tempered and will stand up for what's right no matter what, is often passed over by his ambition. I wanted to wring his neck.
There is magic in this book, mostly centered around demons and Fiery Ones - angels, to be exact. Marta is protected by the angels, and can often escape harrowing situations by the righteousness of her soul. She is "kissed" by a Fiery One on her forehead, and can sense evil intentions when the scar from the kiss burns. It was a fascinating addition to the book.
One aspect I really enjoyed was the politics. Although this is an alternative history story with some splashes of magic thrown in, the politics seemed quite real, with infighting, religious factions, treason, war, and believable motives by all those involved. Another part I really enjoyed was the friendship between Marta and King Baldwin. Marta has a lot of compassion for him, and he clearly is drawn to her. Their friendship was a bright spot in an otherwise dark book filled with people who were out for their own ends. And the King being disabled was done quite well.
Marta is a very strong main character. In fact, all of the characters in this book are good, even the ones you're supposed to hate. But Marta in particular is strong in her convictions, always wanting to do whats right (even if it gets her in trouble), and always willing to stand up for her friends.
There are a couple of complaints I have, but they aren't too strong. One thing is the plot - it meanders a bit, with several inciting events that aren't necessarily cohesive. There's a lot of plot lines going on, and although they were easy to follow, I feel like it could have been a bit tighter. Perhaps it makes more sense in the larger context of the series? But since I haven't read A Wind in the Wilderness, it does read as a bit haphazard. Second, I was a bit confused by the climax of the book. So as to not throw in any spoilers, I'll just leave it at this: there is a certain scene between Marta and Baldwin that didn't seem to fit in with the book as a whole.
Otherwise, this is an enjoyable read. Fans of good politics, intriguing characters, historical fantasy, medieval fantasy, and a healthy dose of magic are sure to enjoy it.
*This review originally published on Booknest.eu*
The Lady of Kingdoms, although marked as #2 in a series, can be read as a standalone. It's part of the Watchers of Outremer series, and A Wind in the Wilderness, the first book, made it to the finalists of SPFBO6.
The Lady of Kingdoms primarily follows the story of Marta Bassarion, a Syrian girl who, from the beginning pages of the book, faces many unwanted circumstances. In a series of events, she is transported from the AD 600s to the 1100s, without her family, entirely alone. Things, of course, have drastically changed in the years she missed. She finds herself unable to speak the language of those in Jerusalem and the surrounding area, and is forced into servitude weaving. She is quite good at it, and is bought by the prestor of the Watchers, a group of people committed to doing good and righting wrongs. This Watcher has an artifact she recognizes as her father's, something called the Brassarion Lance, which is a magical spear that makes its holder unstoppable in battle.
Another character this book follows is Sybilla, sister of the king, with ambitions for the throne. She marries a warrior, hoping that between his might and her intelligence, they can make an unstoppable bid to be named the king's appointee for the throne when he dies. The king, Baldwin, is also called the Leper King. He's had leprosy since he was a boy, and I really enjoyed his character. He struggles between doing what is right, and what is necessary, whereas Sybilla has no qualms to do whatever is necessary to get what she wants. She is, in fact, quite ruthless. She manipulates others for her own ends.
Miles of Plancy is a squire to the prestor, and Marta and he strike up a friendship when she is brought into the Ibelin family. Marta falls for him, and he for her, but Miles is also ambitious. A bastard, he has no inheritance, so he must forge for himself a name in order to obtain a fief. He irked me, to be honest. Marta, who is sweet tempered and will stand up for what's right no matter what, is often passed over by his ambition. I wanted to wring his neck.
There is magic in this book, mostly centered around demons and Fiery Ones - angels, to be exact. Marta is protected by the angels, and can often escape harrowing situations by the righteousness of her soul. She is "kissed" by a Fiery One on her forehead, and can sense evil intentions when the scar from the kiss burns. It was a fascinating addition to the book.
One aspect I really enjoyed was the politics. Although this is an alternative history story with some splashes of magic thrown in, the politics seemed quite real, with infighting, religious factions, treason, war, and believable motives by all those involved. Another part I really enjoyed was the friendship between Marta and King Baldwin. Marta has a lot of compassion for him, and he clearly is drawn to her. Their friendship was a bright spot in an otherwise dark book filled with people who were out for their own ends. And the King being disabled was done quite well.
Marta is a very strong main character. In fact, all of the characters in this book are good, even the ones you're supposed to hate. But Marta in particular is strong in her convictions, always wanting to do whats right (even if it gets her in trouble), and always willing to stand up for her friends.
There are a couple of complaints I have, but they aren't too strong. One thing is the plot - it meanders a bit, with several inciting events that aren't necessarily cohesive. There's a lot of plot lines going on, and although they were easy to follow, I feel like it could have been a bit tighter. Perhaps it makes more sense in the larger context of the series? But since I haven't read A Wind in the Wilderness, it does read as a bit haphazard. Second, I was a bit confused by the climax of the book. So as to not throw in any spoilers, I'll just leave it at this: there is a certain scene between Marta and Baldwin that didn't seem to fit in with the book as a whole.
Otherwise, this is an enjoyable read. Fans of good politics, intriguing characters, historical fantasy, medieval fantasy, and a healthy dose of magic are sure to enjoy it.
*This review originally published on Booknest.eu*
November 22, 2019
The Watchers of Outremer series continues when teenage Marta Bessarion is catapulted through time from the 7th to the late 12th century.
She lands (quite literally) in the Holy Land just before the 3rd Crusade. The rest of the novel takes the reader on an exciting, thrilling- and sometimes breathtaking right through the Crusader states in the 1180s.
The reader will be immersed in the complex politics of the period, and meet some famous historical figures along the way, including Balian d'Ibelin, Baldwin IV 'The Leper King' of Jerusalem, and his flamboyant sister Sybilla. They stand alongside some fascinating Fictional characters, including a love interest for Marta and Persi, a young woman of business who represents the oft forgotten Christian Kingdoms of Medieval Africa.
Of course, there are some stops along the way to take in the culture and customs of the period.
It may come as a surprise for some to learn that 12th century Jerusalem under Crusader rule was prosperous, tolerant and cultured. They rebuilt cities, gardens, churches and places of worship. The depopulated and ruined city Martha knew is replaced with a beautiful metropolis, wealthy and bustling with different cultures.
The events of the period makes for a plot seething with undercurrents of political intrigue and war . Which leads the character into many dangerous and exciting adventures and escapes as the protagonists are are caught up in battles, sieges, and swept up in the time of political intrigue, whilst she struggling to stay determine what is right and just.
The atmosphere of conflict and tension goes deeper with the fantasy elements of a Magic spear said to make the bearer invincible, an evil sorcerer in Saladin's camp and shape-shifting demon using her influence to corrupt some of the most powerful people in the Kingdom. Yet all of these just -work- in the story, which although meticulously researched wears it very well.
I only had a couple of complaints. I related to Marta only in part, and some other characters more. I think part of if was that she came over as a little too perfect, and at times quite naive to what those who ruled had to do to secure the Kingdom.
There also seemed to be an element of fatalism in the idea that only if everything was done in a certain way would the Kingdom be saved. I understand the idea of following the path of righteousness, but at times I felt this was little more than Marta's rigid ideas and her belief that everything would be OK if people just listened to her.
Almost as if as if everything was foreordained, but not allowing for free will or personal choice.
It puts me in mind of what one of the characters says (roughly paraphrasing) that real life is not like the Courtly Romances, "where the virtuous always end up happy and the wicked always die"'.
There were also a couple of places where the story did not feel complete and I wanted to see more of the characters, but that was a deliberate choice to make room for a sequel (or two).
I found some of the action scene a little hard to follow in a couple of places, but this did not detract from the story.
It was well researched and excellently written story, well recommended for lovers of Historical Fiction and Fantasy with strong female leads.
Finally, isn't the cover just gorgeous? The book releases on the 27th of this month. Preorder your copy from all e-book retailers.
I agreed to be an Early Reader for this title and was sent an ARC by the author. This did not influence my review and all opinions expressed are my own.
She lands (quite literally) in the Holy Land just before the 3rd Crusade. The rest of the novel takes the reader on an exciting, thrilling- and sometimes breathtaking right through the Crusader states in the 1180s.
The reader will be immersed in the complex politics of the period, and meet some famous historical figures along the way, including Balian d'Ibelin, Baldwin IV 'The Leper King' of Jerusalem, and his flamboyant sister Sybilla. They stand alongside some fascinating Fictional characters, including a love interest for Marta and Persi, a young woman of business who represents the oft forgotten Christian Kingdoms of Medieval Africa.
Of course, there are some stops along the way to take in the culture and customs of the period.
It may come as a surprise for some to learn that 12th century Jerusalem under Crusader rule was prosperous, tolerant and cultured. They rebuilt cities, gardens, churches and places of worship. The depopulated and ruined city Martha knew is replaced with a beautiful metropolis, wealthy and bustling with different cultures.
The events of the period makes for a plot seething with undercurrents of political intrigue and war . Which leads the character into many dangerous and exciting adventures and escapes as the protagonists are are caught up in battles, sieges, and swept up in the time of political intrigue, whilst she struggling to stay determine what is right and just.
The atmosphere of conflict and tension goes deeper with the fantasy elements of a Magic spear said to make the bearer invincible, an evil sorcerer in Saladin's camp and shape-shifting demon using her influence to corrupt some of the most powerful people in the Kingdom. Yet all of these just -work- in the story, which although meticulously researched wears it very well.
I only had a couple of complaints. I related to Marta only in part, and some other characters more. I think part of if was that she came over as a little too perfect, and at times quite naive to what those who ruled had to do to secure the Kingdom.
There also seemed to be an element of fatalism in the idea that only if everything was done in a certain way would the Kingdom be saved. I understand the idea of following the path of righteousness, but at times I felt this was little more than Marta's rigid ideas and her belief that everything would be OK if people just listened to her.
Almost as if as if everything was foreordained, but not allowing for free will or personal choice.
It puts me in mind of what one of the characters says (roughly paraphrasing) that real life is not like the Courtly Romances, "where the virtuous always end up happy and the wicked always die"'.
There were also a couple of places where the story did not feel complete and I wanted to see more of the characters, but that was a deliberate choice to make room for a sequel (or two).
I found some of the action scene a little hard to follow in a couple of places, but this did not detract from the story.
It was well researched and excellently written story, well recommended for lovers of Historical Fiction and Fantasy with strong female leads.
Finally, isn't the cover just gorgeous? The book releases on the 27th of this month. Preorder your copy from all e-book retailers.
I agreed to be an Early Reader for this title and was sent an ARC by the author. This did not influence my review and all opinions expressed are my own.
July 24, 2020
This book gave me so much of what I didn't even know I wanted, and I loved every page. The deeper look into Khalil, the , the fighting, the owner-of-my-heart (Marta), the vivid and horrifying descriptions of demons, of scheming court politics and romance and more.
First off, that historical research! *fans self* Rowntree never beats you over the head with the details, but instead naturally submerges you in it. You don't think you're sitting through a lecture, you think, "oh, yeah, I know this world; I could totally live in it". Also, the Jerusalem depicted in this book is one I thoroughly wish I could visit, so I'll jot that down should I ever get a time-traveling adventure of my own.
In the last book, I fell in love with Lukas. I love Marta even more. (Sorry, Lukas.) Her determination to beat the odds, to do what's right over what's conventional, to demand better from the world and herself, all of that and more are reasons I love her.
For those of you who are intrigued by Khalil and the cabal of demons, this book expands on them, too. I so desperately want to know what Lilith & Co. are up to, why, and how they remain so confident at every turn, and while this book shined more light on things, it gave me a slew of added questions. But, given that this is a multi-book series, that only makes sense!
Rowntree's prose has somehow gotten even more beautiful, and she handles flashbacks/flash-forwards with precision. I've read too many books wherein I didn't know what was happening when, but that never occurred here.
I wanted to add this point as well, because some people might interpret the Watchers of Outremer series as being exclusively a Christian fantasy. As a non-religious person myself, and as someone who has a distaste for anything preachy, I love this book. (And all of the other books in the series.) Rowntree is respectful of all faiths, there's no preaching or proselytizing, no condemnations of anyone's belief system, etc. During this time, religion was such so integral to the fabric of society that it can't not be mentioned. Yes, the characters are religious. The governments are strongly religious. This is entirely accurate of the time. My personal take is that the story is more of an epic struggle of good vs. evil, sans overt religious coding. Even if, like me, you are not religious, trust me, read this book. You will be glad you did.
Also, because I'd be remiss not to mention it: can we PLEASE talk about that COVER ART? 😍😍😍
First off, that historical research! *fans self* Rowntree never beats you over the head with the details, but instead naturally submerges you in it. You don't think you're sitting through a lecture, you think, "oh, yeah, I know this world; I could totally live in it". Also, the Jerusalem depicted in this book is one I thoroughly wish I could visit, so I'll jot that down should I ever get a time-traveling adventure of my own.
In the last book, I fell in love with Lukas. I love Marta even more. (Sorry, Lukas.) Her determination to beat the odds, to do what's right over what's conventional, to demand better from the world and herself, all of that and more are reasons I love her.
For those of you who are intrigued by Khalil and the cabal of demons, this book expands on them, too. I so desperately want to know what Lilith & Co. are up to, why, and how they remain so confident at every turn, and while this book shined more light on things, it gave me a slew of added questions. But, given that this is a multi-book series, that only makes sense!
Rowntree's prose has somehow gotten even more beautiful, and she handles flashbacks/flash-forwards with precision. I've read too many books wherein I didn't know what was happening when, but that never occurred here.
I wanted to add this point as well, because some people might interpret the Watchers of Outremer series as being exclusively a Christian fantasy. As a non-religious person myself, and as someone who has a distaste for anything preachy, I love this book. (And all of the other books in the series.) Rowntree is respectful of all faiths, there's no preaching or proselytizing, no condemnations of anyone's belief system, etc. During this time, religion was such so integral to the fabric of society that it can't not be mentioned. Yes, the characters are religious. The governments are strongly religious. This is entirely accurate of the time. My personal take is that the story is more of an epic struggle of good vs. evil, sans overt religious coding. Even if, like me, you are not religious, trust me, read this book. You will be glad you did.
Also, because I'd be remiss not to mention it: can we PLEASE talk about that COVER ART? 😍😍😍
April 14, 2020
The Lady of Kingdoms:
Are you looking for an exciting adventure that provides an in-depth look at the Christian realms of the Holy Land during the 12th century? Well then, this is probably the book for you!
The Lady of Kingdoms contains just enough of a recap to orientate a reader, whether they are coming from the previous book in the series, or just starting straight in. The story whirls like a sandstorm through the cool palaces of Jerusalem and to the hot wastes of Arabian desserts. It weaves the adventures of Marta Bessarion like a tapestry alongside figures such as the Leper King Baldwin IV, Lady Sibylla, Balian of Ibelin, and many other characters from the pages of Crusader history.
This book was a gripping read, seizing my interest and ruining my sleep schedule until I finished! However, I do have several criticisms.
I found the pace somewhat cramped. It seemed that there was too much movement and too many events packed into the story. One upside of this reflection is to point out that it clearly shows the wealth of historical events and settings that the book covers! And I should stress that this book has clearly been well-researched and the presentation of all the historical characters is very well done. But in following them, I found the story suffered slightly from a sense of rapidity that didn’t let me get to know the main characters, outside from how they conducted themselves in the midst of crisis.
I must further confess that I didn’t fall for the main heroine, Marta. I found her somewhat lacking in flaws as a character, especially when compared to all the other people around her, who are mostly depicted as being deeply flawed. This made it rather hard to relate to Marta; whereas everyone else had obvious problems that provided heaps of potential for them to grow from, Marta’s conflict in the story seemed limited to finding herself in trouble, rather than finding trouble inside herself. Nevertheless, she is a fun character to follow as she darts from one place to the next, daring both death and danger.
The supernatural elements of this series, introduced in the first book (A Wind from the Wilderness) set a high bar! My thoughts on how this aspect was continued in The Lady of Kingdoms are mixed. Some of it was absolutely splendid, being original and evocatively portrayed. Some though, I found falling a bit flat. Definitely an overall good presentation in this area, however, and well woven into the narrative.
To sum up, a gripping read, with many excellent elements.
Are you looking for an exciting adventure that provides an in-depth look at the Christian realms of the Holy Land during the 12th century? Well then, this is probably the book for you!
The Lady of Kingdoms contains just enough of a recap to orientate a reader, whether they are coming from the previous book in the series, or just starting straight in. The story whirls like a sandstorm through the cool palaces of Jerusalem and to the hot wastes of Arabian desserts. It weaves the adventures of Marta Bessarion like a tapestry alongside figures such as the Leper King Baldwin IV, Lady Sibylla, Balian of Ibelin, and many other characters from the pages of Crusader history.
This book was a gripping read, seizing my interest and ruining my sleep schedule until I finished! However, I do have several criticisms.
I found the pace somewhat cramped. It seemed that there was too much movement and too many events packed into the story. One upside of this reflection is to point out that it clearly shows the wealth of historical events and settings that the book covers! And I should stress that this book has clearly been well-researched and the presentation of all the historical characters is very well done. But in following them, I found the story suffered slightly from a sense of rapidity that didn’t let me get to know the main characters, outside from how they conducted themselves in the midst of crisis.
I must further confess that I didn’t fall for the main heroine, Marta. I found her somewhat lacking in flaws as a character, especially when compared to all the other people around her, who are mostly depicted as being deeply flawed. This made it rather hard to relate to Marta; whereas everyone else had obvious problems that provided heaps of potential for them to grow from, Marta’s conflict in the story seemed limited to finding herself in trouble, rather than finding trouble inside herself. Nevertheless, she is a fun character to follow as she darts from one place to the next, daring both death and danger.
The supernatural elements of this series, introduced in the first book (A Wind from the Wilderness) set a high bar! My thoughts on how this aspect was continued in The Lady of Kingdoms are mixed. Some of it was absolutely splendid, being original and evocatively portrayed. Some though, I found falling a bit flat. Definitely an overall good presentation in this area, however, and well woven into the narrative.
To sum up, a gripping read, with many excellent elements.
December 14, 2019
This was everything I was expecting, with some truly good and clever twists. Marta and her spear are the best. Really. I want to keep Marta and squish her. She's fierce and tiny, and has a heart as big as the world. On the other hand, you have Sibylla, who I am probably supposed to hate but I don't. She's resourceful, although selfish, and clever. She's one of those villains that chills you, and the reader side of me winces while the writer side of me was fascinated. Baldwin's story, however, was the second most powerful, and I think he's one of the most relatable characters. Most of the book I pitied him, like Marta, but towards the end I realized that I didn't really pity him, he was trapped inside himself by his own choice, denying truth.
I highly recommend this warm and fierce tale of girl-power. It's a fast read because it moves along well and kept me interested from all angles. I'm one of those people who likes to skip the villains in stories and I didn't in this one.
And finally, I need this on my shelf because the cover is amazing and bright and gorgeous even though that has nothing to do with the review, this book deserves its cover. So curl up with orange chocolates and tea, and enjoy this middle-eastern fantasy.
I highly recommend this warm and fierce tale of girl-power. It's a fast read because it moves along well and kept me interested from all angles. I'm one of those people who likes to skip the villains in stories and I didn't in this one.
And finally, I need this on my shelf because the cover is amazing and bright and gorgeous even though that has nothing to do with the review, this book deserves its cover. So curl up with orange chocolates and tea, and enjoy this middle-eastern fantasy.
November 30, 2019
This novel is part of the continuing story of the Christian Bessarion family, ripped apart in time by a wicked spell. It follows the teenage daughter, who finds herself in Jerusalem at the time of Baldwin IV, the Leper King.
The Lady of Kingdoms is a beautifully devised historical tale dealing principally with subtle political manipulations, often involving marriages as a key factor in alliances, but beyond the merely human level there are also the schemes of the demonic Lilith who watches for weakness and is poised to devour. The fantasy is understated but it serves to make the spiritual struggle particularly vivid. Women have significant roles, including Sybilla, the ambitious sister of the King of Jerusalem, and Marta Bessarion, who wields the Sacred Lance. The novel is fascinating and thought-provoking.
The Lady of Kingdoms is a beautifully devised historical tale dealing principally with subtle political manipulations, often involving marriages as a key factor in alliances, but beyond the merely human level there are also the schemes of the demonic Lilith who watches for weakness and is poised to devour. The fantasy is understated but it serves to make the spiritual struggle particularly vivid. Women have significant roles, including Sybilla, the ambitious sister of the King of Jerusalem, and Marta Bessarion, who wields the Sacred Lance. The novel is fascinating and thought-provoking.
November 26, 2019
Excellent book! I lost myself daily following Marta's adventures. It was not just a story but a history lesson, my kind of book, where you learn stuff without realising it. I enjoyed the contrast between the Jerusalem of the Bessarions' time to that of Baldwin and the Ibelins: the mixture of religions and how they got along again contrasting to today. A love story that kept you dangling - will they, won't they? But I won't give the answer away. It had strong women characters: Marta, Persi, Maria, Sybilla, all different, all fascinating. The explanation at the end is helpful, telling of who was real, who was invented. I look forward to reading the next episode in the series!
Read
February 11, 2022The Lady of Kingdoms follows the political intrigues between siblings, one a king dying of leprosy and the other his older sister who would do anything to be queen, all the while trying to keep the barons from rebelling and attacking armies from taking their lands. If that wasn't enough, we have Marta, a young woman who will do anything to help save the kingdom that is being torn apart around her, well almost anything. She lives in heroic opposition to "the ends justify the means." Her courage in the face of imprisonment and death leads to many exciting scenes. I loved the historical rich details and the end notes. I enjoyed the first book of the series and loved this one even more.
December 1, 2021
Even better than book 1
I loved book 1, but this one went above and beyond. Marta is an exemplary character, striving to do right even as she second guesses herself and makes mistakes.
The rest of the cast are also excellent--nuanced and interesting. Baldwin is probably my favorite.
The world--the history and the story Rowntree has woven throughout that tapestry--is stunning. She did her research and she brought it all to life.
There were several moments that brought me up short. Lines and quotes that were so full of truth and beauty they demanded I stop to reread them.
I loved book 1, but this one went above and beyond. Marta is an exemplary character, striving to do right even as she second guesses herself and makes mistakes.
The rest of the cast are also excellent--nuanced and interesting. Baldwin is probably my favorite.
The world--the history and the story Rowntree has woven throughout that tapestry--is stunning. She did her research and she brought it all to life.
There were several moments that brought me up short. Lines and quotes that were so full of truth and beauty they demanded I stop to reread them.
April 16, 2020
I thought The Lady of Kingdoms was an amazing read. I really liked book #1 and I found Book #2 much more interesting. Marta Bessarion's story is mesmerizing, heroic and filled with Historical facts. The Crusades have many stories and I loved this one.
I give The Lady of Kingdoms 5 stars for its amazing read.
I would recommend this book to Historical Fiction Fans.
I give The Lady of Kingdoms 5 stars for its amazing read.
I would recommend this book to Historical Fiction Fans.
August 8, 2023
This was an interesting blend of history, folklore, and fantasy set during the Crusades period. I admired the main character, Marta Bessarion, as well as the author's attempt to make this story as close to historical records as she could. This is part of a series, and I am interested in reading the rest!
December 3, 2019
This was the first book by Rowntree that I have read, but it definitely won't be the last. The characters were well written and engaging. The historical setting came alive on the page. And the action had me racing through the chapters to a very satisfying ending.
January 18, 2020
Wow! What a great adventure story! Marta Bassarion makes Xena, Warrior Princes seem fairly boring in comparison. I hope my own daughter will grow to be as preux as Marta. I'm looking forward to the upcoming sequel, The House of Mourning.
March 25, 2020
I really loved this book. The characters, the setting, the action, just... wow.
I especially liked the whole concept of the seraphim looking like dragons.
This book is probably going to be one of my favorite reads of the year.
I especially liked the whole concept of the seraphim looking like dragons.
This book is probably going to be one of my favorite reads of the year.
July 31, 2021
Main character Marta is awesome. She handles all her challenges well, and I want to read how her story ends.
I was somewhat familiar with the history involved, but this book brings it to life. Plus I appreciated the Author's Note at the end telling what she added or changed to the history.
I was somewhat familiar with the history involved, but this book brings it to life. Plus I appreciated the Author's Note at the end telling what she added or changed to the history.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 34 reviews