Amy has invited her former high school sweetheart Chris and his fiancé Jake to dinner in honor of their recent engagement. Chris arrives first to warn Amy that Jake will be searching for signs that they still harbor feelings for each other… a notion Amy protests is ridiculous given their relationship ended twenty-five years ago when Chris acknowledged he was gay. Yet when they examine the evidence behind this accusation, they’re forced to admit the profound dissatisfaction they’ve had with all subsequent romantic partners and their futile attempts to replicate the profound connection they once shared with each other.