What do you think?
Rate this book
Left to Die
Lindy Greene’s life is perfect. Too perfect. But living as a missionary nurse, serving in a small hospital in China, soon brings the disaster she fearfully anticipates. All of her well-thought-out plans for the future disintegrate after pulling a fatally ill, disfigured, abandoned child from a pile of trash. She doesn’t even like babies.
Nathan Thomas can’t find balance. College suited him just fine until his cash ran out, forcing him to the Chinese mission field with his parents. The chaotic atmosphere in China does little to relax his agitated mind, and the pretty blonde nurse at the hospital does nothing to help him focus.
The Chinese mission field isn’t for the faint of heart. Nathan wonders how he can survive his remaining time there, while Lindy struggles to help everyone she can. With different ideals pulling them in separate directions, there is one thing drawing them together: a tiny, sickly, crippled orphan who relies on them to stay alive.
154 pages, Kindle Edition
First published January 1, 2017
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews
April 7, 2017
I picked this up with the intention of reading a few pages. You know, just to check it out and see if it was any good. I read the first third that night and finished it the next morning. I didn’t even have time to crow about it on Goodreads. In other words, it was good. ;) As soon as sweet Jia-Bo entered the story, you couldn’t pay me to quit reading. She was such a darling little fighter, and I cheered Lindy on as she worked her hardest to save her. (All the medical jargon was pretty cool, and the author did a good job of making it understandable.) But oh, the place she found Jia was horrible! And the orphanage scene… *cries* The message of God aligning our will with His is really important to me, and I loved the outcome. :D (And can we talk about how cute Nathan babysitting Jia was??!!! <3) Not recommended for younger readers because of thematic elements.
Best quote: Lindy nodded, a sigh escaping her lips. “I just needed a break from people.” “Oh, want me to leave?” She gave him a weak smile. “No. You don’t really count as people.”
Altogether, while this book was really cute and sweet, it was much more than that with some really knock-your-socks-off important themes. Definitely a new favorite. ;)
Best quote: Lindy nodded, a sigh escaping her lips. “I just needed a break from people.” “Oh, want me to leave?” She gave him a weak smile. “No. You don’t really count as people.”
Altogether, while this book was really cute and sweet, it was much more than that with some really knock-your-socks-off important themes. Definitely a new favorite. ;)
September 7, 2022
2022 Reread
Loved this story just as much as the first time I read it. Maybe more?
2017
I knew this was a shorter story, so wasn't expecting it to take me very long to read. I was pleasantly surprised to discover that it was longer than I had thought. I was pulled into the story right away and my heart cried over Jia, but especially over the other children in the orphanage Lindy visited. There is a bit of sweet guy and girl interest, but that's not the focus of the story and it was all done tastefully. One thing I appreciated about this book was the talk about God's ways and how we so often think we know His will, and when things change, we can't figure out why. It's not that God has changed His mind, but perhaps it's because we didn't understand in the first place. I would recommend this book to anyone interested in the plight of the unwanted children of China, or even anyone just wanting a good story to read.
Loved this story just as much as the first time I read it. Maybe more?
2017
I knew this was a shorter story, so wasn't expecting it to take me very long to read. I was pleasantly surprised to discover that it was longer than I had thought. I was pulled into the story right away and my heart cried over Jia, but especially over the other children in the orphanage Lindy visited. There is a bit of sweet guy and girl interest, but that's not the focus of the story and it was all done tastefully. One thing I appreciated about this book was the talk about God's ways and how we so often think we know His will, and when things change, we can't figure out why. It's not that God has changed His mind, but perhaps it's because we didn't understand in the first place. I would recommend this book to anyone interested in the plight of the unwanted children of China, or even anyone just wanting a good story to read.
June 17, 2017
4.5 stars
I had been wanting to read Ivy’s book for quite a while. My sisters had both read it before me an I had been eyeing it with longing every time I turned on my kindle. I finally got the chance in the last month and I am so thankful I read this little volume. It is probably the best novella I have read to date. It is not easy to create a story in such a short word count and make it satisfying to the readers. Ivy nailed it.
The characters were so sweet, but human and I related a lot with each of them for different reasons. This book was so impactful and I find it even more so because Miss Rose writes from experience. And that shines through.
Likes:
Um, lots of stuff.
~ Lindy of course. Her struggles were real to me and something I have struggled with in a minor way, so I totally related to that.
~I loved how easily the setting was captured. With so few words I felt myself in China, and I have no basis of knowledge for that. I could picture where everyone was and what was going on.
~The medical stuff. I am a huge medical buff. I have studied a lot in the field and found nearly all of Ivy’s facts to be correct to my knowledge. I just love medical detail y’all, call me weird.
~ The romance. It was so understated, but there and real and normal, and natural feeling! I have read a post by Ivy on how to write romance, and I must say, I very much appreciate her approach. So clean and wholesome.
Quibbles:
To be honest, I didn’t really have any? *shrugs* It is that good people! READ IT!
Overall:
Please, pretty please just read it. It will give you a new look and maybe open your eyes to something that is a very real and problematic issue in our society. Also, the moral that was artfully woven in (without being preachy) was so applicable. I feel like in our day and age, we get these plans and we get so fixed on our own plans, that sometimes we forget that God may have a different plan. I will stop there. . .
I had been wanting to read Ivy’s book for quite a while. My sisters had both read it before me an I had been eyeing it with longing every time I turned on my kindle. I finally got the chance in the last month and I am so thankful I read this little volume. It is probably the best novella I have read to date. It is not easy to create a story in such a short word count and make it satisfying to the readers. Ivy nailed it.
The characters were so sweet, but human and I related a lot with each of them for different reasons. This book was so impactful and I find it even more so because Miss Rose writes from experience. And that shines through.
Likes:
Um, lots of stuff.
~ Lindy of course. Her struggles were real to me and something I have struggled with in a minor way, so I totally related to that.
~I loved how easily the setting was captured. With so few words I felt myself in China, and I have no basis of knowledge for that. I could picture where everyone was and what was going on.
~The medical stuff. I am a huge medical buff. I have studied a lot in the field and found nearly all of Ivy’s facts to be correct to my knowledge. I just love medical detail y’all, call me weird.
~ The romance. It was so understated, but there and real and normal, and natural feeling! I have read a post by Ivy on how to write romance, and I must say, I very much appreciate her approach. So clean and wholesome.
Quibbles:
To be honest, I didn’t really have any? *shrugs* It is that good people! READ IT!
Overall:
Please, pretty please just read it. It will give you a new look and maybe open your eyes to something that is a very real and problematic issue in our society. Also, the moral that was artfully woven in (without being preachy) was so applicable. I feel like in our day and age, we get these plans and we get so fixed on our own plans, that sometimes we forget that God may have a different plan. I will stop there. . .
January 24, 2018
About this book:
“Lindy Greene’s life is perfect. Too perfect. But living as a missionary nurse, serving in a small hospital in China, soon brings the disaster she fearfully anticipates. All of her well-thought-out plans for the future disintegrate after pulling a fatally ill, disfigured, abandoned child from a pile of trash. She doesn’t even like babies.
Nathan Thomas can’t find balance. College suited him just fine until his cash ran out, forcing him to the Chinese mission field with his parents. The chaotic atmosphere in China does little to relax his agitated mind, and the pretty blonde nurse at the hospital does nothing to help him focus.
The Chinese mission field isn’t for the faint of heart. Nathan wonders how he can survive his remaining time there, while Lindy struggles to help everyone she can. With different ideals pulling them in separate directions, there is one thing drawing them together: a tiny, sickly, crippled orphan who relies on them to stay alive.”
Series: As of now, no.
Spiritual Content- Hebrews 13:5 at the beginning; A couple Scriptures are mentioned & read; Many Prayers, Praising, & Thanking God; Many talks about God & His plans; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Both Lindy’s and Nathan’s families are missionaries; Mentions of God, Jesus, His will, & callings; Mentions of prayers, praying, & blessings over food; Mentions of churches, underground churches, pastors, & going to a seminary school; Mentions of missionaries & mission fields; Mentions of Christians & faiths; A few mentions of miracles; A few mentions of blessings & being blessed;
*Note: Mentions of those who believe in curses, misfortune, & bad luck.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘stupid’; Having to do nurse/doctor activities (IVs, treating illnesses, etc., up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of abandoned babies (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of dying babies, an infant’s death, & holding the baby (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of prisons & prison-like places; A few mentions of an accident & injuries; A few mentions of nightmares; A few mentions of vomiting; A few mentions of gossip;
*Note: Going to & a few mentions of Starbucks.
Sexual Content- a cheek kiss, a not-detailed kiss, and two barely-above-not-detailed kisses; Touches, Embraces, & Warmth (barely-above-not-detailed); Blushes; Some noticing; Mentions of dating, relationships, & girlfriends; Some love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Mentions of a mother who fought for her life after giving birth; A couple mentions of nursing.
-Londyn “Lindy” Greene, age 21
-Nathan Thomas
P.O.V. switches between them
??? pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Three Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
{Add ½ star for those interested in orphan care or whose families have adopted.}
As many of y’all know, China is a country near and so dear to my heart. I was able to visit Maria’s Big House of Hope in the summer of 2016, which is truly a place that has the presence of the Lord.
When the sweet author (whose family has adopted from China) contacted me about reviewing “Left to Die”, I knew it would be a hard read, but such an important topic. Personally, I found one thing was no longer actuate (the mention of China’s one-child policy) and also that it’s very rare to seeing someone as young as Lindy who is single and adopting (when the age minimum is 30), it happens, but it very, very rare.
I loved Lindy’s character and understood her thoughts on a personal level. Nathan was very sweet, and I enjoyed seeing their light romance in this novella. That epilogue was precious and so exciting for them. The writing style was very relaxed and I’m curious to see what this author writes next! :)
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Author for this honest review.
“Lindy Greene’s life is perfect. Too perfect. But living as a missionary nurse, serving in a small hospital in China, soon brings the disaster she fearfully anticipates. All of her well-thought-out plans for the future disintegrate after pulling a fatally ill, disfigured, abandoned child from a pile of trash. She doesn’t even like babies.
Nathan Thomas can’t find balance. College suited him just fine until his cash ran out, forcing him to the Chinese mission field with his parents. The chaotic atmosphere in China does little to relax his agitated mind, and the pretty blonde nurse at the hospital does nothing to help him focus.
The Chinese mission field isn’t for the faint of heart. Nathan wonders how he can survive his remaining time there, while Lindy struggles to help everyone she can. With different ideals pulling them in separate directions, there is one thing drawing them together: a tiny, sickly, crippled orphan who relies on them to stay alive.”
Series: As of now, no.
Spiritual Content- Hebrews 13:5 at the beginning; A couple Scriptures are mentioned & read; Many Prayers, Praising, & Thanking God; Many talks about God & His plans; ‘H’s are capital when referring to God; Both Lindy’s and Nathan’s families are missionaries; Mentions of God, Jesus, His will, & callings; Mentions of prayers, praying, & blessings over food; Mentions of churches, underground churches, pastors, & going to a seminary school; Mentions of missionaries & mission fields; Mentions of Christians & faiths; A few mentions of miracles; A few mentions of blessings & being blessed;
*Note: Mentions of those who believe in curses, misfortune, & bad luck.
Negative Content- Minor cussing including: a ‘stupid’; Having to do nurse/doctor activities (IVs, treating illnesses, etc., up to semi-detailed); Many mentions of abandoned babies (up to semi-detailed); Mentions of dying babies, an infant’s death, & holding the baby (barely-above-not-detailed); Mentions of prisons & prison-like places; A few mentions of an accident & injuries; A few mentions of nightmares; A few mentions of vomiting; A few mentions of gossip;
*Note: Going to & a few mentions of Starbucks.
Sexual Content- a cheek kiss, a not-detailed kiss, and two barely-above-not-detailed kisses; Touches, Embraces, & Warmth (barely-above-not-detailed); Blushes; Some noticing; Mentions of dating, relationships, & girlfriends; Some love, falling in love, & the emotions;
*Note: Mentions of a mother who fought for her life after giving birth; A couple mentions of nursing.
-Londyn “Lindy” Greene, age 21
-Nathan Thomas
P.O.V. switches between them
??? pages
~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~*
Pre Teens- One Star
New Teens- One Star (and a half)
Early High School Teens- Three Stars
Older High School Teens- Four Stars
My personal Rating- Four Stars
{Add ½ star for those interested in orphan care or whose families have adopted.}
As many of y’all know, China is a country near and so dear to my heart. I was able to visit Maria’s Big House of Hope in the summer of 2016, which is truly a place that has the presence of the Lord.
When the sweet author (whose family has adopted from China) contacted me about reviewing “Left to Die”, I knew it would be a hard read, but such an important topic. Personally, I found one thing was no longer actuate (the mention of China’s one-child policy) and also that it’s very rare to seeing someone as young as Lindy who is single and adopting (when the age minimum is 30), it happens, but it very, very rare.
I loved Lindy’s character and understood her thoughts on a personal level. Nathan was very sweet, and I enjoyed seeing their light romance in this novella. That epilogue was precious and so exciting for them. The writing style was very relaxed and I’m curious to see what this author writes next! :)
Link to review:
https://booksforchristiangirls.blogsp...
*BFCG may (Read the review to see) recommend this book by this author. It does not mean I recommend all the books by this author.
*I received this book for free from the Author for this honest review.
July 24, 2017
*clutches heart* *wipes away tears*
Oh. My. Goodness. What a beautiful story. I sniffled until I was borderline-crying, I smiled until my face heart, and I laugh with joy at the happy moments.
After reading Ivy Rose's first published work (The Old River Road) back last summer, I could hardly wait to read another and jumped at the chance to review Left to Die. I was not disappointed in the least. Although a vastly different storyline, this book was just as lovely – just as touching. Maybe even more so.
The tale of abandonment is...absolutely heartbreaking. <3 Jia was such a sweet little thing, and reading of Lindy coming to care for her was so precious.
Lindy was a wonderful main character, her struggles over loving or not loving Jia were shown in a way so real-to-life.
And while we're talking characters...you don't even want to get me started on Nathan. XD He was an amazing guy. He certainly wasn't perfect, but he strove to do better and to serve God in the moment of time he was living.
And then the ending... *happy sigh* A sweet and satisfying conclusion. <3 ((But... Can we have a sequel for this book? Please? Like, a story between the main book and the epilogue?? *smiles* I want to know more about sweet lil' Connor... B-))
All the way around, this was a fabulous book and I enjoyed it immensely. I look forward to reading more by this author. :D
Favorite Quotes...
No matter what happened, that little mite of a baby would forever impact him.
Maybe she was getting too stuck in yesterday’s dream, instead of being open to His whispers for today.
**I received an e-ARC from the author in exchange for my honest review.**
Oh. My. Goodness. What a beautiful story. I sniffled until I was borderline-crying, I smiled until my face heart, and I laugh with joy at the happy moments.
After reading Ivy Rose's first published work (The Old River Road) back last summer, I could hardly wait to read another and jumped at the chance to review Left to Die. I was not disappointed in the least. Although a vastly different storyline, this book was just as lovely – just as touching. Maybe even more so.
The tale of abandonment is...absolutely heartbreaking. <3 Jia was such a sweet little thing, and reading of Lindy coming to care for her was so precious.
Lindy was a wonderful main character, her struggles over loving or not loving Jia were shown in a way so real-to-life.
And while we're talking characters...you don't even want to get me started on Nathan. XD He was an amazing guy. He certainly wasn't perfect, but he strove to do better and to serve God in the moment of time he was living.
And then the ending... *happy sigh* A sweet and satisfying conclusion. <3 ((But... Can we have a sequel for this book? Please? Like, a story between the main book and the epilogue?? *smiles* I want to know more about sweet lil' Connor... B-))
All the way around, this was a fabulous book and I enjoyed it immensely. I look forward to reading more by this author. :D
Favorite Quotes...
No matter what happened, that little mite of a baby would forever impact him.
Maybe she was getting too stuck in yesterday’s dream, instead of being open to His whispers for today.
**I received an e-ARC from the author in exchange for my honest review.**
February 2, 2018
This book grabbed me from the moment I first picked it up, and I started and finished it in less than a day (a record time for me with any story this length!). It was so sweet, heartwarming, and touching, to read a story about an abandoned Chinese baby girl with bad asthma and club feet, who nobody wants...not even the American missionary girl who finds her in a heap of fly-infested garbage. What I especially loved too was how seamlessly and naturally both Lindy and Nathan slipped into the whole 'parenting' routine for baby Jia, without either one of them realizing how much she meant to them! It was hilarious at times, as well as heartbreaking, especially those dreadful orphanage scenes. A book I would highly recommend to anyone who loves good, uplifting, thought provoking, and heartwarming Christian-fiction.
February 20, 2017
I love love love this book! Ivy Rose is an inspiring, compelling writer! While I can see room for improvement with the writing, story-wise, this book is AMAZING! I mean seriously, a baby, a missionary nurse, and medical issues, what could go wrong?
The description was stellar, the characters were amazing and compelling, and it was just amazing! I wish there was a sequel, or it was a series!!! Well done, Ivy Rose!! :)
Recommended for all ages, although younger children may not completely grasp the concepts and emotion portrayed in this book.
The description was stellar, the characters were amazing and compelling, and it was just amazing! I wish there was a sequel, or it was a series!!! Well done, Ivy Rose!! :)
Recommended for all ages, although younger children may not completely grasp the concepts and emotion portrayed in this book.
February 7, 2017
Originally posted on Reveries Reviews
I wasn't sure about this novel. I've never read a book about missionaries (unless you count the Bible), and I was pretty convinced I wouldn't enjoy it (mostly because these kind of things really make me feel guilty). I was a bit nervous, to say the least. But this was a sensational book that has earned a place amongst my favorites.
Plot {5/5}:
The plot was fantastic! It all unfolded so beautifully and was perfect and amazing and wonderful and - *kicks self* It was well-paced, interesting, and kept my attention 100% throughout the entire book.
And I've just got to say ... the epilogue was so perfect, guys. Just <3
Characters {4/5}:
I didn't get extremely attached to Lindy (although I really liked her), but Jia ... I think I'm in love again, guys. I know I've said that before, but ... this is it. At least in a sisterly way.
I think I need a little sister now ...
And yes, I do realize it's expensive and a lot of work and gruesome and I probably wouldn't be able to handle it with my lack of experience - Left to Die was nothing if not realistic - but ... but ...
Back on track.
I loved Nate. He was amazing! Not as good as Gil, of course, but ... Besides, Nate and Lindy were so cute together!
Setting {4/5}:
Sometimes there could have been a little more description, but overall, the setting was vividly portrayed. I think I always realized how bad it was in China with the orphans and such ... or at least I was able to imagine it that bad (I can be pessimistic about these things) ... but it was still sad to read about it.
Writing {4/5}:
I feel like there could have been a little work on the writing here and there, but overall, it was good. I really like Ivy Rose's writing style. It just ... appeals to me. No particular reason. :)
Content:
Parental guidance suggested for younger teens. No language or sexual content (except maybe a couple kisses, no details). Descriptions of sickness and the medical care and abandonment/other poor treatment of infants/children (somewhat graphic, but still pretty clean) that may disturb sensitive readers or young children.
Overall {5/5}:
AAAAAH THAT WAS SO GOOD!!!
*puts on serious face* It was a noble story which I'm recommend to any lover of missionary stories, Christian fiction, light romance, adorable babies, and somewhat sad stories with very happy endings.
~Kellyn Roth, Reveries Reviews
I wasn't sure about this novel. I've never read a book about missionaries (unless you count the Bible), and I was pretty convinced I wouldn't enjoy it (mostly because these kind of things really make me feel guilty). I was a bit nervous, to say the least. But this was a sensational book that has earned a place amongst my favorites.
Plot {5/5}:
The plot was fantastic! It all unfolded so beautifully and was perfect and amazing and wonderful and - *kicks self* It was well-paced, interesting, and kept my attention 100% throughout the entire book.
And I've just got to say ... the epilogue was so perfect, guys. Just <3
Characters {4/5}:
I didn't get extremely attached to Lindy (although I really liked her), but Jia ... I think I'm in love again, guys. I know I've said that before, but ... this is it. At least in a sisterly way.
I think I need a little sister now ...
And yes, I do realize it's expensive and a lot of work and gruesome and I probably wouldn't be able to handle it with my lack of experience - Left to Die was nothing if not realistic - but ... but ...
Back on track.
I loved Nate. He was amazing! Not as good as Gil, of course, but ... Besides, Nate and Lindy were so cute together!
Setting {4/5}:
Sometimes there could have been a little more description, but overall, the setting was vividly portrayed. I think I always realized how bad it was in China with the orphans and such ... or at least I was able to imagine it that bad (I can be pessimistic about these things) ... but it was still sad to read about it.
Writing {4/5}:
I feel like there could have been a little work on the writing here and there, but overall, it was good. I really like Ivy Rose's writing style. It just ... appeals to me. No particular reason. :)
Content:
Parental guidance suggested for younger teens. No language or sexual content (except maybe a couple kisses, no details). Descriptions of sickness and the medical care and abandonment/other poor treatment of infants/children (somewhat graphic, but still pretty clean) that may disturb sensitive readers or young children.
Overall {5/5}:
AAAAAH THAT WAS SO GOOD!!!
*puts on serious face* It was a noble story which I'm recommend to any lover of missionary stories, Christian fiction, light romance, adorable babies, and somewhat sad stories with very happy endings.
~Kellyn Roth, Reveries Reviews
September 5, 2024
5+ stars (7/10 hearts). I deeply enjoyed this book when I first read it, eight years ago… but now, as an adult, I loved it.
It’s such an unexpectedly deep book. It starts out so commonplace, in contemporary China—a slightly exotic feel for most North Americans, granted, but life goes on there as it does anywhere else. The characters are real and natural—Lindy & Nathan were both very relatable with their personal issues and plans—and then suddenly comes the heart-shredding, courtesy of a days-old baby girl, deathly sick, discarded in the garbage under a pile of infected trash. Considered unlucky because of her gender and her disability.
I’m not one for medical details generally, but it’s clearly that Hailey Rose has a huge heart for caring medically for people. Her details are interesting—and they make sense to the uninitiated, haha!—and they’re steeped in love and respect. I cried over Jia and Lindy, so powerless in the face of national indifference but challenging the narrative just one God-given miracle at a time. I have only read one more powerfully pro-life book— To Save a Life —and this book goes a little beyond by advocating for foster care, adoption, love, and general care for all babies, including those disabled or at risk—so often considered useless or of lower value. The part about the orphanage was a real heart squeeze… The silent crier and Min Min specifically personified the tragedy.
But it’s not just about abandoned babies and unwanted orphans, and end up knocked out by the powerful message of letting go of your plan and trusting God’s even when it hurts and makes no sense. I’m at a point in my life where it spoke deeply to me… it’s so simple but so helpful.
It’s such a simple book, and yet it strikes so hard.
P.S. For those of us who were there when the book first published and knew Hailey… this book is doubly precious knowing where she is at now in her life journey and everything God has done for her. <33
Content: Mention of hugs & kisses.
A Favourite Short Quote: They squealed greetings and waved back, broad smiles stretching across their faces.
How was it that even though they were so poor, their smiles were more beautiful than those of the most prosperous people Lindy knew?
A Favourite Humorous Quote: “It’s okay. You’re all right. I know... your favorite person is busy, but she told me to take care of you.”
Jia wailed again, a thick bead of water sliding down her cheek.
Nathan chuckled. “Tell me about it. I already know I’m a poor substitute.”
It’s such an unexpectedly deep book. It starts out so commonplace, in contemporary China—a slightly exotic feel for most North Americans, granted, but life goes on there as it does anywhere else. The characters are real and natural—Lindy & Nathan were both very relatable with their personal issues and plans—and then suddenly comes the heart-shredding, courtesy of a days-old baby girl, deathly sick, discarded in the garbage under a pile of infected trash. Considered unlucky because of her gender and her disability.
I’m not one for medical details generally, but it’s clearly that Hailey Rose has a huge heart for caring medically for people. Her details are interesting—and they make sense to the uninitiated, haha!—and they’re steeped in love and respect. I cried over Jia and Lindy, so powerless in the face of national indifference but challenging the narrative just one God-given miracle at a time. I have only read one more powerfully pro-life book— To Save a Life —and this book goes a little beyond by advocating for foster care, adoption, love, and general care for all babies, including those disabled or at risk—so often considered useless or of lower value. The part about the orphanage was a real heart squeeze… The silent crier and Min Min specifically personified the tragedy.
But it’s not just about abandoned babies and unwanted orphans, and end up knocked out by the powerful message of letting go of your plan and trusting God’s even when it hurts and makes no sense. I’m at a point in my life where it spoke deeply to me… it’s so simple but so helpful.
It’s such a simple book, and yet it strikes so hard.
P.S. For those of us who were there when the book first published and knew Hailey… this book is doubly precious knowing where she is at now in her life journey and everything God has done for her. <33
Content: Mention of hugs & kisses.
A Favourite Short Quote: They squealed greetings and waved back, broad smiles stretching across their faces.
How was it that even though they were so poor, their smiles were more beautiful than those of the most prosperous people Lindy knew?
A Favourite Humorous Quote: “It’s okay. You’re all right. I know... your favorite person is busy, but she told me to take care of you.”
Jia wailed again, a thick bead of water sliding down her cheek.
Nathan chuckled. “Tell me about it. I already know I’m a poor substitute.”
October 6, 2018
I enjoyed this book.
Umm, I didn't exactly ever connect with the characters, though I did love Jia.
Nathan seemed a side character until he was needed in the last couple chapters, so his and Lindy's relationship felt a lot more forced than it was supposed to be, like a telling and not showing, and was hard to believe. When we got to know the guy though, I did come to like him.
There was no useful information for my research for foster care and adoption, they were only mentioned in passing, lots of paperwork and her signing all the highlife do lines to get a foster parent license, but that's where it ends.
I think that's probably because this was a China foster care and not a US foster care system, so despite that I was hoping for some information, I'm not taking off any stars.
Why did I mark this book five stars? I don't honestly know. Because it touched me inside, even though I never fully connected. Like, I didn't love the characters, I felt that the struggles were vague and there was a LOT of repetition, lots of telling and not showing. However, it was a really good story line and honestly I feel like this book is better than so many best sellers out there. WE NEED MORE LITERATURE LIKE THIS!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ for Ivy Rose. I will have this book on my shelf some day.
Umm, I didn't exactly ever connect with the characters, though I did love Jia.
Nathan seemed a side character until he was needed in the last couple chapters, so his and Lindy's relationship felt a lot more forced than it was supposed to be, like a telling and not showing, and was hard to believe. When we got to know the guy though, I did come to like him.
There was no useful information for my research for foster care and adoption, they were only mentioned in passing, lots of paperwork and her signing all the highlife do lines to get a foster parent license, but that's where it ends.
I think that's probably because this was a China foster care and not a US foster care system, so despite that I was hoping for some information, I'm not taking off any stars.
Why did I mark this book five stars? I don't honestly know. Because it touched me inside, even though I never fully connected. Like, I didn't love the characters, I felt that the struggles were vague and there was a LOT of repetition, lots of telling and not showing. However, it was a really good story line and honestly I feel like this book is better than so many best sellers out there. WE NEED MORE LITERATURE LIKE THIS!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ for Ivy Rose. I will have this book on my shelf some day.
July 7, 2017
Wow, this book was amazing! I loved it so much. *grins* Lindy has such a sweet personality which made this book very pleasant to read. There is so much tenderness and emotion that was put into the story that made it simply beautiful.
I just have to mention the end as well. ; ) WOW, it was seriously the sweetest thing ever. It made me so happy.
I really liked the authors writing style and I would recommend this to anyone!
I just have to mention the end as well. ; ) WOW, it was seriously the sweetest thing ever. It made me so happy.
I really liked the authors writing style and I would recommend this to anyone!
July 25, 2017
“God, this is crazy. . .” (85)
"Why do You let them be abandoned in the first place, Lord?" (84)
An issue dear to my heart as it is to the author, Ivy Rose, Left to Die is about God's calling in our lives, as it is in bringing to light the tragedy of child abandonment, and the often grueling adoption process. Sometimes it's hard to imagine what the world is like where babies and children are left to fend for themselves, but it can happen anywhere. Having traveled to China, and knowing missionaries that have ministered there, as well as friends that have adopted from orphanages, Left to Die gives only a glimpse. Yet within that glimpse, readers' emotions were touched, yanked and even challenged. Challenged because of understanding Lindy's plight, and finding commonality in uncertainties with her and Nathan's call.
"The walls of Lindy's heart came crashing down. Tears flooded her eyes, and the selfish internal struggle became moot. . . It wasn't a fluke . . ." (158)
Left to Die is a short novella, but it packed quite a punch. Possibly I'm biased for having personal knowledge of what was presented, but in all a story that motivates and encourages for good and for our personal journey. Though it's simple in writing style, the honest and genuine premise of the story pushes it up in my book.
This review first appeared on Just Commonly blog.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a positive review, and have not been compensated for this. This is my honest opinion.
"Why do You let them be abandoned in the first place, Lord?" (84)
An issue dear to my heart as it is to the author, Ivy Rose, Left to Die is about God's calling in our lives, as it is in bringing to light the tragedy of child abandonment, and the often grueling adoption process. Sometimes it's hard to imagine what the world is like where babies and children are left to fend for themselves, but it can happen anywhere. Having traveled to China, and knowing missionaries that have ministered there, as well as friends that have adopted from orphanages, Left to Die gives only a glimpse. Yet within that glimpse, readers' emotions were touched, yanked and even challenged. Challenged because of understanding Lindy's plight, and finding commonality in uncertainties with her and Nathan's call.
"The walls of Lindy's heart came crashing down. Tears flooded her eyes, and the selfish internal struggle became moot. . . It wasn't a fluke . . ." (158)
Left to Die is a short novella, but it packed quite a punch. Possibly I'm biased for having personal knowledge of what was presented, but in all a story that motivates and encourages for good and for our personal journey. Though it's simple in writing style, the honest and genuine premise of the story pushes it up in my book.
This review first appeared on Just Commonly blog.
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book from the author/publisher. I was not required to write a positive review, and have not been compensated for this. This is my honest opinion.
June 2, 2017
This is my second time reading this book and I loved it just as much as I did the first time! The tragedy of abandonment and reality of adoption in China are present among the bittersweet experiences Lindy has to face with baby Jia. I loved reading about the little baby surviving on miracles and Lindy and Nathan's independent struggles with trying to fulfill God's calling for their lives. A very compelling and tender read on an issue dear to the author's own heart!
August 2, 2018
This was awesome!
April 28, 2017
Not only were the characters believable and the story riveting, I found "Left to Die" with a wonderful message of how sometimes God calls us to places for not the reasons we think, but for things we believe we cannot desire since its not his will.
With apt descriptions of China and what the child situation over there is truly like, this book is heartbreaking and heartwarming, all at the same time. Lindy is a character easy to relate to as she strives to follow God's will, only to find God's will is quite different than she thought. After finding a baby in the trash and no one to adopt her, Lindy's faced with decisions she isn't sure how to make, or what the Lord's telling her.
I really enjoyed this book and loved the message behind it as well. Not only does it expose the truth of the sad situation many children in China face, but it also speaks a message of trust to its readers. Highly recommend it!
With apt descriptions of China and what the child situation over there is truly like, this book is heartbreaking and heartwarming, all at the same time. Lindy is a character easy to relate to as she strives to follow God's will, only to find God's will is quite different than she thought. After finding a baby in the trash and no one to adopt her, Lindy's faced with decisions she isn't sure how to make, or what the Lord's telling her.
I really enjoyed this book and loved the message behind it as well. Not only does it expose the truth of the sad situation many children in China face, but it also speaks a message of trust to its readers. Highly recommend it!
February 7, 2017
*note* I was a beta-reader for this book, so my review may be a bit biased. (But I don't think it is. ;))
After having read Ivy's first book, and really enjoying it, I was looking forward to reading this. I wasn't disappointed! In fact, I enjoyed this more than her first book. It is a novella, but it felt like the perfect length. the ending didn't seemed rushed in the least, and I was kept anxiously wondering what would happen to little Jia. And inwardly lecturing Lindy throughout most of it.
And Nathan. He was amazing. I really enjoyed seeing his character growth through out the book, and those last few chapters were precious!
This book does deal with a harsh subject, but I felt that it was very tastefully done. I've read enough about infant abandonment to know it is a very real thing, yet reading it through fiction seemed to make it come alive in a whole other way. It was handled with care, and I'd recommend it for any ages. :)
After having read Ivy's first book, and really enjoying it, I was looking forward to reading this. I wasn't disappointed! In fact, I enjoyed this more than her first book. It is a novella, but it felt like the perfect length. the ending didn't seemed rushed in the least, and I was kept anxiously wondering what would happen to little Jia. And inwardly lecturing Lindy throughout most of it.
And Nathan. He was amazing. I really enjoyed seeing his character growth through out the book, and those last few chapters were precious!
This book does deal with a harsh subject, but I felt that it was very tastefully done. I've read enough about infant abandonment to know it is a very real thing, yet reading it through fiction seemed to make it come alive in a whole other way. It was handled with care, and I'd recommend it for any ages. :)
May 19, 2017
Wow, did I ever enjoy this book! This author is quite talented at weaving an interesting story with Biblical lessons in it. I was reminded several times of how much I do need to trust God and I related to the main character, Lindy, a lot.
What I Liked: Lindy, Nathan, and sweet Jia were wonderful. I didn't want the story to end. As I said above, the character I related most to was Lindy. She had her whole life planned out, but when God brings along "detours", so to speak, He begins to reveal His real plan for Lindy--the one she doesn't necessarily desire. I loved the point that the author made in this story--God never changes, and since He never changes, His plans for us don't. Just sometimes, as fallible humans, we either mistake what He's wanting us to do at the time, or shut Him out and force ourselves to hear what WE want to hear. I found myself encouraged and reminded that God CAN be trusted time and time again. He will never fail us. I've always known that, but it's nice to be encouraged.
As I think over the story, I really like how Lindy and Nathan communicated in their relationship and even prior to it. Nathan was so sweet and gentlemanly to Lindy and Lindy appreciated him and supported him in his ultimate decision whether or not to return to the United States for seminary college. SO MANY BOOKS contain a whole lot of misunderstanding between the couples, and while misunderstanding and confusion in relationships happen, I really liked how this couple talked things over and in the end wanted God's will in their lives above their own. This was a very refreshing aspect to the story for me.
What I Didn't Like: I don't think that there was anything I didn't like in this story.
I give this book 5 stars for an enjoyable, inspiring, God-honoring story. This author did an excellent job and I do believe this book will be going amongst my favorites of 2017.
What I Liked: Lindy, Nathan, and sweet Jia were wonderful. I didn't want the story to end. As I said above, the character I related most to was Lindy. She had her whole life planned out, but when God brings along "detours", so to speak, He begins to reveal His real plan for Lindy--the one she doesn't necessarily desire. I loved the point that the author made in this story--God never changes, and since He never changes, His plans for us don't. Just sometimes, as fallible humans, we either mistake what He's wanting us to do at the time, or shut Him out and force ourselves to hear what WE want to hear. I found myself encouraged and reminded that God CAN be trusted time and time again. He will never fail us. I've always known that, but it's nice to be encouraged.
As I think over the story, I really like how Lindy and Nathan communicated in their relationship and even prior to it. Nathan was so sweet and gentlemanly to Lindy and Lindy appreciated him and supported him in his ultimate decision whether or not to return to the United States for seminary college. SO MANY BOOKS contain a whole lot of misunderstanding between the couples, and while misunderstanding and confusion in relationships happen, I really liked how this couple talked things over and in the end wanted God's will in their lives above their own. This was a very refreshing aspect to the story for me.
What I Didn't Like: I don't think that there was anything I didn't like in this story.
I give this book 5 stars for an enjoyable, inspiring, God-honoring story. This author did an excellent job and I do believe this book will be going amongst my favorites of 2017.
March 7, 2018
A concise, cleverly written, beautiful story about the beauty of motherhood, the value of human life, and following God’s plan…Left to Die was a wonderfully constructed story full of elaborate character arcs and deep themes, and I enjoyed it from page one. I felt it was a perfect length—I’m not sure whether or not this is officially considered a novella but it felt around that length and anyway it was just a perfect length for this story.
The story focuses around Lindy, a young woman living as a missionary in China. Lindy’s whole life is shaped around God’s plan for her—to be a missionary. But is that really all to God’s plan?
The ideas of just that—God’s plan—are explored inside the pages of this book which deals with topics such as pride and humility. I also loved the strong and powerful message about the value of life! The character arcs were beautiful and it was awesome to watch as the characters changed. Side note—there was romance in this book, but it was slight and sublte and fit right into the story.
The only downside I have is the beginning, which was confusing to me. I could not for the life of me figure out what was going on in the first chapter, or why it was important. It didn't really end up contributing to the story, and by the time the second chapter came along I had a grasp on who the characters were, but to me, a first chapter that seemed to supposedly set the scene just added confusion. However, once I got past that, the story was riveting and full of depth. Highly recommended!
Like my reviews? Follow my blog:
http://jcbuchanan.com
The story focuses around Lindy, a young woman living as a missionary in China. Lindy’s whole life is shaped around God’s plan for her—to be a missionary. But is that really all to God’s plan?
The ideas of just that—God’s plan—are explored inside the pages of this book which deals with topics such as pride and humility. I also loved the strong and powerful message about the value of life! The character arcs were beautiful and it was awesome to watch as the characters changed. Side note—there was romance in this book, but it was slight and sublte and fit right into the story.
The only downside I have is the beginning, which was confusing to me. I could not for the life of me figure out what was going on in the first chapter, or why it was important. It didn't really end up contributing to the story, and by the time the second chapter came along I had a grasp on who the characters were, but to me, a first chapter that seemed to supposedly set the scene just added confusion. However, once I got past that, the story was riveting and full of depth. Highly recommended!
Like my reviews? Follow my blog:
http://jcbuchanan.com
April 23, 2019
I have to admit that I had a bit of a hard time connecting with Lindy at first as her determination to remain single and childless is the complete antithesis of what my dreams have always been. I was also a little concerned that she had equated God's calling to life as a missionary nurse to equal the idea of remaining perpetually unattached.
But as soon as Jia came into her life, I was relieved to see that her heart and instinct were warring with her head and her plans. It was obvious from the beginning how attached she was becoming, as much as she kept trying to fight it with logic--and honestly, I'd much rather see it happen this way than for a logical solution to win over a lack of affection. Also, the reasons behind her desire to distance herself made sense and weren't rooted in an unreasonable "dislike of babies". And I loved the way Nathan helped provide the support Lindy needed, even while his heart drew ever closer to Jia. Jia's obvious attachment melted my heart, and I adored the way things came together in the end. <3
All the supporting characters were great, and I especially appreciated the way the family helped and supported Lindy through all the trouble and decisions she faced. And the last chapter with its glimpse of the future was so, so sweet! <3<3 Highly recommended!
Content--descriptions of an abandoned baby found in garbage; mentions of birth defects, diseases, and medical emergencies; mentions of holding a baby skin to skin; mentions of neglectful conditions at orphanages
But as soon as Jia came into her life, I was relieved to see that her heart and instinct were warring with her head and her plans. It was obvious from the beginning how attached she was becoming, as much as she kept trying to fight it with logic--and honestly, I'd much rather see it happen this way than for a logical solution to win over a lack of affection. Also, the reasons behind her desire to distance herself made sense and weren't rooted in an unreasonable "dislike of babies". And I loved the way Nathan helped provide the support Lindy needed, even while his heart drew ever closer to Jia. Jia's obvious attachment melted my heart, and I adored the way things came together in the end. <3
All the supporting characters were great, and I especially appreciated the way the family helped and supported Lindy through all the trouble and decisions she faced. And the last chapter with its glimpse of the future was so, so sweet! <3<3 Highly recommended!
Content--descriptions of an abandoned baby found in garbage; mentions of birth defects, diseases, and medical emergencies; mentions of holding a baby skin to skin; mentions of neglectful conditions at orphanages
March 9, 2018
Everytime Jia got sick; my heart began to race. Please don't die, Jia. This book reminds me a lot about a movie I heard of. I can't remember a lot about it but this book has a vibe to it. So helpful, I know. I love books that point out world issues that we usually avoid. One of my new favorites.
September 20, 2017
Review coming soon.
November 17, 2019
Really enjoyed this novel written by a talented young lady when she was only 18 years old!!! Seriously!?! Talk about making my writing attempts feel inadequate, lol. But seriously, this was a beautiful story about how God can use your life when you seek Him...with lots of realistic scenes of baby snuggles and family interaction that make you realize the author has first hand experience in much that was in this book. Makes me wonder if the author’s little sister had some of the same medical conditions described in the book. My hubby and I have always had the idea of adoption hovering in the back of our minds (though we will soon be parents to 5) and this book did nothing but stir up the coals of that desire to provide homes and love for more needy children. 💕 Great book, Hailey...now show me how to get a hold of your other works. 😉
December 12, 2017
This was such a sweet story! I loved every word of it. "Left to Die" is an inspiring and compelling story that is sure to keep you turning pages. :)
December 11, 2018
It wad okay. The romance seemed a bit forced. The characters weren’t very deep either.
November 21, 2019
I wasn't quiet sure what I was getting into when I read this. After all, I'm not really into baby's ether, (Me and the main character had something in common!) But I quickly got into it.
The first thing that really struck me was that I appreciated how Lindys parents were actually present and a part of her life. It was nice.
I was very hesitant to like Nathan at first. I mean, dropping out of collage and then going to live back with his parents and having no real purpose in life, kinda made me not want to like him. But, as the reasons behind things slowly unfolded and I got to see more, I couldn't help but like Nathan a lot. Especially when he took care of the baby. That was just heart meltingly adorable.
Lindy was very sweet and I appreciated her struggle. I felt like I could really relate to her, cause I'm not super into kids either. But I love how Jia was really healing for Lindy.
This whole book just makes you want to just open up your house and give a home to children, weather they are from the other side of the world and need a permanent home, or just a kid across the street who needs a hug.
The ending was perfect.
The only warning I would give to people is that there are some scenes showing orphanages, and abandoned kids that are pretty hard to read. But the author handled them really well.
Re-read 2019: This book is just. so. good. Happy tears were shed.
The first thing that really struck me was that I appreciated how Lindys parents were actually present and a part of her life. It was nice.
I was very hesitant to like Nathan at first. I mean, dropping out of collage and then going to live back with his parents and having no real purpose in life, kinda made me not want to like him. But, as the reasons behind things slowly unfolded and I got to see more, I couldn't help but like Nathan a lot. Especially when he took care of the baby. That was just heart meltingly adorable.
Lindy was very sweet and I appreciated her struggle. I felt like I could really relate to her, cause I'm not super into kids either. But I love how Jia was really healing for Lindy.
This whole book just makes you want to just open up your house and give a home to children, weather they are from the other side of the world and need a permanent home, or just a kid across the street who needs a hug.
The ending was perfect.
The only warning I would give to people is that there are some scenes showing orphanages, and abandoned kids that are pretty hard to read. But the author handled them really well.
Re-read 2019: This book is just. so. good. Happy tears were shed.
December 2, 2019
DNF for now
Displaying 1 - 26 of 26 reviews