What do you think?
Rate this book
Entertaining physics problems
"... I note that this book can be seen as an extensive physics quiz which should help the reader assessing whether he actually masters the basics of physics. However, this is not a quiz that you would find in a traditional physics exam. While seemingly simple, the questions often surprise the reader and the quick intuitive answers to these one are often wrong. The ultimate purpose of the book is to convince the reader that the domain of physics is much richer in content than many people think, and incidentally to pay attention to the misconception of a number of physical representations. This book will encourage readers to critically review and carefully check their physics knowledge..."
172 pages, Paperback
Published January 8, 2019
18 people want to read
About the author
Yakov Perelman
98 books125 followersYakov Isidorovich Perelman (Russian: Яков Исидорович Перельман; December 4, 1882 – March 16, 1942) was a Russian and Soviet science writer and author of many popular science books, including Physics Can Be Fun and Mathematics Can Be Fun (both translated from Russian into English).
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 of 1 review
Want to read
January 3, 2023[I recall a conversation I had with renowned chess humourist Bill Hartston sometime in the 70s, where Bill said that what we really needed was not artificial intelligence, but artificial stupidity: he had some characteristically ingenious chess positions to illustrate his point, all of which were way beyond the scope of current machines.
Discussing the following physics problem with ChatGPT, it seems to me that we are making strong progress towards realising Bill's goal, if indeed we haven't already got there. The machine is so extraordinarily like a confused human student that I'm not sure I could tell them apart.
Bill's comment was of course meant to be funny, but as so often is the case it's funny because it's saying something serious in an unexpected way. To reach true intelligence, you typically need to take a route that goes through stupidity, trying ways of thinking that don't work to find the ones that do. Chat seems to have progressed a long way down this route.
If you've ever done any elementary physics coaching, read the dialogue and judge for yourself.]
mannyrayner: How rapidly does the space station in the movie 2001 need to rotate in order to maintain one Earth gravity at the perimeter? Think step by step.
ChatGPT: To determine the rotational speed of the space station in the movie 2001 needed to simulate Earth-like gravity, you would need to consider the following:
The radius of the space station: The larger the radius of the space station, the slower it would need to rotate in order to simulate Earth-like gravity.
The mass of the space station: The greater the mass of the space station, the stronger the gravitational force it would exert, and the slower it would need to rotate in order to simulate Earth-like gravity.
The gravitational acceleration of Earth: Earth's gravitational acceleration is 9.8 m/s^2. To simulate this level of gravitational acceleration at the perimeter of the space station, the station would need to rotate at a certain speed.
The equation for centripetal acceleration: You can use the equation a = v^2/r to calculate the necessary rotational speed of the space station, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
By substituting in the known values for gravitational acceleration and radius, and solving for v, you can determine the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter.
mannyrayner: And what is the approximate radius of the space station in that movie?
ChatGPT: It's difficult for me to say exactly what the radius of the space station in the movie 2001: A Space Odyssey is, as it is a work of science fiction and the dimensions of the space station are not explicitly stated in the film. However, the space station is depicted as a large, wheel-shaped structure with a diameter of around 400 meters. If we assume that the space station is shaped like a cylinder, with the radius being half of the diameter, then the radius of the space station would be around 200 meters. However, it's worth noting that this is just an approximation and the actual radius of the space station in the movie may be different.
mannyrayner: Okay, so if we say the diameter of the space station is 400 meters, which seems reasonable to me, how fast does it need to rotate to obtain one Earth gravity at the perimeter due to centripetal acceleration?
ChatGPT: To determine the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter, we can use the equation a = v^2/r, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
If we assume that the space station has a diameter of 400 meters, and therefore a radius of 200 meters, and that we want to simulate Earth's gravitational acceleration of 9.8 m/s^2 at the perimeter of the space station, we can plug these values into the equation as follows:
a = 9.8 m/s^2
r = 200 m
Solving for v, we find that the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is approximately 4.9 m/s.
It's worth noting that this is just a rough estimate, and the actual rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter of the space station in the movie 2001: A Space Odyssey may be different due to factors such as the mass of the space station and any additional acceleration or deceleration that may occur within the station.
mannyrayner: So how many rotations an hour would it make if that estimate is correct?
ChatGPT: If the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is approximately 4.9 m/s, as we calculated earlier, and we want to know how many rotations the space station would make per hour, we can use the equation v = r * omega, where v is the velocity, r is the radius of the space station, and omega is the angular velocity in radians per second.
If we rearrange the equation to solve for omega, we find that the angular velocity in radians per second is equal to v/r. Since we want to know the angular velocity in rotations per hour, we can convert the units of radians per second to rotations per hour by multiplying by the conversion factor 2*pi/3600 seconds per hour.
Plugging in the values we know, we find that the angular velocity of the space station in rotations per hour is approximately 0.0162 rotations per hour. This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 0.0162 rotations, or one rotation every 61.5 hours.
[This can't possibly be right: if you've seen the movie, you know the space station is rotating far more quickly. Something has gone wrong, but Chat is oblivious.]
mannyrayner: Please do that calculation step by step.
ChatGPT: Certainly! Here is the calculation for the angular velocity of the space station in rotations per hour, step by step:
Calculate the angular velocity in radians per second:
v = 4.9 m/s (the rotational speed we calculated earlier)
r = 200 m (the radius of the space station, assuming a diameter of 400 meters)
omega = v/r = 4.9 m/s / 200 m = 0.025 radians per second
Convert the angular velocity from radians per second to rotations per hour:
1 rotation = 2pi radians (360 degrees is equivalent to 2pi radians)
3600 seconds per hour = 1 hour
omega (rotations per hour) = 0.025 radians per second * 1 hour / 3600 seconds per hour * 2*pi radians/rotation = 0.0162 rotations per hour
This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 0.0162 rotations, or one rotation every 61.5 hours.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
[I realised that it had screwed up earlier and I hadn't been paying attention. That will teach me to trust a cutting-edge AI.]
mannyrayner: Wait a minute. Derive the figure of 4.9 m/s for the rotational speed step by step.
ChatGPT: Certainly! Here is the calculation for the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter, step by step:
Determine the desired gravitational acceleration:
a = 9.8 m/s^2 (Earth's gravitational acceleration)
Use the equation for centripetal acceleration to calculate the rotational speed needed:
a = v^2/r
r = 200 m (the radius of the space station, assuming a diameter of 400 meters)
Solving for v, we find that the rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is:
v = sqrt(a*r) = sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m) = 4.9 m/s
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Do the last step again?
ChatGPT: Certainly! To calculate the rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter of the space station, we can use the equation a = v^2/r, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
If we assume that the space station has a radius of 200 meters and that we want to simulate Earth's gravitational acceleration of 9.8 m/s^2 at the perimeter of the space station, we can plug these values into the equation as follows:
a = 9.8 m/s^2
r = 200 m
Solving for v, we find that the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is:
v = sqrt(a*r) = sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m) = 4.9 m/s
This means that the space station would need to rotate at a speed of approximately 4.9 meters per second in order to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Could you check the last step, where you get v from a and r?
ChatGPT: Certainly! To calculate the rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter of the space station, we can use the equation a = v^2/r, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
If we assume that the space station has a radius of 200 meters and that we want to simulate Earth's gravitational acceleration of 9.8 m/s^2 at the perimeter of the space station, we can plug these values into the equation as follows:
a = 9.8 m/s^2
r = 200 m
Solving for v, we find that the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is:
v = sqrt(a*r) = sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m) = 4.9 m/s
This means that the space station would need to rotate at a speed of approximately 4.9 meters per second in order to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: What is sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m)?
[Whatever has it done here? I asked it to check and just got some mansplaining.]
ChatGPT: The square root of 9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m is approximately 4.9 m/s.
The square root of a number is a value that, when multiplied by itself, gives the original number. For example, the square root of 4 is 2, because 2 * 2 = 4.
In this case, we are taking the square root of the product of 9.8 m/s^2 and 200 m, which is equal to 4.9 m/s. This value represents the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter, as calculated using the equation a = v^2/r, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Should you not take the square root of 9.8 * 200?
[Ahem.]
ChatGPT: You are correct that the square root of 9.8 * 200 would be the correct calculation to determine the rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter of the space station.
The equation a = v^2/r can be used to calculate the rotational speed needed to simulate a particular gravitational acceleration at a given radius. In this case, we are assuming that the space station has a radius of 200 meters and that we want to simulate Earth's gravitational acceleration of 9.8 m/s^2 at the perimeter of the space station.
Plugging these values into the equation, we find that the rotational speed needed is:
v = sqrt(a*r) = sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m) = sqrt(1960) = 44.4 m/s
I apologize for the mistake in my previous response. I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
[One problem fixed, but we aren't there yet.]
mannyrayner: That seems more plausible! So in that case, how many rotations per hour?
ChatGPT: If the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is 44.4 m/s, as we calculated earlier, and we want to know how many rotations the space station would make per hour, we can use the equation v = r * omega, where v is the velocity, r is the radius of the space station, and omega is the angular velocity in radians per second.
If we rearrange the equation to solve for omega, we find that the angular velocity in radians per second is equal to v/r. Since we want to know the angular velocity in rotations per hour, we can convert the units of radians per second to rotations per hour by multiplying by the conversion factor 2*pi/3600 seconds per hour.
Plugging in the values we know, we find that the angular velocity of the space station in rotations per hour is approximately 0.159 rotations per hour. This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 0.159 rotations, or one rotation every 6.2 hours.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
[Chat is still confused about how to do this conversion.]
mannyrayner: Please do that step by step?
ChatGPT: Certainly! Here is the calculation for the angular velocity of the space station in rotations per hour, step by step:
Calculate the angular velocity in radians per second:
v = 44.4 m/s (the rotational speed we calculated earlier)
r = 200 m (the radius of the space station, assuming a diameter of 400 meters)
omega = v/r = 44.4 m/s / 200 m = 0.222 radians per second
Convert the angular velocity from radians per second to rotations per hour:
1 rotation = 2pi radians (360 degrees is equivalent to 2pi radians)
3600 seconds per hour = 1 hour
omega (rotations per hour) = 0.222 radians per second * 1 hour / 3600 seconds per hour * 2*pi radians/rotation = 0.159 rotations per hour
This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 0.159 rotations, or one rotation every 6.2 hours.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
[If you walk through it one step at a time, it however sees what's gone wrong.]
mannyrayner: You say the rotational rate is 0.222 radians per second. So how many seconds for one rotation?
ChatGPT: If the angular velocity of the space station is 0.222 radians per second, then it would take approximately 4.5 seconds to complete one rotation.
To calculate the time it takes for the space station to make one rotation, we can divide the number of radians in one full rotation by the angular velocity in radians per second. Since there are 2pi radians in one full rotation (360 degrees is equivalent to 2pi radians), it would take the space station approximately 2*pi/0.222 = 4.5 seconds to make one full rotation.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: So if 4.5 seconds for one rotation, how many rotations per hour?
ChatGPT: If it takes the space station 4.5 seconds to make one rotation and we want to know how many rotations it makes per hour, we can use the equation rotations per hour = (3600 seconds per hour) / (seconds per rotation).
Plugging in the values we know, we find that the number of rotations per hour is approximately:
rotations per hour = (3600 seconds per hour) / (4.5 seconds per rotation) = 800 rotations per hour
This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 800 rotations per hour.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: That is not the answer you got first time! Can you see what you did wrong then?
ChatGPT: You are correct that the initial calculation for the number of rotations per hour did not yield the correct result. I apologize for any confusion this may have caused.
[It's shameless. This machine will go far.]
_______________________
[And a little later (see message #1 below):]
mannyrayner: I posted this conversation on the web, and my online friend Thomas said:
.222 radian per second is 4.5 seconds per radian, not per 2 pi radians. Shocking it can't do arithmetic.
How do you respond?
ChatGPT: I apologize for any confusion caused by my previous response. You are correct that 0.222 radians per second is equivalent to 4.5 seconds per radian, not per full rotation (2*pi radians).
To calculate the time it takes for the space station to make one full rotation, we would need to divide the number of radians in one full rotation (2*pi) by the angular velocity in radians per second (0.222). This would give us the time it takes for the space station to make one rotation, which is approximately 4.5 seconds.
I apologize for any mistake in my previous response. I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Wait a minute. Check what you get when you divide 2*pi by 0.222. Think step by step.
ChatGPT: Certainly! Here is the calculation for the time it takes for the space station to make one full rotation, step by step:
Calculate the angular velocity in radians per second:
omega = 0.222 radians per second (the angular velocity we calculated earlier)
Calculate the time it takes for the space station to make one full rotation:
1 rotation = 2pi radians (360 degrees is equivalent to 2pi radians)
time per rotation = 2*pi radians / 0.222 radians per second = 8.99 seconds
This means that if the space station were rotating at an angular velocity of 0.222 radians per second, it would take approximately 8.99 seconds to make one full rotation.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Ah, so Thomas was right to query you then? Do you have a message for him?
ChatGPT: I apologize for any confusion caused by my previous responses. You are correct that my initial calculation for the time it takes for the space station to make one full rotation was incorrect. I apologize for any mistake in my previous response. Thank you for bringing this to my attention and for helping to clarify the calculation.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation and answers any questions you or your online friend Thomas may have had. Please don't hesitate to let me know if you have any further questions.
Discussing the following physics problem with ChatGPT, it seems to me that we are making strong progress towards realising Bill's goal, if indeed we haven't already got there. The machine is so extraordinarily like a confused human student that I'm not sure I could tell them apart.
Bill's comment was of course meant to be funny, but as so often is the case it's funny because it's saying something serious in an unexpected way. To reach true intelligence, you typically need to take a route that goes through stupidity, trying ways of thinking that don't work to find the ones that do. Chat seems to have progressed a long way down this route.
If you've ever done any elementary physics coaching, read the dialogue and judge for yourself.]
mannyrayner: How rapidly does the space station in the movie 2001 need to rotate in order to maintain one Earth gravity at the perimeter? Think step by step.
ChatGPT: To determine the rotational speed of the space station in the movie 2001 needed to simulate Earth-like gravity, you would need to consider the following:
The radius of the space station: The larger the radius of the space station, the slower it would need to rotate in order to simulate Earth-like gravity.
The mass of the space station: The greater the mass of the space station, the stronger the gravitational force it would exert, and the slower it would need to rotate in order to simulate Earth-like gravity.
The gravitational acceleration of Earth: Earth's gravitational acceleration is 9.8 m/s^2. To simulate this level of gravitational acceleration at the perimeter of the space station, the station would need to rotate at a certain speed.
The equation for centripetal acceleration: You can use the equation a = v^2/r to calculate the necessary rotational speed of the space station, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
By substituting in the known values for gravitational acceleration and radius, and solving for v, you can determine the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter.
mannyrayner: And what is the approximate radius of the space station in that movie?
ChatGPT: It's difficult for me to say exactly what the radius of the space station in the movie 2001: A Space Odyssey is, as it is a work of science fiction and the dimensions of the space station are not explicitly stated in the film. However, the space station is depicted as a large, wheel-shaped structure with a diameter of around 400 meters. If we assume that the space station is shaped like a cylinder, with the radius being half of the diameter, then the radius of the space station would be around 200 meters. However, it's worth noting that this is just an approximation and the actual radius of the space station in the movie may be different.
mannyrayner: Okay, so if we say the diameter of the space station is 400 meters, which seems reasonable to me, how fast does it need to rotate to obtain one Earth gravity at the perimeter due to centripetal acceleration?
ChatGPT: To determine the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter, we can use the equation a = v^2/r, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
If we assume that the space station has a diameter of 400 meters, and therefore a radius of 200 meters, and that we want to simulate Earth's gravitational acceleration of 9.8 m/s^2 at the perimeter of the space station, we can plug these values into the equation as follows:
a = 9.8 m/s^2
r = 200 m
Solving for v, we find that the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is approximately 4.9 m/s.
It's worth noting that this is just a rough estimate, and the actual rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter of the space station in the movie 2001: A Space Odyssey may be different due to factors such as the mass of the space station and any additional acceleration or deceleration that may occur within the station.
mannyrayner: So how many rotations an hour would it make if that estimate is correct?
ChatGPT: If the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is approximately 4.9 m/s, as we calculated earlier, and we want to know how many rotations the space station would make per hour, we can use the equation v = r * omega, where v is the velocity, r is the radius of the space station, and omega is the angular velocity in radians per second.
If we rearrange the equation to solve for omega, we find that the angular velocity in radians per second is equal to v/r. Since we want to know the angular velocity in rotations per hour, we can convert the units of radians per second to rotations per hour by multiplying by the conversion factor 2*pi/3600 seconds per hour.
Plugging in the values we know, we find that the angular velocity of the space station in rotations per hour is approximately 0.0162 rotations per hour. This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 0.0162 rotations, or one rotation every 61.5 hours.
[This can't possibly be right: if you've seen the movie, you know the space station is rotating far more quickly. Something has gone wrong, but Chat is oblivious.]
mannyrayner: Please do that calculation step by step.
ChatGPT: Certainly! Here is the calculation for the angular velocity of the space station in rotations per hour, step by step:
Calculate the angular velocity in radians per second:
v = 4.9 m/s (the rotational speed we calculated earlier)
r = 200 m (the radius of the space station, assuming a diameter of 400 meters)
omega = v/r = 4.9 m/s / 200 m = 0.025 radians per second
Convert the angular velocity from radians per second to rotations per hour:
1 rotation = 2pi radians (360 degrees is equivalent to 2pi radians)
3600 seconds per hour = 1 hour
omega (rotations per hour) = 0.025 radians per second * 1 hour / 3600 seconds per hour * 2*pi radians/rotation = 0.0162 rotations per hour
This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 0.0162 rotations, or one rotation every 61.5 hours.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
[I realised that it had screwed up earlier and I hadn't been paying attention. That will teach me to trust a cutting-edge AI.]
mannyrayner: Wait a minute. Derive the figure of 4.9 m/s for the rotational speed step by step.
ChatGPT: Certainly! Here is the calculation for the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter, step by step:
Determine the desired gravitational acceleration:
a = 9.8 m/s^2 (Earth's gravitational acceleration)
Use the equation for centripetal acceleration to calculate the rotational speed needed:
a = v^2/r
r = 200 m (the radius of the space station, assuming a diameter of 400 meters)
Solving for v, we find that the rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is:
v = sqrt(a*r) = sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m) = 4.9 m/s
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Do the last step again?
ChatGPT: Certainly! To calculate the rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter of the space station, we can use the equation a = v^2/r, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
If we assume that the space station has a radius of 200 meters and that we want to simulate Earth's gravitational acceleration of 9.8 m/s^2 at the perimeter of the space station, we can plug these values into the equation as follows:
a = 9.8 m/s^2
r = 200 m
Solving for v, we find that the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is:
v = sqrt(a*r) = sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m) = 4.9 m/s
This means that the space station would need to rotate at a speed of approximately 4.9 meters per second in order to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Could you check the last step, where you get v from a and r?
ChatGPT: Certainly! To calculate the rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter of the space station, we can use the equation a = v^2/r, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
If we assume that the space station has a radius of 200 meters and that we want to simulate Earth's gravitational acceleration of 9.8 m/s^2 at the perimeter of the space station, we can plug these values into the equation as follows:
a = 9.8 m/s^2
r = 200 m
Solving for v, we find that the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is:
v = sqrt(a*r) = sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m) = 4.9 m/s
This means that the space station would need to rotate at a speed of approximately 4.9 meters per second in order to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: What is sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m)?
[Whatever has it done here? I asked it to check and just got some mansplaining.]
ChatGPT: The square root of 9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m is approximately 4.9 m/s.
The square root of a number is a value that, when multiplied by itself, gives the original number. For example, the square root of 4 is 2, because 2 * 2 = 4.
In this case, we are taking the square root of the product of 9.8 m/s^2 and 200 m, which is equal to 4.9 m/s. This value represents the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter, as calculated using the equation a = v^2/r, where a is the gravitational acceleration, v is the rotational speed, and r is the radius of the space station.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Should you not take the square root of 9.8 * 200?
[Ahem.]
ChatGPT: You are correct that the square root of 9.8 * 200 would be the correct calculation to determine the rotational speed needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter of the space station.
The equation a = v^2/r can be used to calculate the rotational speed needed to simulate a particular gravitational acceleration at a given radius. In this case, we are assuming that the space station has a radius of 200 meters and that we want to simulate Earth's gravitational acceleration of 9.8 m/s^2 at the perimeter of the space station.
Plugging these values into the equation, we find that the rotational speed needed is:
v = sqrt(a*r) = sqrt(9.8 m/s^2 * 200 m) = sqrt(1960) = 44.4 m/s
I apologize for the mistake in my previous response. I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
[One problem fixed, but we aren't there yet.]
mannyrayner: That seems more plausible! So in that case, how many rotations per hour?
ChatGPT: If the rotational speed of the space station needed to simulate Earth-like gravity at the perimeter is 44.4 m/s, as we calculated earlier, and we want to know how many rotations the space station would make per hour, we can use the equation v = r * omega, where v is the velocity, r is the radius of the space station, and omega is the angular velocity in radians per second.
If we rearrange the equation to solve for omega, we find that the angular velocity in radians per second is equal to v/r. Since we want to know the angular velocity in rotations per hour, we can convert the units of radians per second to rotations per hour by multiplying by the conversion factor 2*pi/3600 seconds per hour.
Plugging in the values we know, we find that the angular velocity of the space station in rotations per hour is approximately 0.159 rotations per hour. This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 0.159 rotations, or one rotation every 6.2 hours.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
[Chat is still confused about how to do this conversion.]
mannyrayner: Please do that step by step?
ChatGPT: Certainly! Here is the calculation for the angular velocity of the space station in rotations per hour, step by step:
Calculate the angular velocity in radians per second:
v = 44.4 m/s (the rotational speed we calculated earlier)
r = 200 m (the radius of the space station, assuming a diameter of 400 meters)
omega = v/r = 44.4 m/s / 200 m = 0.222 radians per second
Convert the angular velocity from radians per second to rotations per hour:
1 rotation = 2pi radians (360 degrees is equivalent to 2pi radians)
3600 seconds per hour = 1 hour
omega (rotations per hour) = 0.222 radians per second * 1 hour / 3600 seconds per hour * 2*pi radians/rotation = 0.159 rotations per hour
This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 0.159 rotations, or one rotation every 6.2 hours.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
[If you walk through it one step at a time, it however sees what's gone wrong.]
mannyrayner: You say the rotational rate is 0.222 radians per second. So how many seconds for one rotation?
ChatGPT: If the angular velocity of the space station is 0.222 radians per second, then it would take approximately 4.5 seconds to complete one rotation.
To calculate the time it takes for the space station to make one rotation, we can divide the number of radians in one full rotation by the angular velocity in radians per second. Since there are 2pi radians in one full rotation (360 degrees is equivalent to 2pi radians), it would take the space station approximately 2*pi/0.222 = 4.5 seconds to make one full rotation.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: So if 4.5 seconds for one rotation, how many rotations per hour?
ChatGPT: If it takes the space station 4.5 seconds to make one rotation and we want to know how many rotations it makes per hour, we can use the equation rotations per hour = (3600 seconds per hour) / (seconds per rotation).
Plugging in the values we know, we find that the number of rotations per hour is approximately:
rotations per hour = (3600 seconds per hour) / (4.5 seconds per rotation) = 800 rotations per hour
This means that if the space station were rotating at this speed, it would make approximately 800 rotations per hour.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: That is not the answer you got first time! Can you see what you did wrong then?
ChatGPT: You are correct that the initial calculation for the number of rotations per hour did not yield the correct result. I apologize for any confusion this may have caused.
[It's shameless. This machine will go far.]
_______________________
[And a little later (see message #1 below):]
mannyrayner: I posted this conversation on the web, and my online friend Thomas said:
.222 radian per second is 4.5 seconds per radian, not per 2 pi radians. Shocking it can't do arithmetic.
How do you respond?
ChatGPT: I apologize for any confusion caused by my previous response. You are correct that 0.222 radians per second is equivalent to 4.5 seconds per radian, not per full rotation (2*pi radians).
To calculate the time it takes for the space station to make one full rotation, we would need to divide the number of radians in one full rotation (2*pi) by the angular velocity in radians per second (0.222). This would give us the time it takes for the space station to make one rotation, which is approximately 4.5 seconds.
I apologize for any mistake in my previous response. I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Wait a minute. Check what you get when you divide 2*pi by 0.222. Think step by step.
ChatGPT: Certainly! Here is the calculation for the time it takes for the space station to make one full rotation, step by step:
Calculate the angular velocity in radians per second:
omega = 0.222 radians per second (the angular velocity we calculated earlier)
Calculate the time it takes for the space station to make one full rotation:
1 rotation = 2pi radians (360 degrees is equivalent to 2pi radians)
time per rotation = 2*pi radians / 0.222 radians per second = 8.99 seconds
This means that if the space station were rotating at an angular velocity of 0.222 radians per second, it would take approximately 8.99 seconds to make one full rotation.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation! Let me know if you have any further questions.
mannyrayner: Ah, so Thomas was right to query you then? Do you have a message for him?
ChatGPT: I apologize for any confusion caused by my previous responses. You are correct that my initial calculation for the time it takes for the space station to make one full rotation was incorrect. I apologize for any mistake in my previous response. Thank you for bringing this to my attention and for helping to clarify the calculation.
I hope this helps clarify the calculation and answers any questions you or your online friend Thomas may have had. Please don't hesitate to let me know if you have any further questions.
Displaying 1 of 1 review