What do you think?
Rate this book
Shadow Skye #2
The Broken Raven
In the heart-pounding second book in the Shadow Skye trilogy, unlikely heroes Agatha and Jaime must fight for their clan’s home when a new danger comes to the Isle of Skye.
After their escape from Norveg, Agatha and Jaime return with their clan to the Isle of Skye to find that their enclave is now in the hands of the treacherous people of Raasay. They find tenuous shelter with another clan, but disaster soon strikes when the terrifying shadow creatures known as sgàilean escape their magical prison and wreak havoc across the island. Now Agatha and Jaime must call on old and new allies to fight this threat. In the meantime, a ship from Norveg sails for the court of King Edmund of Ingland, where a dangerous alliance is forming, and Sigrid, a girl with an extraordinary memory, works to free herself from the clutches of a cruel king. All three protagonists must summon their particular powers to save the island from the horde of dark creatures and foil the plans of two vengeful monarchs.
After their escape from Norveg, Agatha and Jaime return with their clan to the Isle of Skye to find that their enclave is now in the hands of the treacherous people of Raasay. They find tenuous shelter with another clan, but disaster soon strikes when the terrifying shadow creatures known as sgàilean escape their magical prison and wreak havoc across the island. Now Agatha and Jaime must call on old and new allies to fight this threat. In the meantime, a ship from Norveg sails for the court of King Edmund of Ingland, where a dangerous alliance is forming, and Sigrid, a girl with an extraordinary memory, works to free herself from the clutches of a cruel king. All three protagonists must summon their particular powers to save the island from the horde of dark creatures and foil the plans of two vengeful monarchs.
336 pages, Hardcover
First published January 21, 2021
13 people are currently reading
587 people want to read
About the author
Joseph Elliott
28 books61 followersJoseph Elliott is a writer, teacher, and actor known for his work in children’s television. The Good Hawk is his first book. He lives in London.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews
December 10, 2021
4/5
Os traigo mis impresiones de La niña cuervo, segunda parte de la trilogía iniciada con La niña halcón , escrita por Joseph Elliot y publicada por parte de @grantravesia 🌙
No voy a comentar mucho de la trama ya que es una segunda parte y no quiero desvelar nada pero os digo que sigue en la misma línea que el primero: muchas aventuras, mucha historia y toques de magia y fantasía. La verdad es que estoy totalmente enamorada de la ambientación de esta historia, en la isla de Skye, en Noruega e Inglaterra...como se nos presentan las formas de vida de los clanes que allí habitaban...adoro la época histórica y considero que está muy bien representada.
Agatha es una niña especial y es que tiene Síndrome de Down, algo que en aquella época no se conocía y veremos cómo algunas personas de los clanes la menosprecian por sentir que ella es rara. Me encanta la inclusión de un personaje de este estilo y es imposible no encariñarse con ella.
La trama está llena de aventuras y estoy deseando saber que va a pasar en el último libro, el final ha sido trepidante 😍 le he dado una nota de 8/10
-https://www.instagram.com/p/CXRfd6oMzWS/
Os traigo mis impresiones de La niña cuervo, segunda parte de la trilogía iniciada con La niña halcón , escrita por Joseph Elliot y publicada por parte de @grantravesia 🌙
No voy a comentar mucho de la trama ya que es una segunda parte y no quiero desvelar nada pero os digo que sigue en la misma línea que el primero: muchas aventuras, mucha historia y toques de magia y fantasía. La verdad es que estoy totalmente enamorada de la ambientación de esta historia, en la isla de Skye, en Noruega e Inglaterra...como se nos presentan las formas de vida de los clanes que allí habitaban...adoro la época histórica y considero que está muy bien representada.
Agatha es una niña especial y es que tiene Síndrome de Down, algo que en aquella época no se conocía y veremos cómo algunas personas de los clanes la menosprecian por sentir que ella es rara. Me encanta la inclusión de un personaje de este estilo y es imposible no encariñarse con ella.
La trama está llena de aventuras y estoy deseando saber que va a pasar en el último libro, el final ha sido trepidante 😍 le he dado una nota de 8/10
-https://www.instagram.com/p/CXRfd6oMzWS/
February 9, 2021
I was sent a galley of this book from the publisher.
In this second book in the trilogy, Agatha and Jaime are home on the Island of Skye again, but all is not well. A rival clan has taken over the holding. Their own clan is forced to share a village with other people, and the confines are causing tensions to escalate. When the shadow creatures that helped them defeat the Norveg are released on Skye, everyone on the island is in peril. Agatha does her part to help at home--in her wonderful Agatha way--while Jaime ventures to Scotia to seek out the maker of the shadows. Meanwhile, a third child is introduced: Sigrid of the Norveg. Enslaved to her king, she is taken to Ingland, where the royals plot to put an end to the Scotian menace once and for all...
This book is quite fun but I had to remind myself to regard this as a secondary world setting, not something that was historical with magic and alt history. This is its own world. If you get too caught up in wondering about the geography or how a grown man can ride an elk, the joy will be lost. There's a lot of joy here, too, dark as the tale can be at times. I continue to adore Agatha--it's wonderful to see a child-hero inspired by children with Down syndrome! She's impulsive and brash but always means well, and I enjoyed seeing her friendship with Aileen develop. Jaime's adventure is wonderful; readers of the first book will be happy to know that Cray returns! The new perspective, Sigrid, is great, adding more humanity to the 'bad guys' of book one.
This is fantasy-adventure book is a very fast read. There is death and danger at every turn, but there's also a pervading sense of friendship and hope. I would have loved these books at age 12, and I still love them now.
In this second book in the trilogy, Agatha and Jaime are home on the Island of Skye again, but all is not well. A rival clan has taken over the holding. Their own clan is forced to share a village with other people, and the confines are causing tensions to escalate. When the shadow creatures that helped them defeat the Norveg are released on Skye, everyone on the island is in peril. Agatha does her part to help at home--in her wonderful Agatha way--while Jaime ventures to Scotia to seek out the maker of the shadows. Meanwhile, a third child is introduced: Sigrid of the Norveg. Enslaved to her king, she is taken to Ingland, where the royals plot to put an end to the Scotian menace once and for all...
This book is quite fun but I had to remind myself to regard this as a secondary world setting, not something that was historical with magic and alt history. This is its own world. If you get too caught up in wondering about the geography or how a grown man can ride an elk, the joy will be lost. There's a lot of joy here, too, dark as the tale can be at times. I continue to adore Agatha--it's wonderful to see a child-hero inspired by children with Down syndrome! She's impulsive and brash but always means well, and I enjoyed seeing her friendship with Aileen develop. Jaime's adventure is wonderful; readers of the first book will be happy to know that Cray returns! The new perspective, Sigrid, is great, adding more humanity to the 'bad guys' of book one.
This is fantasy-adventure book is a very fast read. There is death and danger at every turn, but there's also a pervading sense of friendship and hope. I would have loved these books at age 12, and I still love them now.
January 3, 2021
*This arc was sent to me by the publisher to give an honest review in return*
I liked this book. It takes place after the first book so I won't say the summary. This was a great book but not as great as the first one in my opinion. The writing was still great and all but I there wasn't as much of action and that same feeling from the first book. I did like the new story and learning more about the other worlds then Agatha and Jamie's clans.
The characerts are still the same with some new characters that come along the way. I didn't feel as connected with them but still enjoyed reading about them. In this book, I would say that Jamie is the main and leading character then Agatha is. I enjoy Jamie's pov so I didn't mind it as much and enjoyed seeing he growth throughout the book. He has just a hard journey in this book trying to save his clan. I love Sigrid who is a new character and can't wait to see more of her story in the third book. The side characters in this book were amazing and so were the antagonists.
The ending was not my favorite but I think it's because the author is going to pick it up for the third book. I wonder is Agatha would be turned into a side character because her misson feels completed to me. I did have some problems like with the action, characters, and writing but I feel readers will still like this book. So don't let me keep you away after reading this review. I can't wait for book three to come out just to see how the story ends.
I liked this book. It takes place after the first book so I won't say the summary. This was a great book but not as great as the first one in my opinion. The writing was still great and all but I there wasn't as much of action and that same feeling from the first book. I did like the new story and learning more about the other worlds then Agatha and Jamie's clans.
The characerts are still the same with some new characters that come along the way. I didn't feel as connected with them but still enjoyed reading about them. In this book, I would say that Jamie is the main and leading character then Agatha is. I enjoy Jamie's pov so I didn't mind it as much and enjoyed seeing he growth throughout the book. He has just a hard journey in this book trying to save his clan. I love Sigrid who is a new character and can't wait to see more of her story in the third book. The side characters in this book were amazing and so were the antagonists.
The ending was not my favorite but I think it's because the author is going to pick it up for the third book. I wonder is Agatha would be turned into a side character because her misson feels completed to me. I did have some problems like with the action, characters, and writing but I feel readers will still like this book. So don't let me keep you away after reading this review. I can't wait for book three to come out just to see how the story ends.
May 12, 2023
I just- I love this book but bc I just finished it I can't think of a good review. I just need to say this: I think more people need to hear about it, it's just so magical in it's own sense.
It has all the things I love about a fantasy book and the pacing is soo perfect.
I'll have more to say this when my brain starts working again. For now, I'm ordering the Burning Swift. I need to know what comes next!!!
It has all the things I love about a fantasy book and the pacing is soo perfect.
I'll have more to say this when my brain starts working again. For now, I'm ordering the Burning Swift. I need to know what comes next!!!
September 23, 2020
ARC provided by Candlewick Press and Joseph Elliott via NetGalley. All opinions are mine and freely given.
Blog | Instagram | Twitter | Facebook | BookBub
09-22: 'The Broken Raven,' book two in the Shadow Skye trilogy by Joseph Elliott, mainly follows the journeys of three characters.. Agatha and Jamie of the Clann-a-Tuath and Sigrid a girl hailing from a far away group they refer to as 'deamhan.'
After having barely escaped Norveg after a vicious war, Agatha and Jamie return with their clan to the Isle of Skye to find their enclave lost to the people of Raasay. Temporarily taking up with another clan they freed in the process, their welcome is unstable at best. The leader and other elders openly debating whether or not they should be allowed to continue staying, aided in a bid to recapture their home, or just pushed out to fend for themselves.
Deception leads to the escape of dangerous shadow creatures called sgàilean from their magical prison, leaving everyone in Skye at risk of death. As Agatha and Jamie take different paths in hopes of saving lives, the stakes are rising elsewhere.
Sigrid, a girl with a wildly independent streak and a seemingly eidetic memory who's sold off by her mother to the cruel king of their lands, finds herself in the neighboring court of King Edmund of Ingland. Witness to the intricacies of a deadly alliance as it's birthed, she agrees to try to stop what's coming.. the genocide of those residing in Skye.
Admittedly, I felt like this story started out really awkwardly. After reading for awhile, I understood it was the author's way of infusing the characters not only with their distinguishable personalities, but also defining the people they came from. He was establishing a complete culture from their traditions to their social structures to their languages.
Truth be told, I even adjusted to them all bit by bit, but some were more difficult than others. Created languages sometimes just mess with my immersion, but that's a personal thing and I can't take away from the author for using them where they work well to indicate education levels, ages, and in this case even a wonderfully neuro-diverse heroine.
As for the story itself, I'm a bit conflicted. I think there were things the author did really well, such as the management of multiple narrators and the visual construction of the region of the world where the people lived. I could see it all mapped out so clearly, even with the travel across the seas connecting their villages.. and mad dash across vast lands to the Isle of Skye.
The main characters are all likeable enough. I was kind of fond of Jamie and definitely had a grudging respect for Sigrid and Agatha. I even rather liked one of the villains, the king of Norveg.. though I know I shouldn't have, still.. I enjoyed the fact he was multi-dimensional in nature.
Overall, though a lot of little things occurred, it just didn't feel like the scope of the tale was that broad. I would have liked to see more development with Jamie and the Bo Riders.. one in particular. And I think resolutions were sometimes had with a proverbial flick of a wrist, despite the length of time they might be spread over.
Certainly worth a read just for the more unusual elements alone.
PRE-ORDER LINKS: AMAZON | BARNES & NOBLE | BOOK DEPOSITORY | BOOKSAMILLION | GOOGLEPLAY BOOKS | INDIGO | KOBO | WATERSTONES
June 13, 2022
This is very much the dark middle book of a trilogy. There's a lot of angst, uncertainty, and betrayal. I felt like it wasn't as interesting or innovative as the first book, and they way Sigrid's dialect was written drove me absolutely bonkers.
January 7, 2021
The Broken Raven takes place shortly after the events of The Good Hawk – Jaime, Agatha, Clann-a-Tuath, and Clann-na-Bruthaich are all struggling in various ways with their return home. Through the trials of attempting to regain their enclave from the Raasay people, Jaime and Agatha rely upon faces we’ve encountered before and new ones. I was glad to see the Bo Riders return, although not to the extent of the first novel. I was able to read the second book just as fast as the first; the action was reasonably constant, and switching between POV’s and their situations wasn’t grinding. There are a couple of other things I am interested in learning more about: the King of Norveg’s brother and the role he might play and the history of Skye and Inglund, specifically what the King of Inglund did to his own realm to achieve his goal.
This book is nearly three separate journeys – though their paths do merge. While unexpected, it was a welcome change that each protagonist stood on their own without the other main character’s support. It also allowed other side characters to shine and fill out the story more than they did in the previous book. I feel like Agatha took a backseat in this book and the trials she faces in this book were just less even though she grew as a person and learned some important lessons along the way. Jaime seems to have fallen into melancholy and believes he should look and feel more like a hero than he does – he doesn’t seem to realize that cunning counts as well. The Broken Raven also introduces a new main character – Sigrid, a young dreamhain from Norveg. She is rough and callused, it took me a little while to appreciate her, she became my favorite – I grew to enjoy her point of view and her often comical descriptions of things. Even though she was dealt a terrible hand she is willing to accept it for now without letting it destroy her outlook on life. If I were in her place, I would have more than likely made the same choices.
The ending of The Broken Raven was as unexpected as it was sudden. I knew the book wouldn’t solve everything, alas I wasn’t overly happy with the state of the issues at the end. I will wholeheartedly and anxiously be awaiting the final book in the trilogy, and even with the ending, I am excited to see what transpires. I would highly recommend this book (and series) to those who enjoy neurodiverse characters, mild LGBTQ+ elements, found family, fantasy/historical fantasy, middle grade, and animals. I would also recommend starting with The Good Hawk (you can read my review on the blog as well) – quite a bit of background information would be lost starting with this book first. A big thank you to Candlewick Press, Joseph Elliot, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read a digital ARC of The Broken Raven – all opinions are my own.
This book is nearly three separate journeys – though their paths do merge. While unexpected, it was a welcome change that each protagonist stood on their own without the other main character’s support. It also allowed other side characters to shine and fill out the story more than they did in the previous book. I feel like Agatha took a backseat in this book and the trials she faces in this book were just less even though she grew as a person and learned some important lessons along the way. Jaime seems to have fallen into melancholy and believes he should look and feel more like a hero than he does – he doesn’t seem to realize that cunning counts as well. The Broken Raven also introduces a new main character – Sigrid, a young dreamhain from Norveg. She is rough and callused, it took me a little while to appreciate her, she became my favorite – I grew to enjoy her point of view and her often comical descriptions of things. Even though she was dealt a terrible hand she is willing to accept it for now without letting it destroy her outlook on life. If I were in her place, I would have more than likely made the same choices.
The ending of The Broken Raven was as unexpected as it was sudden. I knew the book wouldn’t solve everything, alas I wasn’t overly happy with the state of the issues at the end. I will wholeheartedly and anxiously be awaiting the final book in the trilogy, and even with the ending, I am excited to see what transpires. I would highly recommend this book (and series) to those who enjoy neurodiverse characters, mild LGBTQ+ elements, found family, fantasy/historical fantasy, middle grade, and animals. I would also recommend starting with The Good Hawk (you can read my review on the blog as well) – quite a bit of background information would be lost starting with this book first. A big thank you to Candlewick Press, Joseph Elliot, and NetGalley for the opportunity to read a digital ARC of The Broken Raven – all opinions are my own.
September 5, 2022
Como sucedió al leer el primer libro, este fue una nueva sorpresa. En donde disfruté la lectura de sus personajes y que los tintes se tornen algo más oscuros. Recalco una vez más a sus personajes. Lejos de lo que estamos acostumbrados como lectoras al entrar a un mundo fantástico, pero a su vez muy familiar. Posee inclusión en todas partes y eso es algo que valoro demasiado. Con desarrollo de inicio a fin, atravesando una aventura fantástica en donde revelan sus lados bondadosos y valientes. Es imposible no encariñarse. Además de que hay nuevos personajes (ejem Sigrid te amo). Al ser capítulos divididos en personajes, se llega a conocer sus puntos de vista. Siendo estos cortos y entretenidos. Haciendo que la lectura dea llevadera. Cuándo hay varios puntos de vista, a veces puede ser confuso, pero no es el caso ya que no pierde el foco en las subtramas, sino que aporta a un bien mayor. Se trabaja tensiones, magia y una aventura que se disfruta. Te mantiene enganchado, es una novela llevadera y que merece más reconocimiento.
December 2, 2020
This book was received as an ARC from Candlewick Press - Walker Books US in exchange for an honest review. Opinions and thoughts expressed in this review are completely my own.
I was absolutely mesmerized by this book. I was nervous at first going into this book after learning the fact that it is book 2 of the Shadow Skye series and having not read The Good Hawk, I was nervous I would not understand parts of the story but boy was I wrong. After reading the first few chapters I was hooked and did not want to stop reading, All of the action, adventure, relationships, and drama just made you want to take a break and escape from reality. Also along for the ride, I could not help but get a little dungeons and dragons vibe from this book and if The Good Hawk has anything like that, I know I will be in for quite the ride. It is definitely a page-turning adventure and it will leave you finished when you are done.
We will consider adding this title to our YA collection at our library. That is why we give this book 5 stars.
I was absolutely mesmerized by this book. I was nervous at first going into this book after learning the fact that it is book 2 of the Shadow Skye series and having not read The Good Hawk, I was nervous I would not understand parts of the story but boy was I wrong. After reading the first few chapters I was hooked and did not want to stop reading, All of the action, adventure, relationships, and drama just made you want to take a break and escape from reality. Also along for the ride, I could not help but get a little dungeons and dragons vibe from this book and if The Good Hawk has anything like that, I know I will be in for quite the ride. It is definitely a page-turning adventure and it will leave you finished when you are done.
We will consider adding this title to our YA collection at our library. That is why we give this book 5 stars.
March 17, 2021
2.5 stars
November 2, 2023
This was once again a very enjoyable read!
August 3, 2021
The Broken Raven is told in the alternating narratives of Agatha, Jaime and newcomer Sigrid. Each of their storylines take them in different directions with new obstacles for each them to face. Jaime is reunited with the Bo Riders and encounters a new creature (Imitator's) while trying to locate Budhbh. Agatha is assisted by Aileen, Jaime's friend, in making their way to The Raasay, but are held prisoner when The Raasay refuse to believe they're in danger. Sigrid is under constant watch by Konge Grimr's men, who despise and want to off her any chance they get. When Lady Beatrice offers her the opportunity to escape in exchange for warning the Isle of Skye about the king of Ingland and Konge's plans, she doesn't hesitate. However, escape for her will lead to one challenge after another, as Konge Grimr's has sent his most trusted man to hunt her down and bring her back to him at any cost. I quite enjoyed the inclusion of Sigrid into the story, it changed things in an exceptional way. Sigrid is determined, and her enhanced memory adds humor and certainly danger. While the story ended on a cliffhanger, I am even more excited to read The Burning Swift next. I'd be remiss if I didn't mention the talented artists who created the covers of Good Hawk and The Broken Raven, the illustrations were designed by twins Anna and Elena Balbusso, I just love how they so beautifully capture the essence of the story. **A huge thank you to Raquel Stecher from Candlewick Press for the hardback copy in exchange for a review**
January 13, 2021
The Broken Raven is book two in a trilogy, and you definitely want to read The Good Hawk first. The Good Hawk introduces us to Agatha and Jamie and their world. But even though they've rescued their kidnapped clan and returned to the Isle of Sky, they haven't managed to reclaim their homes yet. Tensions rise between their clan and their host clan, culminating in the release of the shadow creatures, who are no longer under any orders to spare their clan after the death of the Mad Queen. Once again, it falls to Agatha and Jamie to fight for their friends and their home. We're also introduced to Sigrid, a member of the clan who kidnapped Agatha and Jamie's clan in book 1, and an even greater threat that will loom over the Isle of Sky in the third book.
Once again, the action is nonstop. The characters have several quests to fulfill over the course of the book, and make old allies and new. I was excited that we got to spend some time with Cray and the Bo Riders again, and learn more about the King of England's motivations for spreading the plague. This book expanded the world and left plenty of unanswered questions for the third book.
Thank you to LibraryThing and the publisher for an advance reading copy of this book.
Once again, the action is nonstop. The characters have several quests to fulfill over the course of the book, and make old allies and new. I was excited that we got to spend some time with Cray and the Bo Riders again, and learn more about the King of England's motivations for spreading the plague. This book expanded the world and left plenty of unanswered questions for the third book.
Thank you to LibraryThing and the publisher for an advance reading copy of this book.
August 1, 2020
I consider Good Hawk one of the best books I read in 2019. The Broken Raven doesn't disappoint at all. Storylines from the first book are continued while some new plot points are introduced making this every bit as action packed and fast moving as the first book. Elliott has set up a very cool last book for this trilogy that I can't wait to read.
December 29, 2020
ARC provided by Candlewick Press - Walker Books US
All thoughts and opinions are mine and freely given.
My reviews are honest and a representation of my feelings and my feelings only.
I do not receive any monetary compensation for my reviews by authors or publishers.
I did not love this nearly as much as the first book.
Not to say that this was bad in any way, it just wasn't on the same playing field for me.
The things I loved the most about the first novel were the characters, primarily Agatha, and the life and death stakes that were met at every turn.
Though the high stakes were still present, they merely felt like a series of events, ones I knew would be immediately conquered. The only real "struggle" that I truly felt on an emotional level was the scene between Sigrid and Bolverk on the ridge.
Agatha was the shining star in the first book and I came to love her dearly in the first book. In this one, I felt like she took a major back seat. The plots she was involved in were minor and solved quickly. She just felt like she was, for lack of a better term, less. I wanted more of her. I wanted her in the drivers seat like she was in The Good Hawk.
I am happy with Jaime's overall arc. From the beginning of book one, to where we leave him at the end of book two, he was grown substantially and I am very invested in him as a character and am greatly looking forward to seeing where he will go in book three. His journey is hard and he faces constant obstacles and always STRUGGLES and prevails.
The most enjoyable character and story line to me though, was one that not even I expected. Upon the first introduction to Sigrid, I for one WAS NOT a fan. Her tone was harsh and her dialect took getting used to, to say the least. However, she was what made me keep wanting to pick up the book. I wanted to see where she was and how far she'd come. Her story is raw, unfocused and real. Sometimes even she isn't sure of her motives or her path but she makes decisions with convictions and no matter how hard things became, she pushed herself through capabilities even she didn't know she possessed. The circumstances we leave her in at the end of the book has left me DESPERATE for the next book.
The entire King Edmund plot feels substantially convoluted to me. I'm intrigued to see where the boiling point between Norveg, Ingland, Scotia and Skye will be. Between book one and now book two we've been building and building to this ultimate high and things are going to hit hard in the finale. Though I was a little lost in the Kings' plans, I know for sure that the countries and characters will be forever changed by the course they've set forth.
My favorite aspect of book one continued on to be my favorite aspect of book two.
Joseph Elliott's writing is absolutely phenomenal. Not only am I looking forward to finishing this trilogy, but I can't wait to put my hands on anything else Elliott may write in the future.
All thoughts and opinions are mine and freely given.
My reviews are honest and a representation of my feelings and my feelings only.
I do not receive any monetary compensation for my reviews by authors or publishers.
I did not love this nearly as much as the first book.
Not to say that this was bad in any way, it just wasn't on the same playing field for me.
The things I loved the most about the first novel were the characters, primarily Agatha, and the life and death stakes that were met at every turn.
Though the high stakes were still present, they merely felt like a series of events, ones I knew would be immediately conquered. The only real "struggle" that I truly felt on an emotional level was the scene between Sigrid and Bolverk on the ridge.
Agatha was the shining star in the first book and I came to love her dearly in the first book. In this one, I felt like she took a major back seat. The plots she was involved in were minor and solved quickly. She just felt like she was, for lack of a better term, less. I wanted more of her. I wanted her in the drivers seat like she was in The Good Hawk.
I am happy with Jaime's overall arc. From the beginning of book one, to where we leave him at the end of book two, he was grown substantially and I am very invested in him as a character and am greatly looking forward to seeing where he will go in book three. His journey is hard and he faces constant obstacles and always STRUGGLES and prevails.
The most enjoyable character and story line to me though, was one that not even I expected. Upon the first introduction to Sigrid, I for one WAS NOT a fan. Her tone was harsh and her dialect took getting used to, to say the least. However, she was what made me keep wanting to pick up the book. I wanted to see where she was and how far she'd come. Her story is raw, unfocused and real. Sometimes even she isn't sure of her motives or her path but she makes decisions with convictions and no matter how hard things became, she pushed herself through capabilities even she didn't know she possessed. The circumstances we leave her in at the end of the book has left me DESPERATE for the next book.
The entire King Edmund plot feels substantially convoluted to me. I'm intrigued to see where the boiling point between Norveg, Ingland, Scotia and Skye will be. Between book one and now book two we've been building and building to this ultimate high and things are going to hit hard in the finale. Though I was a little lost in the Kings' plans, I know for sure that the countries and characters will be forever changed by the course they've set forth.
My favorite aspect of book one continued on to be my favorite aspect of book two.
Joseph Elliott's writing is absolutely phenomenal. Not only am I looking forward to finishing this trilogy, but I can't wait to put my hands on anything else Elliott may write in the future.
February 24, 2021
After returning to Skye, Agatha and Jaime, along with the rest of their clan, are staying with the clan they were rescued with, the Clan-na-Bruthaich, as the treacherous members of the Raasay clan refuse to give them their enclave?! back. Shortly after, another disaster strikes when the shadow creatures known as sgàilean escape from their stolen necklace prison. Agatha and Jaime, with the help of some allies new and old, must use their courage again to help aid in this new fight.
All the while, a girl named Sigrid, who's chained to the king as his 'new eyes', set sail from Norveg to the court of King Edmund of Ingland, where a dangerous alliance begins. Sigrid, who has an extraordinary memory and a tattoo of a 'neck snapped raven' on her face, works to free herself from the king. She too finds allies in those unexpected but also discovers enemies as well.
All three protagonists must use their special powers to save those they care about from the planes of vengeful monarchs.
As from the book before, I absolutely loved this book. I'm slightly glad I waited as long as I did to read the first one because I was able to get this book shortly after finishing it. Now though, I've got to wait for the third book and that's going to be a killer! I was so fascinated with the land of Skye and it's people, as well as those of the bull rider's clan. Even though it's mythical, this still isn't a time period I read about frequently so it's an adventure to go on.
Both Agatha and Jaime are characters that put a smile on my face. I wasn't even 'away from them' long between reading the first and second book, and when I was first reintroduced to them this time around, I couldn't help but feeling like meeting old friends. The same honestly goes for re-meeting Cray as well (the relationship between Cray and Jaime makes me giggle at their bantering).
We meet Sigrid in this novel. A young deamhan, her mother pays someone, essentially under the table, to tattoo a raven on her face. The tattooist doesn't have the best talent and makes her raven look like it's got a broken neck. You learn a lot about Sigrid within the chapters of this book, and man, did I quickly care about her and her wellbeing. Joseph Elliott sure does show you both sides of a coin doesn't he? The deamhan people are the ones who kidnapped and enslaved the clans of Skye, yet Sigrid's granpa has taught her that's not how it should be. The way Elliott wrote her language was also unique and, after getting use to it, was an interesting voice to hear while reading.
This series has been creeping up in my Top 5 YA Series list. I'm excited and I can't wait until Book #3 to see where Joseph Elliott takes these characters.
All the while, a girl named Sigrid, who's chained to the king as his 'new eyes', set sail from Norveg to the court of King Edmund of Ingland, where a dangerous alliance begins. Sigrid, who has an extraordinary memory and a tattoo of a 'neck snapped raven' on her face, works to free herself from the king. She too finds allies in those unexpected but also discovers enemies as well.
All three protagonists must use their special powers to save those they care about from the planes of vengeful monarchs.
As from the book before, I absolutely loved this book. I'm slightly glad I waited as long as I did to read the first one because I was able to get this book shortly after finishing it. Now though, I've got to wait for the third book and that's going to be a killer! I was so fascinated with the land of Skye and it's people, as well as those of the bull rider's clan. Even though it's mythical, this still isn't a time period I read about frequently so it's an adventure to go on.
Both Agatha and Jaime are characters that put a smile on my face. I wasn't even 'away from them' long between reading the first and second book, and when I was first reintroduced to them this time around, I couldn't help but feeling like meeting old friends. The same honestly goes for re-meeting Cray as well (the relationship between Cray and Jaime makes me giggle at their bantering).
We meet Sigrid in this novel. A young deamhan, her mother pays someone, essentially under the table, to tattoo a raven on her face. The tattooist doesn't have the best talent and makes her raven look like it's got a broken neck. You learn a lot about Sigrid within the chapters of this book, and man, did I quickly care about her and her wellbeing. Joseph Elliott sure does show you both sides of a coin doesn't he? The deamhan people are the ones who kidnapped and enslaved the clans of Skye, yet Sigrid's granpa has taught her that's not how it should be. The way Elliott wrote her language was also unique and, after getting use to it, was an interesting voice to hear while reading.
This series has been creeping up in my Top 5 YA Series list. I'm excited and I can't wait until Book #3 to see where Joseph Elliott takes these characters.
January 19, 2021
Originally reviewed on Cyn's Workshop
The Broken Raven continues the journey of Agatha and Jamie as they return to their homeland. Unfortunately, their land is still taken over by those who betrayed them, forcing them to live in an enclave with the clave they saved from the hands of the cruel king of Norveg.
Interesting Writing
What was most interesting is the way Elliot decided to write the novel. Now, I am not a reader familiar with old English, Gaelic, or Celtic, but what I can say is it was a unique way that Elliot decided to tell the story. The language and style of writing caught me off guard only because I was not expecting it. It does not hinder the reading. Instead, it makes the story more accessible to the reader.
Elliot made a great decision with the writing, especially when you consider that the main character is autistic. The story is a breeze to read because it is engaging. However, the words and language are phonetically structured, the way it sounds, which is excellent because it will help people who have difficulty reading, and those just learning to read. Honestly, it made the style, while unpredictable, making reading more enjoyable.
Character Development
Now, what The Broken Raven did that The Good Hawk did not was give Jamie a chance to shine. Agatha still shines in this novel as much as the previous novel, which is remarkable for diversity and representation. Once again, it is great to see an autistic individual given a chance to shine in literature; it gives any readers out there an opportunity to see that society should not limit them and they can do whatever they set their minds to. It is empowering to see her respected for change.
However, for Jamie, he did not get a chance to shine so much in The Good Hawk, whereas now Elliot delved more into his growth as a hero and a character. Jamie and Agatha witnessed much death in the previous novel. With everything happening now, the rising tension with the Clan they saved, Jamie is trying to recover from the previous novel’s pain; he is learning to overcome his issues and the traumatic experiences while also learning to accept his sexuality. Elliot gives more time and devotion to growing out his characterization.
Final Thoughts
The Broken Raven is a captivating novel with an engaging plot and characterization while also being accessible for everyone.
See more reviews at Cyn's Workshop and follow me on Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | Tumblr | Spotify Podcast | YouTube | BookBub | Goodreads+ | LinkedIn
The Broken Raven continues the journey of Agatha and Jamie as they return to their homeland. Unfortunately, their land is still taken over by those who betrayed them, forcing them to live in an enclave with the clave they saved from the hands of the cruel king of Norveg.
Interesting Writing
What was most interesting is the way Elliot decided to write the novel. Now, I am not a reader familiar with old English, Gaelic, or Celtic, but what I can say is it was a unique way that Elliot decided to tell the story. The language and style of writing caught me off guard only because I was not expecting it. It does not hinder the reading. Instead, it makes the story more accessible to the reader.
Elliot made a great decision with the writing, especially when you consider that the main character is autistic. The story is a breeze to read because it is engaging. However, the words and language are phonetically structured, the way it sounds, which is excellent because it will help people who have difficulty reading, and those just learning to read. Honestly, it made the style, while unpredictable, making reading more enjoyable.
Character Development
Now, what The Broken Raven did that The Good Hawk did not was give Jamie a chance to shine. Agatha still shines in this novel as much as the previous novel, which is remarkable for diversity and representation. Once again, it is great to see an autistic individual given a chance to shine in literature; it gives any readers out there an opportunity to see that society should not limit them and they can do whatever they set their minds to. It is empowering to see her respected for change.
However, for Jamie, he did not get a chance to shine so much in The Good Hawk, whereas now Elliot delved more into his growth as a hero and a character. Jamie and Agatha witnessed much death in the previous novel. With everything happening now, the rising tension with the Clan they saved, Jamie is trying to recover from the previous novel’s pain; he is learning to overcome his issues and the traumatic experiences while also learning to accept his sexuality. Elliot gives more time and devotion to growing out his characterization.
Final Thoughts
The Broken Raven is a captivating novel with an engaging plot and characterization while also being accessible for everyone.
See more reviews at Cyn's Workshop and follow me on Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | Tumblr | Spotify Podcast | YouTube | BookBub | Goodreads+ | LinkedIn
January 3, 2021
See my full review here: https://www.yabookscentral.com/yafict...
THE BROKEN RAVEN is an intriguing YA fantasy that sweeps the reader away to a land of magic, plotting, and danger. The second book in a series, this steps right into the action, following three characters, Agatha, Sigrid, and Jaime. Shadow creatures known as sgàilean have been unleashed, and in the battle for control of the island, knowledge of how to escape them decides who wins and who loses.
While Agatha and Jaime fight the sgàilean and try to stand for what they believe in, Sigrid is in the clutches of a cruel king who has lost his eyesight. She was chosen to help him see, sold by her mother into his service. Her paths will collide with theirs, though they each play their own role in what is coming.
What I loved: This book sweeps the reader away quickly and is filled with action. Although switching between the three perspectives can be challenging at first, the writing really pulls the reader into this dangerous world. The sgàilean are a chilling foe, and the descriptions add a dark background to the story. Each of the characters grows throughout the story, and it was interesting to see their paths and choices made along the way. Additionally, Agatha has Down syndrome, and I appreciated her inclusion and the fullness of her characterization.
What left me wanting more: As small points, there are some things that take the reader out of this immersive plot. For instance, there are a lot of characters to keep track of, so I needed to go back in the story at places to remember who was who. There are also some created languages and alternate writing that take some time to get the hang of, particularly Sigrid's sections which is written in an alternate spelling of text.
Final verdict: Overall, THE BROKEN RAVEN is an engaging YA fantasy that transports the reader to another world with intriguing characters and cleverly-crafted dangers.
Please note that I received an ARC from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
THE BROKEN RAVEN is an intriguing YA fantasy that sweeps the reader away to a land of magic, plotting, and danger. The second book in a series, this steps right into the action, following three characters, Agatha, Sigrid, and Jaime. Shadow creatures known as sgàilean have been unleashed, and in the battle for control of the island, knowledge of how to escape them decides who wins and who loses.
While Agatha and Jaime fight the sgàilean and try to stand for what they believe in, Sigrid is in the clutches of a cruel king who has lost his eyesight. She was chosen to help him see, sold by her mother into his service. Her paths will collide with theirs, though they each play their own role in what is coming.
What I loved: This book sweeps the reader away quickly and is filled with action. Although switching between the three perspectives can be challenging at first, the writing really pulls the reader into this dangerous world. The sgàilean are a chilling foe, and the descriptions add a dark background to the story. Each of the characters grows throughout the story, and it was interesting to see their paths and choices made along the way. Additionally, Agatha has Down syndrome, and I appreciated her inclusion and the fullness of her characterization.
What left me wanting more: As small points, there are some things that take the reader out of this immersive plot. For instance, there are a lot of characters to keep track of, so I needed to go back in the story at places to remember who was who. There are also some created languages and alternate writing that take some time to get the hang of, particularly Sigrid's sections which is written in an alternate spelling of text.
Final verdict: Overall, THE BROKEN RAVEN is an engaging YA fantasy that transports the reader to another world with intriguing characters and cleverly-crafted dangers.
Please note that I received an ARC from the publisher. All opinions are my own.
July 3, 2022
Review of Audiobook version - ISBN: 9781004034987
Read by Fiona Hardingham, Gary Furlong, Nina Yndis
Published: W F Howes - Nudged Children's Audiobooks (April 2022)
Book two of this medieval fantasy drama set in the British Isles, sees us finding out about more peoples of the area. We are introduced to Sigrid, a 12 year old whose drunkard mother sells her into the service of the Konig to act as the man's eyes. She is tattooed with a raven design to fool others into thinking she is old enough to work, but the job her mother paid for was botched by the man who did it and the poor bird looks like it's dead.
In the aftermath of the previous book, Jaime and Agatha's clan are guests of another clan because their home village has been taken over by invaders. A magical threat sees the youths questing to the mainland to find a magician who can help them fight off an other-worldly peril.
Through the eyes of Sigrid, we see the plotting of the English and Norvegian leaders, and learn of the source of foul magics and disease that have been leveled against the people in the north.
Much like the last one, there is action and adventure and battle. It's not so laborious that I get bored by it (which, admittedly, means it might not be quite complex enough for those who like blow-by-blow strategic battle stories). We have more psychic communication with animals, blood magic and vengeful spirits, and Jaime wrangles with a bit of romantic tension. Sigrid is gifted with a photographic memory (which is fun for me if I don't dwell on the idea too hard, and think of it as a magical effect rather than a psychological one). I like the characters and the plot advances at a good clip...
now to track down a copy of the next instalment.
Read by Fiona Hardingham, Gary Furlong, Nina Yndis
Published: W F Howes - Nudged Children's Audiobooks (April 2022)
Book two of this medieval fantasy drama set in the British Isles, sees us finding out about more peoples of the area. We are introduced to Sigrid, a 12 year old whose drunkard mother sells her into the service of the Konig to act as the man's eyes. She is tattooed with a raven design to fool others into thinking she is old enough to work, but the job her mother paid for was botched by the man who did it and the poor bird looks like it's dead.
In the aftermath of the previous book, Jaime and Agatha's clan are guests of another clan because their home village has been taken over by invaders. A magical threat sees the youths questing to the mainland to find a magician who can help them fight off an other-worldly peril.
Through the eyes of Sigrid, we see the plotting of the English and Norvegian leaders, and learn of the source of foul magics and disease that have been leveled against the people in the north.
Much like the last one, there is action and adventure and battle. It's not so laborious that I get bored by it (which, admittedly, means it might not be quite complex enough for those who like blow-by-blow strategic battle stories). We have more psychic communication with animals, blood magic and vengeful spirits, and Jaime wrangles with a bit of romantic tension. Sigrid is gifted with a photographic memory (which is fun for me if I don't dwell on the idea too hard, and think of it as a magical effect rather than a psychological one). I like the characters and the plot advances at a good clip...
now to track down a copy of the next instalment.
July 5, 2020
ARC provided by Candlewick Press via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The Broken Raven is the second instalment in Joseph Elliott’s Shadow Skye trilogy and it is as captivating as the first one, if not more.
Sigrid is a twelve-year-old girl, gifted with phenomenal memory, who’s forced to become the eyes of the evil King of the deamhain who plans to seek revenge on the people of Skye. His hunger for vengeance and an obscure prophecy become the pillars of a vicious alliance between two dangerous kingdoms.
Clann-a-Tuath’s strenuous return to the Isle of Skye is spoiled when they discover that their enclave is in the hands of the Raasay people and that they have to rely on the generosity of their neighbouring ally, Clann-na-Bruthaich, for survival and a chance to retrieve their own home. To add insult to injury, the sgàilean are released from their magical prison and without a master to serve, they are free to destroy everything and everyone on their path. The shadow threat forces Jaime and Agatha to turn to new unexpected allies and old friends to defeat their enemies.
Middle books are usually the most boring in a trilogy, but Joseph Elliott continues surprising the reader with interesting new characters, compelling scenes and a perpetually engaging story. I’m really excited to read what the author has in store for the end of this adventure.
The Broken Raven is the second instalment in Joseph Elliott’s Shadow Skye trilogy and it is as captivating as the first one, if not more.
Sigrid is a twelve-year-old girl, gifted with phenomenal memory, who’s forced to become the eyes of the evil King of the deamhain who plans to seek revenge on the people of Skye. His hunger for vengeance and an obscure prophecy become the pillars of a vicious alliance between two dangerous kingdoms.
Clann-a-Tuath’s strenuous return to the Isle of Skye is spoiled when they discover that their enclave is in the hands of the Raasay people and that they have to rely on the generosity of their neighbouring ally, Clann-na-Bruthaich, for survival and a chance to retrieve their own home. To add insult to injury, the sgàilean are released from their magical prison and without a master to serve, they are free to destroy everything and everyone on their path. The shadow threat forces Jaime and Agatha to turn to new unexpected allies and old friends to defeat their enemies.
Middle books are usually the most boring in a trilogy, but Joseph Elliott continues surprising the reader with interesting new characters, compelling scenes and a perpetually engaging story. I’m really excited to read what the author has in store for the end of this adventure.
October 6, 2022
I'm not sure I can totally pinpoint it, but I love this series - the world feels real and well-rounded, the characters are flawed but well-rounded, the plot moves quickly, and it's just so engaging.
Sigrid is a good addition - she's kind but rough, impulsive and brave and lost. Norveg is such an interesting place that I wanted to explore more of it, and I hope she gets back to her grandfather at some point.
Jaimie was a little more annoying than I remember from the last book, but it makes sense: he's traumatized and scared of losing everything he had to fight so hard for.
Agatha, Agatha, Agatha... I have the same issues with her from the first book: she's a great character, and I love that one of the main characters and heroes is intellectually disabled, but she is so frustrating! She never listens and she's so impulsive and everyone coddles and encourages her. Yes, she saves the day because of her impulsivity in this one, but it's still annoying.
I'm excited for the conclusion.
Sigrid is a good addition - she's kind but rough, impulsive and brave and lost. Norveg is such an interesting place that I wanted to explore more of it, and I hope she gets back to her grandfather at some point.
Jaimie was a little more annoying than I remember from the last book, but it makes sense: he's traumatized and scared of losing everything he had to fight so hard for.
Agatha, Agatha, Agatha... I have the same issues with her from the first book: she's a great character, and I love that one of the main characters and heroes is intellectually disabled, but she is so frustrating! She never listens and she's so impulsive and everyone coddles and encourages her. Yes, she saves the day because of her impulsivity in this one, but it's still annoying.
I'm excited for the conclusion.
August 13, 2021
I put off reading this for a while as knew I would want to read the next one straight away. But then Joseph Elliott shared the cover of the final part and I succumbed to temptation!
What to say? It was beyond delightful to catch up with Agatha and Jamie again. Their voices are just so clear and genuine. The small details in how Jamie analyses the normal things happening in his life among all the drama have me totally sold on his characterisation!
Agatha remains a delight. Her determination to do what’s right and frustration at the way people speak to her and underestimate her is refreshingly realistic. Agatha is not in this novel as a token she is a full protagonist and her perspective on the politics going on around her shows it up for the foolishness that it is!
And Sigrid is a wonderful addition to this world. I found her voice quite disorientating to start with but it soon brought me fully into the world of Norveg and the very different cultural practices between there, Ingland and Scotia.
In short, I loved it. And I really need to talk about it with some people who’ve finished it! Can’t believe the next part isn’t out until next year.
What to say? It was beyond delightful to catch up with Agatha and Jamie again. Their voices are just so clear and genuine. The small details in how Jamie analyses the normal things happening in his life among all the drama have me totally sold on his characterisation!
Agatha remains a delight. Her determination to do what’s right and frustration at the way people speak to her and underestimate her is refreshingly realistic. Agatha is not in this novel as a token she is a full protagonist and her perspective on the politics going on around her shows it up for the foolishness that it is!
And Sigrid is a wonderful addition to this world. I found her voice quite disorientating to start with but it soon brought me fully into the world of Norveg and the very different cultural practices between there, Ingland and Scotia.
In short, I loved it. And I really need to talk about it with some people who’ve finished it! Can’t believe the next part isn’t out until next year.
January 29, 2022
I like the second perspective of Sigrid that ran throughout the book; although it was rather predictable that her story and Jamie/Agatha's story meet at the end. I also noticed throughout the book that my gaydar was going off... Jaime is so obviously into Cray (he just doesn't know it yet) so I am eagerly awaiting answers in the third book (The Burning Swift) AND at one point there is a discussion between Cray and Jamie:
Jamie: "Why are you helping me?" I asked.
"What do you mean?"
"You've done so much already - for both me and my clan - but you don't owe us anything. So why are you doing it?"
He (Cray) looks at me like the answer is obvious.
"Because I like you, of course."
Cray has already told Jamie about his 'partner' who died in a battle, so Jamie already knows that he is gay, f.y.i.
But anyways then later on Aileen is riding Bras and Jamie is like:
'I've always hated bull-riding, but for some reason, right now, all I want is for Aileen to get off so I can ride Bras instead.'
So I will leave you guys to figure that one out.
I will be back with answers from The Burning Swift!
Jamie: "Why are you helping me?" I asked.
"What do you mean?"
"You've done so much already - for both me and my clan - but you don't owe us anything. So why are you doing it?"
He (Cray) looks at me like the answer is obvious.
"Because I like you, of course."
Cray has already told Jamie about his 'partner' who died in a battle, so Jamie already knows that he is gay, f.y.i.
But anyways then later on Aileen is riding Bras and Jamie is like:
'I've always hated bull-riding, but for some reason, right now, all I want is for Aileen to get off so I can ride Bras instead.'
So I will leave you guys to figure that one out.
I will be back with answers from The Burning Swift!
January 25, 2021
In this, the follow-up to The Good Hawk, the reader will not know what hit them. Filled with insidious plots, horrifying creatures and sudden, unexpected twists in every chapter, this fast-paced, well-conceived novel opens up a journey into a mystical past that plays on existing legends and history and opens up totally new ingenious possibilities…and impossibilities that come to full fruition. The place and time are full of texture and well-painted; the characters are nuanced and well-rounded. The introduction of Sigrid as a character brings another layer of courage and difference into the tale; one that will win hearts and open the imagination. As the story goes back and forth between the different narratives, it maintains an outstanding ebb and flow, building a full of view of this incredible world with all its’ dangers and triumphs. It kept me hooked from page one. While aimed at a teen/young adult audience, it makes an incredible read for any fantasy-lover, regardless of age. Eerie, thrilling and mind-bending…spectacular!
August 6, 2025
I finished this book thirty minutes ago and am in awe. I'm not sure if I'm capable of writing a cohesive review, so I'll just list a few of my favorite things.
Sigrid's dialect. LOVED IT. The way Joseph Elliot displays the way characters think and speak has been extraordinary since book 1, and it continues to be one of my favorite parts of the book. It's incredibly consistent across chapters and adds a whole new kind of depth to the characters.
I think in books where the plot keeps moving, without many moments for the characters to stop and breathe, their personal development and thought processes can get swept away, but this doesn't happen at all in this book. Our main characters still think about the happenings of the previous book and are still obviously affected by them, even if they don't have the time to dissect their feelings properly (poor Jaime, guy's going through it).
The furthering of relationships, like Agatha and Aileen and Jaime and Cray also have me in a chokehold. I'm so excited to see how they develop in the final book.
Also; Lady Beatrice. Love her dearly.
Sigrid's dialect. LOVED IT. The way Joseph Elliot displays the way characters think and speak has been extraordinary since book 1, and it continues to be one of my favorite parts of the book. It's incredibly consistent across chapters and adds a whole new kind of depth to the characters.
I think in books where the plot keeps moving, without many moments for the characters to stop and breathe, their personal development and thought processes can get swept away, but this doesn't happen at all in this book. Our main characters still think about the happenings of the previous book and are still obviously affected by them, even if they don't have the time to dissect their feelings properly (poor Jaime, guy's going through it).
The furthering of relationships, like Agatha and Aileen and Jaime and Cray also have me in a chokehold. I'm so excited to see how they develop in the final book.
Also; Lady Beatrice. Love her dearly.
September 27, 2020
The Broken Raven (Shadow Skye, Book Two)
By Joseph Elliott
2021
A LibraryThing Early Reviewers book - Advanced Reading Copy.
This sequel takes place soon after the first novel. The main characters and their clan have escaped the Norveg/Norse and are back on the Island of Skye. At the moment, they are sharing the settlement of another clan, since the invaders still hold their home. Taking their home back won't be easy. A new character is also introduced to the plot, a young Norse girl with an amazing memory.
I don't want to go further into the plot, as to prevent spoilers.
This second volume of the series was a lot of fun to read. The language is beautiful, and Sigrid is a great addition to the cast. I look forward to seeing how everything turns out in the third book.
4 stars
Tags: Fantasy, Young Adult, Adventure
By Joseph Elliott
2021
A LibraryThing Early Reviewers book - Advanced Reading Copy.
This sequel takes place soon after the first novel. The main characters and their clan have escaped the Norveg/Norse and are back on the Island of Skye. At the moment, they are sharing the settlement of another clan, since the invaders still hold their home. Taking their home back won't be easy. A new character is also introduced to the plot, a young Norse girl with an amazing memory.
I don't want to go further into the plot, as to prevent spoilers.
This second volume of the series was a lot of fun to read. The language is beautiful, and Sigrid is a great addition to the cast. I look forward to seeing how everything turns out in the third book.
4 stars
Tags: Fantasy, Young Adult, Adventure
January 7, 2021
My 11 year old son and I took a chance last year on a debut novel called The Good Hawk. It proved to be such a page-turner that we read it together in 4 days! A new record! Needless to say we were both very excited about getting back to this world and boy were we not disappointed. If anything, we felt this book was even better than the first. The new character Sigrid has such a beautifully characterful and humorous voice that her chapters really built on the mix of already wonderful voices. I don't want to give away too much in the way of plot but there are some delightful surprises and reappearances which my nephew and I loved. I really couldn't recommend this book more. I'm not normally one to leave reviews but on this occasion I felt compelled to. In this time of uncertainty and gloom, I found this to be the perfect antidote. 5/5
January 24, 2021
A young adult fantasy that takes place in an alternative British Isles of the past. The novel is told in three voices all young teenagers. This is the second in a series but reads well as a stand alone as I read it as an ARC. The primary story involves people reclaiming their homeland (Isle of Skye) which was taken from them. There is a steady dose of adventure and danger but you always get the feeling that things will work out which they do. Easy to read and I feel it will be enjoyed by the intended young audience.
May 6, 2021
I like this series quite well actually, but this book gets 2 stars for not being true to the characters that were written in the first book. If your story doesn't feel diverse enough then add a new character. Jaime is not gay. You can't just decide to turn a straight character gay. He sees Cray as a big brother, not a love interest. I want gay characters in books, I am happy for inclusivity, but it is quite obvious its becoming trendy, and I don't think thats good for anyone. They could have made Agatha gay, that would have at least made sense, but Jaime gay does not.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
August 28, 2021
This series is such an interesting twist of Norse mythology, Scottish folklore, and real world problems told in a similar but alternate universe. The introduction of a new character from Norveg is nice, seeing things from their point of view kind of makes them seem less villainous. I don't know why it took me so long to read this, because I loved it. If you are looking for a unique blend of folktale, mythology, and action then you should definitely try this series. This one was quite the cliff hanger though, the author needs to write the third one soon.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 63 reviews