I can't believe I'm giving a book about a dog, any book about a dog, only two stars, but I was underwhelmed by this one. There are much better books out there about friendship, and learning to trust . . . and most of them have much better illustrations.
I actually read this when I visited a museum in Beppu in Kyushu where there was a big white statue depicting the main lonely dog character here. This giant dog is absolutely enormous--he makes Clifford look like a real shrimp. The story deals with the white dog that eventually makes friends with a human girl. It's kind of a cute story, though the kid looks really mischievous!
Did I just miss the whole concept of the book? How is the rating this high? The girl looks evil (and at one point the dog looked evil too) and it seems like it's basically: dog is lonely, girl finds dog, dog and girl are friends, dog finds another girl and becomes friends? The lack of words on the last few pages left me really confused.
Nara draws the most expressively determined-looking little girls and I love this book that very simply tells the story of a dog (like his sculpture featured at the Palm Springs Art Museum) and one of those fierce toddlers.
Aunque estemos solos y tristes, como un perrito muy muy alto, no hay que dejar de confiar. Porque, tal vez, con un pelin de suerte, una niña de ojos enormes nos encuentre y comience a acompañar.
somewhat I don't understand, somewhat I like it, somewhat I hate it, somewhat somewhat.. In the end, I don't really care what this book about. Just embrace my time with it ;D (i NEED MY coFFee..)
Grade/Interest Level: Primary/Learn to Read Reading Level: Lexile Unknown Genre: Science Fiction, Picture Book
Summary: This is a very short and simple text about a giant dog that went unnoticed by everyone because of his gigantic size, which caused him to be very lonely. One day, a girl noticed him and climbed up his leg. Although the two were hesitant of each other at first, the girl began to sing to the dog and the two became very good friends. This story is accompanied with lots of illustrations; the last several pages of the book have no words, just pictures of the dog and girl together. Most of the illustrations are very unique, but I will admit I do find that the little girl is created in a way that makes her come off as evil at times. In all, this is a good book for beginning readers that will keep their attention with a simple story and enjoyable artwork.
Classroom Use: I would use this book in the classroom to discuss the theme of making friends. All children can relate to the dog at first when he felt lonely and had no friends. It's important for young children to build relationships with their peers and try to include everyone, which this book could do a great job at promoting.
A rather simple plot: There is a HUGE dog who is quite lonely as nobody sees him (because he is so big). Finally a little girl sees him and though she is initially scared, they become close friends and he is no longer lonely. So one message of the story is obvious: those who are different are made to feel as outsiders. In fact, the book is dedicated to "physically challenged children everywhere" and at the end it explicitly states that "no matter how alone you are, there is always someone, somewhere, waiting to meet you." However, I personally also saw the story as an allegory for how sometimes we neglect or choose to ignore the most obvious thing in front of us....which can lead to a rich discussion with kids about perception, assumptions, blending in vs individuality, and so on. The book is illustrated in the traditional Japanese style (not surprising given that the author/illustrator is apparently a famous Japanese artist), which I loved for its simplicity and stylized expressions. The book itself I'd give 3 stars but because I think there is great potential in it for a meaningful discussion with kids, I'll 3.5 stars.
I guess I seriously missed the point of this one because it's just about a VERY large dog and a little girl that become friends (and it is nothing like Clifford if that is something you're thinking). Why the girl looks positively evil is beyond me. And I'm not sure but she might be jealous of the dog because he becomes friends with another little girl at the end but there are no words on the last few pages so I cannot be sure.
A wonderful story about a giant dog who is soooooo big that he is not seen by anyone until one day a little girl comes along. This book sends a wonderful message about "seeing" and making friends with each other while embracing our differences.
Her art was all the rage when I was in, uh, high school.
But I can see how people are inexplicably drawn to her art that is simple and melancholic at times, especially that girl! What's up with that frown that is absolutely endearing!
I read what some other people wrote and agree with their thoughts. The girl does come across as sinister/evil with how she was drawn. I like the concept of the story and you can find a friend, but overall the story with pictures was just ok.
I wanted to like this book, but good gracious was it ever terrible. The little girl looks sinister and creepy. The text is clunky and cliched. Stick to adult audiences, Nara.
I loved the drawing first, and the message was great too. Actually to me the Japanese message is more direct (Nara is Japanese) and better. However I like this simple picture book with love.