What do you think?
Rate this book
Tales of Inthya #5
Daughter of the Moon
Four months ago, Netheia Isinthi failed to take her father’s throne from her older sister. After refusing to publicly support the new empress, she is banished to Ieflaria’s capital city, Birsgen, where she anticipates a long and uneventful exile.
Klavida of Nalova is a student at the university established by Princess Esofi for the study of magic. She has come from the far north researching Talcia’s creatures—or so she claims. After a chance meeting brings the two together, Klavida wants nothing to do with the angry, ill-mannered princess. But when Netheia offers Klavida access to the royal library, Klavida decides she can tolerate her after all.
As they spend time together, Klavida realizes that Netheia is intensely lonely and has never known genuine friendship. She becomes determined to show her that there is more to life than the pursuit of power and that a peaceful life of freedom can be more satisfying than ruling an empire.
But Netheia’s patron goddess is not ready to accept that she has lost the Xytan Empire—and neither are Netheia’s most ardent supporters.
Klavida of Nalova is a student at the university established by Princess Esofi for the study of magic. She has come from the far north researching Talcia’s creatures—or so she claims. After a chance meeting brings the two together, Klavida wants nothing to do with the angry, ill-mannered princess. But when Netheia offers Klavida access to the royal library, Klavida decides she can tolerate her after all.
As they spend time together, Klavida realizes that Netheia is intensely lonely and has never known genuine friendship. She becomes determined to show her that there is more to life than the pursuit of power and that a peaceful life of freedom can be more satisfying than ruling an empire.
But Netheia’s patron goddess is not ready to accept that she has lost the Xytan Empire—and neither are Netheia’s most ardent supporters.
ebook
First published November 9, 2020
17 people are currently reading
426 people want to read
About the author
Effie Calvin
6 books294 followersEffie is a human being who spends her days writing books and taking pictures of her cat and being a librarian.
She especially likes writing (and reading!) stories about fantasy worlds where LGBTQ people aren't just tolerated, they're openly embraced and seen as equals.
She especially likes writing (and reading!) stories about fantasy worlds where LGBTQ people aren't just tolerated, they're openly embraced and seen as equals.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews
November 13, 2020
This was an entertaining read. While this isn’t my favorite book of the series, I love this series as a whole and am completely addicted to it. I can’t believe that this is book 5 already and I hope there are many more to come. This book is tied into book 4, and other past books, so I would not recommend starting here. If this series peaks your interest then I would actually suggest that you read book 2, Daughter of the Sun, first. It is one of the best books in the series and a great way to start it. After that I would suggest reading book 1, 3, 4 and 5 in that order.
When I realized who this story was going to be about, I was really excited. I love morally grey characters and this character is on the edge of being morally grey or just plain evil. That’s a big ask Calvin tried to tackle. Could we as readers come to actually care about such a character? I’m impressed to say that it worked on me. Shockingly, I did actually care and I thought the HFN ending was a really great choice.
One issue I did end up having is that I wanted more story. These are not very long books for such an epic fantasy world. This world is incredible and I love that there are new magical beings added every book. My problem is that I felt like things really fast-forwarded in the last third of the book. I just wanted everything to slow down and for Calvin to add maybe another 50 pages and just let us experience things better. Some really important parts happened right near the end, one after another, and I just got a bit of whiplash because it went by way so fast.
This book, like most of the books in this series, does have a romance. In this case it is an opposites attract romance but the romance itself is very light. It is lighter than I expected but it did work with these characters in my opinion. Once you realize who the star of this book is, her even having the possibility to find love is a bit surprising so I thought this possibility was handled well.
I’m going to keep this on the shorter side since this is a series so it’s hard to mention too much without giving much away. This is a great fantasy series and I’m always so excited to get my hands on another book. This world gets more and more interesting and is so well written that I’ll read these books as long as Calvin keeps writing them.
A copy was given to me for a honest review.
When I realized who this story was going to be about, I was really excited. I love morally grey characters and this character is on the edge of being morally grey or just plain evil. That’s a big ask Calvin tried to tackle. Could we as readers come to actually care about such a character? I’m impressed to say that it worked on me. Shockingly, I did actually care and I thought the HFN ending was a really great choice.
One issue I did end up having is that I wanted more story. These are not very long books for such an epic fantasy world. This world is incredible and I love that there are new magical beings added every book. My problem is that I felt like things really fast-forwarded in the last third of the book. I just wanted everything to slow down and for Calvin to add maybe another 50 pages and just let us experience things better. Some really important parts happened right near the end, one after another, and I just got a bit of whiplash because it went by way so fast.
This book, like most of the books in this series, does have a romance. In this case it is an opposites attract romance but the romance itself is very light. It is lighter than I expected but it did work with these characters in my opinion. Once you realize who the star of this book is, her even having the possibility to find love is a bit surprising so I thought this possibility was handled well.
I’m going to keep this on the shorter side since this is a series so it’s hard to mention too much without giving much away. This is a great fantasy series and I’m always so excited to get my hands on another book. This world gets more and more interesting and is so well written that I’ll read these books as long as Calvin keeps writing them.
A copy was given to me for a honest review.
November 16, 2020
This series just keeps on giving, the worldbuilding, the characters, gods and goddesses, and dragons, I’m a fan! What I enjoyed about this book is that one of the mains is actually the bad guy (girl) from the fourth book, who you start rooting for. While she’s is a truly horrible person in the beginning, she changes gradually with some frustrating setbacks and even in the end she is still a bit of a work in progress (as well as the romance between her and Klavida) and I liked that decision.
In the fourth book Ioanna and her younger sister Netheia fight for the throne of Xytae. In this book, Ioanna (who has won the battle for the throne) exiles Netheia to Ieflaria where she is held at the royal castle in Birsgen as a guest with restrictions. Here, Netheia meets Klavida, a student at the university, who hopes to find an answer to a problem concerning her gift in the royal library.
As I said, Netheia is an awful person, and even though this is not an excuse, she is a product of the goddess she worships (Reygmadra, the goddess of war) and her surroundings. She is rude, aggressive and childish and solves every problem with fighting instead of thinking, let alone listen to reason. Her personality is quite over the top (although apparently normal in Xytae) and I couldn’t help thinking how she could have ever ruled Xytae without reason or common sense. That aside, Netheia quickly realizes that her behavior is not acceptable in Ieflaria and slowly, very slowly, her friendship with Klavida makes her reevaluate her behavior. What I thought was special in her growth as a person was that she also still wants to please Reygmadra, who she has worshipped all her life, so for a long time Netheia is torn between wanting to change to become a nicer person and pleasing her goddess who has her own plans.
Like practically everybody, Klavida doesn’t like Netheia at all, but over time they develop a friendship and more (although the romance is very light). Klavida is an absolute saint dealing with Netheia’s erratic behavior and even though I often thought Netheia didn’t deserve her, their connection was special and I was hoping that they would figure things out together. Also, the mystery concerning her gift was an interesting addition to the story.
Some occurrences that happened already in the second book hinted at what is unfolding in this book, which shows how nicely these books fit together. There were a couple of points in this book were things were happening a bit fast, but I could still follow it. I enjoyed seeing princesses Adale and Esofi and their dragon Carinth in a small role, yay! I hope to see Netheia and Klavida return in the future as well.
I recommend to read these books in order and especially fantasy and YA fans will likely appreciate this series a lot.
I received an ARC from NineStar Press via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
In the fourth book Ioanna and her younger sister Netheia fight for the throne of Xytae. In this book, Ioanna (who has won the battle for the throne) exiles Netheia to Ieflaria where she is held at the royal castle in Birsgen as a guest with restrictions. Here, Netheia meets Klavida, a student at the university, who hopes to find an answer to a problem concerning her gift in the royal library.
As I said, Netheia is an awful person, and even though this is not an excuse, she is a product of the goddess she worships (Reygmadra, the goddess of war) and her surroundings. She is rude, aggressive and childish and solves every problem with fighting instead of thinking, let alone listen to reason. Her personality is quite over the top (although apparently normal in Xytae) and I couldn’t help thinking how she could have ever ruled Xytae without reason or common sense. That aside, Netheia quickly realizes that her behavior is not acceptable in Ieflaria and slowly, very slowly, her friendship with Klavida makes her reevaluate her behavior. What I thought was special in her growth as a person was that she also still wants to please Reygmadra, who she has worshipped all her life, so for a long time Netheia is torn between wanting to change to become a nicer person and pleasing her goddess who has her own plans.
Like practically everybody, Klavida doesn’t like Netheia at all, but over time they develop a friendship and more (although the romance is very light). Klavida is an absolute saint dealing with Netheia’s erratic behavior and even though I often thought Netheia didn’t deserve her, their connection was special and I was hoping that they would figure things out together. Also, the mystery concerning her gift was an interesting addition to the story.
Some occurrences that happened already in the second book hinted at what is unfolding in this book, which shows how nicely these books fit together. There were a couple of points in this book were things were happening a bit fast, but I could still follow it. I enjoyed seeing princesses Adale and Esofi and their dragon Carinth in a small role, yay! I hope to see Netheia and Klavida return in the future as well.
I recommend to read these books in order and especially fantasy and YA fans will likely appreciate this series a lot.
I received an ARC from NineStar Press via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review
November 14, 2020
I love this series of fantasy books with sapphic undertones. I really highly recommend reading them all, to understand the over-reaching arcs (and some overlapping characters) presented.
I was surprised to find out who this installment was going to be centred around, and Netheia is a protagonist you love to hate. But there is also something endearing and almost naive about her. She's spoiled and entitled, but at the same time you see that a lot of it is down to how she had been raised in such a cutthroat manner with her father and mother who egged her and her siblings on in such unhealthy ways, while also devoting herself entirely to her War Goddess, who similarly also just played people and sides.
Netheia slowly comes to terms with the beliefs and ideals that she had thought were so right and true.
You almost get a sense of someone raised in a cult, trying to come to terms with the real world outside of it. You see her trying to justify her actions back to things she had thought she knew, and recognizing that they don't really hold water.
This slow change comes about, in part, through the friendship of Klavida, who is studying magical creatures and another Goddess of animals and her blessings, in order to understand something secretive about herself. She's a sweet character who feels lonely and lost in her own way, finding similar feelings in Netheia and is inexplicably drawn to her despite her infamous reputation. She believes Netheia can change and deserves that chance.
I found the redemption arc and self discovery here very fulfilling, and interesting. I really enjoy these stories of humans and blessed people with touches of magic, as well as other mystical creatures and strange Gods and Goddesses and the political intrigue throughout the lands.
I honestly look forward to another edition, and forget just how engrossing they are when you are amidst reading them.
I was surprised to find out who this installment was going to be centred around, and Netheia is a protagonist you love to hate. But there is also something endearing and almost naive about her. She's spoiled and entitled, but at the same time you see that a lot of it is down to how she had been raised in such a cutthroat manner with her father and mother who egged her and her siblings on in such unhealthy ways, while also devoting herself entirely to her War Goddess, who similarly also just played people and sides.
Netheia slowly comes to terms with the beliefs and ideals that she had thought were so right and true.
You almost get a sense of someone raised in a cult, trying to come to terms with the real world outside of it. You see her trying to justify her actions back to things she had thought she knew, and recognizing that they don't really hold water.
This slow change comes about, in part, through the friendship of Klavida, who is studying magical creatures and another Goddess of animals and her blessings, in order to understand something secretive about herself. She's a sweet character who feels lonely and lost in her own way, finding similar feelings in Netheia and is inexplicably drawn to her despite her infamous reputation. She believes Netheia can change and deserves that chance.
I found the redemption arc and self discovery here very fulfilling, and interesting. I really enjoy these stories of humans and blessed people with touches of magic, as well as other mystical creatures and strange Gods and Goddesses and the political intrigue throughout the lands.
I honestly look forward to another edition, and forget just how engrossing they are when you are amidst reading them.
November 25, 2020
This was so good. I didn't think I'd like reading about the bad Princess Netheia, but I think her story is one of my favourites thus far. Changing for the better and having the courage to speak up against a Goddess... the girl deserves some credit for that.
Also, wolves!! I love wolves... and I hope Netheia accepts Tacia's blessing so she can run free with Klavida.
Also, wolves!! I love wolves... and I hope Netheia accepts Tacia's blessing so she can run free with Klavida.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 11, 2020
This is essentially a continuation of the last book, The Empress of Xytae, in which we mostly follow Netheia Isinthi the fallen second daughter of Xytae. She's childish, rude, and arrogant, but still harbors a deeper secret that perhaps makes it harder for her to change. When she is exiled to the kingdom Ieflaria where she is to remain in the capital city of Birsgen. She's bored and uncomfortable with the new culture that she wants no part of until she meets the mage, Klavida of Nalova. Klavida is also burdened with a gift that could harm her if her secret comes out.
So, this is more of Netheia's story than Klavida, even though the title refers to Klavida's gift. Netheia does all of the growing here, as even though Klavida is sad about essentially having half a gift, very much knows herself. Netheia is the rich, prodigal kid that no one taught the meaning of restraint or even 'no'. She's so entitled that, despite grooming to be the head of her country, she doesn't bother to learn other cultures, especially ones in which she would have had to deal with as Empress. So the fish out of water plot threat was actually kind of annoying, especially since she refused to see that she was being offensive until she met Klavida.
This hints very heavily of some Beauty and the Beast themes, but doesn't quite pull it off. Although it was fun having the Beast (Klavida) be the emotionally stable one, there are very few areas in which our Beauty- Netheia- shows that she did the work to make herself better. There's some cases where Klavida responds to Netheia's humor and her flashes of maturity, but I felt like Klavida was doing most of the emotional heavy lifting for Netheia.
In the vein of the Disney animation, there's not much romantic overtones until later in the book where Netheia actually decides to put in the work to show she's ready to make a turn. But where as the emotional punch of the animation always gets me, this felt flat. There is some scrambling to stop Xytae and Ieflaria from going to war, the chemistry between Netheia and Klavida is just a bit off for me.
What continues to be interesting for me is that each book unlocks a different aspect of the worldbuilding that could hint at some massive world changing event. Here, there's something strange going on with the gods that was heavily hinted at in the last book. Netheia's patron goddess is off, and her manifestations become increasingly unstable as the book moves along, which is such a nice touch. There's also a great scene at the end of this book that answers some questions but still gives a hint of mystery.
So for me, this book was fine, and I think fans of the series would enjoy it. I did enjoy the parallels with Disney's Beauty and the Beast, but was a little disappointed that it didn't quite pull off the themes as nicely as the animation did. That said - Klavida is a great character, and I hope we can see more of her in the future. She's also hinted heavily as trans (as she went through what the world calls 'The Change' and decided to stay in her Changed form). Which, yay! I love how much this world is just full of LGBT characters, and it just is. There's no big thing about genders or orientation - it's just built into the worldbuilding.
I received this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
So, this is more of Netheia's story than Klavida, even though the title refers to Klavida's gift. Netheia does all of the growing here, as even though Klavida is sad about essentially having half a gift, very much knows herself. Netheia is the rich, prodigal kid that no one taught the meaning of restraint or even 'no'. She's so entitled that, despite grooming to be the head of her country, she doesn't bother to learn other cultures, especially ones in which she would have had to deal with as Empress. So the fish out of water plot threat was actually kind of annoying, especially since she refused to see that she was being offensive until she met Klavida.
This hints very heavily of some Beauty and the Beast themes, but doesn't quite pull it off. Although it was fun having the Beast (Klavida) be the emotionally stable one, there are very few areas in which our Beauty- Netheia- shows that she did the work to make herself better. There's some cases where Klavida responds to Netheia's humor and her flashes of maturity, but I felt like Klavida was doing most of the emotional heavy lifting for Netheia.
In the vein of the Disney animation, there's not much romantic overtones until later in the book where Netheia actually decides to put in the work to show she's ready to make a turn. But where as the emotional punch of the animation always gets me, this felt flat. There is some scrambling to stop Xytae and Ieflaria from going to war, the chemistry between Netheia and Klavida is just a bit off for me.
What continues to be interesting for me is that each book unlocks a different aspect of the worldbuilding that could hint at some massive world changing event. Here, there's something strange going on with the gods that was heavily hinted at in the last book. Netheia's patron goddess is off, and her manifestations become increasingly unstable as the book moves along, which is such a nice touch. There's also a great scene at the end of this book that answers some questions but still gives a hint of mystery.
So for me, this book was fine, and I think fans of the series would enjoy it. I did enjoy the parallels with Disney's Beauty and the Beast, but was a little disappointed that it didn't quite pull off the themes as nicely as the animation did. That said - Klavida is a great character, and I hope we can see more of her in the future. She's also hinted heavily as trans (as she went through what the world calls 'The Change' and decided to stay in her Changed form). Which, yay! I love how much this world is just full of LGBT characters, and it just is. There's no big thing about genders or orientation - it's just built into the worldbuilding.
I received this ARC in exchange for my honest review.
November 14, 2020
Daughter of the Moon, you are a beautiful thing. This series is stunning, I am in love. The Tales of Inthya books have changed my whole perspective on companion series. When I went to read book two and saw it was following different characters than book one I was wary, I have never enjoyed being proved wrong so much. Daughter of the Moon (#5) stars Princess Nethia of Xytae, who we know from the previous instalment, a fervent supporter of Reygmadra the war goddess; and Klavida of Nalova (a country far north), a student at Princess Esofi's university and a new face.
The world-building is detailed and thoughtful. I love the map at the beginning, I flicked back to it multiple times while reading. We get some more deity drama (the gods play a big part in this epic fantasy world) and conflict backstory between the various nations. There's the varying details of fashion trends, moral values, teaching methods, trades, climate and creatures across the different countries.
This book takes place 15 years after the first one, and we're back in Ieflaria, yay! So Esofi, Adale & Carinth are back, yay! Nethia is fascinating, she starts out basically evil, and I was hesitantly excited to see how/if Effie Calvin could make the romance believable and healthy (though I had faith, after Daughter of the Sun ❤️). Especially after the red flags... "Klavida nodded, even as her thoughts screamed objections. Nethia had tried to murder her own sister and nearly plunged her nation into civil war. And Klavida had watched her attack a woman, unprovoked, with her own eyes." I'm happy to report that it was everything I wanted, swoon.
"Do you know what I think?.. I think you're in the middle of becoming who you're meant to be. You're not finished yet."
Klavida is a wonderful character for a few reasons. got a gasp from me, what brilliance. She is patient and determined. Considering what she's had to live with all her life , she's remarkable. I loved how she saw and believed in Nethia's potential. Her big family dynamic was lovely too.
In this world there is a magical ritual "that altered a person's body to better reflect the way they preferred to express their gender". Klavida went through this process when she was young, and she has a conversation with Nethia about this at one point. Nethia talks about how the priestesses encourage everyone to try the Change at least once, and she did for fun but hated how uncomfortable it felt, giving her a new empathy for how some people must feel all the time. Wow, love this so much!
The balance between drama and humour is perfectly struck. The epic fantasy element of destiny was delicately done and didn't take away from the choice of falling into a loving relationship and consent and all that, which it totally could've done. I'm amazed at how diverse the characters across this series are, all our leads shine in their own way. I learned of this book on it's release day thanks to Calvin's email newsletter, and dropped everything to start reading that day. Every single page held my full attention and was an absolute joy to read.
The world-building is detailed and thoughtful. I love the map at the beginning, I flicked back to it multiple times while reading. We get some more deity drama (the gods play a big part in this epic fantasy world) and conflict backstory between the various nations. There's the varying details of fashion trends, moral values, teaching methods, trades, climate and creatures across the different countries.
This book takes place 15 years after the first one, and we're back in Ieflaria, yay! So Esofi, Adale & Carinth are back, yay! Nethia is fascinating, she starts out basically evil, and I was hesitantly excited to see how/if Effie Calvin could make the romance believable and healthy (though I had faith, after Daughter of the Sun ❤️). Especially after the red flags... "Klavida nodded, even as her thoughts screamed objections. Nethia had tried to murder her own sister and nearly plunged her nation into civil war. And Klavida had watched her attack a woman, unprovoked, with her own eyes." I'm happy to report that it was everything I wanted, swoon.
"Do you know what I think?.. I think you're in the middle of becoming who you're meant to be. You're not finished yet."
Klavida is a wonderful character for a few reasons. got a gasp from me, what brilliance. She is patient and determined. Considering what she's had to live with all her life , she's remarkable. I loved how she saw and believed in Nethia's potential. Her big family dynamic was lovely too.
In this world there is a magical ritual "that altered a person's body to better reflect the way they preferred to express their gender". Klavida went through this process when she was young, and she has a conversation with Nethia about this at one point. Nethia talks about how the priestesses encourage everyone to try the Change at least once, and she did for fun but hated how uncomfortable it felt, giving her a new empathy for how some people must feel all the time. Wow, love this so much!
The balance between drama and humour is perfectly struck. The epic fantasy element of destiny was delicately done and didn't take away from the choice of falling into a loving relationship and consent and all that, which it totally could've done. I'm amazed at how diverse the characters across this series are, all our leads shine in their own way. I learned of this book on it's release day thanks to Calvin's email newsletter, and dropped everything to start reading that day. Every single page held my full attention and was an absolute joy to read.
May 21, 2022
Anyone interested in redemption arc ? It took me a couple of chapters to truly get into, but once the dynamics between the two MCs became clear and the political plot made itself known, I was there for it! I loved Netheia, she was annoying, funny and cute all at once and I especially loved that her story enabled us to learn more about the gods ! I don't want to spoil anyone but we see more of what was hinted at in the last book, and I was there for it. And seeing again Esofi and Adale was great ! If we were to have more books in this universe, I would love to see them become queens.
Also, Klavida is a trans character, and representation is always appreciated !
Also, Klavida is a trans character, and representation is always appreciated !
March 9, 2022
After Princess Netheia attempted and failed to take the throne from her sister, she finds herself completely isolated before being banished to Ieflaria. Angry and miserable in exile, she prays to Reygmadra only to get crickets in response. Not a single person in Ieflaria is interested in having anything to do with Netheia, especially after she angrily attacks her personal guard. At least her outburst brought someone interesting into her life: Klavida of Navola. Not only was Klavida strong enough to prevent Netheia from doing any real damage, but she’s also genuinely nice to her. The more time they spend together, the more the two build an unlikely friendship… one that Reygmadra is not happy about.
I’ve loved every book in this series, so I’m not surprised that I loved this one as well. As I had predicted, it was quite interesting to follow Netheia in exile. In the previous installment, we only ever saw her from Ioanna and Vitaliya. This time around, we get to learn who she is above the surface and the extreme actions she took in the previous novel. We also get a new cast of characters along with getting to see some familiar characters once again.
I instantly loved one of the newst characters, Klavida. Not only is she a very kind and caring person, but she has her own burdens that she’s working through. On top of everything, she’s not afraid to call Netheia out and force her to look at herself and her actions. There’s only so much Netheia can blame on others, which is something she’s forced to face while in exile thanks to Klavida. We also embark on the mystery we were given in the previous novel, which is when and why did Reygmadra become a chaos goddess over time.
Overall, the romance is very sweet but it’s not the core theme of this book. I saw this as more of a book following two lonely characters who feel isolated for different reasons that are very drawn to each other. I wouldn’t say the romance is fire, because it’s not, but it’s a very sweet and heartwarming one built off an excellent friendship.
I’m very interested in seeing where this series goes next. I believe there will be another installment, so it’ll be interesting to see where Effie Calvin takes us and if it’ll lead to more books in the series. I have a feeling the series will be wrapping up soon, but we’ll see if that’s the case based on how the next book goes. I’m very interested in what Calvin’s plans are for the series as well as what they come up with next when they eventually publish either a standalone novel or start a new series.
I’ve loved every book in this series, so I’m not surprised that I loved this one as well. As I had predicted, it was quite interesting to follow Netheia in exile. In the previous installment, we only ever saw her from Ioanna and Vitaliya. This time around, we get to learn who she is above the surface and the extreme actions she took in the previous novel. We also get a new cast of characters along with getting to see some familiar characters once again.
I instantly loved one of the newst characters, Klavida. Not only is she a very kind and caring person, but she has her own burdens that she’s working through. On top of everything, she’s not afraid to call Netheia out and force her to look at herself and her actions. There’s only so much Netheia can blame on others, which is something she’s forced to face while in exile thanks to Klavida. We also embark on the mystery we were given in the previous novel, which is when and why did Reygmadra become a chaos goddess over time.
Overall, the romance is very sweet but it’s not the core theme of this book. I saw this as more of a book following two lonely characters who feel isolated for different reasons that are very drawn to each other. I wouldn’t say the romance is fire, because it’s not, but it’s a very sweet and heartwarming one built off an excellent friendship.
I’m very interested in seeing where this series goes next. I believe there will be another installment, so it’ll be interesting to see where Effie Calvin takes us and if it’ll lead to more books in the series. I have a feeling the series will be wrapping up soon, but we’ll see if that’s the case based on how the next book goes. I’m very interested in what Calvin’s plans are for the series as well as what they come up with next when they eventually publish either a standalone novel or start a new series.
November 10, 2020
I was so excited to read this one! Calvin's books have become my go-to fantasy light reads. I hadn't expected, starting the first book, to discover how much I had been missing not reading LGBTQ+ romances and universes. And if this one didn't hold all the promises I'd hoped it would, it still had me reading it in one sitting, and enjoying the loveliness, silliness and complexity of the characters, romance and universe.
I had been disappointed with the previous book, the relationship between the two characters resembling much what had been done before. I was then very curious to see how Calvin would tackle such an unlikable and "bad" character, as was presented in the previous novel. Netheia doesn't disappoint, she's just childish and bad-tempered and you wonder why you want to follow her evolution. Calvin does evacuate some difficulties by explaining them away, but it was still pleasantly done.
The first half of the book was a delight, I felt I saw the evolution of Calvin from the first book, in terms of setting and taking her time with character development. But then, as it was the case with the previous books, she ends up telling more than she is showing in the last part of the novel.
I like that these books are short, but then the world building and the ambition behind the overreaching story makes it difficult to be condensed on so few pages. And it's frustrating to read a 180 page-story, where it could have been 300 pages at least, and could have offered so much more time with the characters we get to like.
I'll still want to read the next novel (novels ?) obviously, but I'll have to tone down my expectations a bit to avoid being disappointed.
I had been disappointed with the previous book, the relationship between the two characters resembling much what had been done before. I was then very curious to see how Calvin would tackle such an unlikable and "bad" character, as was presented in the previous novel. Netheia doesn't disappoint, she's just childish and bad-tempered and you wonder why you want to follow her evolution. Calvin does evacuate some difficulties by explaining them away, but it was still pleasantly done.
The first half of the book was a delight, I felt I saw the evolution of Calvin from the first book, in terms of setting and taking her time with character development. But then, as it was the case with the previous books, she ends up telling more than she is showing in the last part of the novel.
I like that these books are short, but then the world building and the ambition behind the overreaching story makes it difficult to be condensed on so few pages. And it's frustrating to read a 180 page-story, where it could have been 300 pages at least, and could have offered so much more time with the characters we get to like.
I'll still want to read the next novel (novels ?) obviously, but I'll have to tone down my expectations a bit to avoid being disappointed.
November 10, 2020
Daughter of the Moon is captivating and fantasy filled. First, I can't believe this is book five! (It seems I have some reading to do). It's well written and pulls you in right away. It works as a stand alone just fine, but it definitely makes you want to go back to book one! Netheia is strong and hard-headed, but you can't help but want to see her find happiness. (Who doesn't hope for a good redemption story)? I won't tell you if she gets her happy ending - you'll have to enjoy the story first to find out!
May 29, 2021
This is one of the rare series that maintains almost 4 stars all through. The writer really knows her craft and as I progress down the series, everyone of the characters elicit care and thoughtfulness of their world. Appreciating read and i look forward to what next the author has for us readers.
February 3, 2024
I've loved Reading Tales of Inthya but this is by far my favourite. It touched me personally reading it and brought tears to my eyes. Throughout the books there were several times The Change ritual had been brought up to match one's body to ones soul. I'd always felt very touched by its inclusion in the story but I for whatever reason never expected what I got out of Daughter of the Moon.
When Klavida tells Netheia she Changed when she was young it brought me to tears, I've enjoyed reading many books and stories but Daughter of the Moon will forever have a place in my heart as the first time I read a story and felt seen, with a heroine who reflected me in that way :')
I cant give enough credit to Effie Calvin for this and how it was mentioned but it never seemed to define Klavida it was just who she was
When Klavida tells Netheia she Changed when she was young it brought me to tears, I've enjoyed reading many books and stories but Daughter of the Moon will forever have a place in my heart as the first time I read a story and felt seen, with a heroine who reflected me in that way :')
I cant give enough credit to Effie Calvin for this and how it was mentioned but it never seemed to define Klavida it was just who she was
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 13, 2021
Even though I haven’t read the previous books before this one (and surely I’m going to read them after this), still I didn’t have difficulties to appreciate and follow the flow of this book.
The story was very interesting, and now I’m so intrigued with regards to the first four books. It was well written and it kept me captivated until the end. I like how the the story developed and how the MCs interacted with each other. I love how the MCs feelings evolved and progressed slowly towards one another. The ending was kinda hanging and it left me unsatisfied. I hope to read more of them both.
Will definitely recommend this book to others.
I received an ARC from the publishers through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
The story was very interesting, and now I’m so intrigued with regards to the first four books. It was well written and it kept me captivated until the end. I like how the the story developed and how the MCs interacted with each other. I love how the MCs feelings evolved and progressed slowly towards one another. The ending was kinda hanging and it left me unsatisfied. I hope to read more of them both.
Will definitely recommend this book to others.
I received an ARC from the publishers through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
November 30, 2020
"I think you're in the middle of becoming who you're meant to be. You're not finished yet." - Klavida
This 5th installment, unlike the others, is a direct sequel of the 4th book.
Here we're to see the journey of Netheia, the antagonist on the previous book, towards redemption.
Klavida is great addition to this world. Her character and circumstance are a complete opposite, yet it works.
The gods/goddesses are also being more involved, and I'd love to see that part of this universe too (I think the author have a Patreon where she's sharing these bits?)
As usual, the bulk of the story is light and fun.
It doesn't have that much angst or irritation. It's more on confusion, pity, understanding and kindness. In someways, it delves into the capacity of human to both feel loyalty and love with anger and betrayal at the same time. Which can actually be related to how one can still love God despite being unhappy with their current circumstance.
In addition, this story is filled with nuance more than the other books (except Book 2). Because here, it doesn't delved into being self righteous, but doing the right thing despite not wanting to.
The only critic I have in this book is that it went by too fast! Specially the conclusion part.
I love fast paced adventures, but since this one is quite romance centric, there wasn't any deep dive on that part. I can't blame the author though, since usually small publications have character/page limits.
I can't emphasis this enough, but I think small F/F fantasy writers needs more boost, since I don't see any huge traction/ fandom of the genre. These books deserves more.
This 5th installment, unlike the others, is a direct sequel of the 4th book.
Here we're to see the journey of Netheia, the antagonist on the previous book, towards redemption.
Klavida is great addition to this world. Her character and circumstance are a complete opposite, yet it works.
The gods/goddesses are also being more involved, and I'd love to see that part of this universe too (I think the author have a Patreon where she's sharing these bits?)
As usual, the bulk of the story is light and fun.
It doesn't have that much angst or irritation. It's more on confusion, pity, understanding and kindness. In someways, it delves into the capacity of human to both feel loyalty and love with anger and betrayal at the same time. Which can actually be related to how one can still love God despite being unhappy with their current circumstance.
In addition, this story is filled with nuance more than the other books (except Book 2). Because here, it doesn't delved into being self righteous, but doing the right thing despite not wanting to.
The only critic I have in this book is that it went by too fast! Specially the conclusion part.
I love fast paced adventures, but since this one is quite romance centric, there wasn't any deep dive on that part. I can't blame the author though, since usually small publications have character/page limits.
I can't emphasis this enough, but I think small F/F fantasy writers needs more boost, since I don't see any huge traction/ fandom of the genre. These books deserves more.
November 23, 2020
Effie Calvin takes us on an intriguing trip of opposites in Daughter of the Moon. I think this is how Netheia would describe her new world in exile, except leave out the word “intriguing” and insert vexing (laugh). Nothing about this country is to Netheia’s tastes, but then it represents everything she is not. Calvin then takes us on a voyage of self-discovery which is extremely uncomfortable for Netheia.
Whereas Klavida is embracing the knowledge and looking for more. In a desperate search for answers, Calvin blends the paranormal and mythology to satisfy today’s question regarding identity in one way (though we all know there are many different answers). Calvin gives us a mythological and romantic answer for Daughter of the Moon.
This solution allows both characters to move forward and it works for this story. I enjoyed this journey and I appreciate Daughter of the Moon for exactly what it is: a fantastical story of two who fall in love and become better for it.
I received an ARC of this book and I am writing a review without prejudice and voluntarily.
*edited version - full version appears on my blog.
Whereas Klavida is embracing the knowledge and looking for more. In a desperate search for answers, Calvin blends the paranormal and mythology to satisfy today’s question regarding identity in one way (though we all know there are many different answers). Calvin gives us a mythological and romantic answer for Daughter of the Moon.
This solution allows both characters to move forward and it works for this story. I enjoyed this journey and I appreciate Daughter of the Moon for exactly what it is: a fantastical story of two who fall in love and become better for it.
I received an ARC of this book and I am writing a review without prejudice and voluntarily.
*edited version - full version appears on my blog.
November 29, 2020
I enjoyed this book. My only problem was that the previous novel was so many books ago that I had forgotten much about Netheia and her family. Fortunately, as I read, I recalled more and more of the situation and characters in the Xytan Empire.
I was really intrigued to see how Netheia would handle life as an exile in Ieflaria. No one trusts her, and behaviors she thought were normal are seen as dangerous and malicious. It’s culture shock for her, and for the other main character, Klavidia, who is also from a different place.
There’s adventure and intrigue as well as some twists here and there. Friends and foes are both present and sometimes it’s hard for the characters to know which is which and who to trust. For me, though, I really enjoyed Netheia’s character growth. Suddenly removed from her warrior culture, she has to learn new ways. She’s wrestling with everything she knows and believes, including the goddess of war whom she worships. Her friendship with Klavidia is essential to that growth. And on top of all that, we learn there are yet more creatures on this planet. There’s a lot more to explore in this series.
I was really intrigued to see how Netheia would handle life as an exile in Ieflaria. No one trusts her, and behaviors she thought were normal are seen as dangerous and malicious. It’s culture shock for her, and for the other main character, Klavidia, who is also from a different place.
There’s adventure and intrigue as well as some twists here and there. Friends and foes are both present and sometimes it’s hard for the characters to know which is which and who to trust. For me, though, I really enjoyed Netheia’s character growth. Suddenly removed from her warrior culture, she has to learn new ways. She’s wrestling with everything she knows and believes, including the goddess of war whom she worships. Her friendship with Klavidia is essential to that growth. And on top of all that, we learn there are yet more creatures on this planet. There’s a lot more to explore in this series.
Read
April 8, 2024I liked the principals in this one, but boy oh boy the geopolitics went off the deep end. The handwavey approach to political history as determined by divine strife and divine favorites works really well! But applying that same logic to social and systems history really does not. The point where I lost it was when Netheia received the letter from her grandmother “explaining” that the reason the Empire fell 1000 years ago was that overnight one emperor decided to institute chattel slavery and then all the provinces were so shocked that they rebelled and boom! From Empire to Vestigial Empire in a decade! That’s not how slavery works! That’s not how decolonization works! That’s not how anything works! I will probably keep reading these because I do like the meta-plot where the Goddess of Love and the Goddess of War are angsty exes and the latter is spiraling into self-destructive depression and trying to instigate Total War among humans. I just wish the author would stick to her strengths, which do not include explaining the fall of empires in economic and social terms.
March 25, 2024
I wasn’t interested in Netheia‘s redemption ark, but overall, I think it ended up going pretty well. A lot of the work is done by Klavida feeding Netheia thing she ought to know — like an outward moral compass. Although, I can understand how exposure to Klavida could’ve led to Netheia’s growth and development because she had never been around someone like that before. The author has a pretty fixed grumpy/shy X sunshine dynamic for couples in these books, and I’m not complaining.
It’s been fascinating to see over the course of the past few books, how expansive the magic in this world really is. I am especially interested in the gods, especially from the revelation towards the end of this book. The series is a comfort read for me, and it’s lived up to my expectations from the past novels.
It’s been fascinating to see over the course of the past few books, how expansive the magic in this world really is. I am especially interested in the gods, especially from the revelation towards the end of this book. The series is a comfort read for me, and it’s lived up to my expectations from the past novels.
June 13, 2021
trigger warning
After the events in Empress of Xytae, Netheia is exiled to Inthya in hopes that the Inthian kindness will rub off on her and she might one day be allowed back.
Netheia was getting on my nerves for most of the time. She reminded me of Clarisse in the Percy Jackson universe, daughter of Ares, who is included in the cabin council despite her plans always are to slaughter the enemies and ask questions later.
But again, Effie Calvin demonstrates that one of her strengths is writing character developement, and she didn't even have much space! Nevertheless, it doesn't feel rushed or anything.
Will come back for book six for sure.
After the events in Empress of Xytae, Netheia is exiled to Inthya in hopes that the Inthian kindness will rub off on her and she might one day be allowed back.
Netheia was getting on my nerves for most of the time. She reminded me of Clarisse in the Percy Jackson universe, daughter of Ares, who is included in the cabin council despite her plans always are to slaughter the enemies and ask questions later.
But again, Effie Calvin demonstrates that one of her strengths is writing character developement, and she didn't even have much space! Nevertheless, it doesn't feel rushed or anything.
Will come back for book six for sure.
December 1, 2020
More Inthya? Yes please!
I have followed the book series since the beginning and have been caught up on the interesting world building - there was no way I can skip The latest installment. Honestly, the subplot of the goddesses alone kept me coming back for more as it’s so poignant in its tragedy. As always, the characters are all written quiet well - though I’m still getting used to the idea of dragons - and more importantly - make logical decisions! You can easily finish the book in one go, goodness know I did. Now back to waiting for book 6!
I have followed the book series since the beginning and have been caught up on the interesting world building - there was no way I can skip The latest installment. Honestly, the subplot of the goddesses alone kept me coming back for more as it’s so poignant in its tragedy. As always, the characters are all written quiet well - though I’m still getting used to the idea of dragons - and more importantly - make logical decisions! You can easily finish the book in one go, goodness know I did. Now back to waiting for book 6!
July 16, 2021
4.5 stars
My favourite book in this series is still "Daughter of the Sun", but this one is a close second. And that fact surprised me a lot! After reading the fourth book, in which Netheia was the antagonist, I was sure I'd never end up rooting for her, but she really won me over! And her relationship with Klavida was so sweet; they really complement each other. But the most intriguing part for me was a conversation between two goddesses and what they revealed. I need to know more because what was hinted at was fascinating. When is the next book coming out ?!
My favourite book in this series is still "Daughter of the Sun", but this one is a close second. And that fact surprised me a lot! After reading the fourth book, in which Netheia was the antagonist, I was sure I'd never end up rooting for her, but she really won me over! And her relationship with Klavida was so sweet; they really complement each other. But the most intriguing part for me was a conversation between two goddesses and what they revealed. I need to know more because what was hinted at was fascinating. When is the next book coming out ?!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
November 17, 2020
What a great book! Just as an individual story and as part of a series. You can really tell the meta plot is coming to a climax, and spreading it over the whole series has really shown off how finely crafted it all is.
But the two PoV characters were a really great choice, both with interesting relationships to important gods, each other, and the previous books.
But the two PoV characters were a really great choice, both with interesting relationships to important gods, each other, and the previous books.
November 18, 2020
Oh my GOD I was so excited for book 5 to come out. I read the other 4 over quarantine, and had 3 other friends read as well. I tell everyone I can about this series, I love it so much.
This book in particular held a lot of weight with me. No spoilers, but the ending (like all the others) made me choke up. I’m so excited for the next in the series, and I’ll spend some time rereading again.
This book in particular held a lot of weight with me. No spoilers, but the ending (like all the others) made me choke up. I’m so excited for the next in the series, and I’ll spend some time rereading again.
February 5, 2021
Just another perfect addition to my comfort read pile. I loved every bit of f/f fluff and angst, and the mythology of the setting continues to intrigue me. Finally a fantasy setting I'd like to live in.
I'm also not too proud as to deny I didn't squeal when two Masimi characters were named with Turkish names.
I'm also not too proud as to deny I didn't squeal when two Masimi characters were named with Turkish names.
February 10, 2021
I love this series, and ended up blowing through this whole book in about three hours. My biggest complaint is that I wish there was more of it. It's a bit shorter than I would have liked. I would have liked a couple extra chapters in the middle to flesh out Nethia and Klavida's respective character arcs a little bit more.
March 28, 2021
This book is only one which got 5 stars in my views ...others were good but 4 stars good...and I didnt read second last because have read synopsis of all and I knew before that villain of second last is ..lead in last book so I read this one first ....now I'm loyal to second sister....so i skipped second last one ...and journey of this series and this book made me happy .
May 6, 2022
Actual Rating: 3.5/5
I quite enjoyed the fantasy elements in this, especially the complicated relationships between the gods that's been slowly developing. However, I just find that I don't care much about the primary point of these stories - the romance! I just don't buy most of the romances, and I feel nothing about them, so I feel very meh about these books on the whole.
I quite enjoyed the fantasy elements in this, especially the complicated relationships between the gods that's been slowly developing. However, I just find that I don't care much about the primary point of these stories - the romance! I just don't buy most of the romances, and I feel nothing about them, so I feel very meh about these books on the whole.
November 13, 2020
Just how far will Netheia go to appease her god and will she overthrow her sister from the throne that she has always know was hers? Can love change you. These are some of the answers Netheia will discover in this story. This was a good book I would recommend it
Read
March 25, 2021Wonderful.
Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful. I've read every book in this series so far and I've loved every one of them. All of then very well written and engaging. I can't wait for the next one ❤
Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful. I've read every book in this series so far and I've loved every one of them. All of then very well written and engaging. I can't wait for the next one ❤
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews