I have mixed feelings.
On the one hand, I like the practice of respecting/planning your life around your cycle, that is, doing certain activities (e.g. cleaning house, creative tasks, starting projects, forms of exercise, social engagements, emphasizing leisure, etc) during certain phases on the cycle.
Vitti also recommends certain foods or whether to eat vegetables raw or cooked based on your phases, and knowing how estrogen/progesterone affect digestion (and can cause constipation or diarrhea) this makes sense to me.
That said, if a woman has irregular periods or no periods, peri menopause, menopause, secondary amenorrhea, PCOS, etc. most of this book would be lost on her. I would be okay with that IF this wasn't a book targeted to women with hormonal/endocrine/period problems, written by an author who claims to have had PCOS and cured herself. 🤨 😔
If you have a regular cycle, you might enjoy the chapters and find it helpful to live more in sync with your cycle. Thinking about female friends I admire for being "in touch" with their body, I see how they do this automatically.
Another problem I had was the information seems contradictory. For example, Vitti insists on eating breakfast within 1.5 hours of waking (okay) but you're also supposed to poop 💩 within 20 minutes of waking and exercise first thing in the morning. 🧐
I am self-employed, with no children or a commute to work. Still, I would not be able to wake, poop, workout, and get ready for work, and eat my breakfast (prepared the night before) in 90 minutes. 🙅🏻♀️ To do her way, I would have to get up, Chug water, poop, make breakfast, eat, go to yoga (or do something else if a class wasn't offered at the time), OR not eat and shorten my practice to 30 min in order to eat on time and then get ready for work.
1) I cannot imagine exercising immediately after eating or even within 20-30 minutes of eating, and 2) this requires me to pass on the benefits of working out in a fasted state. 3) I don’t want to rush any of those things and 4) I also like to eat when I'm hungry -- listen to my body, rather than shovel food in as soon as I'm awake. 😬 Plus, if you have blood sugar issues (and most people with endocrine issues have blood sugar problems, according to Vitti) there are numerous positive benefits to only eating 12 hours a day...
Another contradiction for me was around supplements. Vitti says supplements (esp. vitamins) aren't a solution (many hormonal issues are caused from nutrient deficiencies) because the body cannot utilize synthesized/processed/extracted forms (I agree) and to eat real, whole, nutritious foods as nature intended instead (I agree) and to avoid processed foods (still agree). HOWEVER, she recommends protein shakes. Granted she suggests vegan ones but even vegan protein shakes are very processed/extracted/not wholesome. 🤷🏻♀️ She also tells vegans to take omega supplements... confusing. BUT AT LEAST she recognizes vegans/plant-centered eating
Lastly, there is so much self-talk. 🙄 🙄 🙄 (It's extra nars-y. Maybe it would have been better to put at the end of the book if someone actually wanted to read about how she started a period club in 6th grade). Skip the first 2 chapters.
You can also skip chapter 3 unless you want a lesson on the endocrine system.
The protocol starts at Chapter 4. (see below) The book also frequently promotes her coaching program, which fine—sell it honey 💵 , but the one I clicked on was a whopping $3,000 (there may be cheaper ones). 😳
Here is the protocol:
drink 8-oz water at wake up
no caffeine before breakfast
protein-rich breakfast (max 30g carbs unless you are skinny/fast metabolism, then 50g)
lunch 3.5 hours later
eat most calories at lunch
only 1 complex carb (beans OR rice 🍚)
1 good fat (eg avocado 🥑 or nuts 🥜)
take digestive enzyme 💊
snack, nutrient dense, 2.5-3 hours later if needed (eg berries and nuts)
dinner 2.53 hours after the snack. Protein with raw and cooked vegetables, no grains or sugar
Go to bed 3.5-4 hours after eating.
Also only use 7th generation products (avoid chemicals).
—————-
Interestingly, that ☝️ is the exact way I was eating for the past 5 years (except no added fat) and I ended up with endocrine issues (namely, adrenal fatigue) 😑
Her 4-day reset also seemed low in calories or like a crash diet even though its "real food" It is basically the same thing all 4 days (Day 3/4 you get to add a little avocado).
Breakfast:
8-oz water
fiber supplement
1 1/2 c mixed berries, squeeze lemon juice, 1T flax seed, green juice or chorella tablets (WHat the what?)
Lunch:
whole grain (1/2 c), 1 T flax and 4-oz white fish OR if you're a vegetarian, 1/3 c beans (no grain)
unlimited salad
Snack (water, tea, approved veggies or fruit)
Dinner:
vegetable soup (water boiled vegetables-unlimited) or mung bean minestrone (1.5 cups; it’s mung beans and veggies in water)
unlimited salad
To end on a positive, ⭐️ I did find the research she shared about how overeating, especially on refined carbohydrates, causes you to feel hungry again (even though you do not actually need more calories) because of the hormones/blood sugar response. I also liked that she said there is no such thing as willpower (I agree) because once the NAc and hormones join the fray, you lose.
Bottom line: If you have a relatively normal cycle and want to improve/feel better/live more in sync and protect your lady bits, this book might have some helpful things to try in terms of readjusting your life (eg how you exercise and socialize) and when you eat what kinds of foods.