TL;DR… Good book! Nice images. Writing is a little lackluster. Lack of connection between models and writing. Lack of explanation on ethnic outfits, design elements, and composition, but I would say this book is so much better from a character designing perspective! 3.5
This book is pretty good. Would recommend. I think the book has excellent photography, and showcases how youths are empowered through their activism at such young ages. The photography is good, the designs of their outfits are absolutely stunning, and I fell in love with the book.
My criticisms are more so preferences of missed opportunity. I would have LOVED to hear more about why certain design choices were made, what are the origins and inspirations of the outfits? I am a huge history nerd and think that would help a lot with fleshing out how the photo connects to the activist themselves. I think the book did what it was meant to do, see black youth in beautiful ways unfamiliar to us. As a black youth I did feel that they were beautiful, but I didn’t feel like I was as my heritage wasn’t connected to theirs. I wanted to see the heritage we shared and the choices made into the composition, the design, the fashion, the make up. I want to feel empowered as they do, and in a way I do, just wishing there was more information about the photography themselves as we as readers are kind of disconnected from the people in the photos. The photos don’t really tell us anything about the person, so it’s like, why bother getting to know them? If we had more connection to design choices that are thoroughly explained or some more unique composition- Perhaps re enactments of scenes revisioned or just more explaination on why we should care. In the introduction it explained that but I want to know why we should care about these individuals, why we should care about their aspirations. Some photos had a bit too much airbrush on the faces of the girls which made them felt really plastic. If a book is all about natural beauty why hide so many imperfections? The book’s writing isn’t engaging. It’s just explaining to me about the model’s lives and their accomplishments, which, is cool and definitely is inspiring. I just think since there’s a lack of connection to the most of the photos (most photos are just the models looking absolutely stunning with no substance or reason for how it correlates to the model) provides apathy into the writings and made me not care for the models
Still, I will keep coming back to this book. I wish I could rate it a 3.5, quite possibly bumping it up to a 4 because as a character designer, seeing authentic black beauty is inspiring from an artistic standpoint. Especially the hair. I can design and draw dozens of black characters using this book as my inspiration. I can see myself coming back to this book so if you are someone who really like character designer or some artist who just needs inspiration on drawing black beauty- I can’t recommend this book enough. For the average reader however, especially for the stated demographic of black youth (which I am) I would still recommend it if asked for my feedback, but it’s not a book I would recommend upon being asked unless I was asked specially about photography books, which, I would probably recommend this one s I haven’t read many.