Mou Zongsan (1909-1995), one of the representatives of Modern Confucianism, belongs to the most important Chinese philosophers of the twentieth century. From a more traditional Confucian perspective, this book makes a critical analysis on Mou's moral metaphysics, mainly his thoughts about Confucian ethos.
The author observes that Mou simplifies Confucian ethos rooted in various and specific environments, making them equal to modern ethics, which is a subversion of the ethical order of life advocated by traditional Confucianism. The author believes, also, that Mou has twisted Confucian ethos systematically by introducing Kant's concept of autonomy into the interpretation of Confucian thoughts.
Scholars and students in Chinese philosophy, especially those in Confucian studies, will be attracted by this book. Also, it will appeal to readers interested in comparative philosophy.
Secret Subversion I: Mou Zongsan, Kant, and Early Confucianism by Tang Wenming is a work of comparative philosophy. It is the first volume in a two part series on the work of the philosopher who translated Immanuel Kant's critiques into Chinese and developed a moral metaphysics on the basis of Kantian philosophy. In the first volume, Tang critiques Mou for misreading Kantian "moral autonomy" as a significant feature of Confucian ethics. He maintains that this reading leads to a reductionist and distorted understanding of traditional Confucianism, which is better understood as a form of virtue ethics.
The strength of this book lay in its hermeneutic parsing of texts by Confucius and Mencius, and Tang's situating of Confucian ethics as a practice concerned with the cultivation of virtue and real embodied relationships rather than abstract moral categories.
In his criticism of Mou Zongsan and Immanuel Kant, Tang occasionally veered into straw-man territory, and rather than engaging in a specific idea from either thinker referred to a general "moralistic" viewpoint with which he disagreed. Certain authors, most notably Friedrich Nietzsche, were referred to as voices of authority, whose claims were stated, but did not seem to be developed. The frequent use of phrases such as "As everyone knows," or "Undoubtedly" were distracting to me, but that may just be a pet peeve of mine.