First, an Alison Bechdel story. Last year at the NYC Comic Con, Bechdel was signing copies of Fun Home, and Mulzer and I stood in line to get our copy signed. As she was adding a quick drawing to the title page, I told Bechdel how I had bought three volumes of her "Dykes to Watch Out For" to share with the students of the GSA I'd started at my high school in the Bronx. Every one had been borrowed and never returned, so she could be happy knowing that her work must be very appreciated by my students. As soon as I finished talking, I feel terrible, because she looked so uncomfortable and awkward at my talking to her. Her work is so vivacious and alive that I never would have thought her to be so shy.
Second, a few publishing gripes. "By the Author of Fun Home?" No, dear Houghton Miflin, Alison Bechdel is the author of "Dykes to Watch Out For," first and foremost. I know the tag line is to catch readers who first heard of her after the main-stream media discovered her via her wonderful graphic memoir, but it seems a bit patronizing given the importance and scope of "Dykes." Also, I searched the "Graphic-Novel/Comics" section at B&N forever trying to find this book, but could find neither it nor "Fun Home." When I finally asked at the help-desk, I was told it was in the Gay/Lesbian Interest section. I know that "Dykes" is an important work of queer art, but leaving it out of the comic section entirely seems reductive. I suppose as a lesbian cartoonist, there is no shortage of literary ghetos that Bechdel can find herself banished to. How about cross-shelving it, so it reflects both qualities?
Now the review. Dykes to Watch Out For is one of the greatest serial stories ever published. The characters are so real, so well-rounded and developed, and the story arc so long and sustained that its one of the few on-going narratives where I really feel like the characters are out there somewhere. Saying that you "feel like you know the characters" is perhaps one of the most tired cliches when it comes to discussing a book, but with this series it is honestly true. Reading the series in its entirety is both fascinating and distressing - you see the characters, as well as Bechdel's art and politics grow and mature before your eyes, but you also realize that it's only taken you a few days to read through 30 years of an artists life. Not only do the characters realistically age visibly and emotionally, but you follow the development of queer and lesbian politics, feminism, and modern American History as Regan, Bush, Clinton, and then Bush (again) crop up in discussions, news headlines, and protests. What most amazes me is how Bechdel creates a seamless narrative through single-page episodes; while character stories weave their way through multiple issue, each page is a self-contained narrative, and yet they settle upon one another to make a single coherent whole without any holes or gaps.
Finishing was a bit sad -- Bechdel has currently put "Dykes" on hiatus, so as of now there are no new stories with Mo, Lois, et al to look forward to.