I got this book mostly because it had “Narnia” in the title and also partly because I’ve been haphazardly collecting books about the Narnia series since I was young. I was expecting a scholarly analysis of the Narnia books, and, while it did analyze the books, it read more like an extended commentary. Instead of synthesizing different elements throughout the series, it went through the books in order of publication, rehashing the main events of the stories and pulling out the Christian meanings behind them.
At first I was a little frustrated with this arrangement (especially since I was reading the series while making my way through this book, so I didn’t really want a reminder of everything that had happened). I had already heard many of the points Rogers made in other analyses of the series, but he also offered insights that I hadn’t thought of previously. Those parts made the book a worthwhile read. Although his treatment of the series isn’t exactly “scholarly” in the sense of being thoroughly backed up by outside sources, Rogers does occasionally reference other Lewis works in his commentary. These parts help shed light on the ideas Lewis was trying to convey in the Narnia books, and they somewhat satisfied my desire for a scholarly perspective on the series.
Overall, because if its short length and easy-to-read style, I’d recommend Rogers’ commentary to any adventurer who is new to the land of Narnia. It does a good job of introducing some of the elements that make the series such powerful Christian stories, although you can probably find similar discussions in a plethora of other Narnia-related books. But, if you’re a seasoned reader of Lewis, I’d suggest something a little more meaty and a lot more original, such as Michael Ward’s Planet Narnia.