Off the top, I must commend the author on writing style. This is a narrative history and I enjoyed his conversational style and liberal use of quips. It gave a jaunty but still professional vibe. I have often said, 1945 is the most interesting year and, in the case of Canada, that seems proven throughout the book.
It deals with specific events like The Halifax Riots and new movements ranging from the social safety net to women’s rights (they kept industry going while the men fought) to the start of universal health care. As effective as that is, it is when the author covers people that the book excels. I am probably one of the few who was very aware of General Harry Crerar though I knew nothing of Rear-Admiral Murray. The former stoically if unimaginatively led Canadian troops in Europe. The latter was sent out to pasture after Canadian sailors tore apart Halifax in alcohol-fuelled riots.
The book also digs deep into Prime Minister King who remains a strange individual but effective leader. He hung onto power and saw Canada through dark days. Still, the author strays into ridicule like many contemporary historians. Cuthbertson describes King as, “Short and pudgy as a dumpling” and having a challenged combover. King never married and there is speculation that he may have had a relationship with his two-decade serving valet. This content may not contribute to the book’s thesis but it is entertaining.
The tale of Rocket Richard who suffered following his hockey career was fascinating. It stands as the sole Francophone aspect of the book (outside of Francophones being wary of what a global war meant to them). Richard is presented as the bridge between Canada’s “two solitudes”. I was surprised to learn he was twice rejected for military service due to two broken ankles and broken wrist suffered in sport. He doubled down on hockey and shone during the war playing for the Canadiens when there were just two Francophones on the team.
Businessmen who stepped into the war effort are given their due including the well-known C.D. Howe and mostly forgotten, E.P. Taylor. What just these two men contributed during the war and what they accomplished following, is astonishing. The book goes on to cover war brides, Irgor Gouzenko (who seemingly ushered in the Cold War), and the unfairness of how troops were brought back home.
The book makes the case that though the war had its deprivations and nearly 100,000 were killed or wounded, the conflict was good for Canada. 1945 made for an interesting year. The war put Canada on the world stage and modernized the economy. Yet, there were many fault-lines that would only grow. And that is why history goes on.