The eschatological heart of Paul’s gospel in his world and its implications for today
Drawing upon thirty years of intense study and reflection on Paul, Douglas Campbell offers a distinctive overview of the apostle’s thinking that builds on Albert Schweitzer’s classic emphasis on the importance for Paul of the resurrection. But Campbell—learning here from Karl Barth—traces through the implications of Christ for Paul’s thinking about every other theological topic, from revelation and the resurrection through the nature of the church and mission. As he does so, the conversation broadens to include Stanley Hauerwas in relation to Christian formation, and thinkers like Willie Jennings to engage post-colonial concerns.
But the result of this extensive conversation is a work that, in addition to providing a description of Paul’s theology, also equips readers with what amounts to a Pauline manual for church planting. Good Pauline theology is good practical theology, ecclesiology, and missiology, which is to say, Paul’s theology belongs to the church and, properly understood, causes the church to flourish. In these conversations Campbell pushes through interdisciplinary boundaries to explicate different aspects of Pauline community with notions like network theory and restorative justice.
The book concludes by moving to applications of Paul in the modern period to painful questions concerning gender, sexual activity, and Jewish inclusion, offering Pauline navigations that are orthodox, inclusive, and highly constructive.
Beginning with the God revealed in Jesus, and in a sense with ourselves, Campbell progresses through Pauline ethics and eschatology, concluding that the challenge for the church is not only to learn about Paul but to follow Jesus as he did.
Douglas A. Campbell is a professor of New Testament at Duke Divinity School. His main research interest is the life and theology of the apostle Paul, with particular reference to an understanding of salvation informed by apocalyptic as against justification or salvation-history. However, he is interested in methodological contributions to Paul's analysis from any disciplinary angle, ancient or modern, whether Greco-Roman epistolary and rhetorical theory, or insights into human networking and conflict-resolution discovered by sociologists.
His writings command the respect of scholars worldwide, including Framing Paul: An Epistolary Biography and The Deliverance of God: An Apocalyptic Rereading of Justification in Paul.
Easily the best/most transformational book I’ve read thus far this year and I highly expect it will stay that way. Dr. Campbell reads Paul through a Barthian lens particularly because Barth was a wonderful Paulinist himself. He also brings insights from Hauerwas, Jennings, and many others into conversation with Barth to interpret Paul in a way that actively seeks to stand its ground against the evils of foundationalism. This book is quite lengthy but also very readable, and I appreciated all of the extra sections included at the end of each chapter for greater synthesis/comprehension (key theses, key scriptural passages, further reading, etc.). I can’t recommend this book enough for people who love Jesus and want to grow in their discipleship.
I am reviewing this for another context, so won't post my whole review here. But, this is my favorite Paul book to date. Campbell, draws heavily on Barth to explore Paul's theology of formation and mission, with in a non-foundationalist, Christological framework.
Insightful, easy to read yet deep theology of Paul, or in the vein of Paul.
This is a consistently apocalyptic reading of Paul. Apocalyptic is probably the wrong name for this, but that is the moniker. It would be better named as discontinuous reading. Discontinuity is the key feature. In the spectrum of continuity to discontinuity, the apocalyptic reading is on the far discontinuous end. This approach is taken to its logical end in this volume. It does reveal or unlock a lot of Paul’s theology, but when pressed into a rigid framework, like any rigid framework, it frays at the edges.
The background theology is explicitly Barthian, especially as Barth is supplemented by Jüngel (this is not explicitly noted). Barthes “Nein!” (no) is explicated in Jüngel and here is taken as the starting point (foundation) of the theological enterprise. It’s hard to argue against the discontinuous revelation of God in the person of Jesus as the fundamental starting point of theology. What we can know of God begins here. What the extreme apocalyptic reading loses here is the insight gained by a creational starting point and the acts of God in history. It seems self evident that no methodology is going to capture the whole of the message and impact of Paul. The traditional or Lutheran reading, the salvation historical reading, the new perspective and the apocalyptic all provide different readings and insights into Paul’s theology. When Paul is pressed too hard into any of these frameworks, either the frame breaks or we must break Paul. Here, Douglas Campbell makes the choice to say in certain places, Paul is mistaken. In order to reach certain conclusions that are compatible with modernity/postmodernity, one has to say Paul needs to be corrected here. This is perfectly legitimate from a scholarly perspective.
The book is well laid out and the writing flows very easily. He avoids theological or technical terminology except when he wields certain terms as wrecking balls. In this it is clear that the target audience is 20-something seminarians at Duke (Clearly he is aiming at right target for him!). This is not a complex theology that has high entrance requirements or a difficult reading level. The favored technical term (as he deploys it) is foundationalism. At some point, it becomes a substitute for the word evil and simply loses any force. He also deploys infralapsarian, Sachkritik, as other coded dismissal (as well as some late 20th century code words). Given the high-school level language, contrasted with the technical language is an effective rhetorical technique, making opponents seem like pedantic, out of touch ancients, but it weakens the argument when pressed. The thinness of the argument collapses under a load.
This is probably the weakness of the book. The arguments are strung out so thinly that they become hard to follow in a careful way. There is a lot of hand waving and anecdotes sprinkled liberally, especially into the later third when he needs to break with Paul. Easy to get into and some penetrating analysis, but not concise.
There is a lot to be mined here. Lots of great insight and clarification of Paul and dogmatics in general, especially the priority of the resurrection and relational over the structural. But at some point, it becomes para-orthodox. A scholarly reading presented in clear language, making a lot of excellent insights very accessible. But when he explicitly wanders away from Paul, orthodoxy and orthopraxy suffer.
Worth the read to contrast with traditional, salvation historical, and new perspective readings of Paul.
Pauline Dogmatics is a must read. I almost wrote that it is a must read for all Christians. Really it is a must read for anyone who cares to opine concerning Christianity- friend or foe. Campbell provides two essential things to his audience which are invaluable, and which can't be avoided (he, thankfully, brings a lot more than that, but these two are really what make this book a must read). The first is in the area of self-awareness. The church for way too long now has lacked a self-awareness. It doesn't understand the substance of its belief; much is believed without knowing why, how, or the etymological development of the arrived upon belief(s), or the unintended consequences thereof. Paul, and his writings, therefore, are understood in specific ways without an awareness of the lens through which they are understood. Campbell clearly brings a realization of that lens to us, and along with it comes self-awareness of belief. Second, Campbell equips us with alternative lenses, which, at the very least are substantively seductive. Whether the reader ends up taking up Campbell's conclusions as his/her own or not, he/she will still benefit from the exercise of reading this gift as acquiring self-awareness and hope in thought comes with it. This book may end up proving to be a saving grace for theology in a changing world; and Campbell does the heavy lifting without giving in to the temptation of compromise for an easy way out.
His discussion of bodily resurrection (the time-space field perspective on it is quite illuminating), election, and communion with the Trinity as the goal of creation are highlights of the book. Regarding the resurrection, Campbell, though, does not take into account the Gospel references like John 5:28 that will upset some of his conclusions.
Also good for invoking thought and reconsideration is the chapter on the "Triumph of Love."
I found his "Pauline" endorsement of same-sex marriage to be deeply problematic (one chapter out of 29 chapters). Maybe I am too foundational, as he puts it, and, maybe, Jesus was also foundational in this regard since He pointed to Adam and Eve, male and female (Genesis 2), as the basis of marriage. Arguing from Scriptural silence on this issue to assertion can be suspect and he is guilty of that on this account. For Campbell, being "anti-foundational" and superlapsarian drives his same-sex marriage affirmation, an affirmation that is not there in Scripture. He may be guilty of being too relevant to today's culture mores.
Campbell makes you think and rethink and, therefore, his thoughts poke at you in a good way even if you disagree with him on certain points.
Read the chapters completely out of order and different sections at a time for a restorative justice class taught by Campbell, where we looked at Paul's theology to gain a better understanding for how we are to approach the prison system today. Really enjoyed the book, but also probably a bit biased because I really like Campbell.
Excellent book, I did not agree with everything, but it is very well argued and I will use it as a reference for many years to come. Campbell defends an apocalyptic reconstruction of St. Pauls thought, that is similar to what Karl Barth would have argued for.
My new favourite book on Pauline theology. I honestly can’t recommend the book enough. I love both Barth and Hauerwas, so I was always going to love this book; but I think you’ll benefit from its insights no matter where you are on the theological/ethical spectrum.
For a book that emphasizes the pitfalls and problems of foundationalism (elevating our own truth criteria over the truth that is God, ultimately to judge God’s truth or falsity), it sure sneaks it in toward the last few chapters.
I know that I have said this in other reviews, but Pauline Dogmatics has emerged as the most thought-provoking book that I have ever had the pleasure to read. In this work, Douglas Campbell—one of today’s most distinguished Pauline scholars—presents what he deems to be Paul’s gospel. But Campbell also makes tremendous strides to interpret Paul in light of Paul—which means examining all of Paul’s claims in light of Paul’s own deepest convictions. This guides Campbell in exploring how we can maintain genuinely Pauline ethics, thoughts, and practices in an environment that is radically different from that which Paul knew.
There proved to be something extremely edifying about reading Campbell's work. He resonates with my soul in a way that few authors and theologians do. Campbell is unflinchingly devoted to believing in a God who is fundamentally loving and benevolent toward humanity—as he argues that Paul too was—and, in so doing, he arrives at many of the same conclusions that one might associate with progressive Christianity. But he does not fall into most of the traps that I feel most progressive Christians do when they begin to take their stances too far in my opinion. For instance, Campbell is deeply Trinitarian. He has high regard for the Bible and never whitewashes sin (which he maintains includes any sexual activity outside of a marriage covenant). And, while he is a Universalist, not for a moment does he lapse into religious pluralism. In fact, Campbell condemns such thinking, as we all know that Paul would.
Ultimately, I by no means agree with all of Campbell’s views. In fact, I would estimate that I agreed with it probably only about 75% of it. For instance, I doubt that foundationalist thinking is as destructive as Campbell makes it out to be. Furthermore, I strongly believe that universal reconciliation was a much more explicit aspect of Paul’s thinking than Campbell posits. But I am thankful nonetheless, to Campbell for challenging my views. He is an author to ruminate on, to digest, and to explore. Pauline Dogmatics: The Triumph of God’s Love just might be life-changing.