I am used to "Choose Your Own Adventure" books being fantasy or adventure, not middle school romance, but the Usbourne Co has had other clean, interesting fun for kids, and so I was willing to give this one a try.
My middle-schooler has enjoyed these, and wanted me to read a couple. I must confess that I didn't go through and read all the choices like I might have if it had been a fantasy. What would have happened if I had chosen something else? Trying to navigate the way through middle school romances and crushes seemed to me like something from one of Dante's circles, so going through it once was enough.
Not where you could see it on the choosing page, but later on, when you flipped to the choice, my middle-schooler had marked "the best" choice, and oddly enough, I made all the same "best" choices. So, I guess in terms of this book, we still think alike, to some degree.
The middle-schooler did say that in one of these books' choices, she didn't like either choice. One was to lie to your new friends and the other was to lie to your old friends. No third choice. If you feel like you have to lie to your friends so they'll like you, then they're not really your friends. And if you're lying to them then you're not acting much like a friend, either. But maybe, for a lot of people, learning about true friendship comes beyond the middle-school years.
I found one set of choices that I didn't like, either. It was to either confront someone about something or ignore it. There was a third option that wasn't given. To talk gently and calmly about it, wanting clarification. Maybe the author figured that nuanced choice was beyond middle-schoolers, but it isn't really. Or maybe I'm just surrounded by articulate and gentle (most of the time) middle-schoolers.
Liam was a good, forgiving character. The little sister was a well-done character, too, as unintentionally annoying as sometimes little siblings can be in real life.
I liked that Phoebe immediately corrected her lie to Liam. (That wasn't given as an option.)
I disagreed that silence is a lie. Sometimes, "discretion is the better part of valor." Or, as my grandma used to say, "You don't need to tell everything that you know." That's not a good philosophy to take to extremes, though. If someone or something's in danger, it's time to talk.
It seemed to me that this book had less choosing than the classical "Choose Your Own Adventures" did.
The ending that I got didn't say how other people (namely the conniving jealous girl) would react to Phoebe's choices, or how they worked through the ramifications. It just left us hanging.