Sophia (From Ruthless Charmer) is older and wiser after having foolishly run off to elope with an evil man at the age of 18. But of course, society does not forgive or forget so easily. She never planned to return to London, but she is serving as companion to a dramatic French woman who insists, and so she goes. There she meets Caleb, the illegitimate son of a viscount, and falls in love.
This book is more 3.5 stars for me. I felt that the story spun its wheels a few times, and I didn't buy Sophia's initial rejection of Caleb's offer of marriage, even if she was drunk at the time. Yes, this story is set in a time where certain expectations can overrule everything else, but Sophia had thrown those expectations aside at the age of 18 and while she learned a lot in the intervening years, it didn't ring true to me that a fiercer acceptance of societal dictates was one of those things. Not given the company she kept or her time away from her family. I understood her doubts about her own ability to recognize a good man, but this didn't prove to be much of an obstacle.
The reason I rounded up, as strange as this may sound, is that this book contained one of the best epilogues I've ever read in a romance novel. It didn't just give us a glimpse into the HEA, but instead it whisked us through life, closing a couple of lose threads along the way, but mostly showing the shape of the main characters' lives until death parts them. The last line was beautiful and bittersweet.