I barely read non-fiction besides academic writing, however, I readily agreed to read this book when @hachetteindia offered the book for review. My interest in the book comes from my academic reading and research for my BA dissertation on nature. In sociologically analysing nature, one of the aspects I had taken was to understand nature as the environment. Following which I argued how environment cuts across the societal spectrum, especially caste in Bengal. Anyway, coming to the book, it is divided into two parts. Firstly, the author presents to us the reality of climate change, its consequences on agriculture, everyday life, rural sector and the urban spaces. With clear graphical representations, the author emphasised on the rate of environmental degradation in the country and the world. Secondly, the author, through personal narrative and research has detailed the ways in which rate of pollution could be stopped and natural disasters like flooding urban areas, drought, wildfire, landslides could be prevented. Not only does she highlight what could be done at the broader, institutional level but also the changes individuals could make in their everyday life to deal with the environment efficiently. What I liked about the book was it accessible language and style in which it was written. One doesn’t have to be into academia to understand environment and its concerns. The book proves to be an informative text to take stock of climate change, especially in India in recent times. And I would encourage you to pick it up to understand what has been happening to the environment in recent times beyond your EVS textbook knowledge. As much as I hoped to like the book, unfortunately, I found a host of issues with the book. To begin with, I was annoyed with the uninteresting quotations used by the author at the beginning of every chapter. The words of dead, white, or Hindu upper caste, privileged men were used throughout the book and that simply left a bitter taste, for me. Secondly, the chapter which I was most excited about, “Women in Peril”, was the shortest with no interesting research and arguments about the women’s peril in the environmental context. There could be a million ways to have dealt with ecofeminist issue but it seemed as though the author simply stated what was commonsensical and offered nothing new. Thirdly, on page 171, the author makes a sweeping remark that India is getting wealthier and poverty is being removed with no data whatsoever. However, the ground reality is actually different today with a GDP as low as -23.5% and the economy was in perils back in 2018 when the book was out as well. Lastly, what struck me most was how this book seemed to be written from a privileged, middle class, urban perspective from start to end and meant to come up with middle class, urban solutions to combat climate change. It failed drastically in addressing the social and its stratifying layers. It seemed extremely narrow in its approach and failed to provide a comprehensive, well-argued analysis of Climate in India today.
Thank you Hachette India for the review copy. Views are personal.